General Mills, Inc v Maria & Nikitas Chritofis

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

TRADE MARKS ACT 1995



DECISION OF A DELEGATE OF THE REGISTRAR OF TRADE MARKS WITH REASONS

Re:Opposition by General Mills, Inc to registration of trade mark application 1297840(32) - NATURE'S VALLEY - filed in the name of Maria and Nikitas Christofis.

Delegate: Nicole Worth
Representation: Opponent: Trevor Stevens of Davies Collison Cave, Patent & Trade Mark Attorneys
Applicant: Michael Hall of Counsel, instructed by Jirsch Sutherland IP
Decision: 2012 ATMO 59
S52 opposition: Ground pursued under s 44 only - section 44 partially established – no award of costs.

Background

  1. On 7 May 2009 Maria and Nikitas Christofis (‘the Applicants’) applied to register a trade mark, relevant details of which appear below:

    Trade Mark: NATURE’S VALLEY

    Goods: Class 32: Aerated beverages (non-alcoholic); alcohol free beverages; beverages consisting of a blend of fruit and vegetable juices; beverages containing not more than 1.15% (by volume) of alcohol; beverages made from fruit concentrates; coconut milk (beverages); edible essences for making beverages; electrolyte replacement beverages for general and sports purposes; essences for making beverages; extracts of vegetables (beverages); fruit beverages; fruit concentrates for making beverages; fruit juice beverages; fruit juice extracts (beverages or for making beverages); fruit juice extracts for use as a beverage; fruit juice nectar (beverages or for making beverages); fruit syrup (beverages or for making beverages); grain based non-alcoholic beverages; hop concentrates for use in the preparation of beverages; hop essences for use in the preparation of beverages; hop extracts for use in the preparation of beverages; isotonic beverages; kvass (non-alcoholic beverages); lemon juice (beverage); low alcohol beverages containing not more than 1.15% (by volume) of alcohol; malt based preparations for making beverages; malt-containing beverages (beers); malt-containing beverages (non-alcoholic, except beers); milk of almonds (beverage); mineral water (beverages); multi-vitamin fruit juice beverages (not for medical use); non-alcoholic barley based beverages; non-alcoholic beverages; non-alcoholic fruit juice beverages; non-alcoholic honey-based beverages; pastilles for effervescing beverages; powders for effervescing beverages; preparations for making beverages; seltzers (beverages); sherbets (beverages); sorbets (beverages); soya based beverages (not being dairy substitutes); spring water (beverages), other than for medical purposes; squashes (non-alcoholic beverages); syrup for making beverages; syrup powder for beverages; syrups for beverages; tisanes (non-medicated beverages and other than tea based); tomato juice (beverage); tonic water (non-medicated beverages); tropical fruit squash (beverages); vegetable extracts (beverages); vegetable juice concentrates (beverages); vegetable juices (beverages); water (beverage) other than for medical use; waters (beverages); whey beverages.

  2. The application was examined and accepted for possible registration. Acceptance of the application was advertised in the Australian Official Journal of Trade Marks on 10 September 2009.

  3. After obtaining an extension of time in which to do so, on 10 March 2010 General Mills, Inc. (‘the Opponent’) filed a Notice of Opposition nominating most of the grounds available under the Trade Marks Act 1995 (‘the Act’).

  4. The parties served and filed evidence in due course. Five days prior to the hearing the Applicant served and filed its written submissions in which it indicated its intention to request an adjournment of the matter, in order to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read General Mills, Inc v Maria & Nikitas Chritofis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] ATMO 59
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an opposition by General Mills, Inc. (the Opponent) to the trade mark application by Maria & Nikitas Chritofis (the Applicant). The Opponent sought to prevent the registration of the Applicant's trade mark, arguing it was substantially identical with or deceptively similar to its own registered trade mark. The hearing officer, Nicole Worth, was tasked with determining whether the grounds of opposition were established.

The primary legal issue before the hearing officer was whether the Applicant's proposed trade mark was substantially identical with or deceptively similar to the Opponent's registered trade mark, pursuant to section 44 of the *Trade Marks Act*. This required an assessment of both the trade marks themselves and the similarity of the goods in respect of which they were to be registered. The onus was on the Opponent to prove its grounds of opposition on the balance of probabilities.

In her reasoning, the hearing officer compared the trade marks side-by-side, noting that the Applicant's mark, "NATURE'S VALLEY," was substantially identical to the Opponent's registered mark, "NATURE VALLEY," finding the addition of the possessive "S" to be a trifling variant. The assessment then turned to whether the goods were of the same description, considering the potential for purchasers to perceive the same trade origin if the marks were used on similar products. The hearing officer adopted a pragmatic approach, acknowledging the extensive specifications of goods for both parties.

Ultimately, the hearing officer found that the Opponent had partially met the onus of proof. While a conflict was identified in relation to some goods, it was not established for all. The application was refused in respect of goods not specifically discussed and found to be sufficiently different. The Applicant was granted one month to amend its goods specification to those identified as not conflicting. In the absence of such amendment, the application would be refused entirely. No order as to costs was made, with each party to bear its own costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Opponent bears the onus of proof of establishing its ground of opposition on the balance of probabilities. See for example Gyles J in Pfizer Products Inc v Karam (2006) 70 IPR 599 at [6] to [26]. See also Chocolaterie Guylian N.V. v Registrar of Trade Marks (2009) 82 IPR 13 per Sundberg J at [22] to [27], and NV Sumatra Tobacco Trading Company v British American Tobacco Services Limited [2011] FCA 1051 (9 September 2011) per Greenwood J at [16] to [32].Evidence The evidence served and filed in respect of this matter is as follows: Section 44 of the Act relevantly provides:(1) Subject to subsections (3) and (4), an application for the registration of a trade mark (applicant's trade mark) in respect of goods (applicant's goods) must be rejected if:(a) the applicant's trade mark is substantially identical with, or deceptively similar to:(i) a trade mark registered by another person in respect of similar goods or closely related services; or(ii) a trade mark whose registration in respect of similar goods or closely related services is being sought by another person; and(b) the priority date for the registration of the applicant's trade mark in respect of the applicant's goods is not earlier than the priority date for the registration of the other trade mark in respect of the similar goods or closely related services.Note 1: For deceptively similar see section 10.Note 2: For similar goods see subsection 14(1).Note 3: For priority date see section 12. The Opponent’s evidence indicates that the basis for the ground of opposition under section 44 is its trade mark registrations numbered 347155, 832955 and 1237372. At the hearing only registration 347155 was pursued in detail. I will proceed on this basis also, and address the other registrations should the ground not be established with respect to registration 347155. The relevant details of registration 347155 are:Trade Mark: NATURE VALLEYGoods: Class 30: All goods in this classPriority Date: 11 June 1980 Windeyer J, in Shell Co of Australia Ltd v Esso Standard Oil (Aust) Ltd[3] said of substantial identity:In considering whether marks are substantially identical they should, I think, be compared side by side, their similarities and differences noted and the importance of these assessed having regard to the essential feature of the registered mark and the total impression of resemblance or dissimilarity that emerges form the comparison.[3] (1963) 1B IPR 523, at 528. In comparing the trade marks NATURE VALLEY and NATURE’S VALLEY, I consider that a ‘total impression of resemblance’ between the two trade marks emerges. The difference of the possessive ‘S’ present in the Applicant’s mark is a trifling variant, such that the Opponent’s trade mark is substantially identical to it. What remains to be determined, then, is whether the respective goods for the Opponent’s and Applicant’s trade marks are similar. Section 14 of the Act states that goods are similar to other goods if they are the same as the other goods, or of the same description as that of the other goods. The expression ‘goods of the same description’ is a term of art describing the relationship between products such that they would be seen by purchasers as having the same trade origin if sold under deceptively similar marks[4]. In considering whether the goods of the parties are of the same description, I bear in mind the comments of Mason J regarding notional use in Berlei Hestia Industries Ltd v The Bali Company Inc[5]:[T]he question whether there is a likelihood of confusion is to be answered, not by reference to the manner in which the respondent has used its mark in the past, but by reference to the use to which it can properly put the mark. The issue is whether that use would give rise to a real danger of confusion.[4] As described in Shanahan’s Australian Law of Trade Marks and Passing Off Online 4th Edition, 2008 at 35.505, which cites Polo Textile Industries Pty Ltd v Domestic Textile Corp Pty Ltd (1993) 26 IPR 246 (FC).[5] [1973] HCA 43; (1973) 129 CLR 353, at 362.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Section 55 of the Act relevantly provides:DecisionUnless the proceedings are discontinued or dismissed, the Registrar must, at the end, decide:(a) to refuse to register the trade mark; or(b) to register the trade mark (with or without conditions or limitations) in respect of the goods and/or services then specified in the application;having regard to the extent (if any) to which any ground on which the application was opposed has been established.Note: For limitations see section 6. I find that the Opponent has partially met the onus upon it in terms of the ground of opposition under section 44. Whilst I have found that there is no conflict between the marks in respect of some of the Applicant’s goods, I do not intend to go through the specification of goods item by item, particularly as many of those items are separated by only fine distinctions. Rather I believe it necessary to adopt a pragmatic approach. The Applicant’s evidence indicates that currently its goods of interest are fruit juices. Bearing in mind that the Applicant should not be limited to only those goods where there is no conflict with others in its specification, and that it would be unreasonable to discuss each of its 50 plus items and how they compare to the 250 plus items in class 30, I consider it reasonable that the Applicant limit its goods to those which I have discussed and found to be sufficiently different to “all goods in class 30”, being:Fruit juices, vegetable juices, malt based beverages, malt-based preparations for making beverages; mal-containing beverages; soya based beverages (not being dairy substitutes).I refuse the application in respect of the remaining goods. I will allow the Applicant one month from the date of this decision to amend it goods to those identified above. In the event that the Applicant does not amend its goods within the time specified, I refuse the application in its entirety. If the Registrar has been served with a notice of appeal before that time the disposition of the registration should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction.Costs Each of the parties has requested costs. As neither party has been entirely successful I decline to make an order as to costs in favour of any party. I consider that the appropriate course on this occasion is that each party should be responsible for meeting its own costs.Nicole WorthHearing OfficerTrade Marks Hearings20 June 2012

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.