Background
Background to the litigation
The Minister opposes the application. For the reasons that follow, I have found that the applicants have not established that the Tribunal’s decision is affected by jurisdictional error. The application for judicial review is, therefore, dismissed.BACKGROUND The applicants are husband and wife. Both are citizens of Malaysia (CB 92, 117). The first applicant (applicant) arrived in Australia on 1 April 2014 as the holder of an Electronic Travel Authority (ETA). The applicant’s ETA expired on 1 July 2014 (CB 177). The second applicant arrived in Australia on 30 September 2015 also as the holder of an ETA. Her ETA expired on 30 December 2015 (CB 178).Visa applications On 4 April 2016, the applicant lodged an application for the visa which was dated 12 March 2016 (CB 1-54). The second applicant lodged her application for the visa on 11 April 2016 (CB 148). On 10 June 2016, the applicant was advised by the then-named Department of Immigration and Border Protection that his visa application was invalid (CB 55-58). On 10 October 2016, the Department received further visa applications dated 5 October 2016 (CB 59-142). Accordingly, two separate sets of visa applications have been lodged by the applicants in respect of their protection claims. In his initial application, the applicant explained his reasons for claiming protection so that he did not have to return to Malaysia as follows (CB 30-32):Why did you leave that country? I leave that country because I want to get protection from Australia. My life are not safe, i have debt that ruin my whole life. Me and my friend owe sum money from black market called Along (sic) at that time to setup a business, but then he misuse the money. He took the money and gambling until lost. I have to repay the debt but the interest getting higher everyday. My friend has runaway and left me with the debt until I got warn if I didn't pay the money on time with full amount, they will kill me and my family. I have moved my parents to other part of that country to make them safe and my parents ask me to stay away from Malaysia for the time being until they got money to repay back.What do you think will happen if you return to that country?If i return back to that country, my life and my parents life will getting worst. I don't want to go back for the meantime, the black market people did warning me, if i didn't repay the debt on time, i need to work with them in black market group or else they will kill me.Do you think you will be harmed or mistreated turn to that country?Yes, i don't want to live in the fear and chaos environment, if in return back to that country.Do you think the authorities of that country can and will protect you if you go back? Give details about why you think the authorities could not, or would not, protect youNo.For now i don't think authorities at that country will protect me because everyone in that country, they just ease to stay away from those who in trouble.Do you think you would be able to relocate within that country? Give details about why you are unable to relocateNo, i need a shelter to protect my self and to start new life so that I can keep my family and repay back the black market money after they cool down.Did you experience harm in that country?Yes, i had experienced harm in that country. Those black market people had burned my stall, smashed my car with baseball wood, send me black letter to kill me.Did you seek help within the country after the harm? Give details (including the name of the person/organisation/authorities you asked for help, and if they helped you, what they did)Yes, i did tried moved to other part of that country with my family but my parents ask me to stay away from Malaysia because they does not want me to get killed and getting worst.Did you move, or try to move, to another part of the country to seek safety? Give details (including where you tried to move, why you were unable to move or where you moved to and what happened)Yes, i don't want to live in the fear and chaos environment, if in return back to that country.
Decision
Reasons for decision
The second applicant referred to her husband’s claims in her own application (CB 135-137).Delegate’s Decision On 6 January 2017, a delegate of the Minister (the delegate) refused to grant the applicants visas (CB 143-163). The delegate found that the applicants were not persons in respect of whom Australia has protection obligations as set out in ss 36(2)(a) or (aa) of the Act. The delegate also found they were not members of the same family unit as a non-citizen in respect of whom the Minister was satisfied Australia has protection obligations and who holds a Protection visa of the same class as that applied for by the applicant (ss 36(2)(b) and (c) of the Act). In reaching their conclusion regarding the complementary protection criteria, the delegate stated (CB 162):34. I note that the applicants have outlined their situation in minimal detail and with no supporting evidence. I also note the delay in which it took for the applicants to lodge a protection visa, particularly in reference to Applicant l. Applicant l arrived in Australia on l April 2014 and lodged an application for protection on 10 June 2016, more than two years after his arrival. While Applicant 2 applied some 15 months after her arrival. I consider it reasonable to expect that individual in the applicants' circumstances would seek to engage Australia’s protection obligations as soon as possible. Overall, I consider that such a delay tends to weigh strongly against the sincerity, or at least the depth, of their stated fear of being harmed in their home country.Application for review to the Tribunal On 3 February 2017, the applicants applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision (CB 164-170). By letter dated 8 February 2017, the Tribunal acknowledged receipt of the applications. The applicants were advised that if they wished to provide material or written arguments for the Tribunal to consider, they should do so as soon as possible (CB 172-173). On 27 July 2018, the Tribunal wrote to the applicants inviting them to attend a hearing on 22 August 2018 to give evidence and present arguments relating to the issues arising in their case (CB 179-181). On 22 August 2018, the applicants appeared before the Tribunal with the assistance of a Malay interpreter (CB 189-191). The hearing record records that the hearing commenced at 9:09 AM and concluded at 11:05 AM. It also records that “no documents were submitted during preliminaries”. On 27 September 2018, the Tribunal wrote to the applicants inviting them to comment on or respond to certain information which it considered would, subject to their comments or response, be the reason, or a part of the reason, for affirming the decisions under review (CB 192-202). The particulars of the information were as follows:· In his first application for a protection visa (later deemed invalid), lodged on 4 April 2016, [the first applicant] claimed that after he and a friend borrowed some money from the black market money lender called A Long, his friend took the money and gambled and lost it. His friend then ran away and he had to repay the debt, but the interest rose every day. [The first applicant] claimed that "I get warn if I didn't pay the money on time with full amount, they will kill me and my family. I have moved my parents to other part of that country to make them safe." He said that he did experience harm in Malaysia. "Those black market people had burned my stall, smashed my car with baseball wood, send me black letter to kill me." In his second application, lodged on 7 October 2016, [the first applicant] did not mention a friend with whom he borrowed money or any threats to his family. He said he borrowed money to start a business but couldn't start the business as planned. The money lender started to torture him asking for money, but he couldn't pay back the money. The money lender started to give 'us' a lot of problem. "He whacked me very badly and also beat my wife in front of me." He also claimed that things got worse ''when the money lender send some gangsters to kill me and my wife. We were both very scared and ran away from there to save my life."· In her application for a protection visa lodged in October 2016, [the second applicant] referred to her husband's claim and claimed that she experienced harm in Malaysia because ''we were whacked very badly and they try to kill us.' She also later claims: "we were beaten and tortured, they also want to kill us".· At hearing, [the first applicant] gave evidence that he met [the second applicant] in Malaysia before he came to Australia in 2014, but they became closer and married whilst in Australia. He gave evidence that the money lenders did not threaten or beat her in front of him at any stage or threaten to kill 'him and his wife' at any stage, as they had not married before he left Malaysia in 2014.· At hearing, [the second applicant] also gave evidence that she met and married [the first applicant] in Australia but said she did not know him at all before she came to Australia. She gave evidence that she has never been threatened or beaten by the money lenders as claimed in her application for protection. [The second applicant’s] visa history indicates that she arrived in Australia on 30 September 2015.· All claim forms have the questions "Did you seek help within the country after the harm ? .. Give details (including the name of the person/authorities you asked for help, and if they helped you, what they did)." In his first claim, [the first applicant] responded "Yes, I did tried to move to other part of that country with my family but my parents ask me to stay away from Malaysia because they does not want me to get killed and getting worst." He does not mention reporting the matter to the police. In his second claim, [the first applicant] responded "Yes we went to the police but they didn't help us." [The second applicant’s] application for protection lodged in October 2016 contained the same words as [the first applicant’s] second application.· At hearing [the first applicant] gave evidence that he went to the police after he was physically assaulted. The police talked to him at the counter, and he made a report and was told that they would investigate. However, they didn't help and didn't care. [The second applicant’s] evidence, as noted above, was that she did not know [the first applicant] at that time, despite the information in her written claim.· At the Tribunal hearing, [the first applicant] gave evidence that he and a friend borrowed money about one month before he left Malaysia. His evidence is that they repaid it for about two weeks until his friend abandoned him, though he was not sure how much they paid or even how often. He later said that he moved when the money lender started harassing him and was in his new address for about one month before departing for Australia, and was not located by the money lenders in his new address. At that time, he said he was living in [Location A], where he had lived for about two years with the friend referred to in his claims. The timing in the claims/evidence given at each stage about the alleged loan, repayments, lapsing repayment and [the first applicant’s] departure from Malaysia appears internally inconsistent.· In his first application for protection [the first applicant] claimed that he lived in [Location B] from birth to March 2014). In neither application does he provide any information about residence in [Location A], despite his evidence at hearing that he lived there for more than two years.· [The first applicant] gave evidence at hearing that he was required to make daily payments on a loan of 20,000 Malaysian Ringit, and that interest alone was 100 ringit per day at least. He could not recall how much he was required to pay or how often. He could not recall ever being sent a 'black letter'. He said he was only assaulted on one occasion. On that occasion, they grabbed him by the throat and threatened that if he didn't pay, they would kill him. This caused him to move his home.· [The first applicant] gave evidence during the hearing that he did initially try to repay the loan from Australia, but he had no knowledge or job when he arrived. He is unaware how much is outstanding. He later said that he has not actually paid or tried to pay the loan at all since he came to Australia.· [The first applicant] and [the second applicant] each said at hearing that they believed that the money lenders were active and could track them throughout the country. However, as noted above, [the first applicant] gave evidence that the money lender did not find him in his new home where he lived for about one month before leaving Malaysia and also that they have not located his family in [Location B] or made enquiries of them about his whereabouts since he left the country.· [The first applicant] arrived in Australia on 1 April 2014. He first applied for protection on 4 April 2016. This significant delay in seeking protection might be considered to suggest that [the first applicant] was not in fear of harm from any person in Malaysia at the time he arrived in Australia.