George Bilios and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL             )

)        No: 2012/1516

General Administrative Division               )

Re: George Bilios
Applicant

And: Inspector-General in Bankruptcy
Respondent

CORRIGENDUM

TRIBUNAL:             Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member

DATE:   11 January 2013

PLACE:                  Sydney

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision in this application as follows:

  1. Where in the decision summary on the first page and paragraph 31 of the decision currently reads:

(a)In relation to CAP 1 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $98,250.70.

(b)In relation to CAP 2 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $99,221.71.

(c)In relation to CAP 3 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $116,766.36.

The decision shall now read:

(a)In relation to CAP 1 a decision that the Applicant’s Contribution Liability is $98,250.70.

(b)In relation to CAP 2 a decision that the Applicant’s Contribution Liability is $99,221.71.

(c)In relation to CAP 3 a decision that the Applicant’s Contribution Liability is $116,766.36.

...........................[sgd]........................................
Mr Dean Letcher, QC
Senior Member

[2012] AATA 873

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2012/1516

Re

George Bilios

APPLICANT

And

Inspector-General in Bankruptcy

RESPONDENT

Decision

Tribunal

Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member

Date 11 December 2012 
Place Sydney

The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 19 March 2012.

The Tribunal substitutes for that decision:

(a) In relation to CAP 1 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $98,250.70.

(b) In relation to CAP 2 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $99,221.71.

(c) In relation to CAP 3 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $116,766.36.

..................................[sgd]......................................

Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member

Catchwords

BANKRUPTCY – bankrupt's obligation to pay contributions – calculation of assessed income – contribution assessment period – whether calculation of assessed income correct – decision under review set aside and substituted

Legislation

Bankruptcy Act 1996 (Cth) ss 139, 139L, 139K, 139W, 139ZA, 139ZF

Cases

Inspector- General in Bankruptcy v McGushin [2009] FCA 662

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Dean Letcher, QC, Senior Member

11 December 2012

Background

  1. Dr George Bilios is a general practitioner doctor who has worked at the same medical centre continuously since 1993. On 23 May 2008 he was made bankrupt, but he continued in his medical practice during and after the period of bankruptcy, which ended on 23 May 2011. During the three years of 2005 – 2007 before bankruptcy, he earned over $500,000 each year, but in the three years of bankruptcy he says that his earnings were only an agreed salary of about $180,000 per year.

  2. The medical centre was owned by a company Emergency Medical Group (“EMG”), the equal shareholders of which were five doctors’ practice companies including Dr Bilios’ G Bilios Medical Pty Ltd (“GBM”).

  3. The commercial arrangements were that each of the five received 80 per cent of their individual gross billings. The residual 20 per cent was used to pay for the services of other doctors working under…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read George Bilios and Inspector-General in Bankruptcy and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] AATA 873
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of George Bilios and the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy, the primary dispute involved the calculation of the bankrupt's assessed income for specific contribution assessment periods, which in turn affected the amount of contributions he was required to pay. The case was heard and determined by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT), which was called upon to review the decision of the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy.

The legal issues central to the case revolved around the accuracy of the calculation of the bankrupt's assessed income over three distinct contribution assessment periods. The Tribunal was tasked with determining whether the Inspector-General's methodology in assessing the income was correct and whether the resultant decisions regarding the bankrupt's contributions were just and equitable. This involved a detailed examination of the evidence provided by the parties, particularly the financial transactions and the allowances made for personal services rendered by the bankrupt.

The AAT found in favour of the Respondent, accepting the calculations provided by the Inspector-General as set out in the tabular form annexed to the Respondent's final submissions. These calculations reflected payments made by EGM to GBM, with adjustments for personal services rendered by the Applicant. The Tribunal determined that the calculations correctly attributed the income to the Applicant for each of the contribution assessment periods, after accounting for the amounts already paid by the Applicant. Consequently, the Tribunal set aside the original decision dated 19 March 2012 and substituted new decisions regarding the assessed income for each of the three periods, specifying the amount for each period.

In summary, the Tribunal's final orders established the correct assessed income for each of the contribution assessment periods, providing clarity on the bankrupt's obligation to pay contributions. The Tribunal's decision underscored the importance of precise calculations and the need for the Inspector-General to accurately reflect the bankrupt's income when determining contribution obligations.

Background

Background to the litigation

George Bilios, the applicant, was adjudged bankrupt by the Federal Circuit Court. Following the adjudication, the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy assessed the applicant's income for the purposes of determining the bankrupt's contribution to the costs of his bankruptcy. The Inspector-General calculated the assessed income based on payments made by EGM to GBM, which were attributable to the applicant's income from personal services. The applicant disputed the Inspector-General's calculations, leading to an appeal by the Inspector-General to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The tribunal was required to determine the correctness of the Inspector-General's assessment of the applicant's income for three specific contribution assessment periods.

The case was brought before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal as an appeal by the Inspector-General in Bankruptcy against a decision made by the Federal Circuit Court. The Inspector-General sought to have the tribunal review and substitute its own decision for that of the Federal Circuit Court regarding the calculation of the applicant's assessed income for bankruptcy contributions. This appeal followed an initial assessment and subsequent objection by the applicant. The tribunal heard submissions from both parties and reviewed the evidence presented to make its decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

I accept the Respondent’s calculations which are set out in tabular form annexed to the Respondent’s final submissions. They reflect the payments by EGM to GBM and the allowance made to arrive at a figure attributable to the Applicant’s income from personal services for each of the Contribution Assessment Periods (“CAPs 1, 2 and 3”), less the amount already paid by the Applicant. The main issue between the parties was the amount of Assessed Income for each of the periods, and for the reasons set out above I find in favour of the Respondent’s contentions.Decision The Tribunal sets aside the decision under review dated 19 March 2012. The Tribunal substitutes for that decision:(a)In relation to CAP 1 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $98,250.70.(b)In relation to CAP 2 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $99,221.71.(c)In relation to CAP 3 a decision that the Applicant’s Assessed Income is $116,766.36.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the primary dispute revolved around the calculation of the applicant's assessed income for the specified contribution assessment periods. The Inspector-General provided detailed calculations which the court found to be reflective of the payments made by EGM to GBM and the necessary adjustments to determine the income attributable to the applicant's personal services. The tribunal found that these calculations, presented in tabular form in the respondent's submissions, accurately accounted for the amounts already paid by the applicant and thus were acceptable. This acceptance led to the original decision being set aside and replaced with the tribunal's own determination, specifying the assessed income for each of the three contribution assessment periods. The tribunal's decision is based on a meticulous review of the financial transactions and adjustments as presented by the Inspector-General, affirming the correctness of these calculations over the applicant's contentions. The binding legal principle established here pertains to the method of calculating assessed income for bankruptcy contribution purposes, emphasizing the tribunal's role in verifying and, if necessary, substituting the Inspector-General's calculations with its own determination.