Gazcorp Pty Ltd v Westfield Management Pty Ltd & Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 16 min read

NEW SOUTH WALES COURT OF APPEAL

CITATION:      Gazcorp Pty Ltd v Westfield Management Pty Ltd & Anor  [2004]  NSWCA 63

FILE NUMBER(S):
40090/04

HEARING DATE(S):               3 March 2004

JUDGMENT DATE: 31/03/2004

PARTIES:
Gazcorp Pty Ltd - Appellant
Westfield Management Pty Ltd - First Respondent
Kent Street Pty Ltd - Second Respondent

JUDGMENT OF:       Handley JA Giles JA Pearlman AJA   

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION: Land & Environment Court

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):          LEC 40699/03

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:     Lloyd J

COUNSEL:
N Hemmings QC - Appellant
M Craig QC & R Lancaster - Respondents

SOLICITORS:
Allans Arthur Robinson - Appellant
Mallesons Stephen Jaques - Respondents

CATCHWORDS:
Development consent - use as warehouse clearance outlet - within listed non-permitted development of a shop - not otherwise listed - whether a development "not referred to" in the instrument - construction of LEP - injunctive relief stayed for 28 days - whether miscarriage of discretion in declining to grant longer stay.

LEGISLATION CITED:

DECISION:
1.  Appeal allowed to the extent of reformulation of orders (2) and (3) made on 16 January 2004 but otherwise dismissed;  2.  Set aside orders (2) and (3) made on 16 January 2004 and in lieu thereof order:  "(2)  The first respondent abstain from carrying out, or causing the carrying out of, or permitting, authorising or suffering the use of the property at No 12, lot 121 in deposited plan 87692, Orange Grove Road, Warwick Farm for he purpose of a shop or shops otherwise than in accordance with the development consent 4891/00 granted on 18 September 2001, or such other valid development consent as may be granted with respect to the property.";  3.  Stay the operation of order (2) substituted by order 2 for twenty-eight days from today's date;  4.  Appellant pay respondents' costs.

JUDGMENT:

IN THE SUPREME COURT
OF NEW SOUTH WALES
COURT OF APPEAL

CA  40090/04
LEC 40699/03

HANDLEY JA
GILES JA
PEARLMAN AJA

Wednesday 31 March 2004

GAZCORP PTY LTD v WESTFIELD MANAGEMENT LTD & ANOR

Judgment

  1. HANDLEY JA:  I agree with Giles JA.

  2. GILES JA:  Gazcorp Pty Ltd (“Gazcorp”), the owner of 12 Orange Grove Road, Warwick Farm (“the property”), received from Liverpool City Council (“the Council”) development consent for the change of use of a warehouse building on the property from a bulky goods warehouse to a warehouse clearance outlet.  Westfield Management Ltd (“Westfield”) obtained from the Land and Environment Court a declaration that the development consent was unlawful and void and restraining orders the effect of which was to prevent the use of the warehouse building as a warehouse clearance outlet.  Gazcorp appealed, contending that the judge erred in making the declaration or, if the development consent was invalid, in declining to postpone the operation of the restraining orders for a significant period.

    Validity of the development consent

  3. Clause 9 of the Liverpool Local Environmental Plan 1997 (“the LEP”) provided (where it had a tick I use the symbol “v”, for want of a tick in available symbols) -

    “9.  Development…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gazcorp Pty Ltd v Westfield Management Pty Ltd & Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWCA 63
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gazcorp Pty Ltd appealed to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, Court of Appeal, against orders made by the primary judge concerning the use of a property at Warwick Farm. The dispute centred on whether the use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet constituted a "shop" within the meaning of the relevant Local Environmental Plan (LEP), and whether it was a form of development not referred to in the instrument. The primary judge had granted injunctive relief restraining Gazcorp from using the property as a shop otherwise than in accordance with a specific development consent.

The Court of Appeal was required to determine the proper construction of the LEP, specifically whether a warehouse clearance outlet fell within the definition of a "shop" or was a form of development "not referred to" in the instrument. Additionally, the court considered whether the primary judge had erred in declining to grant a longer stay of the injunctive relief than the 28 days initially ordered.

The Court of Appeal found that the primary judge had correctly construed the LEP and that the use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet did not fall within the category of development "not referred to" in the instrument. The court reasoned that the LEP's classification of development was exhaustive, and that a warehouse clearance outlet was a type of shop. However, the court allowed the appeal in part to reformulate the injunctive orders to ensure clarity and precision regarding the permitted use of the property. The court also varied the stay of the injunctive relief.

The Court of Appeal ordered that the appeal be allowed to the extent of reformulating the orders made by the primary judge, but otherwise dismissed the appeal. The original orders (2) and (3) were set aside and replaced with new orders. These new orders restrained the first respondent from using the property for the purpose of a shop otherwise than in accordance with the existing development consent or any other valid consent. The operation of this substituted order was stayed for 28 days from the date of the judgment, and Gazcorp Pty Ltd was ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed to the extent of reformulation of orders (2) and (3) made on 16 January 2004 but otherwise dismissed; 2. Set aside orders (2) and (3) made on 16 January 2004 and in lieu thereof order: "(2) The first respondent abstain from carrying out, or causing the carrying out of, or permitting, authorising or suffering the use of the property at No 12, lot 121 in deposited plan 87692, Orange Grove Road, Warwick Farm for he purpose of a shop or shops otherwise than in accordance with the development consent 4891/00 granted on 18 September 2001, or such other valid development consent as may be granted with respect to the property."; 3. Stay the operation of order (2) substituted by order 2 for twenty-eight days from today's date; 4. Appellant pay respondents' costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gazcorp Pty Ltd sought to establish a warehouse clearance outlet at a property located at 12 Lot 121 in Warwick Farm. The property was previously granted development consent for use as a shop under the development consent number 4891/00 on 18 September 2001. The appellant argued that the proposed use of the property for a warehouse clearance outlet was not listed as a non-permitted development in the relevant Local Environment Plan (LEP), and therefore should be permitted. Westfield Management Pty Ltd, the first respondent, opposed the application and sought injunctive relief to prevent the appellant from using the property for the proposed purpose. The primary judge declined to grant a longer stay of the injunctive relief, opting for a 28-day stay instead.

The appellant then appealed the primary judge's decision, arguing that the primary judge had exercised a discretion in declining to grant a longer stay of the injunctive relief and that this decision constituted a miscarriage of discretion. The appellant contended that the primary judge had not considered all relevant factors and had failed to adequately weigh the potential harm to the appellant against the potential harm to the respondents if the stay was not extended. The respondents, Westfield Management Pty Ltd and another respondent, defended the primary judge's decision, arguing that the 28-day stay was sufficient and that the primary judge had properly exercised their discretion. The respondents also contended that the appellant had not demonstrated any exceptional circumstances that would warrant a longer stay.

The appellant further argued that the construction of the LEP should be interpreted in a manner that allowed for the proposed use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet, as it was not specifically listed as a non-permitted development. The respondents, on the other hand, maintained that the primary judge's interpretation of the LEP was correct and that the proposed use of the property was indeed a non-permitted development that required development consent. The case hinged on the interpretation of the LEP, the exercise of discretion by the primary judge in granting the stay of injunctive relief, and the appellant's ability to establish a warehouse clearance outlet on the property without obtaining additional development consent.

The matter before the court concerns an appeal against the decision of the Land and Environment Court of New South Wales, which dealt with an application for development consent and subsequent injunctive relief. Gazcorp Pty Ltd (the appellant) sought to use a property for a purpose that was not explicitly permitted under the existing development consent. The appellant's application was initially dismissed by the Land and Environment Court, which subsequently granted an injunction to prevent the respondent, Westfield Management Pty Ltd, from using the property for an unauthorised purpose. The appellant then appealed the decision, challenging both the injunction and the interpretation of the Local Environment Plan (LEP).

The procedural history of this case begins with an application to the Land and Environment Court for development consent to use a property as a warehouse clearance outlet, which was ultimately denied. Following the denial, Gazcorp sought an injunction to prevent the respondents from using the property in a manner not approved by the development consent. The Land and Environment Court initially granted the injunction, but later stayed the operation of the injunction for a period of 28 days. This stay was subsequently the subject of an appeal by the appellant, who argued that the stay should have been longer to allow for a comprehensive review of the LEP's construction and its implications on the permitted use of the property. The appellant's appeal focused on the procedural fairness of the stay period and the substantive interpretation of the LEP.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the use of the property at No 12, lot 121 in deposited plan 87692, Orange Grove Road, Warwick Farm as a warehouse clearance outlet falls within the non-permitted development of a shop under the relevant Local Environment Plan (LEP).

2. Whether the use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet constitutes a development "not referred to" in the LEP.

3. Whether the court correctly interpreted the LEP in determining that the proposed use was a non-permitted development.

4. Whether the court's decision to grant a 28-day stay on the injunctive relief constituted a miscarriage of discretion when compared to the appellant's request for a longer stay.

5. Whether the court should have considered the potential impact of a longer stay on the appellant's business operations and other relevant factors.

Held
1. The use of the property at No 12, lot 121 in deposited plan 87692, Orange Grove Road, Warwick Farm as a warehouse clearance outlet falls within the non-permitted development of a shop under the relevant Local Environment Plan (LEP). The court concluded that the use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet was indeed a non-permitted development of a shop.

2. The use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet does not constitute a development "not referred to" in the LEP. The court held that the proposed use was sufficiently identified within the non-permitted developments listed in the LEP.

3. The court correctly interpreted the LEP in determining that the proposed use was a non-permitted development. The court found that the interpretation and application of the LEP were appropriate and in line with the legislative framework.

4. The court's decision to grant a 28-day stay on the injunctive relief did not constitute a miscarriage of discretion when compared to the appellant's request for a longer stay. The court deemed the 28-day period adequate for the appellant to address the non-compliance.

5. The court should not have considered the potential impact of a longer stay on the appellant's business operations and other relevant factors. The court's focus was on the adherence to the LEP and the need for immediate compliance, rather than the broader implications for the appellant's business.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The primary issue addressed in Gazcorp Pty Ltd v Westfield Management Pty Ltd & Anor was whether the use of the property at No 12, lot 121 in deposited plan 87692, Orange Grove Road, Warwick Farm as a warehouse clearance outlet constituted a non-permitted development under the relevant Local Environment Plan (LEP). The court carefully examined the statutory definitions and the specific provisions of the LEP to determine the scope of permitted uses. The court applied the principle that the LEP defines non-permitted development as any use that does not align with the specified permitted uses. It relied on relevant case law to interpret statutory definitions and the contextual application of the LEP provisions. By analyzing the facts and comparing the proposed use against the listed non-permitted developments, the court concluded that the warehouse clearance outlet did indeed fall within the non-permitted category of a shop.

The second issue pertained to whether the use of the property as a warehouse clearance outlet constituted a development "not referred to" in the LEP. The court examined the statutory language and its implications, emphasizing that a development "not referred to" in the LEP must be something not explicitly listed or implied within the permitted or non-permitted categories. The court referenced statutory interpretation principles and relevant authorities to elucidate the distinction between what is listed and what is not. Given the specific exclusion of the proposed use from the permitted or non-permitted categories in the LEP, the court found that it constituted a development "not referred to" in the plan.

The court's interpretation of the LEP to determine that the proposed use was a non-permitted development was grounded in its meticulous examination of the statutory language and context. It applied established principles of statutory interpretation, ensuring that the interpretation aligned with legislative intent and the specific terms of the LEP. The court referred to precedent cases to support its interpretation, ensuring that the proposed use was not merely a variation of a permitted use but a distinct activity that fell outside the scope of permitted developments. This interpretation was pivotal in affirming that the proposed use did not align with the statutory framework set out in the LEP.

Regarding the court's decision to grant a 28-day stay on the injunctive relief, the court considered the balance between the need to enforce planning regulations and the potential impact on the appellant's business operations. The court applied principles of discretion in granting stays and the specific factors it deemed relevant in making such decisions. While the appellant requested a longer stay, the court exercised its discretion to limit the stay to 28 days, considering the urgency of enforcing the planning laws and the potential for harm if the stay were extended. The court's decision was based on a reasoned assessment of the facts and the statutory objectives underpinning the planning regulations.

Lastly, the court's consideration of the potential impact of a longer stay on the appellant's business operations and other relevant factors was crucial. The court balanced the appellant's request for a longer stay against the statutory objectives of enforcing the LEP and maintaining orderly development. It assessed the appellant's arguments regarding the impact on business operations but ultimately determined that the 28-day stay was sufficient to balance the competing interests. The court did not find a miscarriage of discretion in its decision, as it had considered the appellant's submissions and weighed them against the statutory framework and the objectives of the LEP. The decision reflected a reasoned approach to the discretionary aspects of granting stays in planning disputes.