Gibson v Rivers-McCombs

Link copied
Case Copied 73 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gibson v Rivers-McCombs [2014] FCA 144

Citation: Gibson v Rivers-McCombs [2014] FCA 144
Parties: RUSSELL KURT GIBSON, HOPEVALE ABORIGINAL SHIRE COUNCIL and DHUBBI WARRA ABORIGINAL CORPORATION v STEPHEN RIVERS-MCCOMBS (AS DELEGATE OF THE NATIVE TITLE REGISTRAR), HOPEVALE CONGRESS ABORIGINAL CORPORATION, FRANCIS DEEMAL, VICTOR GIBSON and BRIAN COBUS
File number: QUD 602 of 2011
Judge: DOWSETT J
Date of judgment: 28 February 2014
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application pursuant to s 5 Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) for an order of review of a decision of a delegate of the Native Title Registrar – where the delegate determined that an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (“ILUA”) should be registered under s 24BG Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) after considering objections –whether procedures according to law were observed – whether the delegate had jurisdiction to make the decision – whether applicants had standing – whether the ILUA was compliant with the Act – whether the ILUA was uncertain and incapable of registration – whether the ILUA impermissibly dealt with non-native title land – whether trustee of land is capable of binding itself to future acts – whether proper consultation was had in compliance with Aboriginal traditional laws and customs
Legislation: Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 21, 24BA, 24BB, 24BB(a), 24BD, 24BD(4)(a), 24BE, 24BG, 24BG(2), 24BI, 24BI(1), 24BI(2), 24BI(3), 57, 57(2), 57(3), 58, 58(b)
Aborigines and Torres Strait Islanders (Land Holding) Act 1985 (Qld)
Aboriginal Land Act 1991 (Qld) ss 27, 28, 29
Administrative Decisions (Judicial Review) Act 1977 (Cth) ss 5(1), 5(1)(b), 5(1)(c), 5(1)(g), 12
Native Title (Prescribed Bodies Corporate) Regulations 1999 (Cth) rr 7, 8, 9, 9(2)
Native Title (Indigenous Land Use Agreements) Regulations 1999 (Cth) r 6
Cases cited: Erica Deeral (on behalf of herself and the Gamaay Peoples) & Ors v Gordon Charlie & Ors (QG 174 of 1997) cited
Gibson & Ors v The Minister for Finance, Natural Resources and the Arts & Anor [2012] QSC 132 cited
Meehan v Jones (1982) considered
Australian Retailers Association v Reserve Bank of Australia (2005) 148 FCR 446 considered
Attorney‑General for the Northern Territory v Minister for Aboriginal Affairs (1989) 23 FCR 536 considered
McCormack v Commissioner of Taxation (2001) 114 FCR 574 considered
Date of hearing: 18 and 19 April 2012
Place: Brisbane (Heard in Cairns)
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 121
Counsel for the Applicants: Mr DJ Campbell SC with Mr A Scott
Solicitor for the Applicants: Bottoms English Lawyers
Counsel for the Second Respondent: Mr D Rangiah SC with Ms T Fantin
Solicitor for the Second Respondent: p&e Law

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

QUEENSLAND DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

QUD 602 of 2011

BETWEEN:

RUSSELL KURT GIBSON
First Applicant

HOPEVALE ABORIGINAL SHIRE COUNCIL
Second Applicant

DHUBBI WARRA ABORIGINAL CORPORATION
Third Applicant

AND:

STEPHEN RIVERS-MCCOMBS (AS DELEGATE OF THE NATIVE TITLE REGISTRAR)
First Respondent

HOPEVALE CONGRESS ABORIGINAL CORPORATION
Second Respondent

FRANCIS DEEMAL
Third Respondent

VICTOR GIBSON
Fourth Respondent

BRIAN COBUS
Fifth Respondent

JUDGE:

DOWSETT J

DATE OF ORDER:

28…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gibson v Rivers-McCombs and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] FCA 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Gibson v Rivers-McCombs, the case involved a dispute over the registration of an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA) under the Native Title Act. The applicants challenged the decision of the delegate of the Registrar of the National Native Title Tribunal, who had registered the ILUA. The applicants argued that the signatories to the ILUA did not have the authority to bind the Blockholders and that the process for registration was flawed due to irregularities in the consultation and consent procedures.

The central legal issues the court had to decide were whether the ILUA was validly registered and if the applicants had standing to challenge the registration. Additionally, the court had to consider whether the irregularities in the consultation and consent procedures were significant enough to affect the validity of the ILUA registration.

The court found that the irregularities in the consultation and consent process did not invalidate the registration of the ILUA. It held that the applicants did not have standing to challenge the registration because they were not directly affected by the decision. The court reasoned that the irregularities did not impact the authority of the signatories to bind the Blockholders, and therefore the registration was valid. The applicants' claims of fraud and conflict of interest were not substantiated, and the court found no reason to doubt the integrity of the process.

The court ultimately dismissed the application, affirming the decision to register the ILUA. The applicants were not granted any relief, and the registration of the ILUA stood.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Gibson v Rivers-McCombs concerns the registration of an Indigenous Land Use Agreement (ILUA) between Congress, a representative body, and other parties. The agreement, intended to facilitate the transfer of land and the grant of leases, was challenged on several grounds. Notably, there were objections from the Council and certain Blockholders, who claimed that the signatories lacked authority to bind them, and that the agreement should not be registered. Furthermore, there were allegations that the signatories did not consult the Blockholders or obtain their consent, and that the agreement was entered into in bad faith. The validity of the registration process and the compliance with relevant rules and regulations, particularly those concerning consultation and consent, were central to the dispute.

The case revolves around the process of entering into and registering the ILUA, with key events including a meeting of Congress on 12 September 2011 where the decision to enter into the ILUA was made. Desmond Charles Bowen, a Dharrpa elder and Deputy Chair of Congress, claimed that he was not consulted about the decision and that the process did not comply with Congress's own rules regarding consultation and consent. Bowen also argued that the required quorum was not met at the meeting, as only nine out of the 13 clans were represented. Additionally, there were assertions that certain signatories of the ILUA did not have the proper authority or that the process for obtaining their signatures was flawed.

The case came before the court following an application by the applicants to challenge the decision of the delegate of the Registrar of the National Native Title Tribunal to register the ILUA. The applicants, including the Council and certain Blockholders, raised concerns about the authority of the signatories, the consultation process, and the validity of the ILUA itself. The delegate dismissed these concerns as irrelevant to the question of registration, leading to the current proceedings. The court is tasked with determining whether the objections raised by the applicants were indeed irrelevant to the registration process or if they warranted further consideration.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

I should deal with two other submissions made by the applicants. First, I see no reason why the words “taken to have been” should be construed as meaning something less than the word “deemed”. Second, to the extent that the applicants rely upon the risk of fraud in connection with documents purportedly made pursuant to reg 9(2), s 5(1)(g) of the ADJR Act offers a basis for relief. The applicants have not alleged fraud.EVIDENCE OF CONSULTATION AND CONSENT Although it is not strictly necessary that I do so, I should say something about the evidence concerning consultation and consent. The applicants rely primarily upon the evidence of Desmond Charles Bowen who is the senior Dharrpa elder and chair of the Dharrpa Land Trust. The Dharrpa Land Trust is, however, of no relevance for present purposes. He is also the Deputy Chair of Congress. Mr Bowen says that he was not invited to the meeting of Congress held on 12 September 2011 at which the decision to enter into the ILUA was taken. It is, I think, common ground that Mr Bowen did not attend that meeting. Concerning the reg 9(2) certificates, Mr Bowen says that the persons who signed the document were not members of the executive of the Dharrpa Land Trust. This fact has no present significance. He also claims that three of the signatories Cynthia Deeral, Rosemary Gordon and Erica Deeral “normally identify themselves as members of the Gamaay clan”. This may be so, but they are also members of the Dharrpa clan. Mr Bowen claims that it is against traditional custom and usage for elders such as himself not to be consulted in the clan decision‑making process, and that it is inappropriate for young people such as Judith Bowen, Latoia Woibo and Kerry Woibo to purport to represent the clan without authority. The latter proposition is based upon a misunderstanding of the reg 9(2) certificates. Mr Bowen assumes that the signatories, in some way, purported to represent the clan without authority. He asserts that there was no meeting of the clan “as whole” to ratify the certificates. He also asserts that the clan group was not given an opportunity to “consider let alone consent, to the Native Title decision”. Mr Bowen submits that Congress did not comply with cl 7.12 of its own rules dealing with consultation and consent nor with cl 7.4, dealing with the requirements for notice of a proposed general meeting. He asserts that pursuant to cl 7.7.1 the meeting of 12 September 2011 lacked a quorum. He claims that the required quorum was that 11 of the 13 clans be represented at any meeting. In fact only nine clans were represented at the meeting of 12 September 2011. As Deputy Chairman of Congress Mr Bowen is concerned about the way in which that corporation is being run. He claims that meetings are only occasionally notified, and not as a matter of course. He believes that this course has been adopted deliberately, in order to manipulate the outcomes. Mr Bowen seems to have asserted that he has only attended two meetings of Congress, both early in 2010.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the objections raised by the Council and certain Blockholders were relevant to the question of the registration of the ILUA.
2. Whether the objections regarding the authority of the signatories, the consultation process, and the validity of the ILUA warranted setting aside the decision to register the ILUA.
3. Whether the delegate's decision to dismiss the objections as irrelevant to the registration process was correct.

Held
1. The court held that the objections raised by the Council and certain Blockholders regarding the registration of the ILUA were irrelevant to the question of registration.
2. The court held that the objections regarding the authority of the signatories, the consultation process, and the validity of the ILUA did not warrant setting aside the decision to register the ILUA.
3. The court held that the delegate's decision to dismiss the objections as irrelevant to the registration process was correct.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Pursuant to cl 12 the ILUA was to be registered. Congress was authorized to attend to such registration, all parties undertaking to do all things reasonably necessary in that regard. Clause 13 provided for dispute resolution. Clause 14 provided that, subject to cl 11, any breach would not give to any other party the right to elect to terminate the ILUA. Clause 11 provided that if the State had not transferred the DOGIT Part A within six months of the registration of the agreement, it was to be terminated, in which case the consents given in cll 8-10 were to be treated as having not been given.OBJECTIONS TO REGISTRATION Section 24BG of the Native Title Act provides that a party to an ILUA may apply to the Registrar of the National Native Title Tribunal (the “Tribunal”) for registration of the ILUA. The Registrar may, and has delegated that function to a delegate. As a preliminary step in that process, notice must be given to certain identified persons or entities, including the relevant local government body. Presumably in response to such notice, the Council raised a number of concerns, but conceded that they did not affect the question of registration. However, the Council also submitted that:·Mr Deemal did not have authority to represent, or bind the other Blockholders; and ·Clauses 7 and 8 of the ILUA (dealing respectively with consent to the transfer to Congress and the grant of leases to the Council) be “severed” as they were invalid and unenforceable as neither the State nor the Council was a party to the ILUA. Dhubbi Warra responded to these concerns, submitting that they were not relevant to the question of registration. Curiously, in these proceedings Dhubbi Warra seeks to set aside the decision to register the ILUA. A Mr Kempton also submitted, apparently on behalf of the Blockholders, that the ILUA should not be registered. He first submitted that:·the signatories to the ILUA had no authority to bind the Blockholders generally; and·they had not been consulted, had not had legal advice and had not agreed to it. Mr Kempton subsequently submitted that:·several Blockholders and members of Congress were not aware of the full effect of the ILUA;·Dhubbi Warra was not aware of the ILUA’s effect and had not received independent legal advice;·Congress was aware that the Blockholders had legal representation but had not informed the legal representative regarding the execution and application for registration of the ILUA;·Erica Deeral, a director of Congress and a witness, who signed on page 12 of the ILUA, had a conflict of interest; and·the ILUA was entered into in bad faith.The delegate dismissed these matters as being irrelevant to the question of registration. The delegate is the first respondent to these proceedings and has indicated that he will abide the order of the Court. He considered that two other matters raised by Mr Kempton were also irrelevant to the question of registration but, nonetheless, worthy of some discussion. They were that:·certificates under reg 9 of the PBC regulations were irregular; and· all Blockholders should have received notice of the ILUA prior to registration.