Gibson v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

[2011] TASSC 72

COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA

CITATION:Gibson v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal

[2011] TASSC 72

PARTIES:  GIBSON, L W
  GIBSON, G M
  SMITH, B W
  SMITH, KW
  FORD, K M
  CONNOCK, R A
  v
  RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AND PLANNING
  APPEAL TRIBUNAL
  KRULOW, R J
  KRULOW, S J
  GLAMORGAN SPRING BAY COUNCIL

FILE NO/S:  LCA 927/2010
JUDGMENT

APPEALED FROM:  L W and G M Gibson, B W and K W Smith, K M Ford and R M Connock v Glamorgan Spring Bay Council and R J and S J Krulow [2010] TASRMPAT 199

DELIVERED ON:  22 December 2011
HEARING DATE:  3 August 2011
JUDGMENT OF:  Porter J

CATCHWORDS:

Environment and Planning – Consents, Approvals and Permits – Modification – Generally – Provisions for a combined process of amending a planning scheme and granting a permit – Power in planning authority to amend a permit granted as a result of combined process – Amendments permitted where no change to the effect of the decision, no increase in detriment to any person, and no change to the use or development – Meaning and application of each criterion – Whether errors of law in approach of Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal on appeal from planning authority.

Land Use Planning and Approvals Act 1993 (Tas), ss43H(1), 43K(2).

Aust Dig Environment and Planning [241]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             Appellants:  L W Maher
             Respondents R J and S J Krulow:          S B McElwaine
             Resource Management and
             Planning Appeal Tribunal:  No appearance
             Glamorgan Spring Bay Council:            (Notice of submission)

Solicitors:
             Appellants:  Davis Ford
             Respondents R J and S J Krulow:          S B McElwaine & Associates
             Glamorgan Spring Bay Council:            Abetz Curtis

Judgment Number:  [2011] TASSC 72
Number of paragraphs:  59

Serial No 72/2011
File No LCA 927/2010

L W GIBSON and G M GIBSON, B W SMITH and K W SMITH,
K M FORD, R A CONNOCK v RESOURCE MANAGEMENT
AND PLANNING APPEAL TRIBUNAL, R J KRULOW, S J KRULOW, GLAMORGAN SPRING BAY COUNCIL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  PORTER J

22 December 2011

Introduction

  1. This is an appeal from a decision of the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal dismissing an appeal to it from a decision of the Glamorgan Spring Bay Council.  The decision of the Council was to allow amendments to be made to a conditional permit granted in 2008 by the then Resource Planning and Development Commission ("the Commission").  The permit related to a stone processing business operated by R J and S J Krulow at Cruttenden Street in Buckland.  I will call them "the respondents" as they are the true contradictors in this appeal, the Council having submitted to the Court's jurisdiction.  The appellants are L W Gibson, G M Gibson, B W Smith, K W Smith, K M Ford and R A Connock who live in, or adjacent to, Cruttenden Street.  Essentially, the dispute centres on conditions which deal with environmental issues concerning the business; principally noise, dust and visual impact.

Background

  1. The starting point is a consideration of some provisions…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gibson v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] TASSC 72
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gibson v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal involves the respondents, who operate a business on their land in the Rural Zone of the Glamorgan Spring Bay Planning Scheme. Their activity, which is otherwise prohibited, was allowed under existing use rights. The dispute centres on the amendment of the planning scheme and the granting of a permit to clarify the status of the respondents' activity and to apply contemporary conditions. The original permit was granted by the Council and later modified by the Commission under section 43H. The respondents subsequently applied to the Council to further amend the permit, which led to the Council's decision to alter certain conditions of the permit. This decision was appealed to the Tribunal, which in turn was the subject of an appeal to the Commission. The legal issues before the court were primarily whether the Tribunal had erred in its interpretation and application of the criteria set out in the Act for amending the permit.

The court examined whether the Tribunal had correctly applied the criteria that amendments to a permit are permissible where there is no change to the effect of the decision, no increase in detriment to any person, and no change to the use or development. The court found that the Tribunal had misconstrued the meaning and application of these criteria, leading to an incorrect conclusion. The court held that the Tribunal should have considered the broader context and the purpose behind the criteria, which is to ensure that any amendments maintain the integrity and effect of the original decision. The court also highlighted that the Tribunal failed to adequately address the specific conditions of the permit and how they related to the criteria in question.

The court concluded that the Tribunal's approach was flawed, and the appeal was allowed. The respondents' application to amend the permit was upheld, as the Tribunal's decision was quashed and remitted to be reconsidered in light of the court's findings. The Commission directed that the Tribunal should properly apply the criteria for amending the permit as outlined in the Act, ensuring that any changes made do not alter the effect of the original decision or cause additional detriment to any person. The final orders were that the Tribunal's decision be quashed, and the matter be remitted back to the Tribunal for reconsideration in accordance with the court's reasons.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Under s43H, the Commission effectively reviews the grant of the permit. The Commission is in essentially the same position as the Tribunal under s61 when dealing with appeals from the decision of planning authorities under ss57 and 58: see s61(4)[1]. That is so because the Tribunal on an appeal to it, stands in the shoes of the pleading authority as the original decision-maker. [1] "61 Appeals against planning decisions In this case, the respondents' land was in the Rural Zone of the Glamorgan Spring Bay Planning Scheme in which the use classification of "General industry" (the use or development of any land for an industry not elsewhere defined) was prohibited. The respondents were carrying on their business, but this was by way of certain existing use rights. The purpose of the amendment and permit was to clarify the status of the activity and to apply contemporary conditions to that activity. The draft amendment which went to the Commission was to amend the scheme so as to provide for a specified departure in the Rural Zone for the respondents' property "to allow the otherwise prohibited use general industry for processing, selling and distributing sandstone in accordance with [the] permit …". The permit which had been granted by the Council was one "for the use and development of a general industry being for the processing, selling and distributing of sandstone." [sic] In November 2008, under s43H, the Commission made a decision on the draft amendment and the permit. What the Commission did was to avoid "spot zoning", and amended the planning scheme so as to make "General industry (processing, selling and distributing sandstone)" a discretionary use and development in accordance with the scheme, and deleted the reference to the permit. The Commission seemed to both modify conditions or restrictions which were attached to the permit granted by the Council, and added new ones. Whatever the precise detail, it is plain that the Commission proceeded under s43H(1)(b)(ii). Adopting the words of the Tribunal, the Commission decided to: The permit granted by the Commission included a number of conditions relating to use. Conditions which are relevant to these proceedings are set out below. At the risk of creating further confusion, throughout these reasons I will use the numbering as originally adopted by the Commission. (The Council, when amending the permit, adopted a numbering scheme which contained two paragraphs numbered "1", with the result that all conditions after number 1 were one number less than in the original. This numbering was used by the Tribunal.) In April 2010 the respondents applied to the Council to amend the permit. That application was made under the Act, s43K. That section is central to this appeal and it is convenient to now set out the relevant part: The Council decided that amendments could be properly made in accordance with s43K(2). Those conditions of the permit which I have set out were altered. They were altered in the following ways, the descriptions of which I have taken from the Tribunal's reasons, but substituting the Commission's original numbering:

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.