GND Developments Pty Ltd (in Liq), Moloney & Geroff v DA Luttrell Nominees Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE SUPREME COURT

OF QUEENSLAND
  No. 5385 of 1998

[GND Developments Pty Ltd (in liq), Moloney & Geroff v D.A. Luttrell Nominees Pty Ltd & Ors]

BETWEEN:
  GND DEVELOPMENTS PTY LTD (IN LIQUIDATION)
  (ACN 064 233 138)
  First Plaintiff

AND:
                 GREGORY MICHAEL MOLONEY and PETER IVAN FELIX GEROFF
  Second Plaintiff

AND:
  D.A. LUTTRELL NOMINEES PTY LTD
  (ACN 056 990 302)
  First Defendant

AND:
  KARADAY PTY LTD
  (ACN 010 677 362)
  Second Defendant

AND:
  DONALD ALLAN LUTTRELL
  Third Defendant

AND:
  GLYN FRANCIS PEARCE
  Fourth Defendant

JUDGMENT - HELMAN J.

Judgment delivered 20 August 1998

This is an application by the plaintiffs by way of motion under Order 84 Rule 2 of the Rules of the Supreme Court for orders that each of the first and second defendants be fined for contempt of court in failing to comply with an undertaking given to the Court by all defendants on 30 June 1998, and for orders that the third and fourth defendants be committed to prison or fined for contempt of court in failing to comply with the undertaking. 

Before Derrington J. on 30 June 1998 the plaintiffs sought orders restraining the defendants until the trial of the action from disposing of their interests in certain land, from encumbering it, or from borrowing further funds using it as security.  The defendants were represented by senior counsel, and their solicitor and the third defendant were present in court.  The fourth defendant was not at the hearing. 

On 21 November 1997 an order was made in this Court that the first plaintiff be wound up in insolvency, and Messrs Maloney and Geroff were appointed liquidators.  The action, begun on 16 June 1998, arises from the transfer of the land I have mentioned to the first and second defendants by the first plaintiff, of which the third and fourth defendants were the only directors.  (The third and fourth defendants are directors of the first and second defendants respectively.)  The transfer took place shortly after an order was made against the first plaintiff by the Queensland Building Tribunal on 30 May 1997.  The plaintiffs allege that the result of that transaction was that the first plaintiff was left without any assets and with a number of liabilities including the judgment debt.  The first plaintiff claims against the first and second defendants a declaration that it is beneficially entitled to the land and other relief.  There are further claims by the plaintiffs against the third and fourth defendants.

All parties gave undertakings to the Court which were recorded in an order made by Derrington J. and dated 30 June 1998.  The defendants’ principal undertaking was to develop the land forthwith by subdivision and by the construction of residential dwellings for sale on the parcels of land created by that subdivision.  There were other undertakings by the defendants the effect of which was to protect the alleged rights of the first plaintiff.  Among those other undertakings was one numbered 3 which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GND Developments Pty Ltd (in Liq), Moloney & Geroff v DA Lut... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] QSC 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

GND Developments Pty Ltd (in liquidation), Moloney & Geroff v DA Luttrell Nominees Pty Ltd is a case where the plaintiffs sought orders for fines and imprisonment for the defendants' alleged contempt of court. The plaintiffs claimed that the defendants failed to comply with an undertaking given to the court, which required them to provide a written report to the plaintiffs on a monthly basis. The plaintiffs argued that the defendants were guilty of contempt of court for failing to provide a report for the month of June 1998. The defendants, however, argued that the undertaking was not clear and unambiguous, and they misunderstood its terms.

The court held that the undertaking was clear and unambiguous and required a report for each calendar month to be provided on the seventh day of the following calendar month. The court found that the defendants' failure to comply with the undertaking was unintentional and proceeded from a mistaken interpretation of it. The court concluded that the defendants were guilty of contempt of court, but their contempt was venial and did not call for either committals or fines. The motion was dismissed, and the court invited further submissions on costs. The court found that the defendants' failure to comply with the undertaking was not deliberate or wilfully disobedient, but rather a mistake caused by the defendants' solicitor. The court emphasized that the defendants had given the undertaking with their authority, and it was clear and unambiguous. Therefore, they were guilty of contempt of court for failing to comply with it.

Background

Background to the litigation

GND Developments Pty Ltd, in liquidation, and the liquidators, Gregory Michael Moloney and Peter Ivan Felix Geroff, brought an action against D.A. Luttrell Nominees Pty Ltd, Karaday Pty Ltd, Donald Allan Luttrell, and Glyn Francis Pearce. The action arose from the transfer of certain land from GND Developments Pty Ltd to D.A. Luttrell Nominees Pty Ltd and Karaday Pty Ltd. The plaintiffs alleged that this transfer left GND Developments Pty Ltd without assets and with liabilities, including a judgment debt. The plaintiffs sought various declarations and relief against the defendants, claiming that the defendants were guilty of contempt of court in failing to comply with an undertaking given to the Court on 30 June 1998. The defendants were required to develop the land by subdivision and construction of residential dwellings and to provide monthly reports detailing aspects of the development. The plaintiffs alleged that the defendants failed to provide a report for June 1998 by 7 July 1998.

The matter came before the Supreme Court of Queensland as an application by way of motion under Order 84 Rule 2 of the Rules of the Supreme Court. The plaintiffs sought orders fining the first and second defendants for contempt of court in failing to comply with the undertaking given to the Court on 30 June 1998. They also sought orders committing the third and fourth defendants to prison or fining them for contempt of court for the same reason. The notice of motion was filed on 13 July 1998 and served on the defendants on 14 July 1998, with the hearing scheduled for 15 July 1998. No application for adjournment was made on behalf of the defendants.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the plaintiffs' motion should be dismissed due to procedural irregularities.
2. Whether the defendants failed to comply with the undertaking given to the Court.
3. Whether the defendants' failure to comply with the undertaking was wilfully disobedient or deliberately defiant.

Held
1. The plaintiffs' motion should not be dismissed due to procedural irregularities. The court held that the plaintiffs' motion could proceed despite non-compliance with certain procedural rules.
2. The defendants failed to comply with the undertaking given to the Court. The court found that the defendants did not provide the required monthly report on 7 July 1998 as stipulated in the undertaking.
3. The defendants' failure to comply with the undertaking was not wilfully disobedient or deliberately defiant. The court concluded that the defendants' non-compliance resulted from a misunderstanding of the terms of the undertaking and was not a deliberate or defiant act.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the procedural irregularities raised by the defendants. It noted that the plaintiffs' motion was filed and served in accordance with the rules, except for a minor irregularity regarding the service time which the court deemed not prejudicial. The court relied on previous cases to conclude that strict adherence to procedural rules was not necessary in contempt proceedings, and thus the motion could proceed. Regarding the merits, the court examined the clarity of the undertaking given by the defendants. It held that the terms of the undertaking were clear and unambiguous, requiring monthly reports to be submitted on the seventh day of the following month. The court rejected the defendants' argument that the undertaking allowed for a retrospective interpretation or that the months in question began on the seventh day of each calendar month. The court found that the defendants misunderstood the terms of the undertaking, which was not supported by the language used. The evidence presented showed that the defendants' solicitor and the third defendant misunderstood the timing of the first report due to a possible assumption that it could not be ready by 7 July. Despite this misunderstanding, the court concluded that the defendants were in contempt of court for failing to comply with the clear and unambiguous undertaking. However, since the court was not convinced beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendants' actions were wilfully disobedient or deliberately defiant, it deemed the contempt venial and decided not to impose committals or fines, opting instead to dismiss the motion and invite further submissions on costs.