Gardon & Zhang

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(DIVISION 1)

Gardon & Zhang [2022] FedCFamC1F 371

File number(s): SYC 4528 of 2021
Judgment of: CHRISTIE J
Date of judgment: 30 May 2022
Catchwords: FAMILY LAW – INTERIM 90RD THRESHOLD ISSUE – Meaning of de facto relationship – Where the applicant husband has suffered cognitive decline – Where the parties are no longer cohabiting – Where The NSW Trustee and Guardian on behalf of the applicant, seeks a declaration that the relationship has broken down – Alteration of property interests sought – Where the respondent wife asserts the relationship has not broken down – Judgment reserved pending Fairbairn v Radecki appeal to the High Court of Australia ––Where the Court is required to consider all evidence relevant to the threshold issue.  
Legislation: Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) ss 4AA, 90SM, 90RD
Cases cited:

Fairbairn & Radecki (2020) 62 Fam LR 62.

Fairbairn v Radecki [2022] HCA 18.

Nord & Van (2018) FLC 93- 833.

Division: Division 1 First Instance
Number of paragraphs: 160
Date of last submission/s: 17 May 2022
Date of hearing: 7-8 December 2021
Place: Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Harper on 7-8 December 2021
Solicitor advocate for the Applicant: Mr Katsikaris on 17 May 2022
Solicitor for the Applicant: Mr Katsikaris, Katsikaris Family Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Ms Judge
Solicitor for the Respondent: Mr Keen, Keen Lawyers

ORDERS

SYC 4528 of 2021

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 1)

BETWEEN:

MR GARDON

Applicant

AND:

MS ZHANG

Respondent

order made by:

CHRISTIE J

DATE OF ORDER:

30 May 2022

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The Application in a proceeding filed 15 November 2021 by the applicant is dismissed.

2.The Initiating Application filed 18 June 2021 by the applicant is dismissed.

Note:   The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 10.14(b) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 10.13 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Family Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

Section 121 of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) makes it an offence, except in very limited circumstances, to publish proceedings that identify persons, associated persons, or witnesses involved in family law proceedings.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment by this Court under the pseudonym Gardon & Zhang, has been approved pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

CHRISTIE J:

Introduction

  1. This is an application brought on behalf of Mr Gardon (“the husband”) (“Mr Gardon”), by The NSW Trustee and Guardian (“the Trustee”), as financial manager, seeking a declaration that the de facto relationship between the husband and Ms Zhang (“the wife”) (“Ms Zhang”) has broken down. The application seeks a declaration that the de facto relationship between the husband and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gardon & Zhang and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FedCFamC1F 371
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Gardon and Zhang, the court was required to determine whether the de facto relationship between the husband and wife had ended prior to the husband's entry into assisted care in 2019. This determination was necessary to decide if a property adjustment application could be made under the Family Law Act. The husband, who was under a guardianship order due to his declining health, was represented by his sister and solicitor. The wife presented her case through affidavits and evidence of her continued care for the husband, despite their sexual relationship ending around 2007. The court considered the evidence presented by both parties, including the wife's ongoing care for the husband and her efforts to manage the couple's finances.

The central legal issue was whether the relationship had indeed ended, given the husband's deteriorating health and the wife's role as his primary caregiver. The court assessed the evidence in aggregate, taking into account the wife's care for the husband, her financial management of the couple's affairs, and her interactions with third parties. The court found that while some evidence suggested a change in the nature of the relationship, the wife's continued care and commitment to the husband indicated that the relationship remained intact. The court concluded that the relationship had not ended, and thus a property adjustment application could not be made.

The court's decision was based on a comprehensive evaluation of the wife's role as the husband's primary caregiver and her ongoing commitment to him, despite the changes in their relationship. The wife's actions, including her care for the husband and her management of their financial affairs, demonstrated a continued de facto relationship. The court found that the wife's efforts to secure her financial contribution to their shared property did not signify the end of the relationship but rather her recognition of her role in their shared assets. Consequently, the court ruled that the relationship had not ended, and the property adjustment application was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Given the husband’s guardianship, he did not file an affidavit. The evidence in his case was given by his sister, Ms F and his solicitor. Ms F’s affidavit states that the parties’ de facto relationship broke down in or around July 2019. This would appear to be a conclusion as opposed to evidence of the facts and circumstances which are said to constitute the breakdown of the relationship.Background The husband was born in 1955 in Sydney, Australia. The wife was born in 1952 in Country L. The parties lived together from 2001 until the husband entered the G Centre in 2019. It was not argued at trial that in the period between 2001 and July 2019 the parties were not in a de facto relationship. The husband was first diagnosed with a neurological disease in or about 1980. The parties met in 1996 and soon after commenced a relationship. Two years after their meeting, in or about 1998, the wife says the parties entered into a sexual relationship. At the time the parties met, the wife owned three properties: M Street, Suburb N, P Street, Suburb Q and R Street, Suburb Q. The husband owned one property, S Street, Suburb T (“the Suburb T property”). In early 2000, the parties purchased a block of land as joint tenants at U Street, Suburb V (“the Suburb V property”) with plans to build a house on the land. Construction of the house concluded in June 2007 and the parties moved in shortly after. In or around April 2001, the wife moved into the husband’s property at Suburb T. They resided there together for around five years until the husband sold the property. Between the sale of the Suburb T property and construction of the Suburb V property, the parties resided at a rental property belonging to the husband’s brother for six to 12 months. The wife recalls that the husband started developing symptoms associated with his disease prior to them moving into the Suburb V property. This is also around the time the wife recalls the parties sexual relationship ceasing. However, the wife asserts they remained sleeping in the same bed. The husband ceased employment in around 2007 while the wife continued to undertake full time employment. Around the same time, the wife became the husband’s carer and began receiving a carer’s allowance. Between 2007 and 2012, the husband was able to carry out some tasks for himself. During that period, the wife cared for the husband including taking him to medical appointments, shopping and assisting him with his medication. In 2012, the wife retired from her employment. In the period between 2007 and 2012 the wife was the only member of the couple in receipt of personal exertion income. Her correspondence with the parties’ financial adviser suggests she applied those funds to the living expenses of the parties. It emerged from the evidence that as the husband’s health deteriorated she was almost solely responsible for his day to day care. On 27 April 2012, the husband appointed the wife as his attorney under an Enduring Power of Attorney (“EPOA”) and as his guardian.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Consistent with Fairbairn, the central issue for determination in this matter is whether the parties’ relationship ended. Accordingly, the focus of the Court’s consideration is on events in the period commencing a few years immediately before the date on which the Trustee contends the parties separated and concluding at the time of hearing.Evidence At the interim hearing, the Trustee relied on the following documents:(a)An Initiating Application filed 18 June 2021;(b)An affidavit of Ms F filed 18 June 2021;(c)A financial statement filed 18 June 2021;(d)The applicant’s tender bundle provided 3 December 2021; and(e)Various documents tendered by the applicant marked as exhibits in the proceedings. In turn, the wife relied on the following documents:(a)An Amended Response to an Initiating Application filed 3 September 2021; (b)An affidavit of Ms Zhang filed 19 August 2021;(c)An affidavit of Ms Zhang filed 20 August 2021; (d)An affidavit of Mr K filed 20 August 2021; and (e)Various documents tendered by the respondent and marked as exhibits in the proceedings. Given the husband’s guardianship, he did not file an affidavit. The evidence in his case was given by his sister, Ms F and his solicitor. Ms F’s affidavit states that the parties’ de facto relationship broke down in or around July 2019. This would appear to be a conclusion as opposed to evidence of the facts and circumstances which are said to constitute the breakdown of the relationship.Background The husband was born in 1955 in Sydney, Australia. The wife was born in 1952 in Country L. The parties lived together from 2001 until the husband entered the G Centre in 2019. It was not argued at trial that in the period between 2001 and July 2019 the parties were not in a de facto relationship. The husband was first diagnosed with a neurological disease in or about 1980. The parties met in 1996 and soon after commenced a relationship. Two years after their meeting, in or about 1998, the wife says the parties entered into a sexual relationship. At the time the parties met, the wife owned three properties: M Street, Suburb N, P Street, Suburb Q and R Street, Suburb Q. The husband owned one property, S Street, Suburb T (“the Suburb T property”). In early 2000, the parties purchased a block of land as joint tenants at U Street, Suburb V (“the Suburb V property”) with plans to build a house on the land. Construction of the house concluded in June 2007 and the parties moved in shortly after. In or around April 2001, the wife moved into the husband’s property at Suburb T. They resided there together for around five years until the husband sold the property. Between the sale of the Suburb T property and construction of the Suburb V property, the parties resided at a rental property belonging to the husband’s brother for six to 12 months. The wife recalls that the husband started developing symptoms associated with his disease prior to them moving into the Suburb V property. This is also around the time the wife recalls the parties sexual relationship ceasing. However, the wife asserts they remained sleeping in the same bed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The wife communicated with the G Centre for the purpose of making arrangements such as taking the husband out, including for Christmas lunch (December 2019) and, as detailed above, facilitating medical appointments inside and outside the aged care facility. The tendered material from the G Centre supports the conclusion that NN Services have at all times dealt with the wife as the husband’s next of kin.Conclusions Counsel who appeared on behalf of the Trustee succinctly submitted as follows: …the case on behalf of the application [i]s three fold: 1. [Ms Zhang] intended that the relationship break down or that the parties be separated and acted upon that intention, separating in or about September 20192. Regardless of [Ms Zhang’s] intention, the circumstances of the de facto relationship no longer existed in or about July 2019 and [Ms Zhang’s] behaviour, in particular her pursuing return of the $453,000 contributed initially to the [Suburb V] property was so incompatible with the conduct of the relationship to date so as to indicate that the relationship had come to an end; and3. That break down can mean something other than the end of a relationship (Case Outline filed on behalf of the husband at [26]). The factual circumstances upon which the applicant sought to rely to ground the second limb of the argument were as follows: (a)The contention that the wife had indicated an intention to move to Western Australia. (b)The contention that the wife had, for a period of time, been pursuing methods by which she could have returned to her the sum of $453,000. (c)The extent to which the wife made representations in respect of her financial position which had the effect of treating assets owned by her as irrelevant to the financial circumstances of the couple. The husband’s sister gave evidence that the wife spoke to her in September 2019 abut moving to Western Australia. Namely, that the wife said she is moving to Western Australia to be closer to Country L and because property is cheaper there. Further Ms F’s evidence was to the effect that the wife had discussed with her the purchase of property with Ms Zhang’s brother, in Western Australia. The wife in evidence confirmed she discussed helping her brother set up his home but was not moving herself. No evidence of any property purchase was before the Court. The wife certainly had a trip to Western Australia planned for early 2020 but cancelled it due to COVID-19. In an email to Ms F dated 7 April 2020 the wife said “I will make sure I stay in Sydney until [Mr Gardon’s] affairs are handed over to the family before leaving”. That could be interpreted as a reference to a planned move but equally could be consistent with the necessity for the wife to travel for family related reasons. The wife was not cross-examined about it. The wife did not move to Western Australia. The determination, having regard to the whole of the relevant circumstances, of whether the parties’ relationship ended, is, by its nature, an exercise of discretion. It involves an assessment of the available evidence supportive of a finding about the status of the relationship. Human relationships are infinitely mutable. In this case, from about 2014, the evidence suggests that the wife found life more challenging as she navigated her husband’s failing physical health and the diminution in his cognitive skills. She experienced her own significant physical health challenges and juggled both of these with an aging parent living overseas. She diligently attended to her husband’s day to day care and all the non-financial contributions required to run a household. She also attended to their financial affairs. While, I accept that she explored whether legal separation would assist the parties’ financially and that she allocated to herself from the parties’ funds an amount designed to recognise her “lottery win” contribution to the parties’ real property, I do not accept that those circumstances point only to the end of the parties’ long term relationship. In reaching that conclusion I am aware that the wife has provided daily care and continues to provide daily care to the husband. She is attentive to his health and welfare in a manner consistent with her long term commitment to him.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, they identified as potentially factually relevant:43. …persistent refusal by the respondent to make “the necessary or desirable adjustments”, to use the language of Stanford, which might have evidenced an ongoing relationship.Consideration As the parties presented their respective cases the Court was being asked to determine whether the relationship between the parties had ended (as is required by s 90SM of the Act) before a property adjustment application may be made or whether, as contended by the respondent, it remained on foot. Each party pointed to various pieces of evidence as supportive of his or her respective case. As will become apparent, I accept that this is a case where some of the evidence points towards a conclusion that the relationship had changed in ways which the applicant would contend are indicative of the relationship having come to an end, while other parts of the evidence speak to the continuation of the relationship. It is by examining the evidence “in aggregate” that it is possible to reach a conclusion about whether the relationship had broken down. The Trustee submitted that the wife ended the parties’ long term relationship at the time the husband entered into assisted care (or soon thereafter). The wife says that the nature of the cohabitation changed but the relationship remained intact. The wife has an ongoing relationship with the husband. The question for the Court is whether or not it is a de facto relationship. During the hearing I put to the parties that there would appear to be three potential factual findings:(a)The parties separated and have not resumed their relationship; or(b)The parties separated and subsequently resumed their relationship; or(c)The parties did not separate. I was taken by counsel for the Trustee to evidence of the wife having reported to third parties that the relationship was over or that she contemplated separation:(a)In conversations with the husband’s sister;(b)In the meeting with Dr Z; and(c)In consultations with Mr W;I consider that evidence below. A report authored by Dr Z following meetings with the husband and the wife on 11 June 2019 contains the following:[Ms Zhang] reported that she used to be in a dating relationship with [Mr Gardon] but since building the house together in 2007 and moving in, she is no longer his partner but only his carer (she receives a Carers Allowance). In contrast, [Mr Gardon] reported that he considers [Ms Zhang] is both his partner and carer. It has to be accepted that the report, under the heading psychosocial history is not a verbatim record of what was said but an impression. It is plain that Dr Z used quotation marks at other places in the report to denote use of the person’s own words. The expression “dating relationship” is unusual since the parties’ relationship was characterised by cohabitation over a lengthy period of time. It is clear from the evidence that the parties’ sexual relationship ended about 2007 and this gives potential context to the use of the expression “partner” here.