Gallieni and Gallieni and Ors

Link copied
Case Copied 71 min read

FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

GALLIENI & GALLIENI AND ORS [2011] FamCA 791
FAMILY LAW – PROPERTY – Superannuation – add-backs – contributions – constructive or resulting trust – winding up of company – difficulty quantifying asset pool – accrued jurisdiction
Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) s 92, 92(3),
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 79(3), 232, 233, 233(1)(a), 472 and 1337C(1)
Re Coomber v Coomber [1911] 1CH 723
Warby v Warby (2002) FLC 93-091
ASIC v Edensor Nominees Pty Ltd (2001) 204 CLR 559
Bergman v Bergman (2009) FLC 93-395
Puddy v Grossvard and Anor (2010) FLC 93-432
Re Dalkeith Investments Pty Ltd (1984) 9 ALCR 247
Wallington v Kokotovich Constructions Pty Ltd (1993) 11 ACSR 759
Dalby v Bodily [2004] All (D) ER 43
Re Westbourne Gallenes Ltd [1973] AC 360
Re Tivoli Freeholds Ltd [1972] VR 445
Re Posgate and Denby(Agencies) Ltd (1986) 2BCC 99,352
Martin v Australian Squash Club Pty Ltd (1996) 14 ACLC 452
Hickey and Hickey and A-G for the Commonwealth of Australia (Intervener) (2003) FLC 93-143
Aleksovski v Aleksovski (1996) FLC 92-705
AB v ZB (2003) FLC 93-140
In the marriage of Jordan, RK and Jordan, R (1997) FLC 92-736
APPLICANT: Mr Gallieni
RESPONDENT: Ms Gallieni
FIRST & SECOND INTERVENERS: Mr D and Ms D
THIRD & FOURTH INTERVENERS Mr H and Ms H
FILE NUMBER: MLC 7541 of 2008
DATE DELIVERED: 5 October 2011
PLACE DELIVERED: Cairns
PLACE HEARD: Melbourne
JUDGMENT OF: Benjamin J
HEARING DATE: 28 February, 1, 2, 3,  7, 8, 11, 16 & 17 March & 5 May 2011, 5 & 13 October 2011

REPRESENTATION

COUNSEL FOR THE APPLICANT: Mr Kenworthy up to part way through 11 March 2011 after which the applicant represented himself
SOLICITOR FOR THE APPLICANT: Kenworthy Lawyers up to part way through 11 March 2011 from which time the applicant was self represented but had the assistance of Mr Kenworthy
COUNSEL FOR THE RESPONDENT: Mr O'Shannessy
SOLICITOR FOR THE RESPONDENT: Slater & Gordon
COUNSEL FOR THE FIRST AND
SECOND INTERVENERS:
Ms Smallwood
SOLICITOR FOR THE FIRST AND SECOND INTERVENERS: Mallesons Stephen Jacques
COUNSEL FOR THE THIRD AND FOURTH INTERVENERS In person

Orders

1.K Pty Ltd (“the Company”) be wound up pursuant to s 233(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”), or alternatively, pursuant to s 461(1) of the Corporations Act.

2.Mr L, of Company F is appointed liquidator of the Company, subject to these orders and the conditions of appointment (set out in the liquidator’s consent dated 16 March 2011). 

3.Mr D and Ms D (the First and Second Interveners), are not required to publish a notice in accordance with Rule 5.6 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth).

4.The purported issue of:-

·    20 shares in the Company to the husband,

·    two shares in the Company to the wife, and

·    four shares in the Company to Mr H and Ms H,

effected on or about 18 March 1997 are declared void and are set aside. Consequently…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gallieni and Gallieni and Ors and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] FamCA 791
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The proceeding involved an application for the winding up of K Pty Ltd. The primary parties were the applicant seeking the winding up, and the respondents, including Mr. and Mrs. Gallieni (referred to as the husband and wife), and Mr. and Ms. D and Mr. and Ms. H (referred to as the interveners). The dispute concerned the proper shareholding and directorship of the company, as well as the improper receipt of company funds by the husband.

The court was required to determine whether the company should be wound up, the correct shareholding and directorship of the company, the extent of the company's indebtedness to the third and fourth interveners, and the amounts improperly received by the husband and wife from the company. Additionally, the court needed to make orders regarding the discharge of mortgages, the distribution of assets upon liquidation, and the allocation of costs.

Benjamin J ordered the winding up of K Pty Ltd and appointed a liquidator. The court declared void the purported issue of shares to the husband, wife, and Mr. and Ms. H, and the appointment of Mr. and Ms. H as directors. The court clarified the shareholding of the company, with Mr. D and Ms. D each holding one share, and the husband and wife each holding two shares. The court also declared that the company owed Mr. and Ms. H $28,000 for a loan. Crucially, the court ordered the husband and wife to repay significant sums to the company, representing monies improperly received, with specific provisions for set-off against any distributions. The court further directed the liquidator to investigate other potential misappropriations and to rectify the company's registers and accounts. The orders also addressed the discharge of mortgages, the distribution of assets upon liquidation, and the allocation of liquidation costs, including indemnities between the parties. Separate superannuation orders were made by agreement, directing the trustee of the MLC Masterkey Superannuation Fund to pay a specified amount to Ms. Gallieni from Mr. Gallieni's interest in the fund.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. K Pty Ltd (“the Company”) be wound up pursuant to s 233(1)(a) of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”), or alternatively, pursuant to s 461(1) of the Corporations Act.

2. Mr L, of Company F is appointed liquidator of the Company, subject to these orders and the conditions of appointment (set out in the liquidator’s consent dated 16 March 2011).

3. Mr D and Ms D (the First and Second Interveners), are not required to publish a notice in accordance with Rule 5.6 of the Federal Court (Corporations) Rules 2000 (Cth).

4. The purported issue of:-

· 20 shares in the Company to the husband,

· two shares in the Company to the wife, and

· four shares in the Company to Mr H and Ms H,

effected on or about 18 March 1997 are declared void and are set aside. Consequently the liquidator shall do all acts, sign all documents such that the Register kept by the Company is corrected and such share issues are removed pursuant to s 175 of the Corporations Act.

5. The appointment of Mr H and Ms H (the Third and Fourth Interveners) as directors of the Company on or about 18 March 1997 is declared void and is consequently set aside. Consequently the liquidator shall do all acts, sign all documents such that register kept by the Company is corrected pursuant to s 175 of the Corporations Act.

6. It is declared that the shareholding of the Company is as follows:-

(a) the husband holds two of the six issued shares in the Company;

(b) the wife holds two of the six issued shares in the Company

(c) Mr D (the First Intervener) holds one of the six issued shares in the Company; and

(d) Ms D (the Second Intervener) holds one of the six issued shares in the Company.

Consequently the liquidator shall do all acts, sign all documents such that the Register kept by the Company is corrected and such shareholding is shown on the said Register.

7. The parties and liquidator do all things necessary to have the mortgage, registered in favour of St George Bank (being the mortgage securing advances to the Company) over the property at O Street, Suburb T, discharged. The parties do all things necessary to have the mortgage, registered in favour of St George Bank (being the mortgage securing advances to the Company) over the property at S Street, Suburb E be discharged.

8. Subject to these orders (including order 10), the parties to these proceedings, in their personal capacities or as a director of any corporate entity, are restrained from submitting any proof of debt in the winding up of the Company.

9. It is declared that the Company owes Mr and Ms H, (the Third and Fourth Interveners), a sum of $28,000 (together with interest unpaid, if any, since June 2010) in respect of the loan entered into between the Company and the Third and Fourth Interveners on or about 26 March 1997.

10. In respect of such of the payments referred to below:-

Such payments as were made on or before 30 June 2008, the husband and wife pay to the Company (or have set off against any proposed distribution of income and/or capital to them) such sums; and

Such payments as were made after 30 June 2008, the husband pay to the Company (or have set off against any proposed distribution of income and/or capital to him) such sums;

These being monies of the Company improperly had and received by the husband, or entities controlled by the husband including:-

(a) $114,111.80 in respect of the husband’s legal costs of this proceeding;

(b) $208,276.34 in respect of Citibank loan repayments made by C Pty Ltd from 30 June 1991 to 30 June 2008 (excluding interest on that loan from 1991 to 31 March 1997);

(c) $57,501.30 in respect of the tax liability of C Pty Ltd paid by the Company on 26/08/09; and

(d) $63,834.20 in respect of other payments made to bank accounts controlled by the husband.

Such other money as is determined by the liquidator in accordance with these orders (subject to the overriding supervision of the Court).

Such payments to be made by the husband or the husband and wife (as the case may be) within three (3) months from the date of this order. If such payment/s are not made then the liquidator shall deduct any such amount/s (together with interest calculated as and from three (3) months from the date of this order and at a rate in accordance with the Rules of this Court) from the amount to be otherwise distributed to the husband and/or the wife. The return of such money and any and interest shall be assets and/or income of the Company.

11. If necessary, the liquidator is directed to undertake an investigation into, and take an account of, monies (other than the monies specifically referred to at orders 9 and 10 above) received by the husband or related entities of the husband from the Company, and to report to the shareholders in relation to his findings in that regard prior to any distribution being made to members of the Company.

12. The liquidator shall bring to the accounts of the Company money taken from it by the husband (and/or his related entities) so as to rectify the books and records of the Company having regard to these orders and the findings of fact contained in the reasons for the orders.

13. The liquidator shall inform the Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) within twenty eight (28) days of the date of this order of the amendment to the Company Register as to shareholders and directors made pursuant to these orders.

14. The liquidator has leave to apply to the Court for directions pursuant to s 79(3) of the Corporations Act.

15. As to the costs of the liquidator:-

(a) one-third of the costs of the liquidation will be paid out of the assets of the company,

(b) two-thirds of the costs of liquidation are to be set off against the amount otherwise payable on liquidation to the husband and the wife (in equal shares).

(c) if there is insufficient capital due to the husband and wife on liquidation, such shortfall shall be paid out of the capital due to Mr D and Ms D (the First and Second Interveners). They are in turn are indemnified, as to half each by the husband and the wife.

(d) if the capital due to the husband is insufficient to meet the whole or part of his share of the two-thirds cost of liquidation then the shortfall shall be paid out of the capital to be otherwise paid to the wife, who in turn is indemnified by the husband in respect of such sum.

(e) the liquidator shall be entitled to draw against the assets and income of the company to pay his fees as and when they fall due.

16. At or about the time of completion of the liquidation, the liquidator shall:-

(a) determine and inform the shareholders of the Company as to the amount payable to each of them in accordance with these orders for liquidation of the company.

(b) pay to Mr D and Ms D (the First and Second Interveners) their respective entitlements.

(c) in respect of the husband and the wife, pay from each of their respective entitlements one half of the wife’s tax liability of $36,202 and one half of the Citibank liability of about $69,000 (secured over Mr and Ms H’s home).

(d) calculate the amount due to each of the husband and wife having regard to:-

i) the net entitlement of each of the husband and wife on the liquidation of the Company;

ii) a division of non superannuation matrimonial property of the husband and wife as to 65 per cent to the wife and 35 per cent to the husband;

iii) the wife retaining S Street, Suburb E at a value of $750,000 (less the amount due to the St George Bank – being the housing loan of about $114,475) and her motor vehicle at a value of $500.

iv) the husband retaining his motor vehicle with a value of $8,000, his household contents of $1,500 and the legal fees he paid for his parents of $50,089;

(e) after giving at least twenty eight (28) days notice pay to the husband and wife their respective entitlements, subject to any further deductions that many arise in any costs determinations in these proceedings.

17. The husband and wife shall otherwise retain the property in his or her possession or control.

18. IT IS DECLARED that the asset of the $50,089 being legal fees paid by the husband on behalf of Mr and Ms H, (the Third and Fourth Interveners) is an asset of the husband.

19. The husband and wife shall indemnify Mr and Ms H (the Third and Fourth Interveners) in respect of the amounts outstanding to Citibank secured by a mortgage over the home of Mr and Ms H. Such indemnity shall expire when that loan is paid out by the liquidator in accordance with these orders.

20. With regard to Mortgage Number … secured over property S Street, Suburb E (Certificate of Title Volume … Folio …), Mr and Ms H (Third and Fourth Interveners) shall within seven (7) days of the date of this order do all acts and sign all documents to provide discharge of that mortgage; and if they fail to provide the discharge of the said mortgage a Registrar of this Court shall execute such discharge of mortgage pursuant to s106A of the Family Law Act.

21. Within sixty (60) days of the date of this order:-

(a) the husband will do all acts and sign all documents to transfer his interest in property at S Street, Suburb E to the wife.

(b) at the time of transfer, the wife will do all acts and sign all documents necessary to either discharge or release the husband in respect of the mortgage to the St George Bank secured against the subject property and the wife shall indemnity the husband in respect of the housing loan mortgage (but not the mortgage being the collateral security in respect of the Company) and other liabilities against the said property including council rates, water rates and land taxes, but excluding the alleged liability to Mr and Ms H (the Third and Fourth Interveners).

22. The husband, wife, Mr D and Ms D (the First and Second Interveners) have liberty to apply in terms of the liquidation of the Company and the implementation of these orders. Such leave shall continue for the period of the liquidation, two (2) years from the date of this order or such other period as is determined by this Court.

23. The respective applications for costs between the parties are listed for hearing at 10.00am on 2 April 2012 (or such other date as is directed by the court and the parties are given leave to apply in respect of the allocation of this date upon the giving of seven (7) days notice to the court and to the other parties) and the Court makes the following directions in that regard:-

(a) that two (2) working days prior to that day each party who wishes to make submissions on costs file and serve a written outline of those submissions, including on what basis the costs are being sought whether pursuant to the accrued jurisdiction; party/party; practitioner client; indemnity together with the precise order that such party or parties seek in terms of costs;

(b) any further evidence the parties seek to rely upon in respect of the costs application is to be filed and served at least fourteen (14) days prior to the hearing of the costs applications.

(c) Leave be given for the husband to attend the hearing by telephone from Western Australia provided he notifies the other parties and the Court at least seven (7) days in advance.

SUPERANNUATION ORDERS MADE BY AGREEMENT

24. These superannuation orders are binding on the Trustee of the MLC Masterkey Superannuation Fund (“the Trustee”), it being noted that the Trustee has been afforded procedural fairness in relation to the making of these orders.

25. These superannuation orders relate to the interest of the husband Mr … Gallieni also known as or previously known as … (“Mr Gallieni”) in relation to his account number …07 in the MLC Masterkey Superannuation Fund.

26. The flagging order made by the Court on 21 May 2009 in relation to the interest of Mr Gallieni is lifted as and from the operative date.

27. The base amount to be allocated to the wife, Ms Gallieni, out of the interest of Mr Gallieni in the MLC Masterkey Superannuation Fund (“the Fund”) is $78,082.

28. Pursuant to s 90MT(1)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) whenever the Trustee of the Fund makes a splittable payment from the interest held by Mr Gallieni in the Fund the Trustee shall pay to Ms Gallieni an amount which is calculated in accordance with Part 6 of the Family Law (Superannuation) Regulations 2001 (Cth) using the base amount in paragraph 28 hereof and that there be a corresponding reduction in the entitlement that Mr Gallieni would have had but for these orders.

29. These superannuation orders have effect from the operative date.

30. The operative date for the purpose of these superannuation orders is twenty one (21) days after the date of these orders.

31. The wife shall cause a sealed copy of these orders to be served, by ordinary prepaid post upon the Trustees of the fund, within fourteen (14) days.

32. These proceeding are removed from the list of matters requiring determination.

NOTATION and DIRECTION

33. The methodology contained in the spreadsheets in Exhibit B in these proceedings (including assumptions [2] and [3] set out therein) accurately reflect these orders and the liquidator is DIRECTED to apply that methodology in winding up the company and in making distributions to the parties.

34. All subpoenaed documents be returned to the persons or institutions from which they emanated and all exhibits are returned to the person or persons who tendered the same, such return to occur twenty eight (28) days after the determination of any costs application or within twenty eight (28) days after

2 April 2012 whichever is the later.

35. All outstanding applications (except as to costs) are dismissed and removed from the list of cases requiring determination.

36. The application by the husband and the third and fourth interveners for leave to make an oral application for stay is dismissed, noting that this does not constitute a dismissal of a stay application.

37. A transcript of the proceedings on 13 October 2011 be taken out and placed on the court file.

IT IS CERTIFIED

38. Pursuant to Rule 19.50 of the Family Law Rules 2004 (Cth) it was reasonable to engage counsel to attend.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.