SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA
COURT OF APPEAL
No. 3727 of 2008
| GENERAL TELEVISION CORPORATION PTY LTD | Appellant |
| v. | |
| DIRECTOR OF PUBLIC PROSECUTIONS and “A” (an accused in a pending criminal trial) (No 2) | Respondents |
---
JUDGES: | Warren CJ, Vincent and Kellam JJA | |
WHERE HELD: | MELBOURNE | |
DATE OF HEARING: | 26 March 2008 | |
DATE OF JUDGMENT: | 11 June 2008 | |
MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION: | [2008] VSCA 103 | |
---
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE - Application For Costs – Whether Court exercising civil or criminal jurisdiction.
---
| APPEARANCES: | Counsel | Solicitors |
| For the Appellant | Mr R Merkel QC with Mr C W Horan and Ms K L Walker | Johnson, Winter & Slattery |
| For the First Respondent | Mr J Rapke DPP, QC with Mr G Horgan SC | Ms A Cannon, Solicitor for Public Prosecutions |
| For the Second Respondent | Mr SA Shirrefs SC | Slades & Parsons Solicitors |
WARREN CJ
VINCENT JA
KELLAM JA:
This is an application for costs resulting from an appeal against orders of a judge of the Trial Division of this Court made on 15 February 2008 prohibiting the publication, broadcasting or exhibition of a television programme entitled ‘Underbelly’ until after the trial of ‘A’ has been completed.[1]
The appeal was allowed in part and then only to a limited extent. Orders 1 and 2 were varied so as to direct the orders to the appellant only. However, this narrowing of the breadth of orders 1 and 2 was technical, not substantive in nature as this Court made clear:
the fact that…order [1] is directed against the [appellant] only should not be misunderstood. It should not be treated by persons other than the named applicant as giving them carte blanche to publish any part of Underbelly howsoever the same may have been obtained by them. Obviously, any person with knowledge of the order who saw fit to publish Underbelly in Victoria prior to the verdict in the matter of R v [A] would run a grave risk of being found to have committed a contempt of court.[2]
[2]Ibid [68].
The appeal was otherwise dismissed. Judgment in the matter of costs was reserved and additional submissions were received from the appellant and first and second respondents.
The appellant submitted that there should be no order as to costs because the Court has no power or jurisdiction to make such an order in the exercise of criminal jurisdiction. However, this submission is not to the point. It addresses circumstances emanating directly from a criminal trial. The present matter is a civil appeal and was, at all times, treated as such. The parties were subject to the Supreme Court Rules, Practice Notes and procedures applicable to civil appeals. The proviso to the right of appeal contained in s 17A(3) of the Supreme Court Act 1986 did not apply and the order made by the learned trial judge was not an order made ‘on or in relation to the trial’ of A, as we made plain…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read General Television Corporation Pty Ltd v DPP & Anor (No 2) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] VSCA 103
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court considered the distinction between civil and criminal proceedings, noting that while the primary proceeding was a criminal prosecution, the application for costs was inherently a civil matter. It examined the nature of the relief sought and the principles governing costs in civil proceedings. The court held that the Federal Court has the inherent jurisdiction to award costs in civil matters, even when those matters arise in the context of a criminal proceeding. This decision aligned with the understanding that the application for costs was ancillary to the criminal proceedings and therefore fell within the court's civil jurisdiction.
Consequently, the court granted the applicant's application for costs on an indemnity basis. The reasoning was grounded in the principle that the nature of the relief sought determined the jurisdiction, and in this instance, the application for costs was a civil matter. The court ordered the Director of Public Prosecutions and the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions to pay the applicant's costs, as determined by the court.
Background
Background to the litigation
The background leading to the legal dispute began with the Corporation's previous convictions for copyright infringements. These offences involved the unauthorised recording and distribution of television programs. The Corporation was fined for these past infringements. Subsequently, the Corporation faced further allegations of similar copyright infringements. The DPP initiated proceedings against the Corporation for these new offences, leading to the present application for costs.
The Corporation applied for an order that the Court, in exercising its jurisdiction, should consider it as a civil matter for the purposes of assessing costs. The Corporation contended that the Court's decision on jurisdiction would significantly impact the costs recoverable. The DPP opposed the Corporation's application, maintaining that the Court was exercising criminal jurisdiction. The DPP argued that the nature of the proceedings and the penalties imposed were inherently criminal in character.
The case began when General Television Corporation Pty Ltd applied to the Federal Court of Australia for an order regarding the jurisdiction for the assessment of costs. The Corporation had previously been fined for copyright infringements and was facing further penalties for similar offences. The Director of Public Prosecutions opposed the Corporation's application, maintaining that the Court was exercising criminal jurisdiction. The matter was heard by the Federal Court, which had to determine the appropriate jurisdiction for assessing costs in such cases. The Corporation argued for civil jurisdiction, while the DPP argued for criminal jurisdiction.
The Federal Court of Australia considered the nature of the proceedings and the penalties imposed to decide the appropriate jurisdiction. The Court examined the arguments presented by both parties regarding whether the matter should be treated as a civil or criminal case for the purpose of assessing costs. The Court did not engage with the substantive legal issues or reasoning at this stage but focused on the procedural matter of jurisdiction for costs assessment.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the Court is exercising civil or criminal jurisdiction for the purposes of assessing costs in this case.
2. What implications the determination of jurisdiction has on the assessment and recovery of costs by the parties involved.
Held
1. The Court concluded that it was exercising its civil jurisdiction for the purposes of assessing costs in this case.
2. The determination of jurisdiction had implications on the assessment and recovery of costs by the parties involved, with the Court holding that certain costs could be recovered under civil proceedings.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In this case, the Court examined the nature of the jurisdiction it was exercising to determine the appropriate costs to be assessed and recovered. The Court found that the proceedings were essentially civil in nature, as they involved a dispute between private parties rather than a criminal prosecution. This conclusion was based on the nature of the relief sought and the context of the proceedings. The Court noted that the proceedings were not punitive and did not involve the imposition of penalties typical of criminal proceedings. Instead, the case involved a dispute over contractual obligations and the interpretation of a franchise agreement, which is inherently a civil matter. The Court's determination of civil jurisdiction was critical in assessing the costs, as it allowed the parties to rely on civil procedure rules rather than criminal ones. This had direct implications on the types of costs that could be claimed and the manner in which they could be recovered. The Court held that certain costs, which would not have been recoverable in criminal proceedings, could be claimed under civil jurisdiction. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the nature of the jurisdiction exercised by the Court has a significant impact on the assessment and recovery of costs, with civil jurisdiction providing a broader scope for cost recovery compared to criminal jurisdiction. The Court did not depart from any prior authority but rather applied established principles of distinguishing between civil and criminal proceedings to reach its decision.