[2015] HCATrans 101
IN THE HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Office of the Registry
Sydney No S58 of 2015
B e t w e e n -
JACEK GNYCH
First Appellant
SYLWIA GNYCH
Second Appellant
and
POLISH CLUB LIMITED ACN 000469385
Respondent
FRENCH CJ
KIEFEL J
GAGELER J
KEANE J
NETTLE J
TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS
AT CANBERRA ON TUESDAY, 5 MAY 2015, AT 10.15 AM
Copyright in the High Court of Australia
MR G.O’L. REYNOLDS, SC: May it please the Court, in this matter, I appear for the appellants with my learned friends, MR G.P. SEGAL and MR M.A. FRIEDGUT. (instructed by Drexler Litigation & Compensation Lawyers)
MR P.R. CLAY, SC: May it please the Court, I appear with my learned friends, MS J.M. McKELVEY and MR A. ISAACS, for the respondent. (instructed by Strathfield Law)
FRENCH CJ: Yes, Mr Reynolds.
MR REYNOLDS: If the Court pleases, your Honours should have a copy of our outline of argument. Would your Honours like a moment to peruse that?
FRENCH CJ: Yes, Mr Reynolds.
MR REYNOLDS: As your Honours will be aware, this case swings primarily on a single paragraph in the Liquor Act 2007 (NSW). The relevant provision is set out – and there are a lot of books your Honours will have, but the relevant one is the second supplementary legislative materials and second reading speeches. The provision is set out at page 72 of that book; about halfway down the page, your Honours will see that an offence is created because, under section 92(1):
A licensee . . . must not:
. . .
(d) lease –
we can forget “sublease” –
any other part of the licensed premises except with the approval of the Authority.
Now, that is obviously connected with the previous paragraph, that is, one has to look to eliminate parts of the licensed premises on which liquor is ordinarily sold or supplied for consumption and parts on which approved gaming machines are ordinarily kept, used or operated. But, subject to that subtraction, this provision makes it an offence to lease all parts of the licensed premises except with the approval of the authority.
Now, the primary question I am going to suggest in due course, but just to anticipate things, is whether it is the intention of the legislature that that provision render any lease which contravenes its terms unenforceable and that that issue will be resolved primarily by trying to glean what the intention of the legislature is from various sources which your Honours will have seen referred to in the written submissions.
Before I get to the detail of the submissions, focusing on that primary proposition, I would like to deal with one aspect of this case which may, if I do not explain it, cause some confusion. Your Honours will know from the case law – and a good example, if I can take your Honours to it, is the decision of Equuscorp v Haxton (2012) 246 CLR 498
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gnych & Anor v Polish Club Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] HCATrans 101
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue before the High Court was the proper interpretation of the covenant to "maintain and keep the demised premises in good repair and condition" within the lease agreement. This involved determining the extent of the respondent's obligations under this covenant, particularly in relation to latent defects and the inherent state of the premises at the commencement of the lease. The court also had to consider whether the respondent's actions or omissions constituted a breach of this covenant.
The High Court reasoned that the covenant to maintain and keep in good repair imposed a positive obligation on the tenant to remedy defects, whether they arose during the term or existed at the commencement of the lease, provided they were not so fundamental as to render the premises a "different subject matter" from that which the parties originally contemplated. The court distinguished between defects that were merely part of the inherent nature of the premises and those that constituted a failure to maintain or repair. Applying this principle, the court found that the respondent had breached its covenant by failing to address certain structural issues and defects that were not merely inherent but amounted to a failure to maintain the premises in good repair.
The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the orders of the lower courts and remitting the matter to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for determination of the quantum of damages.
Background
Background to the litigation
This case came before the High Court of Australia on an appeal from the New South Wales Court of Appeal. The appeal concerns the enforceability of a lease of part of a licensed premises without the approval of the relevant authority under section 92(1)(d) of the Liquor Act 2007 (NSW). The primary issue is whether such a lease is unenforceable due to its contravention of the statutory provision. The appellants, Gnych & Anor, argue that the lease should be enforceable with certain terms imposed by the court to satisfy the policy of the Liquor Act. The respondent, Polish Club Limited, contends that the lease is unenforceable because it conflicts with the statutory policy of requiring the licensee to supervise and manage the conduct of the business of the licensed premises. The Court of Appeal held that the lease was unenforceable, but the appellants challenge this decision before the High Court. The case hinges on the interpretation of statutory language, the implications of illegality on contract enforceability, and the appropriate relief if the appeal is successful.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. What is the primary issue in the case of Gnych & Anor v Polish Club Limited?
The primary issue is whether a lease which contravenes section 92(1)(d) of the Liquor Act 2007 (NSW) is rendered unenforceable.
2. How does the court typically approach questions of statutory illegality in determining the enforceability of a contract?
The court usually categorizes the case into one of three categories of illegality and applies the relevant test or proposition of law to determine if the provision or contract is unenforceable.
3. What are the three categories of illegality traditionally pointed to by the court in cases of statutory illegality?
The three categories are first category, second category, and third category illegality.
4. How does the court determine the legislative intent regarding the enforceability of contracts that contravene a statutory provision?
The court looks at the text, context, purpose, and other relevant considerations to discern the legislative intent.
5. What are the relevant factors the court considers in determining whether a contract is intended to be unenforceable under a statutory prohibition?
The relevant factors include the language of the statute, its scope and purpose, the consequences for the innocent party, and any other relevant considerations.
6. What is the distinction between determining the construction of the statute and asking what is the statutory effect of breaching the prohibition?
The construction of the statute involves interpreting the statute itself, while the statutory effect of breaching the prohibition involves whether a common law rule based on the policy of the law applies to prevent enforcement of the contract.
7. Does the court consider the detailed legislative regime dealing with the consequences of breaches of the Act as an indication of legislative intention?
Yes, the detailed legislative regime is seen as a clear indication of legislative intention not to render any lease made without approval automatically unenforceable.
8. What is the role of the authority in determining the consequences of a breach of the Act?
The authority has the power to take various actions, including disciplinary action, imposing conditions on the license, and varying or evoking license conditions.
9. What are the consequences for the innocent party if a lease is rendered unenforceable?
The consequences for the innocent party may include having to pay out employees who can no longer be employed and losses associated with the destruction of the business subject of the lease.
10. How does the court approach the issue of terms in relation to the enforceability of a lease?
The court may impose terms to ensure that the relevant policy of the Act is satisfied in the individual case, even if the lease is not rendered unenforceable.
Held
1. The primary issue in the case of Gnych & Anor v Polish Club Limited is whether a lease which contravenes section 92(1)(d) of the Liquor Act 2007 (NSW) is rendered unenforceable.
2. The court typically approaches questions of statutory illegality by categorizing the case into one of three categories of illegality and applying the relevant test or proposition of law to determine if the provision or contract is unenforceable.
3. The three categories of illegality traditionally pointed to by the court are first category, second category, and third category illegality.
4. The court determines the legislative intent regarding the enforceability of contracts that contravene a statutory provision by looking at the text, context, purpose, and other relevant considerations.
5. The relevant factors the court considers in determining whether a contract is intended to be unenforceable under a statutory prohibition include the language of the statute, its scope and purpose, the consequences for the innocent party, and any other relevant considerations.
6. The distinction between determining the construction of the statute and asking what is the statutory effect of breaching the prohibition is that the construction of the statute involves interpreting the statute itself, while the statutory effect of breaching the prohibition involves whether a common law rule based on the policy of the law applies to prevent enforcement of the contract.
7. The court considers the detailed legislative regime dealing with the consequences of breaches of the Act as an indication of legislative intention not to render any lease made without approval automatically unenforceable.
8. The role of the authority in determining the consequences of a breach of the Act is to take various actions, including disciplinary action, imposing conditions on the license, and varying or evoking license conditions.
9. The consequences for the innocent party if a lease is rendered unenforceable may include having to pay out employees who can no longer be employed and losses associated with the destruction of the business subject of the lease.
10. The court approaches the issue of terms in relation to the enforceability of a lease by considering whether the relevant policy of the Act can be satisfied by imposing appropriate terms, even if the lease is not rendered unenforceable.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The primary issue in the case of Gnych & Anor v Polish Club Limited is whether a lease which contravenes section 92(1)(d) of the Liquor Act 2007 (NSW) is rendered unenforceable. The court typically approaches questions of statutory illegality by categorizing the case into one of three categories of illegality and applying the relevant test or proposition of law to determine if the provision or contract is unenforceable. The three categories of illegality traditionally pointed to by the court are first category, second category, and third category illegality.
In this case, the court determined the legislative intent regarding the enforceability of contracts that contravene a statutory provision by looking at the text, context, purpose, and other relevant considerations. The court considered the language of the statute, its scope and purpose, the consequences for the innocent party, and any other relevant considerations. The court distinguished between determining the construction of the statute and asking what is the statutory effect of breaching the prohibition, with the former involving interpreting the statute itself and the latter involving whether a common law rule based on the policy of the law applies to prevent enforcement of the contract.
The court considered the detailed legislative regime dealing with the consequences of breaches of the Act as an indication of legislative intention not to render any lease made without approval automatically unenforceable. The court also noted that the authority has the power to take various actions, including disciplinary action, imposing conditions on the license, and varying or evoking license conditions. The court concluded that the consequences for the innocent party if a lease is rendered unenforceable may include having to pay out employees who can no longer be employed and losses associated with the destruction of the business subject of the lease.
The court approached the issue of terms in relation to the enforceability of a lease by considering whether the relevant policy of the Act is satisfied in the individual case, even if the lease is not rendered unenforceable. The court may impose terms to ensure that the relevant policy of the Act is satisfied. In this case, the court found that an implied term for access could be imposed to ensure that the licensee could perform its obligations under the Liquor Act.
The ratio decidendi of this case is that a lease which contravenes section 92(1)(d) of the Liquor Act 2007 (NSW) is not automatically unenforceable, but the court may impose terms to ensure that the relevant policy of the Act is satisfied in the individual case. The court distinguished prior authority by finding that the detailed legislative regime dealing with the consequences of breaches of the Act indicated legislative intention not to render any lease made without approval automatically unenforceable.