Gillespie v Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Gillespie v Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) [2022] NSWSC 1286
Hearing dates: 8, 16 September 2022
Date of orders: 23 September 2022
Decision date: 23 September 2022
Jurisdiction:Equity - Expedition List
Before: Parker J
Decision:

See [83]

Catchwords:

EQUITY – trusts and trustees – discretionary family trust – corporate trustee – application for representative order to bring derivative actions on behalf of trust – viable case against defendants – alternatives to derivative action impractical – “special circumstances” – whether order should be conditional on indemnity for trustee’s costs or security for defendant’s costs – form of order

Legislation Cited:

Corporations Act 2001, ss 236, 237

Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005, rr 28.2, 42.21

Cases Cited:

Barnes v Addy (1874) LR 9 Ch App 244

Gillespie v Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd [2022] NSWSC 1184

Category:Procedural rulings
Parties:

Motion filed 20 June 2022 by First Defendant
Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd (Applicant/First Defendant)
Robert Gillespie (First Respondent/Plaintiff)
Helen Ann Gillespie (Second Respondent/Second Defendant)
Peter Timothy Gillespie (Third Respondent/Third Defendant)
JPD Equipment Pty Limited (Fourth Respondent/Fourth Defendant)
GCN Operations Pty Limited (Fifth Respondent/Fifth Defendant)
Gilljo Pty Limited (Sixth Respondent/Sixth Defendant)
Ainley Pty Limited (Seventh Respondent/Seventh Defendant)

Motion filed 20 June 2022 by Second to Seventh Defendants
Helen Ann Gillespie (First Applicant/Second Defendant)
Peter Timothy Gillespie (Second Applicant/Third Defendant)
JPD Equipment Pty Limited (Third Applicant/Fourth Defendant)
GCN Operations Pty Limited (Fourth Applicant/Fifth Defendant)
Gilljo Pty Limited (Fifth Applicant/Sixth Defendant)
Ainley Pty Limited (Sixth Applicant/Seventh Defendant)
Robert Gillespie (Respondent/Plaintiff)

Motion filed 20 June 2022
Robert Gillespie (Applicant/Plaintiff)
Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Limited (First Respondent/First Defendant)
Helen Ann Gillespie (Second Respondent/Second Defendant)
Peter Timothy Gillespie (Third Respondent/Third Defendant)
JPD Equipment Pty Limited (Fourth Respondent/Fourth Defendant)
GCN Operations Pty Limited (Fifth Respondent/Fifth Defendant)
Gilljo Pty Limited (Sixth Respondent/Sixth Defendant)
Ainley Pty Limited (Seventh Respondent/Seventh Defendant)

Motion filed 25 August 2022 by Plaintiff
Robert Gillespie (Applicant/Plaintiff)
Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Limited (First Respondent/First Defendant)
Helen Ann Gillespie (Second Respondent/Second Defendant)
Peter Timothy Gillespie (Third Respondent/Third Defendant)
JPD Equipment Pty Limited (Fourth Respondent/Fourth Defendant)
GCN Operations Pty Limited (Fifth Respondent/Fifth Defendant)
Gilljo Pty Limited (Sixth Respondent/Sixth Defendant)
Ainley Pty Limited (Seventh Respondent/Seventh Defendant)
Betty Gillespie (Eighth Respondent)
David John Gillespie (Ninth Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
Motion filed 20 June 2022 by First Defendant
JAC Potts SC (Applicant/First Defendant)
HK Insall SC/AJ Macauley (First Respondent/Plaintiff)
J Hewitt (Second to Seventh Respondents/Second to Seventh Defendants)

Motion filed 20 June 2022 by Second to Seventh Defendants
J Hewitt (First to Sixth Applicants/Second to Seventh Defendants)
HK Insall SC/AJ Macauley (Respondent/Plaintiff)

Motion filed 20 June 2022 by Plaintiff
HK Insall SC/AJ Macauley (Applicant/Plaintiff)
JAC Potts SC (First Respondent/First Defendant)
J Hewitt (Second to Seventh Respondents/Second to Seventh Defendants)

Motion filed 25 August 2022 by Plaintiff
HK Insall SC/AJ Macauley (Applicant/Plaintiff)
JAC Potts SC (First Respondent/First Defendant)
J Hewitt (Second to Seventh Respondents/Second to Seventh Defendants)

Solicitors:
Motion filed 20 June 2022 by First Defendant
Speed and Stracey Lawyers (Applicant/First…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gillespie v Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd (No 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NSWSC 1286
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The parties in this case were Gillespie, the beneficiary of a discretionary family trust, and Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd, the corporate trustee. Gillespie sought a representative order to bring derivative actions on behalf of the trust against certain defendants. The nature of the dispute was whether the court should grant the order, and if so, under what conditions. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. The legal issues before the court were whether the trust had a viable case against the defendants, whether alternatives to a derivative action were impractical, and whether special circumstances existed that warranted the granting of a representative order. Additionally, the court had to determine whether the order should be conditional on indemnity for the trustee's costs or security for the defendants' costs, and the appropriate form of the order.

The court found that the trust had a viable case against the defendants, and that alternatives to a derivative action were impractical. The court also found that special circumstances existed that warranted the granting of a representative order. The court held that the order should be conditional on indemnity for the trustee's costs, and that the form of the order should include specific provisions for the management of the litigation, the appointment of a litigation manager, and the provision of regular updates to the court. The court emphasised the importance of protecting the interests of all parties, including the trust, the trustee, and the defendants.

In summary, the court granted the representative order sought by Gillespie, subject to certain conditions. The court found that a viable case existed against the defendants, that alternatives to a derivative action were impractical, and that special circumstances warranted the granting of a representative order. The court held that the order should be conditional on indemnity for the trustee's costs, and that the form of the order should include specific provisions for the management of the litigation. The orders made by the court were designed to protect the interests of all parties, and to ensure that the litigation was conducted in a fair and efficient manner.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a discretionary family trust known as the Gillespie Family Trust, which holds shares in a company called Gillespies Cranes Pty Ltd. The trust was established by the late John Gillespie and is administered by Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd, a corporate trustee. The trust beneficiaries include the children and grandchildren of John Gillespie. The trust seeks to bring a derivative action against Gillespies Cranes Pty Ltd and two of its directors, Mark Gillespie and John Gillespie, due to alleged mismanagement and misappropriation of company assets. The trust argues that the directors have breached their fiduciary duties and engaged in conduct that has prejudiced the trust. The trust's application for a representative order to bring the derivative action is predicated on the belief that the case against the defendants is viable and that alternative means of protecting the trust's interests are impractical. The defendants have challenged the application, arguing that the trust should be required to provide an indemnity for the trustee’s costs or security for the defendants’ costs. The trust contends that such conditions are not warranted given the circumstances.

The case initially came before the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Equity Division, on an application by the Gillespie Family Trust for a representative order to allow it to bring a derivative action against Gillespies Cranes Nominees Pty Ltd and two of its directors. The application was heard by Justice Nye in the Supreme Court, following a failed application in the Federal Court of Australia. The Federal Court declined to grant the representative order on the basis that the trust had not demonstrated that the case was sufficiently strong. The trust subsequently appealed to the Supreme Court, where Justice Nye was tasked with determining whether the special circumstances required for such an order were present, and if so, whether the order should be conditional on indemnity or security provisions.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the special circumstances necessary for the grant of a representative order to bring a derivative action exist in this case.
2. If the special circumstances exist, whether the order should be conditional on the trust providing an indemnity for the trustee’s costs or security for the defendants’ costs.
3. What form the order should take if it is granted.

Held
1. The court found that the special circumstances necessary for the grant of a representative order to bring a derivative action do exist in this case.
2. The court ruled that the order should not be conditional on the trust providing an indemnity for the trustee’s costs or security for the defendants’ costs.
3. The court determined that if the order is granted, it should be in the form of a direction to the trustee to proceed with the proceedings in the name of the trust.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In considering the application for a representative order to bring a derivative action on behalf of the discretionary family trust, the court first examined the criteria for establishing special circumstances. The court recognised that special circumstances may exist where it is impractical or unjust for the trust beneficiaries to bring the proceedings themselves. The court observed that the beneficiaries were in a position of dependency and were unable to bring the proceedings due to a lack of resources and information, which justified the need for the trustee to act on their behalf.

The court then assessed whether the order should be conditional on the trust providing an indemnity for the trustee’s costs or security for the defendants’ costs. The court noted that the provision of an indemnity or security was not a necessary precondition for granting the order, given the impracticality of the alternatives and the potential for injustice if the order was denied. The court concluded that imposing such conditions would not serve the purpose of ensuring fair and just outcomes for the beneficiaries.

Finally, the court considered the form of the order if it was to be granted. The court determined that the order should be in the form of a direction to the trustee to proceed with the proceedings in the name of the trust, as this would allow the trust to maintain its identity and interests in the litigation. The court emphasised that the order should not be in the form of a personal mandate to the applicant, as this would undermine the independence and impartiality of the trustee in managing the trust’s affairs.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that special circumstances for granting a representative order in a derivative action can be established where it is impractical or unjust for the beneficiaries to bring the proceedings themselves, and that such an order need not be conditional on the provision of an indemnity or security. The court’s approach to the form of the order reflects a balance between the need for effective litigation and the preservation of the trust’s distinct legal personality.