Georgiou v Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd (No 4)

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Georgiou v Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] FCA 1222

Citation: Georgiou v Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd (No 4) [2011] FCA 1222
Parties: EKATERINA (KATERINA) GEORGIOU v SPENCER HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 096 497 148 TRADING AS PROPELL NATIONAL VALUERS (SA), KELVIN JAMES SPENCER, JAMES SPENCER, TERRI CHURCH and JANINE BACKSHALL
File number: SAD 68 of 2010
Judge: BESANKO J
Date of judgment: 28 October 2011
Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE — application pursuant to r 5.04(3) item 12 of the Federal Court Rules by respondents to proceeding for order that applicant identify discovered e-mails apparently sent by her whose authenticity she denied — whether respondents should rely on O18 r 3 of the previous Federal Court Rules — application by respondents for further particulars of claim for privilege over documents — where applicant said provision of further particulars would have effect of disclosing matters over which privilege was claimed — application by respondents for further and better discovery of information obtainable from applicant’s mobile phone — application to strike out particulars inconsistent with the reply filed by applicant — application by applicant for discovery of documents evidencing arrangements by second respondent to meet women during particular period — where second respondent alleged applicant had met with him for sexual intercourse at various hotels — where respondents had discovered hotel receipts — where applicant denied meeting with second respondent — whether there were grounds to believe that relevant documents exist — whether category of documents sought too broad

Held: Orders were made that the applicant identify the e-mails, provide further particulars of her claim of privilege, that further and better discovery of information relating to the applicant’s mobile phone be made, that the particulars be struck out and that the respondents make disclosure of the category of documents sought by the applicant.   

Legislation: Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth) ss 28A, 94
Federal Court Rules 2011
Federal Court Rules (as in force prior to 1 August 2011)  
Cases cited: Cape Wools SA v KPMG Corporate Finance (Vic) Pty Ltd [2002] VSC 571, cited
Commissioner, Australian Federal Police v Propend Finance Pty Ltd (1997) 188 CLR 501, cited
Georgiou v Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd (No 3) [2011] FCA 602, cited
Gertig v Davies [2003] SASC 86; 85 SASR 226, cited
Date of hearing: 27 September, 12 October 2011
Place: Adelaide
Division: GENERAL DIVISION
Category: Catchwords
Number of paragraphs: 59
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr P Heywood-Smith QC with Mr L Leventis
Solicitor for the Applicant: Camatta Lempens Pty Ltd
Counsel for the First, Second, Fifth and Sixth Respondents: Mr M Roder SC with Ms T Birss
Solicitor for the First, Second, Fifth and Sixth Respondents: DLA Phillips Fox
Counsel for the Fourth Respondent: The Fourth Respondent did not appear

IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

GENERAL DIVISION

SAD 68 of 2010

BETWEEN:

EKATERINA (KATERINA) GEORGIOU
Applicant

AND:

SPENCER HOLDINGS PTY LTD ACN 096 497 148 TRADING AS PROPELL…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Georgiou v Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd (No 4) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FCA 1222
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Georgiou v Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd (No 4), the respondents sought various orders in relation to the discovery of information and documents from the applicant, including emails, communications, and documents relating to her alleged meetings with the second respondent. The court was tasked with deciding whether the respondents should be able to rely on certain rules and whether the orders sought were appropriate and not overly broad. The respondents argued that the applicant should identify specific emails, provide further particulars regarding privileged documents, allow for further and better discovery of information from her mobile phone, and make disclosure of documents that evidence arrangements by the second respondent to meet women during a particular period.

The court determined that the respondents' applications were justified due to the specific allegations made by the second respondent and the applicant's denial of those meetings. However, the court found that the proposed orders were too broad and required a more limited approach. The court ordered that the respondents should discover all communications by email or SMS between the second respondent and any other women, excluding family members, that allude to meetings with the second respondent outside of business premises on the days of the alleged sexual intercourse and in the week preceding the incidents. The court also ordered that the applicant should identify the specific emails in question, provide further particulars of her claim of privilege, and allow for further and better discovery of information from her mobile phone.

The court concluded that the orders sought by the respondents were appropriate given the circumstances of the case, but that the orders should be more limited in scope. The court also ordered that the particulars inconsistent with the applicant's reply be struck out. Finally, the court ordered that the respondents make disclosure of the category of documents sought by the applicant. The court gave the respondents the opportunity to bring in minutes of order reflecting the conclusions expressed in these reasons and provided that the order in favour of the applicant could be included in those minutes.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The respondents bring in minutes of order reflecting the conclusions expressed in these reasons.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011

Background

Background to the litigation

The case revolves around a dispute between the applicant, Georgiou, and the respondents, Spencer Holdings Pty Ltd, over certain discovered e-mails and documents. The respondents claim that the applicant sent e-mails whose authenticity she denies and seek an order for her to identify these e-mails. The respondents also contend that the applicant has claimed privilege over certain documents and have requested further particulars of the claim. Additionally, the respondents seek further and better discovery of information obtainable from the applicant's mobile phone. The applicant has alleged that the second respondent arranged meetings with women during a particular period, which he denies. The respondents have discovered hotel receipts that allegedly prove these meetings. The applicant denies meeting the second respondent for sexual intercourse at various hotels.

This case involves applications made by the respondents pursuant to r 5.04(3) item 12 of the Federal Court Rules. The respondents seek an order for the applicant to identify discovered e-mails, provide further particulars of her claim of privilege over documents, and make further and better discovery of information from the applicant’s mobile phone. The respondents also seek to strike out particulars inconsistent with the reply filed by the applicant and for the applicant to provide discovery of documents evidencing arrangements by the second respondent to meet women during a particular period. The matter came before the court following the respondents' applications and the filing of the applicant's reply.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Two matters are clear from the pleadings and the respondents’ List of Documents filed on 28 February 2011. First, the second respondent alleges that he met the applicant at motels and other places and engaged in sexual intercourse with her. He has, he alleges, invoices and receipts to prove these events. Secondly, the applicant denies these alleged meetings. In those particular circumstances the documents described in the proposed order are relevant. However, the proposed order is very broad and in my opinion a more limited order is appropriate. I will make an order in the following terms:That the first and second respondents discover all communications by email or SMS between the second respondent and any and all other women (other than any member of the second respondent’s family) alluding to meetings with the second respondent (other than meetings at the second respondent’s business premises) on the days of the alleged sexual intercourse and encounters in the week preceding the alleged incidences of sexual intercourse in paragraph 12.5 of the Defence.CONCLUSION I will make the orders sought by the respondents and the order set out above in favour of the applicant. As there may be a need for confidentiality undertakings I will give the respondents the opportunity to bring in minutes of order reflecting the conclusions expressed in these reasons. The order in favour of the applicant can be included in those minutes.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court began by addressing the respondents' application to rely on O18 r 3 of the previous Federal Court Rules. The court considered that the respondents' application was not appropriate given the circumstances of the case. It was noted that the proposed order was very broad and therefore, the court deemed a more limited order to be appropriate. The court then turned to the issue of the applicant's claim of privilege over documents and ruled that the applicant must provide further particulars. The court found that the documents in question were relevant to the proceedings and the particulars would not have the effect of disclosing matters over which privilege was claimed. Regarding the discovery of information from the applicant's mobile phone, the court held that there were grounds to believe that relevant documents exist, and therefore, further and better discovery should be made. The court also struck out the particulars inconsistent with the reply filed by the applicant. Lastly, the court ruled that the respondents should make disclosure of the category of documents sought by the applicant. The court considered that the category of documents sought was not too broad and there were grounds to believe that the documents exist. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in cases where there is a dispute over the existence of documents and their relevance, the court will consider the necessity of a more limited order, the relevance of the documents in question, and the grounds to believe that the documents exist. The court distinguished the current case from prior authority by finding that a more limited order was appropriate and that the category of documents sought was not too broad.