Gandega and Fulmali and Anor

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GANDEGA & FULMALI AND ANOR [2019] FamCA 423
FAMILY LAW – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – Application to discharge Single Expert – Where allegation of bias on part of Single Expert – Where Single Expert report not yet received – Where discussion of applicable principles – Where application premature – Where application dismissed – Where order for any costs application be by way of written submission.
Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) rr. 15.54, 15.59, 15.65
Bass & Bass [2008] FamCAFC 67
Gandega & Fulmali [2018] FamCA 491
APPLICANT: Ms Gandega
FIRST RESPONDENT: Mr Fulmali
SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr Akbar
FILE NUMBER: PAC 4811 of 2016
DATE DELIVERED: 3 July 2019
PLACE DELIVERED: Parramatta
PLACE HEARD: Parramatta
JUDGMENT OF: Foster J
HEARING DATE: 1 February 2019 and 22 March 2019

REPRESENTATION

SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Marsden Law Group
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST RESPONDENT: Hall Partners
COUNSEL FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: Mr Othen
SOLICITOR FOR THE SECOND RESPONDENT: KPL Lawyers

Orders

  1. That the Second Respondent’s Application in a Case filed 12 November 2018 as amended seeking discharge of the Single Expert be dismissed.

  2. That any application for costs be by way of written submission filed and served within 28 days from this date with any submissions in response being filed and served within a further 14 days and upon completion of written submissions judgment will be reserved to chambers.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

IT IS NOTED that publication of this judgment by this Court under the pseudonym Gandega & Fulmali and Anor has been approved by the Chief Justice pursuant to s 121(9)(g) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

Note: This copy of the Court’s Reasons for Judgment may be subject to review to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.02A(b) of the Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.02 Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth).

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA AT PARRAMATTA

FILE NUMBER: PAC 4811 of 2016

Ms Gandega

Applicant

And

Mr Fulmali

First Respondent

And

Mr Akbar

Second Respondent

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

  1. In the context of ongoing property proceedings the present discrete application for determination is an application by the second respondent to the proceedings to discharge the appointed single expert valuer.

  2. On 9 November 2017 the Single Expert was appointed by reason of the following orders:

    (1)That pursuant to division 15.5.2 of the Family Law Rules 2004, Mr K is appointed to value the Respondent Husband’s interest as of 16 September 2016 in the following business entities:

    (1.1)B Pty Ltd, ACN: …; and

    (1.2)C Pty Ltd, ACN: ….

    (2)That within seven (7) days of the date of these orders, the Applicant shall provide the Respondents with a draft Joint Letter of Instruction.

    (3)That within seven (7) days of receiving the Joint Letter of Instruction, the Respondents shall respond with any required amendments to the Joint Letter of Instruction prepared by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gandega and Fulmali and Anor and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] FamCA 423
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved an application by the Second Respondent seeking the discharge of a single expert appointed in proceedings between the Applicant (wife) and the First Respondent (husband), and the Second Respondent. The dispute concerned the disposition of the husband's interests in several companies, namely B Pty Ltd, D Pty Ltd, and C Pty Ltd, following his incarceration in Asia. The wife sought to set aside these dispositions under s 106B of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth).

The central legal issue before the court was whether the Second Respondent had established sufficient grounds to warrant the discharge of the single expert. This required the court to consider the expert's mandate, the evidence presented by the parties regarding the companies' financial affairs and the husband's interests, and whether the expert's role remained necessary for the determination of the final issues. The court also had to consider the potential for the expert's report to resolve complex financial transactions and valuations relevant to the wife's claim.

Foster J dismissed the Second Respondent's application, finding that the grounds for discharge had not been met. The court reasoned that the single expert's role was crucial for resolving the complex financial disputes, including the valuation of the husband's interests in the companies and the accounting for various transactions. The court noted that the husband's absence and the convoluted nature of the company dealings necessitated expert intervention to provide an independent assessment. The court also considered that the wife's claims under s 106B could only be properly determined at a final hearing, and the expert's report was integral to that determination.

The court ordered that the Second Respondent's application for the discharge of the single expert be dismissed. The court also made orders regarding the submission of written arguments concerning costs, with judgment to be reserved thereafter.

Orders

Orders of the court

1.

That the Second Respondent’s Application in a Case filed 12 November 2018 as amended seeking discharge of the Single Expert be dismissed.

2.

That any application for costs be by way of written submission filed and served within 28 days from this date with any submissions in response being filed and served within a further 14 days and upon completion of written submissions judgment will be reserved to chambers.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry of the order in the Court’s records.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The somewhat convoluted background to these proceedings was set out in reasons for judgment delivered 29 June 2018 as to earlier interlocutory issues (Gandega & Fulmali [2018] FamCA 491) as follows:22. The husband is presently 52 years of age. 23.He asserts that he met the second respondent in about 2008 subsequent to which they began to work together.24.On 31 March 2010 the company B Pty Ltd (ACN…) (“[B Pty Ltd]”) was registered.25.The husband asserts that the company by special resolution on 13 September 2016 resolved that:a) the husband be entitled to wages up to 19 August 2016; b)that the husband be entitled to profits according to his then shareholding of 50% up to the end of “currently running projects;c)that any contingent liabilities will be deducted before profit distribution; and d)that all profits and remaining assets and net shareholding equity would be distributed to the shareholders after all accounts are prepared and finalised by L Pty Ltd.26.As at the date of the purported special resolution the husband was in Asia.27.The husband further asserts that cash funds in the company were removed by way of cash withdrawals and that as at August 2016 the assets of the company were in the order of $2.7 million. 28.The husband further asserts that on 5 October 2016 he was removed as a director of the company. He denies that at any time has he assigned or transferred his shareholding in the company and further denies that he has been paid any money in consideration for such shareholding.29.The wife seeks an order that the disposition of the husbands interest to the second respondent be set aside under s106B. It is common ground that such relief can only be properly determined at final hearing. 30.The husband says that as at December 2016 the company D Pty Ltd (“[D Pty Ltd]”) had a value of about $1.3 million. He says the company had purchased a parcel of land that he asserts has now been disposed of but he has no knowledge as to the whereabouts of any funds realised.31.The husband further says that he was a director and equal shareholder of the company C Pty Ltd (“[C Pty Ltd]”) which he says was “used for import and export”. The husbands says that that company owned a motor vehicle having a value of about $30,000 with the car later being sold. He is unaware as to where the proceeds of sale were paid.32.On 18 August 2016 the husband went to Asia and shortly thereafter he was arrested and charged with various offences.33.The husband otherwise relies upon the affidavit of his solicitor filed 8 October 2017. The solicitor deposes that as at the date of the affidavit being sworn the husband remained in custody in Asia.34.The solicitor refers to the husband’s Financial Statement filed 12 September 2017 in which the husband deposes that his assets comprise his interest in the former matrimonial home at Suburb M and his interest in the companies referred to above. 35.The solicitor asserts that the husband’s shareholding and interest in the companies were transferred to the second respondent pursuant to a power of attorney purportedly given by the husband. It appears that the intention of the second respondent, in circumstances where the husband was in custody in Asia in respect to certain criminal charges, was for the second respondent to facilitate the husband’s exit from the various companies and any associated entities as provided for in the “special resolution” of the company [B Pty Ltd] on 13 September 2016.36.The solicitor asserts that in breach of “arrangements” between the husband and the second respondent the second respondent terminated the retainer of the company’s accountants and has failed to account to the husband for profits and other monies received.37.The solicitor asserts income received by [B Pty Ltd] from various projects has been about $2.3 million, that [C Pty Ltd] has not accounted for the sale of the vehicle referred to and that [D Pty Ltd] has failed to account for sums totalling about $950,000 paid to it following the termination of a proposed contract for purchase of land.38.The solicitor asserts that the husband is in need of funds for his legal fees, to pursue his claims against the second respondent, to obtain valuations and to obtain expert forensic evidence. 39.On 19 September 2017 the solicitor wrote to the second respondent’s solicitors seeking an itemised statement in relation to their costs invoice dated 25 August 2017 for acting in relation to the proposed sale of the property at E Street, Suburb F by D Pty Ltd. No response has been received.The second respondent’s evidence40.The second respondent acknowledged his relationship with the husband and that they created and operated the three companies referred to above.41.The second respondent asserts that on 22 September 2016 his accountant, a Mr P, informed him that the husband had appointed him as his power of attorney pursuant to a General Power of Attorney signed by the husband in Asia on 21 September 2016. 42.The general power of attorney provides, inter alia, that Mr P as the husband’s attorney must keep reasonable accounts and records of the husband’s money and property, always act in the husband’s best interests and always act honestly in all matters concerning the husband’s legal and financial affairs. Whether Mr P has so acted in divesting the husband of his interest in B Pty Ltd will be a matter for determination in due course.43.The second respondent asserts that at the wife’s requested that he transferred to her various sums totalling $8,000 in late 2016. Otherwise he asserts that he has transferred various funds at the request of the husband totalling about $24,000 in late 2016.[B Pty Ltd]44.He says that the company [B Pty Ltd] had advanced to him and the husband various funds by way of director’s loans. He says that as at 30 June 2015 the company had advanced to the husband $576,778 and to him $210,000. Some of the funds advanced by the company to the husband were paid to the mortgage secured over the husband and wife’ matrimonial home. It must be inferred that the funds advanced to the husband and second respondent as directors were derived from cash resources available to the company by way of retained profits or otherwise.45.The second respondent complains that the circumstances of the company were adversely affected by the husband being charged with certain criminal offences and being incarcerated in Asia pending trial.46.The second respondent asserts that his accountant exercising the power of attorney given to him by the husband transferred to the second respondent the husband’s shares in the company on 5 October 2016 and the husband was then removed as a director. The business of [B Pty Ltd] was providing product installation and services. As at about the time the husband was divested of his interest in the company it had 38 full-time employees, over 29 subcontractors for regular clients and about 40 to 50 credit account facilities with suppliers. It appears that the company was of some substance and with significant turnover. Yet the second respondent asserts that by September 2017 he was the only person in the employ of the company with the company having no credit accounts with suppliers.47.In December 2016 the company changed accountants to G Pty Ltd.48.The second respondent asserts that in difficult circumstances he attempted to keep the company operating and advanced funds to the company from his own funds and from his business N Pty Ltd that has a trading relationship with B Pty Ltd.49.Otherwise it appears that the second respondent in 2016 caused the company W Pty Ltd to be incorporated. It is the husband’s contention that this company is simply a new entity conducting the business formerly operated by the husband and the second respondent as [B Pty Ltd]. A determination of this issue will await consideration by the appointed single expert. Otherwise Exhibit C is indicative of the second respondent representing to a third party his intention to assume the business of [B Pty Ltd] into a new organisation, [N Pty Ltd], having “the same staff/customers and suppliers as [B Pty Ltd]”.50.The second respondent’s actions, conduct and evidence must be considered with some circumspection. [D Pty Ltd]51.This company was incorporated by the husband and the second respondent in late 2000 for the purposes of acquiring a property at E Street, Suburb F (“the Suburb F property”) for the sum of $6 million. A deposit of $600,000 was paid and later released to the vendors.52.The second respondent asserts that the deposit funds comprised funds from the husband of $280,000, himself of $291,000 and funds drawn from [B Pty Ltd] of $31,000. 53.Subsequent to exchange of contracts the purchaser company paid stamp duty of $360,150. The second respondent asserts that funds for the stamp duty were provided by his self-managed super fund as to $115,400, from his own funds as to $25,510 and from [B Pty Ltd] in the sum of $219,246.10. Subsequently [B Pty Ltd] provided a further sum of $15,000 in relation to the purchase. The funds asserted to have been advanced by [B Pty Ltd] are at odds with that company’s balance sheet as at 30 June 2016.54.The second respondent asserts that an agreement was reached to extend settlement of the purchase by [D Pty Ltd] to 11 July 2016 in consideration of the payment of a sum of $102,000. The second respondent asserts that these funds were provided to firstly [B Pty Ltd] by him and were then on lent to [D Pty Ltd] by the company. Settlement was not able to be completed by 11 July 2016 and a further agreement for an extension to 24 February 2017 was negotiated in consideration of the payment of $203,000. The second respondent asserts that these funds were advanced to [D Pty Ltd] by [B Pty Ltd].55.Otherwise the second respondent asserts that he has provided various sums to [D Pty Ltd] for outgoings and other expenses totalling about $91,000 in the period from December 2015 to June 2017.56.In January 2017 [D Pty Ltd] and the vendors of the Suburb F property agreed to rescind the contract for purchase with the deposit paid of $600,000 to be returned to [D Pty Ltd] following the sale of the subject property by the vendor to a new purchaser. The new purchaser entered into an agreement with [D Pty Ltd] to pay to [D Pty Ltd] $344,510 on settlement of its purchase of the property. Stamp duty as referred to above of $360,510 was refunded to [D Pty Ltd]. In all [D Pty Ltd] received funds totalling $1,305,020.57.The second respondent controls this company presumably in the absence of the husband. In such circumstance, orders can be made against the second respondent to cause the company to do such things as are required.58.Illustrative of the second respondent’s control the second respondent says that the funds variously received by [D Pty Ltd] were disbursed by him as follows:a)$138,480 in repayment of the sum advanced by his self-managed super fund including interest;b) $11,000 in payment of accounting fees for the company;c)$354,200 in repayment to [B Pty Ltd] relating to funds advanced by it to [D Pty Ltd]; and d)$92,154.20 in repayment to the second respondent of monies he asserts were paid by him on behalf of [D Pty Ltd];these payments totalling $595,834.20.59. Other payments have been made from the [D Pty Ltd] funds as follows:a) $15,620 to H Pty Ltd pursuant to orders made 5 May 2017; andb)$127,790 to O Real Estate as commission in respect of the transaction.60.The second respondent asserts that there are outstanding legal fees payable to his solicitors in the sum of $40,754 for legal fees relating to the [D Pty Ltd] transactions. The husband disputes the quantum of this amount and has sought an itemised invoice which as yet has not been provided. There is only a lump sum bill from the solicitors without particularisation.61.Subject to the issue of the solicitor’s outstanding costs, and if they are ultimately paid in the sum sought, an amount of about $520,475 would remain in the controlled monies account.62.No tax returns or financial statements for [D Pty Ltd] for the year ended 30 June 2016 and 2017 were in evidence before the court. It is to be expected that those accounts when prepared will accurately reflect the various transactions asserted by the second respondent. The various transactions will also be the subject of consideration by the agreed single expert valuer in ascertaining the interest of the husband in [D Pty Ltd] by way of loan account or otherwise. [C Pty Ltd] 63.The second respondent asserts that this company owned a motor vehicle used by [B Pty Ltd]. That vehicle, was the subject of a finance obligation. The second respondent asserts that he and the husband’s attorney agreed to sell the vehicle with the whole of the funds being applied to discharge the financed debt. 64.Otherwise the second respondent complains that he has incurred legal fees in and about the conduct of the family law proceedings between the husband and wife.65.The second respondent further asserts that in order to keep [B Pty Ltd] operating he has advanced from his own funds or his companies about $760,000 to [B Pty Ltd]. Of these funds $275,401 have been paid to the Australian Taxation Office for taxation liabilities arising since 1 March 2017 by way of company tax, outstanding GST and penalties for failure to lodge returns and general interest charges all accruing since the company has been operated solely by the second respondent. There has been no accounting for income otherwise generated by the company over the same period or for monies the second respondent asserts has been repaid to the company by [D Pty Ltd]. 66.No taxation returns or financial statements for [B Pty Ltd] are in evidence before the court for the financial years ended June 2016 and June 2017 where the trading revenue of the company for the financial year to June 2017 was $2.859m (Exh B) and an analysis of the company’s general ledger raises more issues than it solves as to the second respondent’s application and use of company funds. Such concerns can, as was submitted by the wife, be the subject of questions to the single expert when the report is to hand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.