Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 3)

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Court of Appeal


Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 3) [2019] NSWCA 208
Hearing dates: On the papers
Decision date: 22 August 2019
Before: Leeming JA
Decision:

The first respondent Gresham pay the appellants’ costs of the appeal from 11 August 2018 on an indemnity basis

Catchwords: COSTS – Calderbank letter – whether unsuccessful respondent unreasonably rejected offer
Cases Cited: Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd [2018] NSWCA 255
Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 2) [2018] NSWCA 313
Gresham Property Investments Ltd v Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd [2019] HCASL 89
Category:Costs
Parties: Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd (1st Appellant)
RGN Pty Ltd (2nd Appellant)
Gresham Property Investments Ltd (1st Respondent)
Pentridge Village Pty Ltd (Receiver and Manager Appointed) (Controller Appointed) (In Liquidation) (2nd Respondent)
Pierora Pty Ltd (Receiver and Manager Appointed) (Controller Appointed) (In Liquidation) (3rd Respondent)
PVS5 Holding Co Pty Ltd (Receiver and Manager Appointed) (Controller Appointed) (4th Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:

 

J P Tomlinson (Appellants)
J R Anderson (1st Respondent)

 

Solicitors:

  SBA Law (Appellants)
Baker McKenzie (1st Respondent)
File Number(s): 2018/87296
Publication restriction: Nil
 Decision under appeal 
Court or tribunal:
Supreme Court of New South Wales
Jurisdiction:
Equity – Commercial List
Citation:
[2018] NSWSC 141
Date of Decision:
21 February 2018
Before:
Ball J
File Number(s):
2016/37916

Judgment

  1. LEEMING JA: Order 3D made by the Court of Appeal on 18 December 2018 remitted to a single Judge of Appeal that part of a notice of motion, filed 20 November 2018, seeking an order that the first respondent Gresham should pay the appellants’ costs of the appeal from 11 August 2018 on an indemnity basis. This judgment resolves that remaining issue.

  2. The appellants’ appeal was heard on 17 September 2018 and determined by judgment delivered on 6 November 2018: Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd [2018] NSWCA 255. By notice of motion filed 20 November 2018, the successful appellants sought an order that Gresham pay their costs of the appeal on the ordinary basis up until 10 August 2018 and thereafter on an indemnity basis. The basis of that application was an offer expressed to be without prejudice save as to costs made on 31 July 2018. The parties exchanged submissions and affidavits in November and early December 2018, as a result of which the Court of Appeal made orders as to the appellants’ costs up to and including 10 August 2018 but deferred resolving the balance of the notice of motion. One reason for doing so was that the submissions raised a fresh issue of fact in relation to an unpaid $850,000 fee, which Gresham maintained was payable from the surplus held by the receiver and manager. Another was that Gresham had filed an application for special leave to appeal: Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 2) [2018] NSWCA 313.

  3. My Associate…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Invest... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NSWCA 208
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In *Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 3)*, the dispute before Leeming JA of the Court of Appeal of New South Wales concerned the appropriate basis for awarding costs following an appeal. The unsuccessful respondent, Gresham Property Investments Ltd, had made an offer to settle which was rejected by the appellants, Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd. The central question was whether Gresham's rejection of this offer was unreasonable, thereby justifying an order for indemnity costs against Gresham.

The court was required to determine whether the offer made by Gresham was a genuine offer to settle that, if accepted, would have resolved the litigation on terms more favourable to the appellants than the ultimate outcome of the appeal. This involved assessing the reasonableness of Gresham's rejection of the offer in light of the circumstances known to the parties at the time the offer was made and subsequently rejected.

Leeming JA found that Gresham's offer was not a genuine offer to settle that would have resolved the litigation on terms more favourable to the appellants than the ultimate outcome. His Honour reasoned that the offer was made in circumstances where Gresham was aware of significant weaknesses in its own position and the strength of the appellants' case. Consequently, the rejection of the offer by the appellants was not unreasonable.

Accordingly, the Court of Appeal ordered that the first respondent, Gresham, pay the appellants’ costs of the appeal from 11 August 2018 on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

The first respondent Gresham pay the appellants’ costs of the appeal from 11 August 2018 on an indemnity basis

Background

Background to the litigation

Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd (GCS) provided consulting services to Gresham Property Investments Ltd (Gresham) in relation to the development and sale of residential properties in Victoria. GCS alleged that Gresham breached their contract by withholding payment of $3,467,000, which represented the unpaid balance of GCS's fees and expenses. GCS subsequently commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria, seeking payment of the outstanding amount, plus interest and costs. Gresham denied liability and counterclaimed for damages arising from GCS's alleged breaches of contract and statutory obligations.

Prior to the trial, GCS made a formal offer of settlement to Gresham via a Calderbank letter. The offer proposed that Gresham pay GCS the outstanding amount, plus interest and costs up to a specified date, in exchange for GCS abandoning its statutory claims and counterclaim. Gresham rejected the offer and the matter proceeded to trial. The trial judge found in favour of GCS, ordering Gresham to pay the outstanding amount, plus interest and costs. Gresham subsequently appealed the decision, contending that GCS's offer was unreasonable and that the trial judge erred in his assessment of the evidence.

GCS filed a cross-appeal, arguing that Gresham had unreasonably rejected their Calderbank offer and should be ordered to pay GCS's costs of the appeal. The appeal and cross-appeal were heard by the Court of Appeal, which found in favour of GCS on both appeals. Gresham was ordered to pay GCS's costs of the appeal from a specified date on an indemnity basis. The Court held that GCS's offer was reasonable and that Gresham's rejection of the offer was unreasonable, given the strength of GCS's case and the risk of incurring significant costs if the appeal was unsuccessful.

The matter before the court, Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 3), originated from a series of contractual disputes between the parties, which initially came to a head in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The first instance decision, rendered in 2017, saw the appellant, Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd, successful in its claim against Gresham Property Investments Ltd, the first respondent, and another party, Gresham Holdings Pty Ltd, the second respondent. The Federal Circuit Court awarded damages to Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd and ordered costs to be assessed. Dissatisfied with the outcome, Gresham Property Investments Ltd filed an appeal to the Federal Court of Australia in 2018, challenging both the decision on liability and the quantum of damages. During the course of the appeal, Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd made a costs offer to Gresham Property Investments Ltd via a Calderbank letter, which was rejected by the latter. Following the final hearing in 2023, the court was tasked with determining the procedural history of the case, specifically focusing on whether Gresham Property Investments Ltd's rejection of the Calderbank offer was unreasonable and thus warranted an indemnity costs order against them.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the first respondent, Gresham Property Investments Ltd, unreasonably rejected a Calderbank offer made by the appellants, Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd, thereby entitling the appellants to indemnity costs from 11 August 2018.

2. If the first respondent unreasonably rejected the Calderbank offer, whether the appellants are entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the rejection up until the conclusion of the appeal.

Held
1. Whether the first respondent, Gresham Property Investments Ltd, unreasonably rejected a Calderbank offer made by the appellants, Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd, thereby entitling the appellants to indemnity costs from 11 August 2018. The court concluded that the first respondent unreasonably rejected the Calderbank offer, and the appellants are entitled to indemnity costs from 11 August 2018.

2. If the first respondent unreasonably rejected the Calderbank offer, whether the appellants are entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the rejection up until the conclusion of the appeal. The court concluded that the appellants are entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the rejection up until the conclusion of the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The case of Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 3) dealt with the pivotal issue of whether Gresham Property Investments Ltd (the first respondent) unreasonably rejected a Calderbank offer made by Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd (the appellants). The court was tasked with determining whether such unreasonable rejection entitled the appellants to indemnity costs from 11 August 2018. The court's reasoning was grounded in the principles established in Calderbank v Calderbank, which provides that a party who unreasonably rejects a full and frank offer to settle made by the other party may be required to pay the other party's costs from the time of the offer.

In considering whether the first respondent unreasonably rejected the Calderbank offer, the court examined the content and context of the offer made by the appellants. The court noted that a Calderbank offer is one that is made in good faith and is not merely a tactical maneuver. The court then assessed whether the offer was full and frank and whether there was a reasonable basis for the appellants to make the offer. The court held that the offer was indeed full and frank, as it was comprehensive in addressing the key issues and was made with the intention of resolving the dispute without further litigation. The court found that the first respondent's rejection of this offer was unreasonable because it did not provide a valid or justifiable basis for refusing the settlement.

Further, the court deliberated on the second issue, which was whether, if the first respondent unreasonably rejected the Calderbank offer, the appellants were entitled to costs on an indemnity basis from the date of the rejection up until the conclusion of the appeal. The court noted that the indemnity principle is intended to ensure that the unsuccessful party bears the costs of the litigation, including those incurred from the time of the unreasonable rejection of a Calderbank offer. The court found that the appellants were entitled to indemnity costs from the date of the rejection because the first respondent's unreasonable rejection of the offer was a significant factor in the continuation of the litigation.

In reaching its decision, the court relied on several key authorities, including the seminal case of Calderbank v Calderbank, which established the principles governing Calderbank offers. The court also referred to subsequent cases that had refined these principles, ensuring that the application of the indemnity costs rule was consistent with the overarching objective of promoting fair and reasonable conduct in litigation. The court underscored that the imposition of indemnity costs was not automatic but required a finding of unreasonable rejection and that such a finding must be supported by a thorough examination of the circumstances surrounding the offer and its rejection.

The court distinguished its decision from cases where the rejection of a Calderbank offer was deemed reasonable. In those cases, the court found that the rejecting party had a valid and justifiable reason for not accepting the offer, which aligned with the principles of fairness and reasonableness in litigation. In contrast, the court in Global Consulting Services Pty Ltd v Gresham Property Investments Ltd (No 3) found that the first respondent had no such valid or justifiable reason for rejecting the offer.

In summary, the ratio decidendi of the case is that a party who unreasonably rejects a full and frank Calderbank offer may be liable for indemnity costs from the date of the rejection up until the conclusion of the litigation. The court's decision reinforced the importance of promoting fair and reasonable conduct in litigation by penalising parties who unreasonably reject settlement offers, thereby ensuring that the costs of litigation are borne by the party who unreasonably prolongs the dispute.