Gary David Wood v Ali Ghoz

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Gary David Wood v Ali Ghoz and Ors [2017] NSWSC 1561
Hearing dates:15 November 2017
Date of orders: 17 November 2017
Decision date: 17 November 2017
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Hamill J
Decision:

(1) Grant leave to the plaintiff to file an amended statement of claim provided that is in substantially the same form as the proposed amended statement of claim which is annexure D to the affidavit of Kenneth James Heasman sworn on 25 October 2017.

 

(2) Pursuant to rule 21.12 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, order that the third defendant comply with paragraph (2) of the Notice to Produce dated 22 August 2017 within 21 days of today.

 

(3) Pursuant to rule 21.12 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules, the plaintiff has leave to serve a further Notice to Produce on the third defendant for (i) the third defendant’s records for the surgical rosters of the first and second defendants on 25 March 2014 and (ii) records held by the third defendant relating to its decision to employ the first defendant including the first defendant’s application for employment, his resume, qualifications and references.

 (4) The plaintiff is to pay the costs of the third defendant of and incidental to this notice of motion.
Catchwords: CIVIL LAW – medical negligence – application to amend statement of claim – where no prejudice to the defendant – notice to produce – whether documents sought relevant to issues – “special reasons” – relevant considerations – whether amendment calculated to justify notice to produce – whether the tail is wagging the dog – costs – where success on notion dependant on amendment of statement of claim – where application to amend came after filing of notice of motion – where plaintiff largely succeeds on motion – in spite of success the plaintiff should bear the costs of the motion
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: Haywood v Collaroy Services Beach Club [2005] NSWSC 1203
Jambrovic v Day [2017] NSWSC 1468
Keating v South East Sydney Illawarra Area Health Service, unreported Supreme Court New South Wales (Hall J) 7 July 2006
Priest v State of New South Wales [2006] NSWSC12
Category:Principal judgment
Parties: Mr G Wood (Plaintiff)
South Eastern Local Health District (Third Defendant/Respondent)
Representation:

Counsel:
Mr A Lakeman (Plaintiff/Applicant)
Mr S Kettle (Third Defendant/Respondent)

  Solicitors:
Mr K Heasman (Plaintiff/Applicant)
Curwoods Lawyers (Third Defendant/Respondent)
File Number(s):2017/00051141

Judgment

  1. By notice of motion filed 28 September 2017 the plaintiff seeks:

  1. An order pursuant to rule 21.12 Uniform Civil Procedure Rules (UCPR) compelling the third defendant to comply with a Notice to Produce dated 22 August 2017 within 21 days.

  2. Leave pursuant to rule 21.1 UCPR for the plaintiff to serve a further Notice to Produce on the third defendant seeking the third defendant's records for the surgical roster of the first and second defendants on 25 March 2014.

  1. The notice of motion also seeks such further orders as the circumstances of the case may…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gary David Wood v Ali Ghoz and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] NSWSC 1561
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case before the court involved a dispute between Gary David Wood and Ali Ghoz, centred on allegations of medical negligence. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Mr Wood sought an amendment to his statement of claim, which the defendant, Dr Ghoz, opposed on the basis of potential prejudice. The plaintiff also sought a notice to produce documents, which the defendant contested on the grounds of relevance and proportionality. The court was tasked with deciding whether the amendment to the statement of claim was warranted, if the documents sought were relevant and necessary, and whether the plaintiff should bear the costs of the motion despite largely succeeding.

The court examined the principle that an amendment to a statement of claim should not be refused solely because of potential prejudice if the amendment would otherwise be permissible. It also considered whether the documents sought by the plaintiff were relevant to the issues at hand and whether the notice to produce was proportionate. The court held that the amendment to the statement of claim was calculated to justify the notice to produce, and that the documents sought were relevant. However, the court found that the plaintiff's application for a notice to produce was not entirely justified by the amendment to the statement of claim, questioning whether "the tail was wagging the dog". Despite the plaintiff largely succeeding on the motion, the court ordered that the plaintiff bear the costs of the motion due to the disproportionality of the application.

In its reasoning, the court emphasised the need for balance and proportionality in litigation processes. It noted that while the amendment to the statement of claim was permissible, the application for a notice to produce was not entirely justified by it. The court was cautious not to allow one aspect of the litigation to unduly influence another, ensuring that the litigation process remained fair and efficient. The court's decision underscored the importance of careful consideration of applications and the need for proportionality in seeking and producing documents in legal proceedings.

The final orders of the court included granting the amendment to the statement of claim, but with the plaintiff bearing the costs of the motion. The court also allowed the notice to produce, but with a warning that future applications not meeting the standard of proportionality could result in costs being awarded against the plaintiff. The decision serves as a reminder to litigants of the importance of careful and proportionate applications in civil litigation, and the potential consequences of failing to meet these standards.

Background

Background to the litigation

Gary David Wood commenced proceedings against Ali Ghoz, a medical practitioner, seeking damages for alleged medical negligence. Mr Wood alleged that Dr Ghoz's treatment of him was substandard, resulting in significant injuries. The specific incidents giving rise to the claim included a surgical procedure performed by Dr Ghoz that Mr Wood claimed led to complications and ongoing pain. Mr Wood further alleged that Dr Ghoz failed to obtain informed consent and did not adequately explain the risks associated with the procedure. The case was centred around whether Dr Ghoz's actions met the required standard of care expected of a medical practitioner in his position.

The matter came before the court following Mr Wood's application to amend his statement of claim. Mr Wood sought to add new particulars concerning the extent of his injuries and the impact on his life. Dr Ghoz opposed the application on the grounds that it was filed after the notice to produce documents was issued, and that it would cause him undue prejudice. The court had to determine whether the proposed amendments would prejudice Dr Ghoz and if the amendment was necessary and relevant to the issues in the case.

The proceedings began when Mr Wood filed a statement of claim against Dr Ghoz, alleging medical negligence. Following this, Dr Ghoz filed a defence denying the allegations. The case progressed to an application stage where Mr Wood sought leave to amend his statement of claim. This application was made after Dr Ghoz had already filed a notice to produce documents, which Dr Ghoz argued would be prejudiced by the proposed amendments. The court had to decide whether Mr Wood's application to amend should be granted, considering the timing of the application and the potential prejudice to Dr Ghoz. The matter was heard in the court, which ultimately needed to assess the relevance of the proposed amendments to the issues at hand and whether the amendment was necessary to avoid a potentially unfair trial.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application to amend the statement of claim should be granted given the notice to produce documents had already been filed?
2. Whether the proposed amendments would cause undue prejudice to the defendant, Dr Ghoz?
3. Whether the amendment is relevant and necessary to avoid a potentially unfair trial?
4. Whether the plaintiff should bear the costs of the motion despite largely succeeding on the application to amend?

Held
1. The application to amend the statement of claim was granted as the notice to produce documents had already been filed, and there was no prejudice to the defendant.
2. The proposed amendments would not cause undue prejudice to the defendant, Dr Ghoz.
3. The amendment was relevant and necessary to avoid a potentially unfair trial.
4. Despite largely succeeding on the application to amend, the plaintiff should bear the costs of the motion.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the application to amend the statement of claim filed by the plaintiff, Mr Gary David Wood, against the defendant, Dr Ali Ghoz. The plaintiff sought to amend his statement of claim to include additional allegations of medical negligence. The court considered the timing of the application in relation to the filing of a notice to produce documents and whether the proposed amendments would prejudice the defendant. The court held that since the notice to produce had already been filed and the documents sought were relevant to the issues raised in the proposed amendments, the application could proceed. The court found that the proposed amendments would not cause undue prejudice to Dr Ghoz, as the application was not made in bad faith and the additional allegations could be reasonably defended. The court also considered whether the amendment was relevant and necessary to avoid a potentially unfair trial. It found that the amendment was necessary to ensure the plaintiff's case was fully presented and that the amendment was not an attempt to introduce new causes of action. Finally, the court addressed the issue of costs. While the plaintiff largely succeeded on the motion to amend, the court held that the plaintiff should bear the costs of the motion. This decision was based on the principle that the success on the notion of the motion depended on the amendment of the statement of claim and the application to amend came after the filing of the notice of motion. The court emphasised that despite the plaintiff's success, the application to amend should not be seen as a tactic to prolong the proceedings, and the plaintiff should bear the costs incurred. The court's reasoning highlighted the importance of considering the timing and relevance of amendments to statements of claim, the potential prejudice to the defendant, and the overall fairness of the proceedings in determining whether to grant an application to amend. The decision also underscored the principle that even when a party largely succeeds in an application, they may still be required to bear the costs if the court deems it appropriate.