George Stack v Davies Shephard Pty Ltd and GSA Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

official notice

decision of a deputy commissioner of patents

Application  :          Petty Patent No. 645740 in the name of GEORGE STACK

Title:          Water Meter Assemblies

Action:          Section 28 notices by DAVIES SHEPHARD PTY LTD, and GSA INDUSTRIES (AUST.) PTY LTD.

Decision:          Issued   . 

Claim admitted two arrangements of features. One arrangement was fairly based, and if the claim was limited to it the claim would be entitled to an early priority date. The other arrangement was not fairly based. As the other arrangement was introduced in an amendment, the claims had a priority date determined by s.114. As a result the claims were anticipated by use involving the first arrangement of features between the early priority date and the late priority date.

The notice of entitlement merely stated that ‘The person nominated is entitled to the grant of the patent’. Onus lies with the patentee to substantiate their entitlement when there is proper cause to query it. The available material is consistent with a company (G S Technology Pty Ltd) being the eligible person (not the patentee). Circumstances are apparently inconsistent with a clerical error or obvious mistake, and thus an adverse finding might not be correctable. Patentee allowed an opportunity to request to serve further evidence, with the opponents having the opportunity to object. Finding on entitlement deferred pending consideration of possible further evidence.

Decision on whether to afford the patentee an opportunity to amend deferred until the decision on entitlement made.

patents act 1990

decision of a dePUTY commissioner of patents

Re:Petty Patent No. 645740 in the name of GEORGE STACK , and section 28 notices by DAVIES SHEPHARD PTY LTD, and GSA INDUSTRIES (AUST.) PTY LTD.

background

Petty Patent 645740 was filed on 25 August 1993, as application 44897/93. The application was filed as a divisional application based on patent application 85236/91 (PCT/AU91/00404) which was filed on 30 August 1991. In turn, that application claims priority from two provisional applications - PK2036 filed on 30 August 1990, and PK5286 filed on 26 March 1991.

(For the purpose of completeness, I note two other related applications. Petty patent 662284 was filed on 17 February 1994 as a divisional application based on 85236/91; the petty patent was sealed on 24 August 1995. Application 32815/95 was filed on 21 September 1995 as a divisional application for a standard patent, again based on patent application 85236/91. Finally, I note that 85236/91 lapsed on 24 Sept. 1995 through failing to be accepted within 21 months of the first examination report.)

The applicant filed amendments to the petty patent application on 10 and 18 November 1993. The petty patent was granted on 20 Jan 1994. On 20 Dec 1994 Davies Shephard Pty Ltd, and GSA Industries (Aust.) Pty Ltd, filed their s.28 notices with identical evidence. After the patentee had filed evidence in response the matter was heard in Canberra on Nov 23 and 24, 1995. The patentee was represented by Mr A Abaza (solicitor). Davies Shephard…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read George Stack v Davies Shephard Pty Ltd and GSA Industries (A... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1996] APO 1
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of George Stack v Davies Shephard Pty Ltd and GSA Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd involves a challenge to the validity of Petty Patent No. 645740, granted to George Stack, by Davies Shephard Pty Ltd and GSA Industries (Aust) Pty Ltd. The challenge was initiated under section 28 of the Patents Act 1990, which allows a person to assert that a patent is invalid based on various grounds. The key issues in this case revolve around the fair basis of the claims, the priority dates, novelty, and the entitlement of the patentee.

The Deputy Commissioner of Patents examined the claims and found that claim 1 had two possible interpretations. One interpretation was fairly based on the specification, while the other was not. Given that the non-fairly based interpretation was introduced through an amendment, the priority date for the claims was determined by section 114 of the Patents Act, leading to the claims being anticipated by prior uses. The Commissioner concluded that if the claims were limited to the fairly based interpretation, they would be entitled to an earlier priority date and would not be anticipated. However, the decision on whether to allow an opportunity to amend the claims was deferred pending the resolution of the entitlement issue.

The entitlement issue was significant as the notice of entitlement did not substantiate the patentee's entitlement. The available evidence suggested that the eligible person might have been G S Technology Pty Ltd, a company of which Stack was a director and CEO, rather than Stack himself. The Commissioner found that there was a serious question about Stack's entitlement to the patent. Consequently, the Commissioner allowed Stack an opportunity to present further evidence to substantiate his entitlement, with the opponents having the right to object and present their own evidence. The decision on the other grounds of objection, including the opportunity to amend the claims, was deferred pending the outcome of the entitlement issue.

The Commissioner also addressed the issue of costs, noting that in cases before the Commissioner, costs usually follow the event. In this case, costs were awarded against the patentee, Mr. George Stack, up to the date of the decision. The decision underscores the importance of establishing entitlement and the potential consequences of failing to do so, as well as the procedural steps involved in addressing such issues within the framework of the Patents Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.