Gelberg and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) [2023] AATA 2231 (27 July 2023)
Division:VETERANS' APPEALS DIVISION
File Number(s): 2020/5455
Re:Arthur Gelberg
APPLICANT
AndRepatriation Commission
RESPONDENT
DECISION
Tribunal:Senior Member B J Illingworth and Member D Cox
Date:27 July 2023
Place:Adelaide
The decision under review is varied, only to the extent that the Applicant’s Depressive Disorder is defence-caused but is otherwise affirmed.
.........................[Sgnd].......................................
Senior Member B J Illingworth and Member D Cox
Catchwords
VETERANS' AND MILITARY COMPENSATION–Veterans’ Entitlement Act–Veterans’ Review Board decisions–VRB–disability pension–attendant allowance
Legislation
Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986
Cases
Repatriation Commission v Richmond [2014] FCAFC 124
Banovich v Repatriation Commission (1986) 69 ALR 395
Weeks v Repatriation Commission [2019] AATA 4421
Secondary Materials
General Retail Industry Award 2020
REASONS FOR DECISION
Senior Member B J Illingworth and Member D Cox
27 July 2023
INTRODUCTION
Mr Arthur Gelberg (“the Applicant”) has applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (“the Tribunal”) for review of decision by the Veterans’ Review Board (“the Board”), dated 28 August 2020, which affirmed a determination of the Department of Veteran’s Affairs, (“the Department”) dated 2 October 2019, to deny the Applicant’s claim for increase of disability pension under s 15 of the Veterans’ Entitlement Act 1986 (“the Act”).[1]
[1] “Special Rate of Pension” under s 24 of the Act.
The Parties agree the Applicant has a degree of incapacity from his defence-caused injury or disease, or both, of at least 70 per cent, and the Applicant was rendered incapable of working for more than eight hours per week on 2 June 2020, due to his defence-caused incapacity alone. The Parties also agree the Applicant first satisfied s 24(1)(b) of the Act on 2 June 2020, but no date prior. The Tribunal notes the Applicant is in receipt of 100 per cent of the General Rate of Pension.
The Applicant was represented by Bruce Turner of RSL State Branch Victoria (“Applicant’s Advocate”), and the Respondent was represented by Emma Gorman of Australian Government Solicitor (“Respondent’s Counsel”). The Tribunal received into evidence the documents listed in the exhibit list, held on the Tribunal file.
AGREED FACTS AND ISSUES FOR THE TRIBUNAL
The following facts were agreed between the parties:
(a)the Applicant made an application under s 15 of the Act for an increase in pension on 13 December 2018 before he attained the age of 65 years, as required by ss 23 and 24 of the Act;
(b)the Applicant has a degree of incapacity from defence-caused injury or diseases, or both, of at least 70 per cent;
(c)the Applicant is in receipt of 100 per cent of the general rate of pension;
(d)the Applicant was rendered incapable of working for more than eight hours per week on 2 June 2020 due to defence-caused incapacity alone, and therefore did not satisfy section 24(1)(b) of the Act prior to 2 June 2020;[2]
(e)the Applicant was prevented from continuing to undertake his remunerative work…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gelberg and Repatriation Commission (Veterans' entitlements) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] AATA 2231
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Gelberg suffered from an incapacity within the meaning of sections 23(1)(c) and 24(1)(c) of the Veterans' Entitlements Act 1986 (Cth), and if so, whether that incapacity had any impact on his remunerative work, salary, wage, or earnings. The Tribunal was required to assess the veracity of Mr Gelberg's claims regarding his work capacity and cessation of work following his resignation as Director of a business, in light of conflicting medical evidence and his own statements.
The Tribunal found that while Mr Gelberg did suffer from a defence-caused depressive disorder, this incapacity did not affect his ability to earn income. The Tribunal was not satisfied that Mr Gelberg ceased working or received no further payment from his business after resigning as Director. Evidence from medical practitioners suggested Mr Gelberg was capable of performing administrative duties and reported working varying hours both before and after his resignation. Payments received by Mr Gelberg were characterised as 'Sundry Loans' in discharge of a debt owed by the business to him and his wife, rather than salary or earnings. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Gelberg was not entitled to the special rate of pension. The decision under review was varied to the extent that Mr Gelberg's depressive disorder was found to be defence-caused, but was otherwise affirmed.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The Accountant knew of the change of Director occurred a couple of months after June 2018, about the time the change was lodged with ASIC. He understood the Applicant retired due to health reasons. He played no role in that decision, and he simply processed the decision. He did not know the mechanics of how he ran the Business. He told him to speak to his lawyer whether he should give up his position as Appointer, but the Applicant has remained Appointer. There was no change in the Trust Deed.CONSIDERATION The Applicant was the Director of the Business until 21 September 2018 when he resigned, and Mr AG assumed that position. The Applicant said thereafter he stopped working and he received no further payment of money from the Business. The Tribunal is not satisfied either fact is true. Prior to 21 September 2018, the Applicant said he was reducing his work in the Business, due to his medical conditions. On 7 December 2016, he applied for DSP saying he was unable to work. However, evidence, particularly that of the medical practitioners, suggests the Applicant was able to work at least by performing administrative or clerical duties. In Dr Dobson’s report, dated 15 March 2017, he opined the Applicant was capable of working full-time. When questioned by the Tribunal about his work capacity at that time, the Applicant’s answer was vague. He could not say how much work he was in fact performing, but said he was doing some work. This is to be contrasted with his application for DSP before the Tribunal which states, three months earlier, he said he was unable to work. Also, contrary to the Applicant’s evidence that he ceased work following his resignation as Director, the various medical reports make it very clear the Applicant reported he was working to varying degrees in the Business, both before and after 21 September 2018. For example, in Dr Ewer’s report, dated 8 February 2019, and reports following in 2019,[83] Dr Ewer recorded the Applicant told him he was working six to eight hours per week. To Dr Ewer, in the questionnaire, dated 16 June 2020, the Applicant said for the last two and a half years he worked six to eight hours per week and currently worked zero to eight hours per week. In Dr Ewers report, dated 16 June 2020, Dr Ewer said that since his last report, the Applicant reported working 24 to 45 hours per week. [83] Note: 28 February 2019, 4 April 2019, 8 May 2019, and 23 October 2019. In evidence, the Applicant said before he stepped down, he would do 25, 30 or even 50 hours per week and agreed he was performing some work in the Business after 21 September 2018, but that work was of a clerical nature. He also said he worked on weekends. Mr AG said, prior to 21 September 2018, the Applicant had difficulty with the stairs, but it was not until 5 January 2020, when the Applicant was given a letter signed by Mr AG that he was no longer permitted on site, effective from 6 January 2020.[84] This was written because Mrs Gelberg (the Applicant’s wife) spoke to Mr AG, and they decided to “put their foot down and be firm” with the Applicant. He had difficulty with the stairs, and they did not want him to have an accident.[84] Exhibit R1, T16.