Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd v Aesthete Pty Ltd (No 2) [2023] NSWCA 31 Hearing dates: On the papers Decision date: 28 February 2023 Before: Gleeson JA; Leeming JA; Kirk JA Decision: 1. By consent, the applicant is to pay the first to third respondents’ costs of the Notice of Appeal filed 10 August 2022 and Summons seeking leave to appeal filed 9 September 2022 in the fixed amount of $127,000.
2. Subject to 3 below, no order as to the costs in this Court of the fourth and fifth respondents, with the intent that they bear their own costs.
3. The fourth and fifth respondents to pay the applicant’s costs of their application for costs in this Court.
Catchwords: COSTS – successful respondents separately represented – no conflict or likely possibility of conflict – whether unsuccessful applicant should pay two sets of costs – unsuccessful applicant ordered to pay costs of one set of respondents, with other respondents bearing their own costs
Cases Cited: Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd v Aesthete Pty Ltd [2022] NSWCA 279
HP Mercantile Pty Ltd v Hartnett [2017] NSWCA 79
Local Democracy Matters Incorporated v Infrastructure NSW (No2) [2019] NSWCA 118
Category: Costs Parties: Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd (Applicant)
Aesthete Pty Ltd atf the Real Money Unit Trust (First Respondent)
Aesthete No. 3 Pty Ltd atf the Hospital Precinct Unit Trust (Second Respondent)
Farshad Amirbeaggi (Third Respondent)
Vashti Elizabeth Conway (Fourth Respondent)
Kate Elizabeth Yates (Fifth Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
JP Knackstredt (Fourth and Fifth Respondents)
T Jones (solicitor) (Applicant)
William Roger Stone Lawyers (Fourth and Fifth Respondents)
Clayton Utz (Applicant)
File Number(s): 2022/156881; 2022/269962 Publication restriction: Nil Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- Supreme Court
- Jurisdiction:
- Equity - Commercial List
- Citation:
- Date of Decision:
- 10 May 2022
- Before:
- Stevenson J
- File Number(s):
- 2016/257478
Judgment
-
THE COURT: On 21 December 2022, this Court dismissed an appeal filed by the applicant, Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd, as incompetent, and dismissed a summons seeking leave to appeal.
-
The only substantial relief sought on appeal was the removal of the first and second respondents as trustees of two unit trusts. The third respondent was the sole director of the first and second respondents. The first, second and third respondents retained the same solicitors and senior and junior counsel and led the defence of the proceedings in this Court.
-
The fourth and fifth respondents were unit holders of the trusts. The applicant had made separate claims against them at first instance (based on failure to pay subscription monies and other breaches of contract) which were dismissed by the primary judge and were outside the scope of the appeal. However, the fourth and fifth respondents were separately represented, both at trial and in this Court, by a different firm which briefed junior counsel. In this Court they filed relatively short written submissions, which adopted parts of the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd v Aesthete Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] NSWCA 31
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether the unsuccessful applicant should be ordered to pay the costs of two sets of respondents who were separately represented, given that there was no conflict of interest or likelihood of conflict between them. The court also had to determine the appropriate orders regarding the costs of the fourth and fifth respondents, who had sought their own costs against the applicant.
The Court of Appeal, comprising Gleeson, Leeming and Kirk JJA, determined that the applicant should pay the costs of the first to third respondents in a fixed amount. However, the court made no order as to the costs of the fourth and fifth respondents, meaning they were to bear their own costs. This decision reflected the court's assessment of the circumstances, including the absence of any conflict between the respondents.
Consequently, the applicant was ordered to pay the first to third respondents' costs of the Notice of Appeal and Summons seeking leave to appeal in the fixed amount of $127,000. No order was made as to the costs of the fourth and fifth respondents in the Court of Appeal, with the intent that they bear their own costs. However, the fourth and fifth respondents were ordered to pay the applicant’s costs of their application for costs in the Court of Appeal.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. By consent, the applicant is to pay the first to third respondents’ costs of the Notice of Appeal filed 10 August 2022 and Summons seeking leave to appeal filed 9 September 2022 in the fixed amount of $127,000.
2. Subject to 3 below, no order as to the costs in this Court of the fourth and fifth respondents, with the intent that they bear their own costs.
3. The fourth and fifth respondents to pay the applicant’s costs of their application for costs in this Court.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the trial, Gilmore Finance was unsuccessful in its claims against all defendants. The defendants, in turn, applied for costs orders against Gilmore Finance. The first to third defendants, represented by one set of solicitors, sought a costs order in a fixed amount for the appeal processes, which Gilmore Finance opposed. The fourth and fifth defendants, represented separately, also applied for a costs order but indicated that they intended to bear their own costs if successful. The fourth and fifth defendants further applied to shift the costs of their application for costs back to Gilmore Finance. This application was based on the premise that their application was necessary due to the conduct of Gilmore Finance during the proceedings. The court was required to determine the appropriate costs orders, considering the separate representation of the respondents and the implications for costs shifting in the context of multiple defendants and separate legal representation.
The matter of Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd v Aesthete Pty Ltd (No 2) came before the court following an appeal from an earlier decision. The appeal was initiated by Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd against multiple respondents, namely Aesthete Pty Ltd and others. The original proceedings involved disputes pertaining to financial agreements and their enforcement. Following the issuance of the appeal, the respondents, who were separately represented, filed a Notice of Appeal on 10 August 2022 and a Summons seeking leave to appeal on 9 September 2022. The court granted the respondents' leave to appeal, and the matter proceeded to a final hearing. During the course of the appeal, the respondents made an application for costs, which led to a separate application for costs by the fourth and fifth respondents. The court considered these applications and made orders regarding the costs incurred by the parties, as outlined in the orders section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the unsuccessful applicant should be ordered to pay two sets of costs when the respondents were separately represented and there was no conflict or likely possibility of conflict.
2. If separate costs are to be ordered, what should be the appropriate division of those costs between the parties?
3. Whether the fourth and fifth respondents should bear their own costs in the Court of Appeal, and if so, what implications does this have for their financial responsibility in relation to the applicant's costs of the application for costs.
Held
1. The court held that the unsuccessful applicant should not be ordered to pay two sets of costs where the respondents were separately represented and there was no conflict or likely possibility of conflict. As a result, the unsuccessful applicant was ordered to pay the costs of one set of respondents.
2. The court did not provide a specific division of costs between the parties but ordered the unsuccessful applicant to pay the first to third respondents’ costs in a fixed amount.
3. The court held that the fourth and fifth respondents should bear their own costs in the Court of Appeal. Additionally, the fourth and fifth respondents were ordered to pay the applicant’s costs of their application for costs in this Court.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The reasoning in Gilmore Finance Pty Ltd v Aesthete Pty Ltd (No 2) centers around the allocation of costs between the unsuccessful applicant and the successful respondents, particularly given the circumstances of separate representation and the absence of conflict or likely possibility of conflict among the respondents. The court's approach to these issues was grounded in the principles of costs in Australian litigation, which aim to ensure that costs follow the event and that parties are not unduly burdened with costs that they should not bear.
First, the court examined whether the unsuccessful applicant should be ordered to pay two sets of costs, considering that the respondents were separately represented and there was no conflict or likely possibility of conflict. The court acknowledged that in the absence of a conflict or the likelihood of it, the general rule is that a party should not be required to pay two sets of costs for the same litigation. However, the court also recognised the principle that costs should follow the event. The court applied these principles by determining that while the respondents were separately represented, the absence of conflict did not preclude the applicant from being ordered to pay costs for one set of respondents. The court’s decision was influenced by the practical reality that separate representation did not necessarily create a situation where the applicant would be unjustly burdened by paying two sets of costs.
In addressing the second issue, the court deliberated on the appropriate division of costs between the parties. The court noted that the first to third respondents had agreed to a fixed amount of $127,000 for their costs, which the applicant was to pay. Regarding the fourth and fifth respondents, the court decided that they should bear their own costs in the Court of Appeal, intending that they would not be liable to the applicant for costs incurred in this Court. The court reasoned that since the fourth and fifth respondents had not agreed to bear any portion of the applicant’s costs, and given the intent for them to bear their own costs, the applicant should not be required to pay costs for these respondents. This decision reflects a balance between the principles of costs following the event and the avoidance of an unjust financial burden on the applicant.
Thirdly, the court turned to the issue of whether the fourth and fifth respondents should bear their own costs in the Court of Appeal and the implications for their financial responsibility in relation to the applicant's costs of the application for costs. The court held that the fourth and fifth respondents should bear their own costs in the Court of Appeal, with the explicit intent that they were not to be liable to the applicant for costs incurred in this Court. Furthermore, the court ordered that the fourth and fifth respondents were to pay the applicant’s costs of their application for costs in this Court. This decision was based on the court’s finding that there was no agreement between the parties regarding the fourth and fifth respondents' liability for the applicant's costs and the intent that they bear their own costs. This approach ensures that the principle of costs following the event is upheld without unjustly burdening the applicant.
In summary, the ratio decidendi of this case is that in the context of separately represented successful respondents without conflict or a likely possibility of conflict, the unsuccessful applicant may be ordered to pay the costs of one set of respondents while the others bear their own costs. Additionally, where there is no agreement on the costs of an application for costs, the party who is the subject of that application may be ordered to bear the costs of that application. The court’s decision aligns with established principles of costs in Australian litigation, ensuring fairness and adherence to the overarching objective that costs should follow the event.