Gerblich v Perpetual Trustees Victoria Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Appeal from a Master: Civil)

GERBLICH v PERPETUAL TRUSTEES VICTORIA LIMITED

[2016] SASC 14

Judgment of The Honourable Justice S Doyle

11 March 2016

APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL - APPEAL - GENERAL PRINCIPLES - INTERFERENCE WITH DISCRETION OF COURT BELOW - IN GENERAL

MORTGAGES - MORTGAGEE'S REMEDIES - INJUNCTION TO RESTRAIN EXERCISE OF MORTGAGEE'S POWERS

The appellant borrowed approximately $408,000 from the respondent. The loan was secured by way of a registered mortgage over a property owned by the appellant. The respondent brought possession proceedings against the appellant after he fell significantly into default on the loan. Following the dismissal of the respondent’s claim for summary determination, a Master of this Court ordered that the appellant make certain payments into Court to protect the interests of the respondent pending resolution of the possession proceedings.

The appellant did not contend that no payment terms should have been imposed. However, the appellant appealed against the specific payment conditions imposed by the Master. The appellant appealed on a number of largely factual grounds.

Held (per Doyle J), dismissing the appeal:

1.       No error in the exercise of the Master’s discretion has been established.

Commonwealth Bank of Australia v SA Lending Centre [2014] SASC 178, discussed.
Inglis v Commonwealth Trading Bank of Australia (1972) 126 CLR 161; Glandore Pty Ltd v Elders Finance & Investment Co Ltd (1984) 4 FCR 130; Andrew Garrett Wine Resorts Pty Ltd v National Australian Bank Ltd (2004) 206 ALR 69; Salerno v Saunders (1993) 173 LSJS 362; House v the King (1936) 55 CLR 499; Bankwest v Mann [2015] WASC 187, considered.

GERBLICH v PERPETUAL TRUSTEES VICTORIA LIMITED
[2016] SASC 14

Magistrates Appeal: Civil

DOYLE J:

  1. The appellant, Mr Benjamin Gerblich, borrowed approximately $408,000 from the respondent.  The loan was secured by way of a registered mortgage over a property owned by the appellant at 1 Synnett Ave, Seaview Downs (the property). 

  2. The respondent mortgagee brought possession proceedings against the appellant borrower after he fell significantly into default on the loan.  Following the dismissal of the respondent’s claim for summary determination, a Master of this Court ordered that the appellant make certain payments into Court so as to protect the interests of the respondent pending resolution of the possession proceedings.

  3. This is an appeal from the Master’s orders.  For the reasons which follow, no error has been established in the Master’s reasons or decision.  The appeal must be dismissed. 

    Background

  4. The following is a summary of the facts as alleged by the appellant, taken largely from earlier reasons in this Court, and incorporated by reference in the Master’s reasons.  It is based on allegations made in evidence filed by the appellant, but which have not been the subject of findings. 

  5. The property was previously owned by the appellant’s parents, Mr Tony Gerblich and Mrs Lyn Gerblich.  Tony Gerblich is a disability pensioner, and Lyn Gerblich is also in receipt of Centrelink benefits.  The property was,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gerblich v Perpetual Trustees Victoria Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] SASC 14
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Gerblich v Perpetual Trustees Victoria Limited, the Court of Appeal examined an appeal from the Master's orders regarding the payment terms imposed on the appellant, Mr Gerblich, in relation to a mortgage over his parents' property. The appeal sought to challenge the Master's decision to require substantial upfront payments of arrears in interest, arguing instead for more modest monthly payments. The primary legal issues revolved around whether the Master's discretion in setting the payment terms was exercised correctly and whether there was any error in her decision-making process.

The Court of Appeal held that the Master was exercising a broad discretion in determining the payment terms to ensure the respondent mortgagee's protection while also doing justice between the parties. For the appeal to succeed, the appellant had to demonstrate that the Master acted on a wrong principle, was influenced by irrelevant matters, misunderstood the facts, or failed to consider a material consideration. Alternatively, the appellant had to show that the outcome was unreasonable or plainly unjust, indicating a failure to properly exercise the relevant discretion.

The Court found that the Master had considered all relevant material and focused on the contentions raised by the parties, including the appellant's submissions. There was no evidence to suggest that the Master did not understand or properly consider the material placed before her. The Court concluded that the Master's reasons were comprehensive and there was no basis for interfering with her orders. Therefore, the appeal was dismissed, and the Master's decision was upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is an appeal from the Master’s orders. For the reasons which follow, no error has been established in the Master’s reasons or decision. The appeal must be dismissed. Background The following is a summary of the facts as alleged by the appellant, taken largely from earlier reasons in this Court, and incorporated by reference in the Master’s reasons. It is based on allegations made in evidence filed by the appellant, but which have not been the subject of findings. The property was previously owned by the appellant’s parents, Mr Tony Gerblich and Mrs Lyn Gerblich. Tony Gerblich is a disability pensioner, and Lyn Gerblich is also in receipt of Centrelink benefits. The property was, and continues to be, the family home. Prior to the dealings mentioned below it was unencumbered. The appellant and his brother, Mr Simon Gerblich, were employed as software and electronic engineers for a company, Smart World Enterprises Pty Ltd, which was associated with Mr Portellos and his wife Ms Tomazos. They also worked for a related company, The Smart Company Pty Ltd. In addition to his work responsibilities, the appellant came to be almost a butler for Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos. He lived with them in a large house in Tranmere. He used his personal credit card to buy supplies for them. Having met Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos through the appellant, Tony and Lyn Gerblich also became friends with Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos. They stayed at their Tranmere home on occasions. They commenced working (without pay) at the Windsor Gardens Shopping Centre that Mr Portellos controlled. In December 2006, Tony and Lyn Gerblich advanced Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos $20,000 from a $40,000 line of credit they had established, which was secured against the property. This was repaid. In November 2007, Mr Portellos borrowed a further $20,000 from Tony and Lyn Gerblich, which resulted in their line of credit becoming overdrawn. In July 2008, Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos initiated discussions concerning Tony and Lyn Gerblich providing security over the property for a short term loan for $150,000. The appellant was told he would need to be a guarantor because his parents were pensioners. The loan was to be ‘secured’ by a caveat against the property. The appellant claims that he was paid his salary irregularly and in arrears, and that much of his salary was in part repayment of what was owed to him in respect of his credit card, and indeed was funded by the loan secured against his parents’ property and guaranteed by him. The appellant’s evidence was that the $150,000 loan was paid out by a further loan for $243,000 from the ANZ bank. That loan was also used to pay out the line of credit, but the appellant said that other than this, the beneficiaries of the $243,000 were Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos. The $243,000 loan was again secured against the property, and guaranteed by the appellant. In September 2008, Mr Portellos approached Tony and Lyn Gerblich, together with the appellant, for further urgent financial assistance. According to the appellant, the proposal was that the remaining equity in the property be made available to Mr Portellos. The mechanics were that Tony and Lyn Gerblich would sell the property to the appellant, who would borrow the purchase price from the respondent, secured by the mortgage that the respondent now seeks to rely upon in these proceedings. The appellant’s evidence was that he had no need to, and no means to, purchase his parents’ home.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I observe that during the hearing of the appeal the appellant sought to challenge the value the respondent had placed on the property, and asserted a higher value. While the approximate value of the property was of some limited relevance, I do not think the precise value of the property much matters. The Master did not rely upon the respondent’s value for any particular calculation. Its significance was, in my view, confined to a general indication of the extent of the shortfall the respondent might face even if successful in the possession proceedings. In this context, I do not think it matters that a higher valuation might be justified. For this reason, and because the appellant did not challenge the respondent’s assertion as to the value before the Master, I do not think the respondent’s assertion of a higher value in the hearing before me provides a basis for interfering with the Master’s orders.Conclusion In my view, no error has been established in the Master’s exercise of her discretion to determine appropriate payment terms pending resolution of these proceedings. Accordingly, the appeal must be dismissed, and I so order.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In deciding what terms to impose upon the appellant, the Master was exercising a broad discretion to mould the relief so as to protect the respondent mortgagee and at the same time do justice between the parties. It follows that in order to succeed on this appeal the appellant must establish error of the type described in House v The King.[4]That is, the appellant must establish that the Master acted on a wrong principle, allowed extraneous or irrelevant matters to guide or affect her, mistook the facts or did not take into account some material consideration. Alternatively, the appellant must establish that the result embodied in the orders made is, upon the facts, unreasonable or plainly unjust, such that it can be inferred that there has been a failure to properly exercise the relevant discretion despite the precise nature or source of the error not being identifiable.[4] House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499 at 504-505.Consideration The appellant does not contend that no payment terms should have been imposed. The appellant’s contention is that her Honour erred in requiring the payment of $36,450 on account of arrears in interest; that her Honour should merely have required monthly payments of $1,000. While the appellant’s grounds of appeal are diffuse, they can be crystallised into the various specific complaints addressed below. The first complaint made by the appellant is that the Master’s findings were against the weight of the evidence. In support of this ground the appellant referred to a number of affidavits (with large exhibits) which it was suggested the Master had not taken account of. It was also said that in circumstances where a party did not have legal representation (as was the case with the appellant before the Master, and on this appeal), the Court had a duty to look more carefully at the information submitted to the Court. The appellant relied in this respect upon Bankwest v Mann.[5][5] Bankwest v Mann [2015] WASC 187 at [6]. I accept that courts need to be astute to ensure that they appreciate the significance of matters advanced by an unrepresented party. But it does not follow that a court is required to sift entirely unguided through whatever information is put before the court. The court is still entitled to be guided to some extent by the matters raised by an unrepresented party as being important to their case. Here, while the Master was required to consider all of the material placed before her, she was nevertheless entitled to focus upon the contentions raised by the parties, including the appellant through his written submissions. The fact that the hearing proceeded on the papers (to the knowledge of, and with the consent of, both parties) does not materially alter the position. There is nothing in the Master’s reasons that suggests to me that her Honour did not have regard to, and properly understand, all of the material relied upon by the appellant. A significant proportion of that affidavit material related to the appellant’s claims against the mortgagee (by reason of it being on notice of the conduct of Mr Portellos and Ms Tomazos) and against the ANZ bank. Given that the very premise for imposing terms was an acceptance by the Master of Judge Roder’s earlier decision that there was an arguable case against the mortgagee, I do not consider it was necessary for her Honour to analyse that material in her reasons. Similarly, in respect of the claim against the ANZ, it was sufficient that the Master noted the existence of that claim. It was not necessary or appropriate that her Honour analyse, or otherwise form any view as to the prospects of, that claim.