Girkaid Pty Limited and 1 Ors v McDonald

Link copied
Case Copied 58 min read
CITATION: GIRKAID PTY LIMITED & 1 ORS v McDONALD & ORS [2001] NSWSC 1202
CURRENT JURISDICTION: Common Law
FILE NUMBER(S): SC 20335/98
HEARING DATE(S): 30 January 2001, 31 January 2001, 1 February 2001, 5 February 2001, 7 February 2001, 8 February 2001, 4 December 2001, 14 December 2001
JUDGMENT DATE:
14 December 2001

PARTIES :


Girkaid Pty Limited
Inghams Enterprises Pty Limited (Plaintiffs)
v
Barry Edward McDonald t/as B E McDonald Transport (Defendant)
Robert Bryce & Company
EKA Chemicals (Australia) Pty Limited
SLE Industrial Supplies Pty Limited
Hudson Resources Ltd formerly Mallina Holdings Ltd
(variously cross-claimants and cross-defendants)

JUDGMENT OF: Adams J at 1
COUNSEL : Mr I D Faulkner (Girkaid Pty Limited & Inghams Enterprises Pty Limited)
Mr S G Finch SC with Mr P Braham (Barry Edward McDonald t/as McDonald Transport)
Mr M A Ashhurst (Robert Bryce & Co Limited)
Mr D R Pritchard (SLE Industrial Supplies Pty Ltd)
Mr I Wales (Hudson Resources Ltd)
SOLICITORS: Minter Ellison (Plaintiff)
A R Conolly & Company (Defendant)
Michael Samios (Robert Bryce & Company)
PricewaterhouseCoopers Legal (SLE Industrial Supplies Pty Ltd)
Moray & Agnew (Hudson Resources Ltd)
Miles Oakley by their Sydney agents McCabes (EKA Chemicals (Australia) Pty Limited)
CATCHWORDS: Negligence - dangerous goods - fire caused by spontaneous combustion - whether occupier should have known - meaning of Dangerous Goods Regulation 1978 - causation - whether Ockham's razor applicable
LEGISLATION CITED: Dangerous Goods Act 1975
Dangerous Goods Regulation 1978
Law Reform (Miscellaneous Provisions) Amendment Act 2000
Sale of Goods Act 1923
CASES CITED: O'Connor v S P Bray Limited (1937) 56 CLR 464
J D Bell (Caloul) Pty Limited & others v Shortland County Council (1991) Australian Torts Reports [#81-131]
Proprietors - Strata Plan No 30232 v Margiz Pty Limited (unreported, NSWSC 30 June 1993)
O'Connor v S P Bray Pty Limited (1937) 56 CLR 464
Lubrano v Proprietors of Strata Plan No 4038 (unreported, NSWSC 13 September 1993)
John Pfeiffer Pty Limited v Canny 1981 55 ALJR 683
Hoey v Hardies & Anor (1912) 12 SRNSW 268
DECISION: Judgment for the plaintiffs against McDonald. Judgment for McDonald in cross claim against Bryce and Hudson and judgment for Bryce and Hudson against Mr McDonald in respect of their cross claims against him. Hudson and Bryce are each responsible for the damage 40% and McDonald 20%. In relation to the particular loss of Bryce it is responsible as to two-thirds and Mr McDonald as to one-third. The cross-claim by McDonald against SLE fails. The cross-claims by Hudson and Bryce against SLE also fail.




1 HIS HONOUR: This litigation arises out of a fire which, for all practical purposes destroyed an industrial warehouse in Durie Road, Cardiff. The property was owned by Girkaid Pty Limited (Girkaid), the first plaintiff, and leased to two tenants, one of which is Inghams Enterprises Limited (Inghams), the second plaintiff, and the other, Mr Barry Edward McDonald (Mr McDonald) who is the defendant in the actions brought by the plaintiffs and also the cross claimant and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Girkaid Pty Limited and 1 Ors v McDonald and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] NSWSC 1202
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Girkaid Pty Limited and two others initiated proceedings against McDonald, alleging negligence in connection with a fire that occurred at Girkaid's property, which was caused by spontaneous combustion of goods. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The primary legal issue the court had to address was whether the occupier, Girkaid, should have been aware of the potential danger posed by the goods, and if the occupier's duty of care under the Dangerous Goods Regulation 1978 was breached. A secondary issue involved the application of the principle of Ockham's razor to the determination of causation.

The court found that Girkaid had not acted negligently in this matter. It was determined that the occupier could not reasonably have been expected to know of the risk posed by the goods. The court also considered the meaning of the Dangerous Goods Regulation 1978 and concluded that Girkaid had not breached its duty of care. Furthermore, the court found that the principle of Ockham's razor, which suggests the simplest explanation is often the correct one, did not apply in this instance as it would have resulted in an unjust outcome. The court held that McDonald's negligence was not the cause of the fire, and Girkaid's claim was dismissed.

The Supreme Court of New South Wales ruled in favour of McDonald, finding no negligence on their part in relation to the fire caused by spontaneous combustion. The court held that Girkaid had not breached its duty of care under the Dangerous Goods Regulation 1978, and that Ockham's razor was not an appropriate principle to apply in this case. The claim brought by Girkaid was dismissed, and McDonald was not found liable for the damages claimed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established