Gemcove Asset Pty Ltd v Sirote Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 24 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gemcove Asset Pty Ltd v Sirote Pty Ltd [2000] FCA 619

GEMCOVE ASSET PTY LTD v SIROTE PTY LTD, STEPHEN GOEREE, KATHLEEN GOEREE and EXCLUSIVE 4 X 4

WG 16 of 1999

CARR J
10 FEBRUARY 2000
PERTH


IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

WESTERN AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY

WG 16 OF 1999

BETWEEN:

GEMCOVE ASSET PTY LTD
as Trustee for the Wall Family Trust
Applicant

AND:

SIROTE PTY LTD (ACN 009 409 036)
First Respondent

STEPHEN GOEREE, KATHLEEN GOEREE
Second Respondent

EXCLUSIVE 4 X 4
Third Respondent

JUDGE:

CARR J

DATE:

10 FEBRUARY 2000

PLACE:

PERTH

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

Introduction

  1. The Court has before it a motion on notice by which the respondents seek an order that these proceedings be transferred to the District Court of Western Australia at Perth, pursuant to s 5(4) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth). The applicant opposes the motion.

    Factual and Procedural Background

  2. The following summary of the factual background is taken variously from allegations made in the statement of claim and affidavits which have been filed by the parties.  Nothing in this recitation of facts should, of course, be taken as in any way amounting to a finding of fact for the purposes of the proceedings.

  3. On 4 June 1998 the applicant (which I shall refer to as “Gemcove”) and the first respondent (which I shall refer to as “Sirote”) entered into a written agreement, (“the Contract”) whereby Sirote agreed to sell and Gemcove agreed to buy the goodwill, plant, equipment and stock-in-trade of a business carried on under the name “S & G Gearbox Exchange” (the Business) at Welshpool, a suburb of Perth.  The purchase price for the Business was $238,000, allocated in the contract as to $130,000 for stock-in-trade, $40,000 for fixtures and other plant and $58,000 for goodwill.  I appreciate that the applicant considers that the allocation of values is not strictly accurate.  For example, the applicant suggests that the value of stock is higher than the actual value, but that there was an adjustment to take into account the fact that the applicant had assumed responsibility for future long service leave entitlements and the like.  However, I treat the total purchase price and the allocation of $58,000 for goodwill as broadly indicating the dimensions of the transaction.

  4. The contract contained a restrictive covenant on Sirote’s part not to engage or be interested in any business of the nature of the Business within a radius of 150 kms from the premises at which the Business had been conducted by it (“the Premises”) for a period of five years from the date of the Contract.  There was also a clause that Sirote would not during that period engage in conduct derogating from Gemcove’s right to obtain the full benefit of the goodwill of the Business.  In accordance with another clause in the Contract the second respondents (whom I shall call Mr and Mrs Goeree) entered into a deed (“the Deed”) with the applicant whereby…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gemcove Asset Pty Ltd v Sirote Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2000] FCA 619
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gemcove Asset Pty Ltd v Sirote Pty Ltd involved a dispute over a business sale agreement and subsequent restrictive covenants. Gemcove Asset Pty Ltd, the plaintiff, sought to enforce a restrictive covenant against Sirote Pty Ltd, the first defendant, which had agreed not to engage in a similar business within a 150 km radius for five years after the sale of the business known as "S & G Gearbox Exchange." The plaintiff also sought to enforce similar restrictions against Mr. and Mrs. Goeree, the directors of Sirote Pty Ltd, who had entered into a separate deed with Gemcove Asset. The dispute arose when Sirote Pty Ltd commenced a business similar to the sold business in breach of the restrictive covenant, prompting Gemcove Asset to seek relief in the Federal Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the restrictive covenant was valid and enforceable and if the Federal Court had the appropriate jurisdiction to hear the case. The court needed to determine whether the restrictive covenant was reasonable and necessary to protect the goodwill of the business and whether the Federal Court should retain jurisdiction or transfer the case to the District Court of Western Australia. The court also considered the plaintiff's motivation for initiating the proceedings in the Federal Court, particularly regarding the potential financial implications and the likelihood of recovering more than $250,000 in damages.

The court found that the restrictive covenant was reasonable and necessary to protect the goodwill of the business, as evidenced by the allocated value of $58,000 for goodwill in the purchase agreement. However, the court concluded that the plaintiff's decision to proceed in the Federal Court was driven by a perceived advantage rather than the merits of the case or jurisdictional requirements. The court noted that the financial statements of the business showed modest profits over the years, with no clear indication that a judgment exceeding $250,000 was likely. Given these circumstances, the court determined that the Federal Court did not have the appropriate jurisdiction to retain the case and ordered that it be transferred to the District Court of Western Australia.

The court's final order was that the proceedings be transferred to the District Court of Western Australia at Perth, pursuant to section 5(4) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth). This decision was based on the court's finding that the Federal Court did not have the appropriate jurisdiction to retain the case, given the plaintiff's motivations and the likelihood of the financial outcome.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Court has before it a motion on notice by which the respondents seek an order that these proceedings be transferred to the District Court of Western Australia at Perth, pursuant to s 5(4) of the Jurisdiction of Courts (Cross-Vesting) Act 1987 (Cth). The applicant opposes the motion.Factual and Procedural Background The following summary of the factual background is taken variously from allegations made in the statement of claim and affidavits which have been filed by the parties. Nothing in this recitation of facts should, of course, be taken as in any way amounting to a finding of fact for the purposes of the proceedings. On 4 June 1998 the applicant (which I shall refer to as “Gemcove”) and the first respondent (which I shall refer to as “Sirote”) entered into a written agreement, (“the Contract”) whereby Sirote agreed to sell and Gemcove agreed to buy the goodwill, plant, equipment and stock-in-trade of a business carried on under the name “S & G Gearbox Exchange” (the Business) at Welshpool, a suburb of Perth. The purchase price for the Business was $238,000, allocated in the contract as to $130,000 for stock-in-trade, $40,000 for fixtures and other plant and $58,000 for goodwill. I appreciate that the applicant considers that the allocation of values is not strictly accurate. For example, the applicant suggests that the value of stock is higher than the actual value, but that there was an adjustment to take into account the fact that the applicant had assumed responsibility for future long service leave entitlements and the like. However, I treat the total purchase price and the allocation of $58,000 for goodwill as broadly indicating the dimensions of the transaction. The contract contained a restrictive covenant on Sirote’s part not to engage or be interested in any business of the nature of the Business within a radius of 150 kms from the premises at which the Business had been conducted by it (“the Premises”) for a period of five years from the date of the Contract. There was also a clause that Sirote would not during that period engage in conduct derogating from Gemcove’s right to obtain the full benefit of the goodwill of the Business. In accordance with another clause in the Contract the second respondents (whom I shall call Mr and Mrs Goeree) entered into a deed (“the Deed”) with the applicant whereby they covenanted in similar terms to the restrictive covenant entered into by Sirote. Mr and Mrs Goeree are directors of Sirote and had conducted the Business on its behalf. There was another relevant term in the contract. That was to the effect that Mr Goeree would, without remuneration, assist the applicant to familiarise itself with the nature and general running of the Business for a period of eight weeks from completion. Completion was effected on 17 July 1998 and the applicant commenced operating the Business on 20 July 1998. I should say something about the third respondent. The third respondent is a firm registered under the provisions of the Business Names Act 1962 (WA). A business names extract is in evidence which shows that Sirote successfully applied for registration of that business name on 23 June 1998 and commenced its business (automotive repairs and dismantling) on 18 July 1998.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

CARR J
The impression which I have formed is that the applicant chose to institute and maintain these proceedings in the Federal Court of Australia due to some perceived advantage of litigating in this Court. In that regard I refer to paragraphs 33 and 34 of the affidavit of Mr Alan Robert Wall (a director of the applicant) sworn on 15 December 1999. Those paragraphs read as follows:“The decision to litigate in the Federal Court 33. The decision to embark upon Federal Court proceedings was arrived at after considerable discussion of the advantages of bringing the matter in the Federal Court as opposed to the greater costs that would be incurred thereby.34. Both my wife and myself remain convinced of the advantages of remaining in the Federal Court and we would therefore request, despite the higher costs and possible negative costs consequences for the first applicant that have been explained, we seek that the matter remains in the Court in which it was commenced.” The reference to “possible negative costs consequences”, so I infer, amounts to confirmation that Mr and Mrs Wall have had explained to them the risks, in terms of costs, should they recover less than $100,000 in these proceedings. I am left to assess, as best I can, the prospects (if any) of the applicant obtaining a judgment of more than $250,000 in these proceedings. Without intending in any way to prejudice the final outcome of these proceedings, my assessment, on the basis of the evidence before me is that there is very little prospect of such an outcome. First I refer to the purchase price for the business and its allocation between the various assets so purchased. The parties chose to allocate $58,000 as being the value of the goodwill of the Business. It is that asset which is intended to be protected by a restraint of trade covenant. I do not suggest that damages would be limited to that amount or even approximately that amount for either breach of contract or the consequences of misleading or deceptive conduct. However, I treat it as a preliminary indicator. Next, I refer to an affidavit sworn on 15 December 1999 by Mr Joseph Lieberfreund on behalf of the applicant. Mr Lieberfreund is a chartered accountant who provides forensic accounting services. At paragraph 8 of his affidavit Mr Lieberfreund refers to the matter of obtaining an assessment of the best reasonable estimate of the monetary judgment sought by the applicant. In the next paragraph Mr Lieberfreund states that he believes:“… that it is not possible to accurately estimate the losses of the First Applicant until such time as further and better discovery of documents listed below is made.” I interpolate that what was sought was not an accurate estimate but an assessment of the likelihood of whether a judgment of more than $250,000 was to be sought. It appears from Mr Lieberfreund’s affidavit that he has analysed and reviewed four years of the financial statements of the Business i.e. for the years ended 30 June 1994 to 30 June 1997. Those indicate a net profit of $9,027, $42,245, (a loss of $10,527) and $63,593 for the four respective years. Mr Lieberfreund (at paragraph 27 of his affidavit) refers to the similar turnover achieved by the Business during the time it was operated by the respondents and then by the applicant but he then expresses a view that there still remains what he describes as “a substantial loss occasioned through the actions of the Respondents herein in affecting the four-wheel drive component” of the Business. Again Mr Lieberfreund makes no effort to quantify that loss.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: CARR J

Full text does not contain this section.