Gillard v Russell

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

Civil and Administrative Tribunal


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Gillard v Russell [2018] NSWCATCD 69
Hearing dates: 5 September 2018
Date of orders: 08 November 2018
Decision date: 08 November 2018
Jurisdiction:Consumer and Commercial Division
Before: P Boyce, Senior Member
Decision:

(1) Orders
(a) The line of the dividing fence and retaining wall between 18 ***** Place ********** and 21 ***** Place *********** along Boundary “B” is to be centred on the common boundary line as defined by surveyors, Pinnacle Land Surveyors.
(b) The applicants are to trim and cut their paving to provide a clear working area for the erection for the new fence at their sole expense.
(c) The retaining wall beneath the dividing fence is to be constructed of treated pine sleepers placed on their side and fixed so that they act as a retaining wall and footing or foundation and plinth for the proposed dividing fence and are to be installed as part of the fencing work at the joint cost of the parties.
(d) A new dividing fence is to be constructed of colorbonded sheet metal fence supported on steel posts concreted into the ground and have a height of 1.5 metres high above the surface level of the applicants’ land at the common boundary line between the applicants’ land and the respondent’s land at the joint cost of the parties.
(e) The applicants must pay to the respondent on or before the 20 November 2018 the amount of $1,177.00 as their contribution to the survey work carried out by Pinnacle Land Surveyors to identify the common boundary.


(2) Facilitating Orders
(a) Each party is to obtain at least one (1) quote from a licensed fencing contractor for the fencing work set out in these orders within one (1) month of the date of publication of these Reasons for Decision.
(b) The fencing contractor is not to be Local Fencing Pty Ltd.
(c) The parties are to exchange their respective quotes with each other within seven (7) days of receipt of their quote.
(d) The parties are to agree on the quote to be accepted.
(e) If a quote is not obtained by the respondents within one (1) month of the date of publication of these Reasons for Decision, then the quote obtained by the applicants will be the quote to be accepted;
(f) If both parties obtain a quote within the time allowed under these orders and there is absence of agreement between the parties within 6 weeks of the date of publication of these Reasons for Decision as to which quote is to be accepted, the quote or quotes are to be referred to the Presiding Tribunal Member for decision as to which quote will be selected. In making the decision, the Tribunal Member:-
(i) Will not consider submissions made by either party in respect of the acceptability or otherwise of the quotes submitted;
(ii) is not bound to select the lowest quote submitted by the parties;
(iii) is not obliged…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gillard v Russell and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWCATCD 69
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter before the court involved a dispute between the applicants, Gillard, and the respondent, Russell, regarding the construction of a dividing fence and retaining wall between their adjacent properties. The applicants sought orders to determine the location of the common boundary and the construction of the fence and retaining wall. The court was required to determine the common boundary line and the appropriate construction of the fence and retaining wall in accordance with the law.

The legal issues before the court were whether the retaining wall beneath the dividing fence should be considered as a foundation or footing to the dividing fence, and whether section 18 of the Dividing Fences Act 1991 applied to the case. The applicants argued that the retaining wall should not be considered as a foundation or footing to the dividing fence, and that section 18 did not apply because the retaining wall was not a permanent structure. The respondent argued that the retaining wall should be considered as a foundation or footing to the dividing fence, and that section 18 applied because the retaining wall was necessary for the support of the fence.

The court held that the retaining wall should be considered as a foundation or footing to the dividing fence, and that section 18 of the Dividing Fences Act 1991 applied to the case. The court found that the retaining wall was necessary for the support of the fence and that it acted as a retaining wall and footing or foundation and plinth for the proposed dividing fence. The court also found that the common boundary line should be centred on the line defined by the registered surveyors, Pinnacle Land Surveyors. The court ordered that a new dividing fence be constructed at the joint cost of the parties, and that the retaining wall be constructed of treated pine sleepers placed on their side and fixed so that they act as a retaining wall and footing or foundation and plinth for the proposed dividing fence.

The court further ordered that the applicants were to pay the respondent $1,177.00 as their contribution to the survey work carried out by Pinnacle Land Surveyors to identify the common boundary. The court also made facilitating orders regarding the selection of a fencing contractor, the exchange of quotes, and the payment of costs. Each party was ordered to pay their own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

(1) Orders

(a) The line of the dividing fence and retaining wall between 18 ***** Place ********** and 21 ***** Place *********** along Boundary “B” is to be centred on the common boundary line as defined by surveyors, Pinnacle Land Surveyors.

(b) The applicants are to trim and cut their paving to provide a clear working area for the erection for the new fence at their sole expense.

(c) The retaining wall beneath the dividing fence is to be constructed of treated pine sleepers placed on their side and fixed so that they act as a retaining wall and footing or foundation and plinth for the proposed dividing fence and are to be installed as part of the fencing work at the joint cost of the parties.

(d) A new dividing fence is to be constructed of colorbonded sheet metal fence supported on steel posts concreted into the ground and have a height of 1.5 metres high above the surface level of the applicants’ land at the common boundary line between the applicants’ land and the respondent’s land at the joint cost of the parties.

(e) The applicants must pay to the respondent on or before the 20 November 2018 the amount of $1,177.00 as their contribution to the survey work carried out by Pinnacle Land Surveyors to identify the common boundary.

(2) Facilitating Orders

(a) Each party is to obtain at least one (1) quote from a licensed fencing contractor for the fencing work set out in these orders within one (1) month of the date of publication of these Reasons for Decision.

(b) The fencing contractor is not to be Local Fencing Pty Ltd.

(c) The parties are to exchange their respective quotes with each other within seven (7) days of receipt of their quote.

(d) The parties are to agree on the quote to be accepted.

(e) If a quote is not obtained by the respondents within one (1) month of the date of publication of these Reasons for Decision, then the quote obtained by the applicants will be the quote to be accepted;

(f) If both parties obtain a quote within the time allowed under these orders and there is absence of agreement between the parties within 6 weeks of the date of publication of these Reasons for Decision as to which quote is to be accepted, the quote or quotes are to be referred to the Presiding Tribunal Member for decision as to which quote will be selected. In making the decision, the Tribunal Member:-

(i) Will not consider submissions made by either party in respect of the acceptability or otherwise of the quotes submitted;

(ii) is not bound to select the lowest quote submitted by the parties;

(iii) is not obliged to satisfy themselves as to the bona fides or license status of the proposed fencing contractors;

(g) The applicants must pay the cost of the fencing work to the fencing contractor and will be the only party to give instructions to the fencing contractor in relation to the carrying out of the fencing work.

(h) Subject to availability of the fencing contractor, the fencing work is to be completed within three (3) months of acceptance of the quote.

(i) The fencing work is to be carried out with due care and skill using new materials.

(j) The fencing contractor is to be paid on the day the fencing work is completed.

(k) The respondent is to pay to the applicants her contribution, as ordered in these orders, within seven (7) days of completion of the fencing work, without deduction or allowance.

(3) Costs

(a) Each party is to pay their own costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.