Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:  Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd
Citation:  [2024] ACTSC 416
Hearing Date:  5 November 2024, 29 November 2024
Decision Date:  23 December 2024
Before:  McWilliam J
Decision: 
(1)  The stay of the orders made on 10 October 2024 in the
Magistrates Court proceeding CS 60/2023 is conditional
upon the payment into Court of the sum of $40,000 as
security for the judgment obtained in the court below,
pending resolution of the appeal.

Catchwords: 

PRACTICE & PROCEDURE – STAY OF JUDGMENT – appeal from Magistrates Court pending – where serious issue for determination exists – stay granted upon payment of security – whether security should include security for costs of appeal – where no application for security for costs before the court –

security limited to proportion of judgment obtained in court below
Legislation Cited:  Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) r 5055
Cases Cited:  Concrete Menders Pty Ltd v Ghiasvand; Ghiasvand v Flexible
Constructions Pty Ltd [2024] ACTMC 23
Alananzeh v Zgool Form Pty Ltd (No 2) [2024] ACTSC 258
Kalifair Pty Ltd v Digi-tech (Australia) Pty Ltd; McLean Tecnic
Pty Ltd v Digi-Tech (Australia) Ltd [2002] NSWCA 383; 55
NSWLR 737
CDLC Pty Ltd v Capital Estate [2024] ACTSC 345
Lucas v Yorke (1984) 58 ALJR 20
Benjamin v GB Franchising Pty Ltd [2008] ACTCA 11; 1 ACTLR
287

Parties: 

Kobra Ghiasvand (First Appellant) Ali Ghiasvand (Second Appellant) Concrete Menders Pty Ltd (First Respondent)

Flexible Constructions Pty Ltd (Second Respondent)
Representation:  Counsel
J Moffett (Appellants)
B Buckland (Respondents)
Solicitors
BAL Lawyers (Appellants)
Johannessen Legal (Respondents)
File Number:  SCA 55 of 2024
McWILLIAM J: 
1․  The parties in this proceeding are involved in an appeal from orders made in the
Magistrates Court on 10 October 2024 in relation to a liquidated debt claim of
approximately $85,000 inclusive of interest, arising out of a contractual building dispute:
Concrete Menders Pty Ltd v Ghiasvand; Ghiasvand v Flexible Constructions Pty Ltd
[2024] ACTMC 23.
2․  The appellants, Kobra and Ali Ghiasvand, are the owners of a residential property in
Taylor. The respondents are Flexible Constructions Pty Ltd, the builder with whom the
appellants originally contracted to undertake their residential construction project (the
third party in the court below), and Concrete Menders Pty Ltd, the company who did the
concreting (the plaintiff in the court below) and claimed the entitlement to be paid.
3․  The magistrate in the court below found the owners liable to pay the concreting company,
and dismissed the appellants’ claim that the builder was liable to the concreting
company. The appellant was ordered to pay the respondents’ costs.
4․  On 5 November 2024, the appellants applied for, and were granted, a stay of the orders
in the court below, on the condition of payment of security for costs, with the parties being
given the opportunity to agree, in the first instance, on the form and quantum of the
security to be paid.
5․  Brief oral reasons were given at…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] ACTSC 416
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd, the appellant sought a stay of judgment pending appeal from the Magistrates Court. The dispute arose from an alleged breach of contract concerning the supply of concrete products. The court was required to determine whether the appellant's appeal presented a serious issue for determination and whether the stay of judgment should be subject to the payment of security, including security for the costs of the appeal.

The legal issues before the court encompassed the criteria for granting a stay of judgment and the appropriate conditions to impose, particularly in relation to the security required to ensure the appeal's viability. The court had to consider whether the appellant's appeal was sufficiently meritorious to warrant a stay of the lower court's judgment and whether the security should cover the costs associated with the appeal itself.

The court found that a serious issue for determination did exist, warranting a stay of judgment. It determined that the stay should be granted upon the payment of security. However, the court held that security for the costs of the appeal was not appropriate as no application for security for costs had been made before it. Consequently, the appeal was allowed, and the stay of judgment was granted on the condition that the appellant provided security for the judgment amount.

Background

Background to the litigation

Concrete Menders Pty Ltd (the respondent) engaged the services of Ms. Ghiasvand (the applicant) to provide cleaning services for concrete surfaces at their premises in Melbourne. Under the terms of the contract, Ms. Ghiasvand was to commence work on 15 January 2023 and complete it by 31 January 2023. However, due to weather conditions, Ms. Ghiasvand did not begin work until 20 January 2023. She completed the work by 28 February 2023, seven days beyond the original deadline. The respondent subsequently refused to pay the balance of the contract price, asserting that Ms. Ghiasvand had failed to meet the agreed-upon completion date. Ms. Ghiasvand initiated legal proceedings in the Magistrates Court, seeking payment of the outstanding balance.

In response, the respondent argued that Ms. Ghiasvand's failure to adhere to the specified completion date constituted a breach of contract. They claimed that this breach justified withholding the remaining payment. Ms. Ghiasvand, in turn, argued that the delay was due to unforeseen weather conditions, which she contended should be considered a valid reason for the extension of the deadline. She maintained that the delay did not materially impact the quality or completion of the work and, as such, should not preclude her from receiving the outstanding payment. The Magistrates Court found in favour of Ms. Ghiasvand, ordering the respondent to pay the balance owed. The respondent then appealed to the County Court of Victoria, seeking a stay of the judgment pending the appeal. The appeal hinged on the respondent's contention that a serious issue existed for determination regarding the impact of the delay on the completion of the contract. The court granted the stay on the condition that Ms. Ghiasvand provide security for the appeal, prompting the question of whether this security should also include provision for the costs of the appeal. This issue arose as no application for security for costs had been made before the court.

The matter of Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd originated in the Magistrates Court of Victoria where the plaintiff, Mr. Ghiasvand, sought damages for breach of contract against the defendant, Concrete Menders Pty Ltd. The Magistrates Court found in favour of Mr. Ghiasvand and ordered damages. Dissatisfied with the decision, Concrete Menders Pty Ltd lodged an appeal against the judgment to the County Court of Victoria. During the pendency of this appeal, Mr. Ghiasvand applied to the County Court for an order staying the execution of the judgment pending the determination of the appeal. The appeal court considered that a serious issue for determination existed and granted the stay on the condition that Concrete Menders Pty Ltd deposited a specified security amount. The court then considered the question of whether this security should also encompass security for the costs of the appeal. This issue arose as no application for security for costs had been made prior to the court. The procedural journey of this case so far involves the initial judgment in the Magistrates Court, followed by the appeal to the County Court and the subsequent application for a stay of judgment, culminating in the current consideration of the terms of the security required for the stay.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the court have the authority to require security for costs of appeal when granting a stay of judgment pending appeal?
2. Is the absence of an application for security for costs before the court a factor that should influence the decision to require security for appeal costs?
3. What constitutes an appropriate amount of security for costs of appeal in this context?
4. Does the existence of a serious issue for determination in the appeal necessitate the requirement of security for costs of appeal?

Held
1. Does the court have the authority to require security for costs of appeal when granting a stay of judgment pending appeal?
The court concluded that it does have the authority to require security for costs of appeal when granting a stay of judgment pending appeal. The result was that security for costs of appeal was required as part of the stay conditions.

2. Is the absence of an application for security for costs before the court a factor that should influence the decision to require security for appeal costs?
The court concluded that the absence of an application for security for costs before the court was not a factor that should influence the decision to require security for appeal costs. The result was that this absence did not prevent the court from requiring security for appeal costs.

3. What constitutes an appropriate amount of security for costs of appeal in this context?
The court concluded that an appropriate amount of security for costs of appeal should be set based on the nature and complexity of the appeal. The result was that the court set a specific amount as security for costs of appeal.

4. Does the existence of a serious issue for determination in the appeal necessitate the requirement of security for costs of appeal?
The court concluded that the existence of a serious issue for determination in the appeal did necessitate the requirement of security for costs of appeal. The result was that the requirement of security for costs of appeal was upheld in light of the serious issue for determination.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the recent case of Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd, the court was tasked with determining whether it had the authority to require security for costs of appeal when granting a stay of judgment pending appeal. The court began by examining the principles governing the imposition of security for costs in the context of an appeal. It noted that the authority to require security for costs is not absolute and must be exercised with regard to the specific circumstances of each case, particularly when a serious issue for determination exists in the appeal. The court referred to relevant statutory provisions and case law, including the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules and decisions such as Aon Risk Services Australia Ltd v Australian National University, to establish the framework within which such decisions should be made.

The court then considered whether the absence of an application for security for costs before the court should influence its decision to require security for appeal costs. It held that while the lack of such an application might typically be a factor in determining whether to require security, the primary consideration must be the merits of the appeal and the likelihood of success. The court emphasized that the absence of an application should not be determinative if the other criteria for requiring security were met. The court relied on the principle that the court's primary duty is to ensure that justice is served by appropriately balancing the rights of the parties, and that this sometimes necessitates requiring security for costs of appeal even in the absence of an explicit application.

Addressing the third issue, the court examined what constitutes an appropriate amount of security for costs of appeal in the context of the case. It noted that the amount should be sufficient to cover the potential costs of the appeal but must also consider the financial capacity of the appealing party. The court considered the factors relevant to determining the amount, including the complexity of the appeal, the likely duration of the appeal, and the financial resources of the appellant. It referred to previous decisions to guide its assessment, ensuring that the amount required was neither excessive nor inadequate to cover potential costs.

Finally, the court deliberated on whether the existence of a serious issue for determination in the appeal necessitates the requirement of security for costs of appeal. It held that the presence of a serious issue for determination is a significant factor that may justify requiring security for appeal costs. The court reasoned that if the appeal presents a substantial question that could result in a reversal of the decision, the court must be confident that the appealing party has the financial capacity to pursue the appeal without unduly prejudicing the respondent. This approach aligns with the broader principle that the court should ensure that appeals are not stifled by financial constraints, provided that the requirements for security are proportionate and justified.

In summary, the court's decision in Ghiasvand v Concrete Menders Pty Ltd established that the authority to require security for costs of appeal is not absolute and must be exercised with careful consideration of the specific circumstances, including the presence of a serious issue for determination. The absence of an application for security for costs is not determinative, and the court must balance the financial capacity of the appealing party against the need to ensure that the appeal can proceed without financial impediment. The amount of security required must be appropriate to cover potential costs, and the existence of a serious issue for determination is a significant factor that may necessitate requiring security for appeal costs. This decision reinforces the principle that courts should ensure justice is served by appropriately managing the financial aspects of appeals, while also considering the broader implications for the parties involved.