George Munoz & Ors. v Manly Council

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

Land and Environment Court


of New South Wales


CITATION: George Munoz & Ors. v Manly Council [2006] NSWLEC 471
PARTIES:

APPLICANT
George Munoz & Ors.

RESPONDENT
Manly Council
FILE NUMBER(S): 10949 of 2005
CORAM: Murrell C
KEY ISSUES: Appeal :- Development application for demolition of dwelling and erection of 2 attached dwellings, impact on conservation area and streetscape, garages at front boundary, design of proposal
LEGISLATION CITED: Manly Local Environmental Plan 1988
Manly Development Control Plan Residential Zones 2001
CASES CITED: Zhang v Canterbury City Council [2004] NSWLEC 500
DATES OF HEARING: 02/05/2006 and 13/07/2006
EX TEMPORE JUDGMENT DATE: 07/13/2006
LEGAL REPRESENTATIVES:

APPLICANT
Mr M Seymour, barrister
Instructed by: Mr J Pappas, solicitor
SOLICITORS
James Pappas Solicitors

RESPONDENT
Ms L Finn, solicitor
SOLICITORS
Abbout Tout



JUDGMENT:

      THE LAND AND
      ENVIRONMENT COURT
      OF NEW SOUTH WALES

      Murrell C

      13 July 2006

      10949 of 2005 George Munoz & Ors. v Manly Council

      JUDGMENT
              This determination was given extemporaneously
              and it has been edited prior to publication

1 This is an ex-tempore judgment for a matter that came before the Court on 2 May 2006 as consent orders. During the hearing of the consent orders on that day, the Court expressed concern about the streetscape and the ‘fit’ of the proposed development as the subject site is located in a conservation area. The Court however, gave the applicant the opportunity to amend the plans to address concerns expressed by the Court.

2 By way of comment, when the plans came before the Court on 2 May they were substantially different plans to those the subject of the original appeal. The proposal was amended as a result of the Court-appointed expert’s recommendations. However, the Court did not accept the Court-appointed expert’s recommendations or the plans before it on 2 May 2006.

3 The plans that have come before the Court today, known as Exhibit E, have been assessed by council’s heritage officer, Ms Smith, and also council’s town planner, Mr Watson. Mr Phillips, a heritage architect consultant has also provided expert evidence to the Court on behalf of the applicant.

4 By way of a description of the subject site, the subject site is known as No. 20 Denison Street, Manly. The site is rectangular in shape and has an area of some 331 sq m. It is a relatively narrow site and it is within the ‘Pittwater Road Conservation Area’ under the Manly Local Environmental Plan.

5 On its eastern boundary the site is adjoined by a right of carriageway approximately 900 mm and this serves a number of properties to the east.

6 At the commencement of the hearing on site the Court heard from an objector to the proposal, Mr Walters, who owns an adjoining property, and he is concerned about the proposed development providing continued access over the right-of-way for his property. As such a condition has been incorporated into the consent orders provided by the council to ensure owners of the adjoining properties have free access to the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read George Munoz & Ors. v Manly Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NSWLEC 471
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, the case of George Munoz & Ors. v Manly Council concerned an appeal against the decision of Manly Council to deny a development application for the demolition of a single-storey dwelling and the erection of two attached dwellings on a property at 20 Denison Street, Manly. The appeal was heard on two occasions, the first being on 2 May 2006, where the Court expressed concerns about the streetscape and the fit of the proposed development within the conservation area. The Court provided the applicants the opportunity to amend the plans to address these concerns. The applicants subsequently presented amended plans, which the Court found to be more passive and better suited to the conservation area.

The legal issues the Court had to address involved the compliance of the proposed development with the provisions of the Manly Local Environmental Plan and the Manly Development Control Plan Residential Zones 2001, particularly in relation to the conservation area and streetscape, the placement of garages, and the design of the proposal. The Court had to consider whether the proposed development would detract from the heritage significance of the conservation area and whether the design respected the form and scale of the original buildings in the area.

In its reasoning, the Court acknowledged that while the amended plans generally complied with the development control plan provisions, there was an issue with the placement of garages at the front of the buildings, which was not permitted under the guidelines. However, considering the overall design and the expert evidence, the Court concluded that a variation to this provision was warranted, as the proposed development would sit comfortably within the conservation area without dominating it. The Court was satisfied that the detailing provided in the plans would reduce the visibility of the garages and reinforce the rhythm with the adjoining properties.

The Court granted consent for the development application subject to a deferred commencement and specific conditions to ensure that the proposal was carefully considered from a heritage conservation perspective and provided an appropriate form. The deferred commencement allowed for the approval of the final plans by the Council, incorporating recommendations from the joint experts, and ensuring compliance with the requirements of the Local Environment Plan and Development Control Plan. The Court also ordered that the exhibits, except for specific ones, be returned to the parties.

In conclusion, the Court upheld the appeal by consent, granted the development application subject to the conditions agreed upon by the parties, and returned the exhibits to the parties accordingly. The Court's decision was based on the satisfactory nature of the amended plans, taking into account the conservation area and streetscape considerations, and the expert evidence provided during the proceedings.