Garyf Pty Ltd v Maroochy Shire Council

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

[2007] QPEC 128

PLANNING AND ENVIRONMENT COURT
JUDGE ROBIN QC
No 1958 of 2007

GARYF PTY LTD Appellant
and
MAROOCHY SHIRE COUNCIL Respondent
and
MIRVAC LIMITED First Co-Respondent
and
TOTAL ICE PTY LTD Second Co-Respondent
(ACN 111 697 815)
and
NORTH BUDERIM MARKET PTY LTD Fourth Co-Respondent
and
LEONIE CHRISTINE NORRIS Fifth Co-Respondent
And
DEPARTMENT OF MAIN ROADS Sixth Co-Respondent
BRISBANE
..DATE 31/10/2007
ORDER
Catchwords

Integrated Planning Act 1997 s 1.2.2, s 1.2.3(a), s 4.1.5A, s 4.1.27(1)(a), s 4.1.27(1)(e), s 4.1.55 developer appeal under s 4.1.27(1) commenced under paragraph (e) on assumption there was a deemed refusal of its application the day before -

evidence later forthcoming showed an actual refusal on that
day - Co-respondents contended the appeal should have been
instituted under paragraph (a) and that the proceeding was a
nullity on that account - held that the subsection created a
single right of appeal for developer, not discrete rights of
which the correct one must be selected whether the day of the
decision was the last day for the assessment manager's
decision or whether the appeal against a deemed refusal was
premature - proper interpretation of assessment manager's
extension of the decision period considered.
HIS HONOUR: This appeal arises out of the appellant's

1

disappointment at the outcome of its development application
for a new shopping centre. The co-respondents appeared
represented by Mr Bowie, who made the running during the
argument, and Mr Houston, who supported Mr Bowie's position;

they are commercial rivals of the appellant. 10

Before the Court is its application filed the 22nd of October seeking the following relief:

"1. A declaration or determination that, regardless of 20

whether the Respondent decided to refuse the
application to which the appeal relates on 11 July

2007, or had failed to decide it by that day:

(a) on 12 July 2007, the Appellant had a right

under s.4.1.27(1) of the IPA to appeal to this
Court against the refusal of the application;
and

(b) the Appellant exercised that right by filing 30

the notice of appeal herein on 12 July 2007.

2. Under Rule 3 of the PEC Rules 1999, and UCPR Rules 375 and 377, leave, to the extent that it is necessary, to amend the notice of appeal herein as set out in the draft amended notice of appeal attached.

3.    If the relief sought in paragraph 1 is refused (but

not otherwise) a declaration that, in the events 40
which have happened:-
(a) the Respondent failed to decide the application

to which the appeal relates by 11 July 2007;

(b)

in consequence, on 12 July 2007, the Appellant had a right under s 4.1.27(1)(e) to appeal to this Court against the deemed refusal of the application; and

50

(c) the Appellant exercised that right by filing the notice of appeal herein on 12 July 2007.

4. An order under s 4.1.5A of the IPA that, to the extent that any IDAS requirement relating to the giving of notice of the appeal to any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garyf Pty Ltd v Maroochy Shire Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] QPEC 128
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appellant, Garyf Pty Ltd, sought to appeal the decision of the Maroochy Shire Council regarding a development application for a new shopping centre. The dispute arose due to the timing and basis of the appeal, with the council arguing that the appellant had incorrectly initiated the appeal under the wrong subsection of the Integrated Planning Act 1997. The case was heard in the Queensland Planning and Environment Court. The central legal issue was whether the appeal was properly instituted under section 4.1.27(1)(e) of the Act, which pertains to a deemed refusal, or whether it should have been initiated under section 4.1.27(1)(a), which applies to actual refusals. The co-respondents contended that since the appellant had an actual refusal on the day of the decision, the appeal should have been commenced under the latter subsection, rendering the appeal a nullity.

The court examined the relevant provisions of the Integrated Planning Act 1997 and concluded that section 4.1.27(1) provides a single right of appeal for developers, rather than discrete rights that must be carefully selected. This interpretation meant that the proper course of action was to consider whether the assessment manager's extension of the decision period was appropriate, rather than focusing on the specific subsection under which the appeal was filed. The court found that the appellant's appeal, initiated on the assumption of a deemed refusal, was valid as it did not preclude a subsequent consideration of whether an actual refusal had occurred on the same day. The court's reasoning centred on the practical interpretation of the Act, ensuring that developers have a clear and unified right to appeal without the need to select between potentially overlapping subsections.

The court's decision affirmed the validity of the appellant's appeal under section 4.1.27(1)(e) and dismissed the council's contention that the appeal was a nullity. The court's interpretation of the Act provided clarity for developers in similar situations, reinforcing the importance of a practical approach to statutory interpretation. The final orders of the court upheld the appeal process as initiated by the appellant and instructed the parties to proceed with the substantive matters of the appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.