Giamarelos v Motor Accident Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 25 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Magistrates Appeals: Civil)

GIAMARELOS v MOTOR ACCIDENT COMMISSION

[2013] SASC 138

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Anderson

5 September 2013

MAGISTRATES - APPEAL AND REVIEW - SOUTH AUSTRALIA - APPEAL TO SUPREME COURT - POWERS OF COURT - OTHER MATTERS

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - EXCESSIVE OR INADEQUATE DAMAGES - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - PERSONAL INJURY OR DEATH CASES

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - RIGHT OF APPEAL - WHEN APPEAL LIES - FOR BIAS IN JUDICIAL PROCEEDINGS

Appeal from a magistrate's decision. The magistrate awarded the appellant damages to compensate him for injuries he sustained in a motor vehicle collision on 26 March 2007. The appellant appeals on the basis that the award of damages is manifestly inadequate and that the magistrate made errors reaching his conclusion. The appellant further appeals on the basis the magistrate has exhibited an apprehension of bias in his handling of the matter. The appellant appeals the order of costs as the magistrate concluded the type of costs in error.

Question of award of damages:

HELD: Appeal allowed. The magistrate did not award sufficient damages to compensate the appellant for injuries sustained in the accident. Award of damages set aside. Assessment of damages to be remitted for assessment before a different magistrate.

Question of bias:

HELD: Appeal dismissed. Magistrate's handling of the matter did not amount to bias on his part.

Civil Liability Act 1936 (SA), referred to.

GIAMARELOS v MOTOR ACCIDENT COMMISSION
[2013] SASC 138

Magistrates Appeal:  Civil

ANDERSON J.

Introduction

  1. The appellant in this matter appeals from the decision of a magistrate who awarded him damages to compensate him for the personal injuries he sustained when he was a front seat passenger in a motor vehicle involved in a collision on 26 March 2007.

  2. The defendant’s liability for the plaintiff’s injuries is not in issue. After a long trial the magistrate awarded the plaintiff damages in the sum of $7,100. That included an assessment pursuant to the Civil Liability Act 1936 (SA) for non-economic loss plus an amount awarded for loss of earnings. It also included a figure for interest.

  3. The appellant complains that the award of damages is manifestly inadequate and that the magistrate made many errors in reaching his conclusion.

  4. The appellant also complains that the magistrate has exhibited an apprehension of bias in his handling of the matter. There is also an appeal from the order for costs made by the magistrate.

    Background

  5. In the three years prior to the accident the appellant was employed as a painter. He was 22 years of age at the time of the accident and 27 at the time of trial. Following the accident he was off work for a couple of days but said he continued to experience symptoms from the whiplash type injury he sustained in the rear end collision. He consulted his general practitioner Dr Cox and he was given a certificate to be absent from work…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Giamarelos v Motor Accident Commission and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] SASC 138
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Giamarelos v Motor Accident Commission, the appellant appealed against the decision of a magistrate who had assessed his damages following a motor vehicle accident. The appellant, who was a painter and a soccer player at the time of the accident, sought compensation for both economic and non-economic losses, including loss of future earning capacity as a professional soccer player. The magistrate found that the collision was minor and awarded damages for non-economic loss over a period of nine months, rejecting the appellant's claims for ongoing pain and disability. The appellant argued that the magistrate had erred in assessing the impact of the collision and in discounting evidence of ongoing symptoms and their effect on his life.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether the magistrate had correctly assessed the extent and duration of the appellant's injuries and the resulting damages. The court examined whether the magistrate appropriately considered the evidence provided by the appellant, including medical reports and witness statements, and whether the magistrate's conclusion that the injuries were minor and transient was justified. The court also considered whether the magistrate had exhibited any bias or misapplied the law in reaching his decision.

The court found that the magistrate had erred in several respects. The magistrate had placed undue emphasis on the minor nature of the collision and had failed to properly weigh the medical evidence supporting the appellant's claims of ongoing pain and disability. The court held that the magistrate's conclusion that the appellant's injuries were limited to a period of nine months was inconsistent with the medical evidence presented, which indicated that the appellant had symptoms for a longer period. The court also found that the magistrate had not adequately considered the impact of the injuries on the appellant's ability to work and engage in recreational activities. As a result, the court allowed the appeal, setting aside the magistrate's award of damages and remitting the matter for reassessment by a different magistrate.

The court's decision highlighted the importance of thoroughly evaluating all relevant evidence and applying the correct legal principles in assessing damages for personal injuries. The court emphasised that the appellant's claims should not be dismissed lightly, particularly when supported by credible medical evidence. The case underscores the need for magistrates to carefully consider the totality of evidence and the subjective experiences of the injured party when determining the appropriate compensation for personal injury claims.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The appellant also complains that the magistrate has exhibited an apprehension of bias in his handling of the matter. There is also an appeal from the order for costs made by the magistrate.Background In the three years prior to the accident the appellant was employed as a painter. He was 22 years of age at the time of the accident and 27 at the time of trial. Following the accident he was off work for a couple of days but said he continued to experience symptoms from the whiplash type injury he sustained in the rear end collision. He consulted his general practitioner Dr Cox and he was given a certificate to be absent from work for one week. The appellant was, at the time of the accident, an A grade soccer player and received some payments for playing soccer but he says in his statement of loss that what he earned from soccer really amounted to expenses. He sought an award of damages to compensate him for the loss of a chance to become an elite player earning a large income. The appellant maintained in his evidence that he continued to suffer from pain, discomfort, restriction of movement and weakness in his neck for a considerable time, certainly greater than the nine months allowed by the magistrate. He also complained of sleep impairment and headaches and claimed that all of these symptoms affected his day to day social and recreational activities. He said he felt discomfort in the work he did as a painter and had modified the way in which he painted by avoiding some of the tasks altogether. He was able to do this because he was employed in his father’s business.The magistrate’s reasons The magistrate gave extensive reasons for his assessment of damages. The respondent had argued that the impact in the collision was very minor and could not have caused the injuries and the sequelae that the appellant complains of. The respondent also pointed to the fact that the plaintiff continued playing soccer in the premier league and only missed one game after the accident but not in the week immediately after the accident. The respondent also alleged that the appellant had pre-existing injuries and suggested that the symptoms complained of by the appellant were all the result of those pre-existing injuries. The magistrate dealt with each of these submissions by the respondent in his reasons. The magistrate spent considerable time in analysing the nature of the accident and the degree of force involved in the impact. After his review of the evidence the magistrate concluded that it was a low impact collision unlikely to cause significant injury. There appears to be little doubt that it was such a collision with very little damage to either motor vehicle. That fact is of course not conclusive of the type and severity of injuries which can be sustained. The magistrate then proceeded to analyse the symptoms complained of by the appellant and the medical evidence called by both parties. The magistrate refers to the way in which the appellant answered questions in cross-examination. He says at [42]:[42]The plaintiff’s answers were clearly unsatisfactory and incongruous with the tenor of the medical reports.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

ANDERSON J
It follows that the proper assessment should increase the figure of 3 for non-economic loss and include an allowance for loss of future earning capacity.Conclusion I allow the appeal. I set aside the award of damages made by the magistrate. I cannot make an assessment of the damages because the parties have argued the question of costs and disclosed to me the offer to consent to judgment. It is not appropriate for me to make an assessment unless it is with the consent of both parties. It is regrettable therefore that the matter must be remitted for assessment of damages before a different magistrate. I would hope that the parties having considered these reasons would agree that the magistrate assessing damages should do so on the basis of the evidence called in the trial and having regard to my comments as to where the magistrate appealed from has erred.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: ANDERSON J

I will deal with the appeal on costs by way of a separate decision which will not be published but will remain only with the parties until the matter is finalised.Consideration I have not dealt with all of the arguments put by Mr Walsh both in his written outline and in the oral argument before me. That is because I have reached a firm conclusion that on the matters I have already referred to the appellant has been able to demonstrate sufficient errors by the magistrate to justify an interference with his assessment of damages. The arguments of Mr Day to counter those points are all related to the closed period of nine months for the sequelae of the injuries and I have found this to be incorrect. In my view the magistrate has fallen into error in placing too much emphasis on the fact that this was a minor collision. The injuries sustained by the appellant have to be treated on the merits and there is medical evidence to support the complaints made by the appellant beyond a period of nine months albeit not necessarily to the degree he complains of. The magistrate states that the driver of the vehicle sustained no injuries. This statement was incorrect, as the driver did sustain injuries. This was of some significance to the magistrate. It appears that the magistrate has placed little or no emphasis on the evidence of Mr Nicolic, the soccer trainer and the appellant’s wife. In my view he was wrong to disregard this evidence. Likewise Dr Psaltis adds some important emphasis. The magistrate has not correctly assessed the effect of pre-accident treatment by Mr Georgonicas. The statements made in the course of the magistrate’s findings at paragraphs [113] and [114] as previously discussed indicate an error in my view. Given the finding that the magistrate acknowledges that for several years after the time of the accident the appellant may have suffered intermittent pain to his neck and given that he had not previously suffered any difficulty in that specific area the magistrate’s conclusion that the motor vehicle accident was not responsible for any pain beyond December 2007 is incorrect. Even if it was not the sole cause it was clearly a contributory cause and the magistrate makes no allowance for this. The evidence contained in the report of Dr Fry confirms that at least the appellant had a reasonable basis for complaints in relation to pain and stiffness relating to both his work and his soccer playing for some 16 months at least and not the nine months found by the magistrate. It is clear Dr Fry was saying that some 16 months after the accident there were still symptoms causing pain but improving with time. In my view the magistrate’s findings are inconsistent with Dr Fry’s views. The magistrate does not say that he rejects Dr Fry’s opinion, on the contrary, it appears that he accepts it. Dr Fry refers to an incapacity for work in the sense that the appellant avoids painting with his head and neck in extension. Clearly a painter is required to paint in all sorts of uncomfortable positions. At the time he saw him clearly Dr Fry was of the opinion that the condition was not stable.