Gilles v Valuer General

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES LAND AND ENVIRONMENT COURT

CITATION:
Gilles -v- Valuer General [2008] NSWLEC 1508

PARTIES:
APPLICANT
Joseph John Gilles & Anor

RESPONDENT
Valuer General

FILE NUMBER(S):
31260 of 2007,  31261 of 2007 and 31087 of 2007

CATCHWORDS:
Appeal :- Interpretation of Development Control Plan and Development Control Plan Parking; analysis of comparable sales and application of results.

LEGISLATION CITED:
Randwick Local Environmental Plan 1998
Development Control Plan for Matraville Town Centre
Development Control Plan, Parking
Valuation of Land Act 1916

CASES CITED:
Commissioner of Succession Duties (South Australia) and Executor Trustee and Agency Company of South Australia Ltd and Anors 74 CLR 358 at 373

CORAM:
Miller AC

DATES OF HEARING:
25/9/2008, 26/09/2008 & 7/11/2008

JUDGMENT DATE:
31 December 2008

LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES

Applicant
Mr M. CLeary, barrister
GIles Payne & Co

Respondent
Mr M. McGrowdie, barrister
Crown Solicitors Office

JUDGMENT:

THE LAND AND
ENVIRONMENT COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES

Miller AC

30 December 2008

31260 of 2007                   Gilles JJ & Pyntoe P/L v Valuer General

31261 of 2007                   Gilles JJ & Gilles GM v Valuer General

31087 of 2007                   Gilles JJ v Valuer General

JUDGMENT

  1. These are appeals against the land values assessed under section 6A (1) of the Valuation of Land Act 1916 (the Act) in respect of properties 462, 488 and 506 Bunnerong Rd, Matraville as at the Base Date of 1 July 2006.

Background

  1. Land values originally assessed by the Valuer General and contended on behalf of the respective Applicants are as follows:

    Valuer General    Applicant

    462 Bunnerong Rd  $305,000  $141,610
    488 Bunnerong Rd  $825,000  $375,570
    506 Bunnerong Rd  $740,000  $312,975

  2. However, at the hearing it was contended, on behalf of the Valuer General, that the land values were understated and should be:

    462 Bunnerong Rd  $455,000
    488 Bunnerong Rd  $1,040,000
    506 Bunnerong Rd   $940,000

  3. The properties are located on the western side of Bunnerong Rd, Matraville and form part of the Matraville shopping centre which is, almost entirely, a one-sided strip shopping area extending, at its extremities, between Beauchamp Road and Harold St.  Matraville as a shopping centre has declined over the years and is now no more than a neighbourhood or a convenience type centre which suffers severely from its major competitors, namely, Westfield East Gardens, South Point Shopping Centre (both of which are situated on Bunnerong Rd 1.2 km and .5 km, respectively, north of Beauchamp Road) and Pacific Square at Maroubra Junction. They provide a full range of facilities and services including department stores, supermarkets, specialty stores, entertainment as well as incorporating excellent car parking.

The Properties

  1. 462 Bunnerong Rd is located towards the northern end of the Matraville shopping centre approximately 100 m south of Beauchamp Road.  It has a frontage of 6.1 m, an average depth of 33.2 m with a 6.1 m frontage to Baird Lane (which lies parallel to Bunnerong Rd).  Land area is 202.3 square metres.  The land falls slightly from street frontage to the rear lane.

  1. 488 Bunnerong Rd is located almost midway between Beauchamp Road…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gilles v Valuer General and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] NSWLEC 1508
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Joseph John Gilles and others appealed against land values assessed by the Valuer General for properties located on Bunnerong Rd, Matraville. The Valuer General assessed the land values at $305,000, $825,000, and $740,000 for the respective properties, while the applicants contended that the values were $141,610, $375,570, and $312,975. The applicants argued that the Valuer General understated the land values. The NSW Land and Environment Court was required to decide on the correct land values based on the applicable town planning controls, the highest and best use of the properties, and the analysis of comparable sales.

The Court examined the town planning controls, specifically the Randwick Local Environmental Plan 1998 and the Development Control Plan for Matraville Town Centre. The Court concluded that the highest and best use of the properties was for retail/commercial space on the ground floor and residential apartments in the balance of the prospective buildings. The Court also concluded that the maximum car parking that could be provided on the respective properties was 2 single car spaces for 462 Bunnerong Rd, 10 car spaces for 488 Bunnerong Rd, and 5 car spaces for 506 Bunnerong Rd. The Court then determined the maximum prospective development for each property, taking into account the town planning controls and the car parking requirements.

The Court found that the only appropriate method of comparison between the comparable sales and the subject properties was on the basis of a residential apartment equivalent actually achieved on the comparable sales sites and capable of being achieved in a prospective development. The Court considered three critical sales and made adjustments for location, market conditions, and additional costs and penalties. The Court then determined the land values for the subject properties as $297,000 for 462 Bunnerong Rd, $768,000 for 488 Bunnerong Rd, and $731,500 for 506 Bunnerong Rd.

The Court upheld the appeals and amended the land values for the three properties. No order was made as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established