Garlin v United Group

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

CITATION:      Garlin v United Group [2012] NTMC 045

PARTIES:   RICK GARLIN

v

UNITED GROUP LIMITED

TITLE OF COURT:   WORK HEALTH COURT

JURISDICTION:   Interlocutory

FILE NO(s):   21234628

DELIVERED ON:   11 October 2012

DELIVERED AT:   Darwin

HEARING DATE(s):   8 October 2012

JUDGMENT OF:   J Johnson JR

CATCHWORDS:

SECTIONS 107(1) AND 75 OF THE WORKERS REHABILITATION & COMPENSATION ACT – whether a worker may enforce the cost of rehabilitation needs by interim determination.

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:

Worker:   Mr Crawley

Employer:   Mr Liveris

Solicitors:

Worker:   Hall Payne Lawyers

Employer:   Jarman McKenna

Judgment category classification:         C

Judgment ID number:   [2012] NTMC 045

Number of paragraphs:   41


IN THE WORK HEALTH COURT
AT DARWIN IN THE NORTHERN
TERRITORY OF AUSTRALIA

No. 21234628

BETWEEN:

RICK GARLIN

Worker

AND:

UNITED GROUP LIMITED

Employer

REASON FOR JUDGMENT

(Delivered 11 October 2012)

Mr J JOHNSON JR:

  1. This is an Application by the worker for an interim determination. It is a somewhat unusual Application: it is the first time in my experience in the interlocutory jurisdiction of this Court that a worker has sought an interim determination other than for weekly benefits of compensation that have either been declined ab initio, or subsequently reduced or terminated. By contrast, the worker here seeks by his Application an interim determination comprised of the following three elements:

    ·$304.00 per week for attendant care services and home help;

    ·$275.00 as a one-off lump sum to purchase recommended home help equipment; and

    ·A determination that the employer engage a rehabilitation consultant to undertake a contemporary assessment of the worker’s rehabilitation needs so as to ensure that, as far as is practicable, he is restored to the same physical, economic and social conditions in which he was before suffering the relevant injury.

  2. I am told by both parties from the Bar Table today that the worker has met the pre-condition imposed by section 103(J)(3) of the Act, and that is confirmed by Annexure “RG7” to the worker’s affidavit affirmed on 28 August 2012.

    Context

  3. On 29 January 2009 the worker was employed as a crane operator/rigger with the respondent when he suffered an injury to his right wrist during the course of his employment. A claim for compensation was duly submitted to the employer and liability accepted. Unfortunately for the worker and the employer, there appears to have been a downward spiral of the worker’s physical and psychological health since that time, leading to a total loss of earning capacity from April 2009 and continuing. Thus, it may be seen, the worker has been in receipt of weekly benefits of compensation for total incapacity for a continuous period of three and a half years. During that intervening period the worker alleges further injury to his left arm through overuse to compensate for his inability to use his right wrist. There have been numerous surgical and other interventions funded by the employer’s insurer, but medical opinion appears to remain the same, albeit with some qualification, that the worker is unfit to return to work in any capacity[1].

  4. The worker…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Garlin v United Group and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NTMC 45
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Garlin v United Group involved a dispute between an employee and their employer regarding the enforcement of the costs of rehabilitation needs through an interim determination under sections 107(1) and 75 of the Workers Rehabilitation & Compensation Act. The employee argued that they were entitled to an interim determination for the costs of rehabilitation needs, while the employer's insurer argued that such an entitlement was not available until a final determination was made. The court was required to determine whether an interim determination could be applied to the costs of rehabilitation needs and whether such a determination was available until a final determination was made. The court held that the terminology used in section 107(1) of the Act was broad and referrable to the heads of damage in Division 3 and Division 4 of Part 5. The court also held that an interim determination could be applied to any amount of a party's entitlement to compensation or any benefit specified within Divisions 3 and 4 of Part 5. The court found that the employee was entitled to an interim determination for the costs of rehabilitation needs, as such costs were capable of realisation by the terms of section 107(1) of the Act. The court also found that a one-off lump sum payment could assist an injured worker with urgent one-off payments that expert opinion recommends for their rehabilitation in keeping with community standards. Therefore, the court held that the employee was entitled to an interim determination for the costs of rehabilitation needs.

The court's reasoning was based on the purpose and object underlying the Act, which was to promote the rehabilitation and compensation of injured workers. The court held that an interim determination was capable of either maintaining the status quo or shielding a worker from any financial detriment which may flow from an adverse decision of an employer. The court also held that a weekly benefit of compensation to provide a worker with recurrent attendant care services was an entitlement clearly authorised by section 75 of the Act and readily fit an objective interpretation of "interim determination." The court found that the employee was entitled to an interim determination for the costs of rehabilitation needs as it was a benefit capable of realisation by the terms of section 107(1) of the Act. The court also held that a one-off lump sum payment did not so readily lend itself to similar interpretation but it did, nonetheless, have the capacity to assist an injured worker with urgent one-off payments that expert opinion recommends for their rehabilitation in keeping with community standards. The court found that there was nothing in section 107(1) of the Act that would preclude such need being met by an interim determination. The court held that the employer's insurer was liable for the costs of rehabilitation needs until a final determination was made.

In conclusion, the court held that the employee was entitled to an interim determination for the costs of rehabilitation needs under sections 107(1) and 75 of the Workers Rehabilitation & Compensation Act. The court found that the terminology used in section 107(1) of the Act was broad and referrable to the heads of damage in Division 3 and Division 4 of Part 5. The court also held that an interim determination could be applied to any amount of a party's entitlement to compensation or any benefit specified within Divisions 3 and 4 of Part 5. The court found that the employee was entitled to an interim determination for the costs of rehabilitation needs as it was a benefit capable of realisation by the terms of section 107(1) of the Act. The court also held that a one-off lump sum payment did not so readily lend itself to similar interpretation but it did, nonetheless, have the capacity to assist an injured worker with urgent one-off payments that expert opinion recommends for their rehabilitation in keeping with community standards. The court found that there was nothing in section 107(1) of the Act that would preclude such need being met by an interim determination. The court held that the employer's insurer was liable for the costs of rehabilitation needs until a final determination was made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Arguably, and in the scheme of the Act, the terminology used in section 107(1) is in broad terms referrable to the heads of damage in Division 3 (headed Amount of compensation), and Division 4 (headed Rehabilitation and other compensation), of Part 5. Thus, and giving the term “interim determination” a broad meaning consistent with promoting the purpose or object underlying the Act[10], arguably an interim determination is capable of application to any amount “of a party’s entitlement to compensation” or, by definition, any “benefit” specified within Divisions 3 and 4 of Part 5.Consideration I think it may fairly be said that an employer’s insurers can sometimes become exasperated as costs mount on a particular claim, and the likelihood of restoring pre-injury earning capacity dims. At that stage some will then draw a line in the sand by use of the terminology “closing our file”[11]. Effectively, that is one available mechanism to force a worker into dispute so as to have this Court determine long term liability. There is nothing inherently wrong with that, but the question arises whether such endeavour ought shield an employer’s insurer from any liability in the interim, ie; until such time as that dispute is finally heard and determined and any appeal period has expired. In terms of weekly benefits of compensation the answer to that question is clearly “no” subject to the elements of an interlocutory injunction having been made out. But the question of a “benefit” more broadly, in my opinion, requires some further enquiry. A weekly benefit of compensation to provide a worker with recurrent attendant care services appears to me to be consonant with an entitlement to interim weekly benefits of compensation. It is an entitlement clearly authorised by 75 of the Act and readily fits an objective interpretation of “interim determination” insofar as it is capable of either maintaining the status quo or shielding a worker from any financial detriment which may flow from an adverse decision of an employer. In my view therefore, it is a “benefit” capable of realisation by the terms of section 107(1) of the Act. A one-off lump sum payment does not so readily lend itself to similar interpretation but it does, nonetheless, have the capacity to assist an injured worker with urgent one-off payments that expert opinion recommends for his or her rehabilitation in keeping with community standards. There appears nothing in my examination of section 107(1) of the Act that, of itself, would preclude such need being met by an interim determination. The status quo in relation to rehabilitation was that which existed prior to 20 June 2012 when the worker avers to his solicitors being informed by the employer’s insurer that “… no further rehabilitation will be undertaken as I am not considered fit to return to any employment”[12]. That letter had been preceded by a letter dated 13 June 2012 from the worker’s then rehabilitation provider which was headed “Case Closure” and to which I have referred at par 21 above.