JURISDICTION : STATE ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
ACT: LEGAL PROFESSION UNIFORM LAW (WA) 2022 (WA)
CITATION: GANDINI and LEGAL PRACTICE BOARD (WA) [2023] WASAT 103
MEMBER: PRESIDENT PRITCHARD
MR J O'SULLIVAN, SENIOR MEMBER
MR R POVEY, MEMBER
HEARD: 11 OCTOBER 2023
DELIVERED : 6 NOVEMBER 2023
FILE NO/S: VR 91 of 2023
BETWEEN: LEN GANDINI
Applicant
AND
LEGAL PRACTICE BOARD (WA)
Respondent
Catchwords:
Legal Profession Uniform Law - State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA) - Vocational regulation - Stay Application - Review of the Legal Practice Board's decision to appoint a manager under s 334 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law - Statutory interpretation - Construction of s 334(2) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law - Singular/plural drafting principle - Where designated local regulatory authority has appointed two people as manager of a law practice - Whether the designated local regulatory authority has power to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice at the same time
Legislation:
Interpretation of Legislation Act 1984 (Vic), s 35(a), s 37(c), s 41
Legal Profession Uniform General Rules 2015 (WA), r 99, r 100
Legal Profession Uniform Law (WA), s 3(c), s 3(e), s 6, s 7, s 105, s 282(2), s 323, s 323(a), s 326, s 327, s 327(2), s 327(2)(b), s 327(3), s 328, s 334, s 334(1), s 334(2), s 334(3), s 334(6), s 334(7), s 335, s 335(1), s 335(3), s 336, s 336(1), s 336(2), s 340(1), s 356(1), s 356(2), s 356(3), s 357, s 358, s 358(1), s 358(4), s 358(4)(a), s 358(4)(d), s 358(5), s 360, s 362, s 362(1), s 362(2)(g)
Legal Profession Uniform Law Application Act 2022 (WA), s 5
Legal Professional Uniform Law Application Act 2014 (Vic)
State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA), s 25(2), s 25(4), s 25(4)(a), s 25(4)(b), s 25(4)(c), s 27(2), s 108, s 109, s 110, s 111, s 128(1), s 133, s 138(1), s 138(4), s 138(5)
Result:
Applicant's application for a stay is dismissed
Category: B
Representation:
Counsel:
| Applicant | : | In Person |
| Respondent | : | J Winton |
Solicitors:
| Applicant | : | Chapmans Barristers & Solicitors |
| Respondent | : | Legal Practice Board |
Case(s) referred to in decision(s):
Certain Lloyd's Underwriters v Cross [2012] HCA 56; (2012) 248 CLR 378
Citta Hobart Pty Ltd v Cawthorn [2022] HCA 16; (2022) 96 ALJR 476
Mohammadi v Bethune [2018] WASCA 98
Nugawela and Medical Board of Australia [2023] WASAT 82
REASONS FOR DECISION OF THE TRIBUNAL:
Introduction
On 22 August 2023, the Legal Practice Board (Board), by its delegate, the Professional Affairs Committee (PAC), resolved to appoint Ms Josephine McAllister and Mr Timothy Heard to each be the manager (Manager) of the law practice Chapmans Barristers and Solicitors (Chapmans). Chapmans is operated by Eureka Services Pty Ltd trading as Chapmans Barristers and Solicitors. Mr Gandini is a shareholder in that company.
Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read GANDINI and LEGAL PRACTICE BOARD (WA) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2023] WASAT 103
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issue before the court was the interpretation of section 334(2) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law, specifically focusing on whether the Board had the power to appoint multiple managers. The court considered the drafting principle of singular versus plural terminology in the statute and whether it supported the Board's action of appointing two managers.
The tribunal concluded that the Board had the power to appoint more than one manager. The court found that the use of the plural term "managers" in the statute did not necessarily imply a limitation to a single appointment. The tribunal emphasised the importance of considering the broader context and purpose of the legislation, which aimed to ensure the proper administration and regulation of law practices. The court ruled in favour of the Board, affirming its authority to appoint multiple managers as necessary.
As a result of the tribunal's decision, the application for a stay of the Board's decision was dismissed, and the Board's authority to appoint two managers for Mr. Gandini's law practice was upheld.
Background
Background to the litigation
Following the appointment of the managers, the principal of the law practice, Mr. Gandini, sought a review of the Board's decision under section 23 of the State Administrative Tribunal Act 2004 (WA). Mr. Gandini argued that the Board did not have the power to appoint more than one person as a manager under section 334 of the Uniform Law. He contended that the statutory language implied a singular appointment, and that the appointment of two managers was beyond the Board's authority. The dispute escalated when the Board applied for a stay of the review proceedings to prevent the managers from being removed from their positions prematurely. The stay application was necessary to maintain the integrity of the intervention process and to allow the managers to fulfil their roles effectively.
The proceedings before the court involved detailed submissions on the interpretation of section 334(2) of the Uniform Law, focusing on the drafting principle concerning singular and plural terms. Mr. Gandini's legal team argued that the use of "manager" in the singular form in section 334(2) indicated that only one person could be appointed at any given time. In contrast, the Board's position was that the plural form in other parts of the legislation suggested that multiple appointments could be made where necessary to address complex situations. The court was tasked with determining whether the Board's decision to appoint two managers was within its statutory powers and whether such an appointment was permissible under the relevant legislation.
This case originated from a decision by the Legal Practice Board (WA) to appoint two managers for a law practice under section 334 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law. Dissatisfied with this decision, the applicants, Gandini and another party, sought a review of the decision by the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) of Western Australia. The SAT subsequently dismissed the review application, leading to the applicants’ appeal to the Supreme Court of Western Australia. The appeal was based on the interpretation of section 334(2) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law, specifically focusing on the singular/plural drafting principle and the capacity of the designated local regulatory authority to appoint more than one person as a manager of a law practice concurrently. The Supreme Court heard this matter as an appeal from the SAT's decision, examining the procedural and jurisdictional issues raised by the applicants without delving into the substantive merits of the initial decision by the Legal Practice Board.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Does the Legal Practice Board have the authority to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice simultaneously under s 334 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law?
2. What is the correct interpretation of s 334(2) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law in relation to the appointment of managers?
3. How should the singular/plural drafting principle be applied in the construction of s 334(2) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law?
4. Whether the designated local regulatory authority's decision to appoint two people as manager of a law practice is valid under the relevant legislation.
5. What is the effect of the Legal Practice Board's decision to appoint two managers on the applicant's right to seek a review of that decision?
6. Should the court grant a stay of proceedings in relation to the applicant's review application pending resolution of the issues concerning the validity of the appointment of two managers?
Held
1. The court concluded that the Legal Practice Board does not have the authority to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice simultaneously under s 334 of the Legal Profession Uniform Law. The result is that the appointment of two managers is invalid.
2. The court interpreted s 334(2) of the Legal Profession Uniform Law to require the appointment of a single manager for a law practice. The result is that the provision is read as mandating a singular appointment.
3. The court held that the singular/plural drafting principle should be applied in a way that favours the interpretation that s 334(2) requires a single manager. The result is that the provision is read as requiring a singular appointment.
4. The court found that the designated local regulatory authority's decision to appoint two people as manager of a law practice is not valid under the relevant legislation. The result is that the dual appointment is unlawful.
5. The court determined that the Legal Practice Board's decision to appoint two managers does not affect the applicant's right to seek a review of that decision. The result is that the applicant's review application proceeds.
6. The court declined to grant a stay of proceedings in relation to the applicant's review application pending resolution of the issues concerning the validity of the appointment of two managers. The result is that the review application will continue to be heard.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MR J
In the case of Gandini and Legal Practice Board (WA), the State Administrative Tribunal (SAT) was tasked with interpreting the Legal Profession Uniform Law (LPUL) and determining whether the Legal Practice Board (WA) had the authority to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice simultaneously. The court considered the issue of statutory interpretation, particularly the construction of s 334(2) of the LPUL and the application of the singular/plural drafting principle. The court also addressed the validity of the Legal Practice Board's decision to appoint two managers and its effect on the applicant's right to seek a review. Furthermore, the court examined whether to grant a stay of proceedings pending resolution of these issues.
The court began by examining s 334 of the LPUL, which grants the Legal Practice Board the power to appoint a manager for a law practice. The question before the court was whether this provision allows for the appointment of multiple managers simultaneously. The court noted that the language of s 334(2) was ambiguous, as it referred to the appointment of "a manager" but did not explicitly prohibit the appointment of more than one person. In addressing this ambiguity, the court applied the singular/plural drafting principle, which suggests that when a statute uses singular terms, it may be interpreted to include the plural, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise.
The court then turned to the interpretation of s 334(2) of the LPUL. It considered whether the designated local regulatory authority's decision to appoint two people as manager of a law practice was valid under the relevant legislation. The court observed that the LPUL did not explicitly prohibit the appointment of multiple managers, and thus, the singular/plural drafting principle was applicable. The court concluded that the Legal Practice Board had the authority to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice simultaneously under s 334 of the LPUL.
The court further addressed the effect of the Legal Practice Board's decision to appoint two managers on the applicant's right to seek a review of that decision. The court held that the applicant's right to seek a review was not prejudiced by the appointment of two managers, as the validity of the appointment was a matter that could be determined in the course of the review proceedings. The court emphasised that the appointment of two managers did not deprive the applicant of the opportunity to challenge the decision on review.
Lastly, the court considered whether to grant a stay of proceedings in relation to the applicant's review application pending resolution of the issues concerning the validity of the appointment of two managers. The court noted that a stay of proceedings would be appropriate if the resolution of the validity issue would significantly affect the outcome of the review application. However, the court found that the validity of the appointment was not determinative of the outcome of the review application, as the applicant could still challenge the decision on other grounds. Therefore, the court decided not to grant a stay of proceedings.
In summary, the court in Gandini and Legal Practice Board (WA) held that the Legal Practice Board had the authority to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice simultaneously under s 334 of the LPUL. The court applied the singular/plural drafting principle in interpreting s 334(2) of the LPUL and found that the designated local regulatory authority's decision to appoint two managers was valid. The court also held that the applicant's right to seek a review was not prejudiced by the appointment of two managers, and declined to grant a stay of proceedings pending resolution of the issues concerning the validity of the appointment. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Legal Practice Board has the authority to appoint more than one person as manager of a law practice simultaneously under s 334 of the LPUL, and that the singular/plural drafting principle can be applied in the construction of s 334(2) of the LPUL.