MAGISTRATES COURTS OF QUEENSLAND
CITATION: GHI v Queensland Police Service and Ors [2023] QMC 12
PARTIES: GHI
(Defendant/applicant)
v
QUEENSLAND POLICE SERVICE
(Prosecution/first respondent)
and
ABC and DEF
(Complainants/second respondents)
And
QUEENSLAND NEWSPAPERS PTY LTD
NINE NETWORK PTY LTD
NETWORK TEN PTY LTD
(Participating media/third respondents)
FILE NO/S: MAG-00149797/23(8) and MAG-00149986/23(5)
DIVISION: Brisbane
PROCEEDING: Application for a Non-Publication Order
ORIGINATING COURT: Magistrates Courts of Queensland at Richlands
DELIVERED ON: 30 October 2023
DELIVERED AT: Richlands
HEARING DATE: 6 October 2023
MAGISTRATE: Magistrate Simpson
ORDER:The Order of the Court is that:
1. Publication of any identifying matter in relation to the defendant including:
a.The name of the defendant;
b.The address of the defendant;
c.The place of employment of the defendant; or
d.Any other particular of the defendant or another person likely to lead to the identification of the defendant.
And any photograph, picture, videotape, digital image or other visual representation of the defendant or another person that is likely to lead to the identification of the defendant is prohibited pursuant to s 7D(1) Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978 (Qld).
2. For the purposes of this Order, “publication” means disseminate or provide access to the public or a section of the public by any means, including by:
a.Publication in a book, newspaper, magazine or other written publication;
b.Broadcast by radio or television;
c.Public exhibition;
d.Broadcast or electronic communication; or
e.Social media.
3. This Order does not apply to:
a.A publication made by a legal representative or court officers for the purpose of the conduct of the committal proceedings (the proceedings);
b.The publication of a report of the proceedings in the form of a transcript of the committal to the parties to the proceedings;
c.The publication of a report of the proceedings to a party to the proceedings;
d.The publication of a report made by or to a law enforcement authority or police officer for the purposes of securing the attendance of a witness at a court or providing for the security and safety of a witness;
e.Any other publication expressly permitted by order by a magistrate of this court in the conduct of the committal proceedings.
4. This Order ceases to have effect if or when the defendant is committed for trial or sentence.
5. The Court directs that the affidavits, exhibits and other materials filed in this application are to be placed in a sealed container, envelope or other appropriate receptacle and marked:
“ Not to be opened without an order of a Magistrate of the Magistrates Court or Queensland ”
CATCHWORDS: CRIMINAL PROCEDURE – Non-publication orders – Open justice – Public interest – Where complainant opposes the application - Special vulnerabilities of the defendant - Whether order necessary to protect the safety of a person – Proper approach – Calculus of risk – Psychological safety
EVIDENCE - Use of affidavit sworn on information and belief exhibiting medical opinion.
Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978 (Qld), s 7
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read GHI v Queensland Police Service and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] QMC 12
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the need for a non-publication order in light of the defendant's special vulnerabilities and the risk to their psychological safety. It was determined that the order was necessary to protect the defendant's safety and to mitigate the risk of harm to them. The court emphasised that the defendant's vulnerabilities and the potential for harm were significant factors in its calculus of risk. The court also noted the complainant's opposition to the order but found that the defendant's right to a fair trial and protection from harm outweighed the public interest in open justice. The court accepted the use of an affidavit sworn on information and belief, which included a medical opinion, as part of the evidence in support of the application.
In conclusion, the court granted the non-publication order, prohibiting the dissemination of any identifying information about the defendant and any visual representations that could lead to their identification. The order was to remain in effect until the defendant was committed for trial or sentence. The court directed that the affidavits, exhibits, and other materials filed in the application be placed in a sealed container and marked for restricted access. This decision underscores the importance of protecting the psychological safety of defendants with special vulnerabilities while balancing this with the broader public interest in open justice.
Orders
Orders of the court
The Order of the Court is that:
1. Publication of any identifying matter in relation to the defendant including:
a. The name of the defendant;
b. The address of the defendant;
c. The place of employment of the defendant; or
d. Any other particular of the defendant or another person likely to lead to the identification of the defendant.
And any photograph, picture, videotape, digital image or other visual representation of the defendant or another person that is likely to lead to the identification of the defendant is prohibited pursuant to s 7D(1) Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978 (Qld).
2. For the purposes of this Order, “publication” means disseminate or provide access to the public or a section of the public by any means, including by:
a. Publication in a book, newspaper, magazine or other written publication;
b. Broadcast by radio or television;
c. Public exhibition;
d. Broadcast or electronic communication; or
e. Social media.
3. This Order does not apply to:
a. A publication made by a legal representative or court officers for the purpose of the conduct of the committal proceedings (the proceedings);
b. The publication of a report of the proceedings in the form of a transcript of the committal to the parties to the proceedings;
c. The publication of a report of the proceedings to a party to the proceedings;
d. The publication of a report made by or to a law enforcement authority or police officer for the purposes of securing the attendance of a witness at a court or providing for the security and safety of a witness;
e. Any other publication expressly permitted by order by a magistrate of this court in the conduct of the committal proceedings.
4. This Order ceases to have effect if or when the defendant is committed for trial or sentence.
5. The Court directs that the affidavits, exhibits and other materials filed in this application are to be placed in a sealed container, envelope or other appropriate receptacle and marked:
“ Not to be opened without an order of a Magistrate of the Magistrates Court or Queensland ”
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.