Gilchrist and Gilchrist and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 46 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GILCHRIST & GILCHRIST AND ANOR [2009] FamCAFC 199
FAMILY LAW - APPEAL – FROM DECISION OF A FAMILY COURT JUDGE – PROPERTY SETTLEMENT – Husband’s uncle provided money in connection with the acquisition of property by the husband from his former partner – The husband re-partnered and later sold the property – Sale proceeds were expended on debts and put towards a second piece of property (already owned by the husband and wife), no proceeds were provided to the uncle – The husband and wife divorced, wife commenced property proceedings in 2005 – In 2006, the uncle commenced proceedings, raising trust issues, in the NSW Supreme Court – State proceedings were transferred, unopposed, to the Family Court – Orders and declarations were made to the effect that the husband, and husband and wife, held certain sale proceeds on trust for the uncle – Wife appealed asserting the trust was a device to avoid payment of stamp duty, the trial Judge decided the case on matters that were not pleaded, were against the evidence and wrong in law
AVOIDANCE OF STAMP DUTY – Despite wife’s pleading, no submissions of illegality were made at trial – No issues arising from provisions of stamp duties legislation were raised at trial –Had the question of illegality been raised at trial there may have been matters available to be raised in response – Wife ought not be permitted to raise illegality on appeal
MATTERS NOT PLEADED – Trial judge made a finding that the wife was a constructive trustee with the husband in relation to sale proceeds of the first sold property – This question of trusteeship was not pleaded – Trial Judge undertook an process of equitable tracing that was not relied upon in the uncle’s case as pleaded – In ordering relief not founded on the pleadings the trial judge fell into error
Matter remitted for rehearing – Parties at liberty to make written submissions as to costs
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 94(2)
Stamp Duties Act 1920 (NSW)
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rule 51.53
Dare v Pulham (1982) 148 CLR 658
APPELLANT: Ms GILCHRIST
FIRST RESPONDENT: Mr GILCHRIST
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr MINER
FILE NUMBER: PAF 856 of 2005
APPEAL NUMBER: EA 127 of 2008
DATE DELIVERED: 10 November 2009
PLACE DELIVERED: Brisbane
PLACE HEARD: Sydney
JUDGMENT OF: Warnick, Boland and Crisford JJ
HEARING DATE: 19 June 2009
LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Family Court of Australia
LOWER COURT JUDGMENT DATE: 3 October 2008
LOWER COURT MNC: [2008] FamCA 917

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPELLANT: Mr McNally SC
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPELLANT: Matthews Dooley & Gibson
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Matthews Folbigg
COUNSEL FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr Maiden SC
SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Williamsons Solicitors Pty Ltd

Orders

  1. That the appeal is allowed and Orders 2, 3 and 5 of the orders of 3 October 2008 be set aside.   (Order 1 amended).

  2. That the action by Mr Miner pleaded in Statement of Claim case number…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gilchrist and Gilchrist and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] FamCAFC 199
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The matter of Gilchrist and Gilchrist and Anor involved a dispute between Mr Miner and the Gilchrists concerning the equitable distribution of the proceeds from the sale of jointly owned properties. The case was determined by Le Poer Trench J in the Family Court of Australia and subsequently appealed. Mr Miner claimed that he was entitled to half of the proceeds from the sale of the properties, which the Gilchrists had agreed to use to pay off their debts and his interest in the first property. However, the Gilchrists argued that they had used all the proceeds from the sale of the first property to settle their debts and were unable to pay Mr Miner his share from the sale of the second property.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Gilchrists were legally obligated to pay Mr Miner his share of the proceeds from the sale of the properties, as per the agreement reached between the parties. The court had to determine whether the agreement was binding and enforceable, and if so, whether the Gilchrists had breached the terms of that agreement by using the sale proceeds from the first property to pay off their debts instead of paying Mr Miner.

The court found that the Gilchrists had indeed agreed to use the proceeds from the sale of the properties to pay off their debts and to subsequently pay Mr Miner his share. The trial judge had noted that the Gilchrists had used all the proceeds from the sale of the first property to settle their debts, leaving nothing for Mr Miner. The court also found that the Gilchrists had informed Mr Miner that his entitlements would be paid from the proceeds of the sale of the second property. Despite the Gilchrists' argument that they did not have sufficient funds to pay Mr Miner, the court concluded that the agreement was binding and that the Gilchrists had failed to honour it by not paying Mr Miner his share from the sale of the second property. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted for rehearing by a different judge.

In summary, the court held that the Gilchrists were legally bound by the agreement to pay Mr Miner his share from the proceeds of the sale of the properties. By using all the proceeds from the first property to pay off their debts, they had breached the agreement. The appeal was allowed, and the case was remitted for rehearing by a different judge, with orders for the parties to file and serve written submissions on costs within specified timeframes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That the appeal is allowed and Orders 2, 3 and 5 of the orders of 3 October 2008 be set aside. (Order 1 amended).

2.

That the action by Mr Miner pleaded in Statement of Claim case number 3804/06 filed in the Supreme Court of New South Wales and determined by agreement of the parties in the Family Court of Australia be remitted for rehearing by a judge of the Family Court of Australia, other than the Honourable Justice Le Poer Trench.

3.

That each party be at liberty to make an application by way of written submissions in respect of costs incurred by him or her in relation to the appeal by filing such submissions at the Sydney Registry of the Family Court and serving them on the other parties within 21 days of the date hereof.

4.

That each other party have a further 14 days in which to make written submissions in answer thereto by filing such submissions at the Sydney Registry of the Family Court and serving them on the other parties.

5.

That each party be at liberty to reply to an answer by way of written submissions by filing such reply at the Sydney Registry of the Family Court and serving it on the other parties within a further 7 days.

6.

That each party endorse on the cover sheet the date on which a copy of that submission was served on the other parties.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Le Poer Trench J found:Conclusion184.I make the following findings of fact.…191.… [that from January 1998] the wife knew at all relevant times that [Mr Miner] owned one half of the equity in the [M] property.192.At some time, probably about the middle of 2003, the husband and wife agreed to place both the [M] and the [B] property on the market for sale. At that time, the parties had considerable debt and the husband’s business was not generating sufficient income to meet all of their debts as they fell due. It was agreed between the parties that the sale proceeds would be used to pay their debts and pay out [Mr Miner] for his interest in the [M] property.193.… The sale proceeds received by the husband from [M] consisted of $334,078 of funds that were Mr [Miner’s] entitlements.194.The husband informed Mr [Miner] following the completion of the [M] property that his entitlements were to be paid out of the sale of the [B] property.195.The husband used all of the proceeds of the sale of the [M] property to satisfy debts of the husband and the wife.196.When the husband and wife agreed to sell both [B] and [M], it was agreed that the proceeds would first be applied to meet the debts and then [Mr Miner] was to be paid out of the balance, irrespective of which property settled first.197.The [B] property was sold for less than the parties anticipated at the time they expended all of the funds from the sale of [M]. (emphasis added) At this point we note that, as seen, Mr Miner had pleaded that:37.On or about 15 August 2003, the plaintiff and the defendants agreed that the plaintiff’s half-share of the proceeds of sale of the [M] Property would be paid to him after the settlement of the sale of a property owned by the first and second defendants at …[B]… . (emphasis added) As highlighted, the pleading is that both defendants “agreed” on or about 15 August 2003, with Mr Miner. As also seen, by 15 August 2003, the husband and wife had been separated for over a month. We note that in paragraph 194 of his reasons (above), Le Poer Trench J referred only to the husband informing Mr Miner “following the completion of the [M] property that his entitlements were to be paid out of the sale of the [B] property”. No issue of agency between husband and wife was explored. However, earlier, the trial judge had found:111.The husband says that following the sale of the [M] property, he had a conversation with the wife to the following effect: “We have to pay [Mr Miner] his money but we’ve used some of it to clear our business debts. We will need to use some of the settlement money from [B property] to help pay [Mr Miner] what he is owed. You can then have the rest of the money from [B property], which could be up to $100,000.” (emphasis added)The husband says the wife said, “Ok there’s no other way to do it. That’s obviously what we have to do.” 112.The husband then says he spoke to [Mr Miner]. He said to him, “I’m sorry, [the wife] and I don’t have enough left after payment of our debts to give you your half share of $334,000. We have our [B] property for sale and [the wife] has agreed that we will use the proceeds of the sale to make up the remainder of the $334,000.” (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.