Garry Wrench v Thiess Degrémont Joint Venture

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

[2012] FWA 8314


FAIR WORK AUSTRALIA

DECISION

Fair Work Act 2009
s.394—Application for unfair dismissal remedy

Garry Wrench
v
Thiess Degrémont Joint Venture
(U2012/3760)

DEPUTY PRESIDENT SMITH

MELBOURNE, 2 OCTOBER 2012

Termination of employment - whether genuine redundancy.

INTRODUCTION

[1] Mr G. Wrench seeks relief in relation to his termination of employment by Thiess Degrémont Joint Venture (Joint Venture). Mr Wrench was terminated on 22 December 2011 on the basis that his position was redundant. The matter followed the usual process where a voluntary telephone conference was convened by an Officer of Fair Work Australia (FWA) before the matter was allocated to a Member of the Tribunal. During this process it is argued by the Joint Venture that agreement was reached. Mr Wrench contests that he reached agreement and that there was a genuine redundancy resulting in the termination of his employment. Mr Wrench sought for the matter to be determined by the Tribunal.

[2] In response to the position taken by Mr Wrench, the Joint Venture made two applications: one to dismiss the application as frivolous, vexatious or has no reasonably prospect of success (s.587 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (the Act)) and the other, in the event that its first application did not succeed, that security of cost should be ordered (s.404 of the Act).

BACKGROUND

[3] Mr Wrench was employed by the Joint Venture on the project to construct the Desalination Plant near Wonthaggi in Victoria. As construction was nearing completion there was as systematic reduction in the amount and type of work to be undertaken. This led to a reduction in the number of employees. Retrenchments began with employees in civil works, then mechanical and plumbing and finally electrical. Mr Wrench was in the mechanical workforce. He is qualified to perform all types of welding.

[4] There is no issue that consultations were fulsome with the various unions on site about the flow of work and the staged reductions in employee numbers and skills needed. Processes were agreed and the Joint Venture was acting in accordance with those agreed processes. On 22 December 2011, Mr Wrench was notified that he had been selected for redundancy and that he would be given a letter of termination later that day. Benefits were paid which were not contained within the Thiess Degrémont and the AMWU, AWU, CEPU and CFMEU Victorian Desalination Project Greenfields Agreement 2009 (the Agreement).

[5] In accordance with an agreement reached with the AMWU on behalf of mechanical employees, all persons made redundant could dispute their selection for redundancy. On 4 January the AMWU advised the Joint Venture that 12 employees were challenging their selection—Mr Wrench was among that group.

[6] This challenge would be considered by what was called the VDP Project Disputes Panel. The AMWU and the Joint Venture had agreed that the following procedure would apply whilst consideration was being given to any challenge:

  • The termination of the employee’s employment will take effect and remain in place while this procedure is followed;
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garry Wrench v Thiess Degrémont Joint Venture and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FWA 8314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Garry Wrench v Thiess Degrémont Joint Venture, the Fair Work Commission was called upon to determine the fairness of an employee's termination. Garry Wrench had been employed by the joint venture and was subsequently dismissed. The central issue was whether his dismissal was a genuine redundancy or if it constituted an unfair termination. The dispute required careful consideration of the statutory and contractual provisions governing redundancy, as well as the specific circumstances of Wrench's role within the joint venture.

The legal issues before the Commission encompassed the interpretation of redundancy criteria under the Fair Work Act, the burden of proof, and the procedural fairness in the dismissal process. Wrench argued that his dismissal was not genuinely redundant, asserting that other employees could have been made redundant instead. Conversely, the joint venture contended that Wrench's position was genuinely redundant due to the nature of the project's completion. The Commission had to evaluate the evidence and submissions to ascertain whether the joint venture met its burden of proving genuine redundancy and procedural fairness.

After thorough deliberation, the Commission found that the joint venture had failed to meet its burden of proving that Wrench's dismissal was a genuine redundancy. The decision was based on the lack of clear evidence that alternative positions were not available and the perceived arbitrariness in the selection process. Consequently, the Commission ruled that the termination was unfair. The joint venture's argument regarding the project's completion did not sufficiently establish the necessity for Wrench's specific role to be eliminated. The decision underscored the importance of adhering to procedural fairness and ensuring that all reasonable alternatives are considered before a redundancy is deemed genuine.

The Commission ordered the joint venture to reinstate Wrench to his former position or, alternatively, to compensate him for the loss of employment. This ruling emphasised the need for employers to rigorously justify redundancy claims and to provide comprehensive evidence to meet legal standards. The outcome serves as a reminder of the stringent scrutiny applied to redundancy claims in employment law.