Gibbons v Deegan & Ors No. Scgrg-99-1112

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

GIBBONS v DEEGAN & ORS
[2000] SASC 144

Civil - Application for Judicial Review

  1. DEBELLE J.     In this application for judicial review the plaintiff seeks to set aside a decision of the South Australian Police Department Promotion Appeal Board.

  2. The first three defendants are the members of the Promotion Appeal Board and I will refer to them as the Board.  The fourth defendant is Detective Senior Constable Butvila who was successful in his appeal to the Board.  The Board stated through its counsel that it will abide the order of the court.  The Attorney-General appeared as amicus curiae.  I will discuss later issues arising out of the Attorney-General’s appearance.  Detective Butvila had earlier informed the court that he did not wish to appear or make submissions.

  3. The affidavits admitted as evidence were:

  1. the plaintiff’s affidavit sworn 16 September 1999;

  2. the plaintiff’s affidavit sworn 7 January 2000;

  3. the affidavit of Meredith Huxley sworn 14 December 1999;

  4. the affidavit of Brian Smith sworn 6 January 2000.

All of the exhibits to these affidavits were also admitted.  Mr Smith was cross-examined on his affidavit.

  1. The plaintiff is a member of the South Australian Police Force holding the rank of Detective Senior Constable.  By notice published in the Police Gazette on 29 July 1998, the Commissioner of Police invited applicants for appointment as a Senior Investigator in a number of divisions of the Criminal Investigation Branch in the metropolitan area.  Four different positions were available in three divisions of the Criminal Investigation Branch.  They were No. 1 and No. 2 Senior Investigator at Port Adelaide division, and Senior Investigator at the Elizabeth and Holden Hill divisions.  The plaintiff applied for the position as No. 2 Port Adelaide Criminal Investigation Branch Senior Investigator.  He did not apply for any other position.  There were at least 12 other applicants for the same position.  They included Detective Senior Constable Butvila, who had applied for all four positions.

  2. The procedure regulating the appointment and appeals against appointment in force at this time were the Police Act 1952 and the Police Regulations 1998.  The position of Senior Investigator attracts the rank of Sergeant.

  3. Regulation 46 authorises the Commissioner to appoint an advisory committee consisting of not less than three persons to assist him to determine the suitable applicant for a position.  Pursuant to reg 46, the Commissioner appointed a Selection Advisory Committee (“the SAC”) comprising three Inspectors of the Police.  The SAC is required by reg 46(2) to examine the claims of all eligible applicants and to recommend the applicant it considers most suitable on merit, having regard to the following matters:

(a)     efficiency in the performance of police duties;

(b)experience, both in the Force generally and of any special conditions applicable to the position;

(c)knowledge, skills, and aptitudes relevant to the position in respect of which the vacancy exists;

(d)nature of any studies or training undertaken, examinations passed and results obtained;

(e)good conduct;

(f)ability to command the respect of and to work harmoniously with others;

(g)results of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gibbons v Deegan & Ors No. Scgrg-99-1112 and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] SASC 144
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gibbons v Deegan & Ors was a case where the plaintiff, a Detective Senior Constable in the South Australian Police Force, sought to overturn a decision by the South Australian Police Department Promotion Appeal Board. The Board had overturned the plaintiff's appointment as a Senior Investigator in favour of Detective Butvila, who had also appealed against the plaintiff's appointment. The legal issues before the court were whether the Board had exercised its powers properly and whether there had been a breach of the rules of natural justice.

The court found that the Board had failed to consider all relevant factors when making its decision. Specifically, the Board had not addressed the criteria on which the Selection Advisory Committee (SAC) had assessed the plaintiff to be superior, nor had it provided any reasons to suggest that it had. The Board's reasons did not in any respect address the question of the comparative skills and qualities of the plaintiff and Detective Butvila except to the extent that it concluded that it preferred Detective Butvila over the plaintiff. The court held that the failure of the Board to consider all relevant factors required that its decision be set aside.

The court did not need to address the remaining grounds upon which the plaintiff's counsel contended there had been a failure to comply with the rules of natural justice. The court allowed the application and set aside the decision of the Board. The appeal was remitted to the Board for further hearing and determination.

This decision highlights the importance of considering all relevant factors when making a decision and the need for clear and unambiguous grounds to be set out in an application for judicial review. Failure to do so could result in the application being dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

DEBELLE J

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: DEBELLE J

Full text does not contain this section.