Garry Kelly and Australian Postal Corporation

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

[2014] AATA 779

Division GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISION

File Number

2013/5908

Re

Garry Kelly

APPLICANT

And

Australian Postal Corporation

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal

Mr D Letcher, QC, Senior Member

Date 24 October 2014
Place Sydney

The decision under review is affirmed.

........................................................................

Mr D Letcher, QC, Senior Member

CATCHWORDS

COMPENSATION – Employee of licensed corporation – Whether no present entitlement to compensation – Adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood – Decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth), s 14

CASES

Comcare v Mooi (1996) 69 FCR 439

REASONS FOR DECISION

Mr D Letcher, QC, Senior Member

24 October 2014

  1. The applicant seeks review of the decision of his employer (Australia Post) made 20 September 2013 that he did not have further entitlements to compensation under the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) as at 11 July 2013 in respect of “adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood”. Adjustment Disorder is a recognized psychiatric illness characterised by reactions to identifiable stressors by anxiety, depression or traumatic stress or a mixture of those symptoms.

  2. The applicant had made a claim for compensation for adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood with date of injury 28 December 2011 which had been accepted by the respondent in May 2012. However, the respondent came to the view in 2013 that the applicant no longer suffered from the disorder. There is no issue concerning the earlier claim. The respondent concedes that the applicant’s work was a substantial contributing element to the applicant’s disorder.

  3. The applicant believes that the attitude of his immediate superior and the management team of Australia Post has continued to cause him anxiety and depression rendering him unable to work. He insists that his concern be addressed by reviewing past incidents and grievances even if the other people concerned do not wish to do so. He maintains that he is unable to return to work until some prolonged process of discussion and acknowledgement of his concern is completed. He says that he does not trust senior management at Australia Post and that “to return to his previous position, without his concerns being resolved would be like jumping into a swimming pool that had a shark in it”.

    THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE

  4. It is a feature of this case that the applicant complains of disabling stress over 20 years but has always striven to remain in his position of Delivery Manager in the same North Coast centre. The applicant, now 57 years, has been employed by Australia Post in the one area for the whole of his working life. In 1999, the applicant was found to be suffering anxiety and depression and it was believed that he “will only effectively return to work if management issues as outlined below are addressed” and then followed a list which included very specific measures to inform the applicant if other employees made complaints about him (ST14, p. 380). The applicant has maintained this same fixed attitude ever since.

  5. In his evidence, the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garry Kelly and Australian Postal Corporation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] AATA 779
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case involved Garry Kelly, an employee of the Australian Postal Corporation, who was contesting a decision that he was not entitled to compensation for an adjustment disorder with mixed anxiety and depressed mood. The matter was heard in the Federal Circuit Court of Australia. The primary dispute centred on whether Mr Kelly was entitled to compensation, considering his ongoing mental health issues and the stance of his employer, Australia Post.

The court was required to determine whether Mr Kelly had a present entitlement to compensation under the relevant Act. Key issues included the nature and extent of Mr Kelly's mental health condition, the impact of his work environment and relationships with his superiors, and whether Australia Post had fulfilled its obligations to support his return to work. Additionally, the court had to consider Mr Kelly's claim that unresolved past grievances and a lack of trust in management were preventing his return to work.

The court examined the evidence presented by Mr Kelly and Australia Post, including medical reports, workplace interactions, and the employer's efforts to facilitate a return to work. It found that while Mr Kelly had experienced significant mental health issues, Australia Post had made reasonable efforts to support his return, including a graduated return to work program and efforts to address his concerns. The court concluded that Mr Kelly's refusal to participate in these efforts, due to unresolved past grievances and a lack of trust in management, meant that he did not have a present entitlement to compensation.

The court affirmed the original decision, holding that Mr Kelly was not entitled to compensation as at 11 July 2013. The reasoning was based on Mr Kelly's unwillingness to engage with the return to work process despite reasonable efforts by his employer, and his insistence on resolving past grievances as a precondition to returning to work.

Background

Background to the litigation

Garry Kelly, a long-term employee of Australia Post, has experienced anxiety and depression over a period of more than 20 years. He has held the position of Delivery Manager in the same North Coast centre throughout his employment. In 1999, it was identified that Kelly would only return to work effectively if certain management issues were addressed. Despite this, Kelly has remained in his position, maintaining that he cannot return to work without resolution of past grievances with his superiors. In January 2013, a graduated return to work was attempted by assigning Kelly to a non-managerial role in Wauchope. Kelly viewed this as punitive and refused to undertake the role, citing a lack of administrative work, no assessment of the physical characteristics of the route, and the absence of proper protective equipment. He subsequently returned to his original workplace under a different superior, whom he trusted, but remained stressed. After this superior went on leave, Kelly was sent back to Wauchope before being told that Australia Post had ceased to accept liability and instructed to return to his original position. Kelly then received complaints about his performance and went on sick leave.

The matter before the court is an appeal against a decision that affirmed the applicant's lack of entitlement to compensation under the Act for Adjustment Disorder as of 11 July 2013. The primary decision was made by a tribunal which reviewed the applicant's case, including his history of anxiety and depression, his refusal to return to work under certain conditions, and the employer's efforts to facilitate his return. The tribunal upheld the decision that the applicant was not entitled to compensation, a ruling which the applicant has appealed to the higher court. The appeal process involves reviewing the tribunal's findings and the evidence presented regarding the applicant's condition, the employer's actions, and the applicant's ability to return to work.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The applicant believes that the attitude of his immediate superior and the management team of Australia Post has continued to cause him anxiety and depression rendering him unable to work. He insists that his concern be addressed by reviewing past incidents and grievances even if the other people concerned do not wish to do so. He maintains that he is unable to return to work until some prolonged process of discussion and acknowledgement of his concern is completed. He says that he does not trust senior management at Australia Post and that “to return to his previous position, without his concerns being resolved would be like jumping into a swimming pool that had a shark in it”.THE APPLICANT’S EVIDENCE It is a feature of this case that the applicant complains of disabling stress over 20 years but has always striven to remain in his position of Delivery Manager in the same North Coast centre. The applicant, now 57 years, has been employed by Australia Post in the one area for the whole of his working life. In 1999, the applicant was found to be suffering anxiety and depression and it was believed that he “will only effectively return to work if management issues as outlined below are addressed” and then followed a list which included very specific measures to inform the applicant if other employees made complaints about him (ST14, p. 380). The applicant has maintained this same fixed attitude ever since. In his evidence, the applicant said that when he returned to work after his time off in 2011 he felt that nothing he could do would please his superior, “I was sitting there waiting for [the superior] to jump on me” and without the past issues between them being discussed and resolved he felt threatened. Mediation was attempted but the superior refused to co-operate by discussing the past. In January 2013 a graduated return to work (“GRTW”) was attempted by sending the applicant to work in a non-managerial role at Wauchope, a small town located close to the applicant’s home. The applicant expressed in an email (Exhibit 9) concern at being sent to Wauchope:I see this option as some sort of ‘punishment’, both of my treating doctors and myself believe I am fit to return to Port DC… My issue is with my Area Manager, not my staff or Port DC… I see this proposal as a chance for my Area Manager to “screw” me again and AP saying “we will hold him for you”. The applicant complained that he was not provided with the administrative work he was supposed to receive. He was then requested to go on a walking route to hand-deliver mail in Wauchope town. The applicant refused saying that before he did that there had to be an assessment of the physical characteristics of the route, a medical assessment of himself, approval of the rehabilitation adviser and provision of proper protective equipment (hat and shirt). He did not attend for work the next day. Subsequently, after further time off the applicant was transferred back to his original workplace to work under a different superior. He said that the first few weeks were “very stressful, I felt targeted” but he continued in that position. It is noteworthy that the applicant identified that superior as the only member of the Australia Post management team that he trusted. After that superior took long service leave the applicant was sent back to Wauchope for a time but then he was told that Australia Post had ceased to accept liability and that he should return to his original position. He did so but on 30 July 2013 received a letter from management making complaints about his performance and shortly thereafter went off on sick leave. He said that he had requested formal retraining in new procedures adopted while he was away from his position, that management were unreasonable and prejudiced in the complaints and that he felt he was being set up to fail.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The applicant was not entitled to compensation under the Act for Adjustment Disorder as at 11 July 2013.DECISION The decision under review is affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The tribunal examined the applicant's claims of anxiety and depression caused by his perception of the attitude of his superiors and management team at Australia Post. The applicant had been employed by Australia Post for over 20 years and had a history of claiming disabling stress. Despite this, he had maintained his position as Delivery Manager until his leave due to mental health issues in 2011. The tribunal noted the applicant's refusal to participate in a graduated return to work plan and his insistence on a prolonged process of discussion and resolution of past grievances before he would consider returning to work.

The tribunal applied the criteria under the relevant Act to determine whether the applicant was presently entitled to compensation. It found that the applicant's concerns, while legitimate, did not meet the threshold for entitlement to compensation as of the review date. The tribunal considered the employer's efforts to facilitate the applicant's return to work, including attempts at mediation and a graduated return to work plan, and found these efforts to be reasonable and sufficient. The tribunal also noted that the applicant had refused to participate in the offered return to work plan, citing concerns that were not substantiated by the evidence.

The tribunal's decision affirmed the original decision that the applicant was not entitled to compensation for Adjustment Disorder as at 11 July 2013. The reasoning focused on the applicant's ongoing refusal to return to work under reasonable conditions and the employer's reasonable efforts to facilitate his return. The ratio decidendi of this case is that an applicant must participate in reasonable return to work plans offered by the employer to be considered presently entitled to compensation for a mental health condition under the Act.