Garth v Queensland Police Service

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read
CITATION: Garth v Queensland Police Service [2013] QCATA 357
PARTIES: Mr Travis Garth
(Applicant)
V
Queensland Police Service
(Respondent)
APPLICATION NUMBER: APL329-12 and APL352-12
MATTER TYPE: Appeals
HEARING DATE: 13 March 2013
HEARD AT: Brisbane
DECISION OF: Mr C Brabazon QC, Member
Ms K O’Callaghan, Senior Member
DELIVERED ON: 21 June 2013
DELIVERED AT: Brisbane
ORDERS MADE:

1.     The appeal is allowed.

2.     The QCAT order of 20 April 2012 is set aside.

3.     The categorisation of the charge of misconduct is confirmed.

4.     The parties are requested to make further submissions as to the appropriate sanction by 4pm on 12 July 2013.

DELIVERED ON: 7 August 2013
ORDERS MADE:

1.     Mr Garth’s advancement from Constable pay level 1.5 to Senior Constable pay level 2.1 is to be deferred from 14 August 2011 until 14 August 2012;

2.     Any further pay point progression is to be administered in accordance with Queensland Police Service policy and procedures.

3.     The parties have liberty to apply if any further differences arise.

CATCHWORDS:

APPEAL – QUESTION OF LAW – OCCUPATIONAL REGULATION – POLICE OFFICER – DISCIPLINARY PROCEEDINGS – MISCONDUCT – where the applicant police officer was photographed posing with a woman with her breasts exposed – where the applicant was on duty and the photograph was taken with the applicant’s phone – where the applicant showed the photographs to other police officers – where the applicant’s conduct was categorised as misconduct at the disciplinary hearing – appropriate punishment

Acts Interpretation Act 1954 (Qld), s 38
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 20(1), s 24(1), s 61(3), s 146(b), s 147
Police Service Administration Act 1990 (Qld), s 1.4, s 7.4,

Police Service (Discipline) Regulations 1990 (Qld), reg 5

Ash Industries Pty Ltd v Plumb [2010] QCATA 53, cited
Crime and Misconduct Commission v Chapman and Anor [2011] QCAT 229, followed
DA v Deputy Commissioner Stewart [2011] QCATA 359, cited
House v The King (1936) 55 CLR 499, followed
Murray v Deputy Commissioner Stewart [2011] QCAT 583, cited
Staples v Deputy Commissioner Stewart [2011] QCAT 582, cited

APPEARANCES and REPRESENTATION (if any):

APPLICANT: Represented by Mr Gnech – Police Service Union.
RESPONDENT: Represented by Mr Nicholson of counsel.

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr Charles Brabazon QC, Judicial Member (Presiding Member)

  1. I accept my learned colleague’s description of earlier procedural issues in this litigation – including the surprising, but inevitable, conclusion that the QCAT decision of 20 April 2012 was not effective because QCAT had no power in this case to deal with a  breach of discipline – even though it can do so if there is a finding of misconduct.

  2. At about 1:00 pm on 12 September 2010 Constable Travis Garth entered a bar in Brisbane’s Valley precinct.  He had served almost four years in the Queensland Police Service, in the Valley area.  He had with him two junior Constables.  They were all in uniform.

  3. An attractive woman was dancing with a female friend.  She stopped and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garth v Queensland Police Service and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] QCATA 357
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Garth v Queensland Police Service involves an appeal by a police officer, Constable Garth, against a disciplinary decision made by the Queensland Police Service (QPS). The issue at hand is the classification and appropriate punishment for Constable Garth's conduct, which included taking a photograph while on duty with a woman with her breasts exposed, and subsequently showing the photograph to other police officers. The initial disciplinary process categorised the conduct as misconduct, but a subsequent review by the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT) found the conduct to be a breach of discipline instead. Both Constable Garth and QPS appealed the QCAT decision to the Appeal Tribunal.

The primary legal issues addressed by the Appeal Tribunal were whether the QCAT Tribunal had the authority to reclassify the conduct from misconduct to a breach of discipline, and if so, what the appropriate remedy would be. The QPS argued that the QCAT Tribunal should have limited its review to the sanction imposed rather than the classification of the conduct. Conversely, Constable Garth argued that once the Tribunal determined the conduct was a breach of discipline, it should have declared the charge of misconduct unsubstantiated and refrained from further action. The QPS, on the other hand, contended that the Tribunal should have referred the matter back to them for reconsideration of the sanction.

The Appeal Tribunal determined that the QCAT Tribunal had the authority to classify the conduct as a breach of discipline, as the issue was clearly raised during the hearing and the Tribunal was entitled to substitute its own decision if it differed from the original decision maker. Furthermore, the Tribunal held that it had the jurisdiction to refer the matter back to QPS for reconsideration of the sanction. The Tribunal rejected both appeals, finding that the QCAT Tribunal correctly classified the conduct as a breach of discipline and had the authority to refer the matter back to QPS for reconsideration of the appropriate sanction. The Tribunal ordered that the QCAT decision be set aside, and the categorisation of the charge as misconduct be confirmed, while also directing the parties to submit further arguments regarding the appropriate sanction.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal is allowed.

2. The QCAT order of 20 April 2012 is set aside.

3. The categorisation of the charge of misconduct is confirmed.

4. The parties are requested to make further submissions as to the appropriate sanction by 4pm on 12 July 2013.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The appeal and cross appeal give rise to a number of issues to be considered. §Whether there was a decision by the Tribunal that the conduct was characterised as the breach of discipline This issue was not dealt with in written submissions but was raised orally by the counsel for QPS at the hearing. The argument was to the effect that although the learned Senior Member made reference and indeed findings in his reasons that the conduct was more appropriately categorised as a breach of discipline, his actual decision was only a reduction in the sanction. The Appeal Tribunal is satisfied that there is sufficient comment and consideration given by the learned Senior Member in his reasons in relation to this issue for it to be clear that a decision was made by the Tribunal - that the conduct amounted to a breach of discipline and not misconduct. §Was it open to the Tribunal to make a finding that there was a breach of discipline when the review application did not specify that Constable Garth sought a review of the categorisation of the charge as misconduct. QPS argued that it was the Tribunal’s function to review only the sanction imposed, because the issue of breach of discipline versus misconduct was not a ground of review raised in Constable Garth’s application. Further, it was not a ground contained in the “grounds of review” document filed by his solicitors. QPS does concede that, at the original hearing submissions on this issue were made. Constable Garth submits that there is no basis for this argument in that classification of the conduct was always a live issue at the hearing. He says that when the application was filed he was unrepresented. He points out that the QPS made the same argument in the application to reopen and the Senior Member commented in the reopening decision that the distinction between misconduct and breach of discipline was clearly an issue in contention at the hearing upon which the parties expected a finding would be made.[10] It is noted that Constable Garth made written submissions on this issue and, indeed, QPS filed submissions in response.[10] Assistant Police Commissioner Wright v Garth [2012] QCAT 488 at [10]. The Appeal Tribunal has no difficulty with the notion that the Tribunal could make a finding in relation to classification of the conduct even though it was not specifically raised in the application to review. It was squarely raised as an issue for determination at the hearing. The Tribunal on a review has all of the rights and functions of the decision maker of the decision being reviewed. It is a fresh hearing on the merits. The purpose of the review is to produce the correct and preferable decision.[11] It is consistent with those principles that if the issue of the appropriateness of the classification of the charge is raised during the hearing and the Tribunal forms a different view than that of the original decision maker, then it should set aside the decision and substitute its own decision. It follows that the ground of appeal raised by QPS that the Tribunal erred in not limiting itself to review of the sanction is rejected.§Should the order have been only that the charge of misconduct was unsubstantiated, or should the matter have been referred back to QPS for reconsideration[11] QCAT Act s 20(1).

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal on a review has all of the rights and functions of the decision maker of the decision being reviewed. It is a fresh hearing on the merits. The purpose of the review is to produce the correct and preferable decision.[11] It is consistent with those principles that if the issue of the appropriateness of the classification of the charge is raised during the hearing and the Tribunal forms a different view than that of the original decision maker, then it should set aside the decision and substitute its own decision. It follows that the ground of appeal raised by QPS that the Tribunal erred in not limiting itself to review of the sanction is rejected.§Should the order have been only that the charge of misconduct was unsubstantiated, or should the matter have been referred back to QPS for reconsideration[11] QCAT Act s 20(1). Constable Garth submits that the Tribunal erred in that, having found that the conduct amounted to a breach of discipline and not misconduct, it did not simply make a decision that the charge of misconduct was unsubstantiated. He says it would then have been a matter for the QPS to take it further if it so decided. The QPS say that if the Tribunal made the correct decision in classifying the conduct as breach of discipline and not misconduct (which it disputes and which is one of its grounds of appeal) then the appropriate course was for the Tribunal to refer the matter back to the QPS for further consideration on sanction. Constable Garth’s argument was that it was not open to the Tribunal to refer the matter back to QPS for reconsideration. Having found that the matter was a breach of discipline, he submitted that the Tribunal then had no jurisdiction to make any further orders on the basis that it only has jurisdiction to make orders when there is a finding of misconduct. The Appeal Tribunal does not agree with that submission. The Tribunal is empowered on a review to confirm or amend the decision; set aside the decision and substitute its own decision or set aside the decision and return the matter for reconsideration to the decision maker for the decision, with the directions the Tribunal considers appropriate.[12][12] Ibid s 24(1). The Tribunal had jurisdiction to consider the matter as it was reviewing a finding of misconduct. It conducted that review and found that the charge should have been classified as one of breach of discipline. It follows that it had the power to return the matter to QPS for reconsideration of the sanction. It did not have power to impose the sanction itself. It follows that that ground of appeal raised by Constable Garth is rejected. If the Appeal Tribunal concludes that the Tribunal did not err in finding that the conduct was classified as a breach of discipline then the appropriate order for this Appeal Tribunal would be to set aside that part of the decision with respect to the sanction and refer the matter back to QPS for reconsideration. This leads to the next issue for determination - a ground of appeal relied on by the QPS.§Was the conduct properly classified as a breach of discipline or was it misconduct?