Glenn William Starr v Insurance Australia Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

District Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Glenn William Starr v Insurance Australia Limited [2017] NSWDC 284
Hearing dates: 10, 11 and 12 October 2017
Date of orders: 20 October 2017
Decision date: 20 October 2017
Jurisdiction:Civil
Before: Judge D. Russell
Decision:

(1) Judgment for the defendant.
(2) Order the plaintiffs to pay the defendant’s costs.
(3) Grant leave to the parties to approach my Associate, should either party wish to seek a different costs order.
(4) Order that the costs payable by the plaintiffs to the defendant be on the ordinary basis up to and including 25 July 2017 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

Catchwords: INSURANCE – home and contents – home destroyed by fire – contract of indemnity – sum insured – insured only entitled to indemnity – reasonable cost of rebuilding – quotes – estimates
Cases Cited: Mobis Parts Australia Pty Ltd v XL Insurance Co SE (No. 7) [2017] NSWSC 1321
Kenwright v Insurance Australia Limited [2013] NSWDC 255
Raso v NRMA Insurance (New South Wales Court of Appeal, 14 December 1992, unreported)
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Glenn William Starr (first plaintiff)
Tanya Nieuwendyk (second plaintiff)
Insurance Australia Limited (defendant)
Representation:

Counsel:
S. McCarthy (plaintiff)
D. Weinberger (defendant)

  Solicitors:
Laxon Lex (plaintiff)
Holman Webb (defendant)
File Number(s): 2016/00154366

Judgment

INTRODUCTION

  1. The plaintiffs are the owners of a rural property at 104 Yarras Lane at Forrest Grove which is between Lithgow and Bathurst. They insured their property with the defendant.

  2. On 3 September 2015 their home on the property was totally destroyed by fire. A swimming pool near the house was also damaged at that time.

  3. The plaintiffs claimed upon the defendant under the contract of insurance. The defendant offered to pay $494,414 which it asserted was the reasonable cost of re-building the home. It was not disputed that the home could not be repaired.

  4. The plaintiffs eventually accepted the payment of $494,414 but without prejudice to their right to claim more under the policy. The plaintiffs commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court against the defendant, and those proceedings were later transferred to this court.

  5. The plaintiff’s brought their claim on two grounds:

  1. The plaintiffs asserted that they were entitled to be paid $854,437 instead of the amount proffered by the insurance company – the difference being $360,023;

  2. In the alternative, the plaintiffs asserted that the amount proffered and paid by the insurance company did not represent the reasonable cost of re-building the home and the pool.

THE POLICY

  1. The plaintiffs insured their property with the defendant under an NRMA Insurance Home Plus Buildings and Contents Policy (the policy). They initially took out the policy in 2011 and renewed it year by year, the last renewal before the fire being on 2 August 2015. References to page numbers below are references to page numbers in the policy.

  2. The policy is a “plain English” policy. It states that the insurer covers the home and contents “when certain things happen – for example, fire” (p 25).…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Glenn William Starr v Insurance Australia Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWDC 284
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Glenn William Starr and Insurance Australia Limited, with Starr being the policyholder and Insurance Australia the insurer. Starr claimed compensation for the destruction of his home by fire, arguing that he was entitled to the sum insured under the home and contents policy. The dispute centred on the interpretation of the contract of indemnity and the amount Starr was legally entitled to receive for the damages. The case was heard in the relevant court, which provided a decision on the matter.

The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation of the insurance contract and the determination of the reasonable cost of rebuilding Starr’s home. The court had to decide whether Starr was entitled to the full sum insured or if the amount was to be limited to the reasonable cost of rebuilding. Starr provided quotes and estimates to support his claim for the full insured amount, while Insurance Australia argued that the contract limited the payout to the reasonable cost of rebuilding. The court's task was to interpret the contract terms and apply them to the facts of the case to determine the appropriate compensation.

The court found in favour of Insurance Australia, concluding that Starr was only entitled to an indemnity for the reasonable cost of rebuilding his home, not the full sum insured. The court meticulously reviewed the policy documents, Starr’s quotes, and the legal principles governing insurance contracts. It determined that the contract did not entitle Starr to the full insured amount but rather to compensation for the actual cost of repairs. The court held that Starr's estimates did not sufficiently prove the reasonable cost of rebuilding to warrant the full payout. Therefore, the judgment was in favour of the defendant.

The final orders included a judgment for Insurance Australia, an order for Starr to pay the defendant’s costs, the granting of leave to seek a different costs order if desired, and a specific order regarding the basis of the costs payable by Starr to Insurance Australia. The court ruled that Starr must pay the defendant’s costs on the ordinary basis up to and including 25 July 2017 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Judgment for the defendant.

(2) Order the plaintiffs to pay the defendant’s costs.

(3) Grant leave to the parties to approach my Associate, should either party wish to seek a different costs order.

(4) Order that the costs payable by the plaintiffs to the defendant be on the ordinary basis up to and including 25 July 2017 and thereafter on an indemnity basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.