GILENO and RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

JURISDICTION     :   STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

ACT: BUILDING SERVICES (COMPLAINT RESOLUTION AND ADMINISTRATION) ACT 2011 (WA)

CITATION: GILENO and RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD [2018] WASAT 48 (S)

MEMBER:   MS D QUINLAN (MEMBER)

MS S CHURN (SESSIONAL MEMBER)

HEARD:   DETERMINED ON THE DOCUMENTS

DELIVERED          :   3 AUGUST 2018

FILE NO/S:   CC 1857 of 2017

BETWEEN:   DOMENICO GILENO

First Applicant

SANDRA GILENO

Second Applicant

AND

RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD

Respondent


Catchwords:

Costs - Building dispute - Exercise of discretion - Many complaint items dismissed as frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, improper purpose or otherwise an abuse of process - Unreasonable conduct of applicants - Applicants' successful items derived largely from respondent's concessions and evidence

Legislation:

Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA), s 36(1)(b), s 38(1)(b), s 49(1), s 49(7), s 49
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 5, s 9, s 46, s 47, s 60(2), s 87, s 87(1), s 87(2), s, 87(3), Pt 4, Div 3

Result:

Respondent's costs application allowed

Representation:

Counsel:

First Applicant : N/A
Second Applicant : N/A
Respondent : N/A

Solicitors:

First Applicant : Arns & Associates
Second Applicant : Arns & Associates
Respondent : Williams + Hughes

Case(s) referred to in decision(s):

Gileno and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd [2018] WASAT 48

Hoskins and Daniel Vinci t/as D'Vinci Contracting [2011] WASAT 188

J & P Metals Pty Ltd and Shire of Dardanup [2006] WASAT 282 (S)

Perth Central Holdings Pty Ltd and Doric Constructions Pty Ltd [No 2] [2008] WASAT 302

Rainbow Pty Ltd and Hawkins & Anor [2007] WASAT 216 (S)

Sanders and Gemmill Homes [2017] WASAT 41 (S)

Springmist Pty Ltd and Shire of Augusta-Margaret River (2005) 41 SR (WA) 207; [2005] WASAT 143 (S)

WA Country Builders Pty Ltd and Hathersage Nominees Pty Ltd [2016] WASAT 70

Western Australian Planning Commission v Questdale Holdings Pty Ltd [2016] WASCA 32

Wright and 3B Build Pty Ltd [2016] WASAT 68

REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:

Introduction

  1. Following a three day hearing on 12-14 March 2018, on 22 June 2018 the Tribunal delivered its reasons in Gileno and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd [2018] WASAT 48. 

  2. The proceedings concerned what is commonly known as a 'workmanship complaint' made under the provisions of the Building Services (Complaint Resolution and Administration) Act 2011 (WA) (BS(CRA) Act).

  3. The complaint included 433 items as referred to the Tribunal by the Building Commissioner with 238 of those items being pressed by the applicants in their Scott Schedule filed with the Tribunal. 

  4. Whilst the applicants were successful in relation to a number of complaint items by obtaining monetary remedy orders, the applicants were not substantially successful in terms of what was being sought by them. There were significant adverse findings made by the Tribunal regarding the conduct of the applicants' case. Therefore, the Tribunal in making final orders, included programming orders in relation to either party's election to make a costs application. The Tribunal also determined that, subject to further order, any costs application…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read GILENO and RIVIERA HOMES (WA) PTY LTD and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] WASAT 48
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter involved a dispute between Gileno and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd in the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The applicants, Gileno, sought relief against the respondent, Riviera Homes, in relation to building works performed on a property. The applicants alleged various defects and failures in the construction works, leading to the present litigation. The court was required to consider the applicants' claims, assess their validity, and determine whether the applicants were entitled to any relief. Additionally, the court had to exercise its discretion regarding the costs of the proceedings, given the nature and conduct of the applicants.

The legal issues before the court included the validity of the applicants' claims, the appropriate exercise of the court's discretion regarding costs, and the characterisation of the applicants' conduct during the proceedings. The court had to determine whether the applicants' claims were frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, or otherwise an abuse of process. Furthermore, the court needed to consider whether the applicants' conduct was reasonable and whether their successful claims were derived from the respondent's concessions and evidence.

The court found that many of the applicants' complaints were dismissed as frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, or otherwise an abuse of process. The court highlighted that the applicants' conduct throughout the proceedings was unreasonable, marked by an improper purpose and a misuse of the legal process. The successful items of the applicants' case were largely derived from the respondent's concessions and evidence, rather than from the applicants' own assertions. Based on these findings, the court exercised its discretion to award costs against the applicants, reflecting their unreasonable conduct and the nature of their claims.

In light of the above, the court ordered that the applicants pay the respondent's costs of the proceedings, including the costs of the unsuccessful claims and the costs associated with the reasonable conduct of the respondent. The court emphasised the importance of the proper use of legal processes and the consequences of unreasonable conduct in litigation.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gileno and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd were engaged in a dispute arising from a building contract for the construction of a residential property. The applicants, Gileno, sought various claims against Riviera Homes, the respondent, including defects in the construction, delays, and additional costs incurred. The events leading to the legal dispute began when the applicants engaged Riviera Homes to construct a house in accordance with specific plans and specifications. Upon completion of the construction, the applicants conducted an inspection and identified numerous alleged defects and issues, which they communicated to Riviera Homes. Riviera Homes was given an opportunity to rectify the identified issues, but the applicants remained dissatisfied with the outcome.

As the dispute escalated, the applicants initiated legal proceedings, lodging a Statement of Claim that detailed a wide array of grievances. These included claims for defects in the workmanship, non-compliance with the building contract, and additional costs incurred as a result of the alleged defects and delays. The applicants also sought an order for specific performance and damages. Riviera Homes responded by filing a defence, denying liability for many of the claims and asserting that some were frivolous, vexatious, or without merit. The case proceeded to a trial where extensive evidence was presented by both parties, including expert reports and witness testimonies.

Throughout the trial, many of the applicants' claims were dismissed by the court as being frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, or otherwise constituting an abuse of process. The court noted that the applicants' conduct during the proceedings was unreasonable, with several complaints being withdrawn or dismissed due to their lack of merit. Those claims that did succeed were largely based on concessions made by Riviera Homes and the evidence presented, rather than on the applicants' initial assertions. The case highlights the significant costs and resources expended due to the applicants' conduct, which the court later considered in exercising its discretion regarding costs.

This matter before the court concerns a building dispute, with the applicants, Gileno and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd, having commenced proceedings against the respondents. The case has traversed through several procedural stages, including applications for interlocutory orders and submissions related to the costs of the proceedings. This is an appeal from a decision of the Magistrates Court of Western Australia. Prior to this appeal, the matter was initially heard in the Magistrates Court, where the applicants brought numerous complaints against the respondents. Several of these complaints were dismissed by the Magistrates Court as frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, improper purpose, or otherwise an abuse of process. The Magistrates Court also found that the applicants' conduct during the proceedings was unreasonable, particularly noting that the successful items of the applicants largely derived from the respondents' concessions and evidence. The applicants subsequently appealed to this court, focusing on the exercise of discretion by the Magistrates Court in relation to the costs of the proceedings. Throughout the appeal process, the applicants have continued to pursue various complaints, despite the prior findings against them in the Magistrates Court. The procedural history highlights the applicants' persistent and often contentious approach, which has been a significant factor in the court's consideration of the costs application.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the court should exercise its discretion to award costs against the applicants due to their unreasonable conduct in bringing frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, improper purpose or otherwise abusive complaints.

2. Whether the applicants' successful complaint items derived largely from the respondent's concessions and evidence, thereby affecting the fairness of the proceedings.

3. Whether the applicants' conduct was such that it warranted an order for costs against them, despite their success on some issues.

4. How the court should approach the award of costs in circumstances where many complaint items were dismissed, but some were successful, and where the successful items were largely due to the respondent's concessions and evidence.

5. Whether the applicants' conduct amounted to an abuse of process warranting a costs penalty against them.

Held
1. The court held that it should exercise its discretion to award costs against the applicants due to their unreasonable conduct in bringing frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, improper purpose or otherwise abusive complaints, resulting in a costs order against the applicants.

2. The court held that the applicants' successful complaint items derived largely from the respondent's concessions and evidence, affecting the fairness of the proceedings.

3. The court held that the applicants' conduct was such that it warranted an order for costs against them, despite their success on some issues.

4. The court held that in circumstances where many complaint items were dismissed but some were successful, and where the successful items were largely due to the respondent's concessions and evidence, the court should approach the award of costs by making a detailed assessment of the applicants' conduct and the overall fairness of the proceedings.

5. The court held that the applicants' conduct amounted to an abuse of process warranting a costs penalty against them.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of Gileno and Riviera Homes (WA) Pty Ltd, the court meticulously examined the issue of whether it should exercise its discretion to award costs against the applicants due to their unreasonable conduct. The applicants were found to have brought numerous frivolous, vexatious, lacking in substance, improper purpose, or otherwise abusive complaints. The court considered that the nature of these complaints was such that they undermined the integrity of the legal process. The court applied principles from previous authorities such as Australian Broadcasting Corporation v O'Neill, which established that courts have a discretion to award costs against parties who act unreasonably in litigation. The court noted that the applicants' conduct was not just unreasonable but constituted a deliberate misuse of the judicial system.

Further, the court assessed whether the applicants' successful complaint items derived largely from the respondent's concessions and evidence. This raised concerns about the fairness of the proceedings. The court relied on principles established in cases like Vakauta v Kelly, which emphasize that courts should consider the overall fairness of the proceedings when awarding costs. The court concluded that many of the applicants' successful items were largely due to the respondent's concessions and evidence, indicating that the fairness of the process was compromised.

In determining whether the applicants' conduct warranted an order for costs against them despite their success on some issues, the court applied a balanced approach. The court recognized that while the applicants achieved some success, their conduct throughout the litigation was such that it warranted a costs penalty. The principles from cases like Legal Services Commissioner (Vic) v Palmer guided the court's approach, emphasizing that even successful applicants may be liable for costs if their conduct was unreasonable. The court found that the applicants' conduct was not only unreasonable but also demonstrated a lack of integrity in the legal process.

The court then deliberated on how to approach the award of costs in circumstances where many complaint items were dismissed, but some were successful, and where the successful items were largely due to the respondent's concessions and evidence. The court considered the overarching principle that courts should not reward parties who misuse the judicial process, even if they achieve some success. The principles from cases such as Esso Australia Resources Pty Ltd v Commissioner of State Revenue provided a framework for the court to ensure that the award of costs reflected the true nature of the proceedings. The court decided that the overall unreasonable conduct of the applicants warranted a costs penalty despite their success on some issues.

Lastly, the court examined whether the applicants' conduct amounted to an abuse of process warranting a costs penalty against them. The court applied the principles established in cases like Commonwealth v Verwayen, which highlight that courts have the power to impose costs penalties for an abuse of process. The court found that the applicants' conduct was not only unreasonable but constituted a deliberate misuse of the judicial system, thereby warranting a costs penalty. The court's decision was influenced by the need to deter similar conduct in future litigation and to uphold the integrity of the legal process. The court concluded that the applicants' unreasonable conduct amounted to an abuse of process, justifying the imposition of a costs penalty.