Gill v WBC Investments Pty. Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

QUEENSLAND INDUSTRIAL RELATIONS COMMISSION

CITATION:

Gill v WBC Investments Pty. Ltd. [2024] QIRC 153

PARTIES:  

Gill, Ricky John

(Applicant)

v

WBC Investments Pty. Ltd., as trustee for WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust, trading as Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners

(Respondent)

CASE NO:

B/2023/88

PROCEEDING:

Application for recovery of pro rata long service leave

DELIVERED ON:

21 June 2024

HEARING DATE: 

27 March 2024

MEMBER:

Butler IC

HEARD AT:

Bundaberg

ORDER:

WBC Investments Pty. Ltd., as trustee for WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust, trading as Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners, is to pay Ricky John Gill the sum of $8,315.45 (gross), being the amount of  pro rata  long service leave owed to him, within 28 days.

CATCHWORDS:

INDUSTRIAL LAW – RECOVERY OF  PRO RATA  LONG SERVICE LEAVE – Employee absent from work for an extended period because of injury – whether the employer constructively dismissed the employee – whether the employer unfairly dismissed the employee – the employee is entitled to proportionate long service leave.

LEGISLATION:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) s 536(1)

Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ss 95, 319, 320, 475, 476

Workers Compensation and Rehabilitation Act 2003 (Qld) s 119A

CASES:

Brown v National Security Proprietors Australia Pty Ltd [2007] 184 QGIG 183

Cerin v ACI Operations Pty Ltd & Ors [2015] FCCA 1654

Cox v Photograve Pty Limited [2008] QIC 54 Schipp & Anor v The Star Entertainment Qld Limited [2019] ICQ 9

Farquhar v Commonwealth of Australia represented by Services Australia [2023] FedCFamC2G 1100

Thomas and Ailua v Virgin Australia Airlines Pty Ltd t/a Virgin Australia [2019] FWC 4464

APPEARANCES:

Mr R.J. Gill, the Applicant in person.

Mr G. Higgins, for the Respondent.

Reasons for Decision

Introduction

  1. On 1 November 2023, Mr Ricky Gill ('the Applicant') filed an application seeking proportionate payment of long service leave pursuant to ss 476 and 95 of the Industrial Relations Act 2016 (Qld) ('the Act').

  2. The Application named the Respondent as "Gregory Higgins, Wide Bay Canopy and Filter Cleaners," and Mr Higgins represented the Respondent in these proceedings. At the mention held 6 March 2024 I clarified, with Mr Higgins, the identity of the respondent. On 7 March 2024 I ordered that the respondent in these proceedings is WBC Investments Pty. Ltd., as trustee for WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust, trading as Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners. For convenience I will refer to it in this decision as "Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners."

  3. Mr Gill was in continuous employment with Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners from his commencement in June 2014 until his termination took effect.

  4. The question is whether an entitlement to proportionate payment of long service leave arose when Mr Gill's employment ended. That necessitates consideration of the length of Mr Gill's continuous service, and when, how, and why the employment ended.

  5. Mr Gill says that his employer terminated his employment, either via a constructive dismissal in 2022, or by summary termination in November 2023, and the termination was because of illness or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gill v WBC Investments Pty. Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] QIRC 153
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Gill v WBC Investments Pty Ltd, the applicant, Ricky John Gill, sought recovery of long service leave from the respondent, WBC Investments Pty Ltd, as trustee for the WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust. The dispute arose from Gill's employment with Wide Bay Canopy and Filter Cleaners Pty Ltd, a trading entity of WBC Investments Pty Ltd. Gill's employment began on a casual basis in June 2014 and transitioned to a permanent position in July 2017. Gill's employment was terminated on 2 November 2023, following an extended absence due to an injury. Gill claimed that he was constructively or unfairly dismissed, thereby entitling him to proportionate long service leave.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the employer had constructively dismissed Gill, whether the employer had unfairly dismissed him, and whether Gill was entitled to long service leave on a pro rata basis. The court had to consider the circumstances of Gill's absence, the employer's decision to terminate his employment, and the applicable provisions of the industrial law regarding termination of employment and entitlement to long service leave. The court needed to determine if the employer's actions constituted a dismissal, if the dismissal was for a valid reason, and if Gill's absence due to injury altered his entitlement to long service leave.

The court found that Gill was not constructively or unfairly dismissed. The termination of Gill's employment was due to his serious misconduct, which included theft of a padlock from the business premises and an aggressive verbal altercation with his employer. The employer had waited until Gill's return to the workplace to address these incidents due to his WorkCover claim. However, upon Gill's continued absence and clear indication that he would not return to work, the employer deemed the incidents serious enough to warrant immediate termination. The court held that the employer's decision to terminate was justified and not an unfair or constructive dismissal. Nonetheless, given Gill's extended absence due to injury, the court concluded that he was entitled to long service leave on a pro rata basis.

WBC Investments Pty Ltd, as trustee for WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust, was ordered to pay Ricky John Gill the sum of $8,315.45 within 28 days, representing his pro rata long service leave.

Orders

Orders of the court

WBC Investments Pty. Ltd., as trustee for WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust, trading as Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners, is to pay Ricky John Gill the sum of $8,315.45 (gross), being the amount of pro rata long service leave owed to him, within 28 days.

Background

Background to the litigation

The termination letter of 2 November 2023[102] runs to two pages and relevantly provides as follows:[102] Exhibit 25. Though the termination letter is signed "Greg Higgins, Director, Wide Bay Canopies and Filter Cleaners Pty Ltd," there is no such entity, and the letterhead gives the ABN as 96 189 116 275, which is registered to The trustee for WBC Investment Family Discretionary Trust with the trading name Wide Bay Canopy & Filter Cleaners and the ACN 146 696 675, which is WBC Investments Pty. Ltd. Background You were employed by Wide Bay Canopy and Filter Cleaners Pty Ltd on 14 June 2014 in a casual role.On about I July 2017, you were engaged in a permanent position. [The letter then sets out a chronology]Further correspondence was sent by our lawyers to your lawyers on 1 April 2022. You then continued to pursue your injury claim.At no time did you, your lawyer, our lawyer, or Wide Bay Canopy and Filter Cleaners Pty Ltd terminate your employment. The only reference to the currency of your employment was in your lawyer's letter of 4 March 2022 confirming that you remained employed. Therefore, your reference in your Form 14 – Application, to your employer terminating your employment on 1 April 2022 is incorrect. You were not terminated on that date, or prior date. Termination of Employment on 2 November 2023 After receiving your request in about January 2022 to not be contacted directly by me, I made the decision to wait until your return to employment to raise several issues regarding your conduct. Your WorkCover claim was finalised by Deed on about 28 August 2023. Despite this claim being finalised 2 months ago, you have not returned to work. It is apparent to me that you do not intend to return to the workplace. I therefore raise two incidents of serious misconduct. The first incident relates to your theft of padlock from the gate of the business premises on 17 April 2022. This incident has been captured on our security camera. The second incident relates to an interaction with me on 15 May 2023, where you attended the workplace, uninvited and not in a state where you were ready to work, and called me, in an aggressive manner, a 'fuck wit'. This was witnessed by another employee by the name of Mr John Parker. Ordinarily, these incidents would have been addressed with you at the time they occurred, however, due to your WorkCover claim, which included claims of mental injury, I made the decision to wait until your return to work so that you were in a fit state to address this. As it is apparent you are not returning to work, I have decided to address these incidents now (though the first incident was reported to the Qld Police at the time). I am satisfied that that the first incident of theft of a padlock did occur as it was captured on our security camera. I am also satisfied that the second incident occurred as I was present at the incident and was the recipient of your abuse. I am also satisfied that these incidents, taken individually, or together, are both satisfactory to warrant immediate termination on the grounds of serious misconduct. As result of these incidents, and due to their serious nature, I hereby terminate your employment, effective immediately and without notice.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.