GE CAPITAL Australia Ltd v PERTSINIDIS
[2000] SADC 68 `
His Honour Judge Kitchen
Civil
This is an application by the defendant to be released from an undertaking given by him on 23rd June 1999, as varied on 16th December 1999.
By an application dated 20th April 1999 the plaintiff sought an order that the defendant deliver up to the plaintiff a Volvo truck (“the truck”) and a Freightmaster trailer (“the trailer”), possession of both of which the defendant had obtained pursuant to a hire purchase agreement (“the hire purchase agreement”) made between the plaintiff and the defendant, the truck being the subject of a supplement, S1, to the agreement and the trailer being the subject of a supplement, S3, to the agreement, both the supplements being part of the agreement and all being dated 1st June 1995. The basis of the plaintiff’s claim was that by January 1999 the defendant had failed to make several periodic payments due under each of the supplements, S1 at the rate of $3,707 per month and S3 at the rate of $1,278 per month, and on 12th January 1999 the plaintiff served notice terminating both the S1 and the S3 supplements pursuant to the hire purchase agreement, upon the giving of which the plaintiff demanded the delivery up of the truck and the trailer by the defendant, which the defendant failed or refused to do. The plaintiff’s application was supported by the affidavit of David Querzoli, the plaintiff’s Risk Manager, Credit and Operation.
The plaintiff’s application came before me on 2nd June 1999. I adjourned the application to 9th June 1999, directing that the defendant file by 8th June 1999 any affidavit or affidavits upon which he sought to rely.
On 8th June 1999 the defendant filed an affidavit in which he deposed inter alia that on 1 January 1999:
as to S1, and by reason of (inter alia) an overpayment by him in relation to another supplement (S3) to the hire purchase agreement, the arrears of periodic payments were $4,279.38 and not $44,484 as the plaintiff claimed (paragraph 19).
As to S3, the arrears of periodic payments were $120.76, not $6,390 as the plaintiff claimed, and the $120.76 was “less than one periodic payment. The (hire purchase agreement) states that the default must be of a periodic payment” (paragraph 20).
those assertions being drawn from a report by Brett & Watson Pty Ltd, consulting actuaries, obtained by the defendant “.... showing a statement of payments due and payments made .... compiled by reference to my bank statements”; the report was exhibited to his affidavit.
In his affidavit the defendant deposed (in paragraph 23):-
“While I acknowledge that as at 1st January 1999 I was a little more than one periodic payment in default on S1, I say that the lack of co-operation and inaccurate and incomplete book keeping by the plaintiff has significantly contributed to the situation becoming what it is .....”
The defendant’s affidavit also dealt with his contention concerning the…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Ge Capital Australia Ltd v Pertsinidis No. DCCIV-99-552 and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2000] SADC 68
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The Court found that the defendant's undertaking was given as a condition of the Court adjourning the plaintiff's application for possession of the truck and trailer, founded upon the defendant's breach of the hire purchase agreement by failing to make the periodic payments. The purpose of the undertaking was to secure for the defendant his continuing possession of the truck and trailer, notwithstanding his admitted breach of the hire purchase agreement by being in arrear with periodic payments at 1st January 1999, and to give the defendant the opportunity to explore the "pay out" figure. By November 1999, the defendant had discovered what he claimed was material, by way of an acknowledgment by the plaintiff, that the defendant, prior to 1st January 1999, had paid amounts the plaintiff had not previously acknowledged which, together with amounts the defendant alleged, but the plaintiff denied, he had paid before that date and the amounts paid by the defendant pursuant to the order dated 23rd June 1999, aggregated (with a payment to be made in December 1999) more than the entirety of his obligations to the plaintiff. Those matters raised substantial issues of fact between the parties which could be determined only by trial. Accordingly, the parties were directed to file pleadings which were also to encompass the defendant's asserted set-off and counterclaim summarised by Mr Wells Q.C. The Court found that it would be unjust to continue the defendant's undertaking as it would be tantamount to requiring the defendant to contribute to a fund by way of a security for the plaintiff's claim, which, on the defendant's case, the defendant challenges.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi