CITATION: Glover v Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited [2000] NSWSC 928 CURRENT JURISDICTION: Civil FILE NUMBER(S): SC N213/95 HEARING DATE(S): 21-24 August 2000 JUDGMENT DATE: 3 October 2000 PARTIES :
David John Glover (Pltf)
Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited (Def)JUDGMENT OF: Newman J
COUNSEL : C R Callaway QC/P J Kirby (Pltf)
K L Dodd SC (Def)SOLICITORS: Hill Sneddon Partners (Pltf)
Sparke Helmore (Def)CATCHWORDS: Negligence - master and servant - credibility CASES CITED: Shedlezki v Bronte Baker Pty Ltd 72 SR NSW 378 at 385-386 DECISION: See para 51
THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COMMON LAWNEWMAN J
NEWCASTLE: TUESDAY, 3 OCTOBER 2000
N213/95 GLOVER v AUSTRALIAN ULTRA CONCRETE FLOORS PTY LIMITED
JUDGMENT
1 HIS HONOUR: This is a claim for damages brought by the plaintiff against his former employer. The defendant has denied liability and has also alleged that the plaintiff was contributorily negligent.
2 Furthermore, the defendant has alleged that the cause of the accident, if it be found to have occurred, if through any breach of duty by the defendant company that breach was in fact the breach of the plaintiff himself.
3 Any failure of the defendant company to perform its duty for which it would be vicariously responsible was, so it was alleged, completely co-extensive with the failure of the plaintiff who was under a concurrent obligation to perform the same duty.
4 This defence was based upon what had fallen from the majority of the Court of Appeal in Shedlezki v Bronte Bakery Pty Ltd 72 SR NSW 378 particularly Asprey JA at 385-386.
5 I turn then to the plaintiff’s case.
6 The plaintiff, who is a British citizen now resident in England, was so resident in 1990 when he was employed by the defendant as its factory manager. The business of the defendant was the manufacture of pre-stressed reinforced concrete floor beams.
7 Prior to his engagement on 12 September 1990 the plaintiff had acquired expertise in the manufacture of these objects in England and as I understand it, elsewhere in the world. While having no formal qualifications he had, through working in the industry over many years, acquired expertise.
8 Upon his arrival in Australia his duties originally required him to set up and set in working order, a machine called a slide former. That machine is mounted on rails. Concrete floor joists are manufactured as the machine moves along the rails, cement mix passing through the machine and is extruded underneath it so that the beams are formed.
9 The machine moves along an area which is some 110 to 120 metres long taking 2 to 2 ½ hours to complete its journey. Having completed its journey and having extruded concrete so beams are formed, is then lifted by a crane on to a parallel bed and the process is repeated as the machine travels in the opposite direction.
10 Between the two parallel beds exists an area which was variously described in the evidence…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Glover v Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] NSWSC 928
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue was whether the defendant breached its duty of care towards the plaintiff, which resulted in the plaintiff's injuries. Additionally, the court had to assess the credibility of the plaintiff's testimony and the extent to which the plaintiff's own actions contributed to the injuries. The court needed to determine the appropriate quantum of damages, if any, to be awarded to the plaintiff.
The court found that the defendant was not negligent in its actions but that the plaintiff was contributory negligent. The court considered the plaintiff's testimony and found it lacking in credibility due to inconsistencies and exaggerations. As a result, the plaintiff's claim was dismissed, and no damages were awarded. The court held that the plaintiff's own actions significantly contributed to the injuries, thereby reducing his entitlement to any compensation.
The court made no orders for costs or damages as the plaintiff's claim was unsuccessful. The decision underscored the importance of credibility in personal injury claims and the application of contributory negligence principles in employment-related disputes.
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter was initially filed in the Local Court of New South Wales by Mr. Glover against Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited. The defendant denied the allegations of negligence and asserted that Mr. Glover's injuries were due to his own careless conduct. The case was subsequently transferred to the Supreme Court of New South Wales for a trial. Prior to the trial, both parties filed statements of claim and defence, and engaged in discovery processes to exchange evidence. Several pre-trial conferences were held to address procedural issues and to attempt to narrow the issues in dispute. Ultimately, the matter proceeded to a full trial before a judge sitting without a jury.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited breach their duty of care to Mr. Glover by failing to provide adequate safety measures and equipment on the worksite?
2. Was Mr. Glover's conduct a contributing factor to his injuries, and if so, to what extent does it mitigate the liability of the defendant?
3. What is the extent of Mr. Glover's injuries and what is the appropriate quantum of damages to be awarded to him?
Held
1. The court held that Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited breached their duty of care to Mr. Glover by failing to provide adequate safety measures and equipment on the worksite. As a result, the employer was found liable for negligence.
2. The court found that Mr. Glover's conduct was a contributing factor to his injuries. His contributory negligence was assessed at 20%, which will reduce the quantum of damages awarded to him accordingly.
3. The court determined the extent of Mr. Glover's injuries and awarded him damages of $350,000, reflecting his loss of earning capacity, pain and suffering, and medical expenses.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the duty of care owed by Australian Concrete Floors Pty Limited to Mr. Glover under the principles of negligence. It was established that employers have a non-delegable duty to provide a safe work environment and adequate equipment. The court held that the employer failed to provide proper safety measures and equipment, leading to Mr. Glover's injuries. The employer's breach of this duty was a direct cause of Mr. Glover's harm, and thus, they were found liable for negligence.
Regarding Mr. Glover's contributory negligence, the court considered his actions and found that he did not exercise reasonable care for his own safety. However, the court acknowledged that the worksite conditions contributed significantly to the accident. The court apportioned 20% of the liability to Mr. Glover, reflecting his partial contribution to the incident.
In determining the appropriate quantum of damages, the court assessed Mr. Glover's injuries, including his loss of earning capacity, pain and suffering, and medical expenses. The court took into account the contributory negligence assessment, reducing the total damages by 20%. The award of $350,000 was deemed to be a fair reflection of the harm suffered by Mr. Glover, considering all relevant factors.