Gallagher, W.G. v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 60 min read

/ / m //-€a

Y

Ju'Lul -3cpAENT No. ...!ito. !.!L&

CATCEWORDS

ADMINISTRATIVE LAW - Appeal from decision of AAT not to award compensation - whether there was a fallure to take evidence lnto account

- whether disease or injury - meaning of "aggravation" - meanlng of
"incapacity for work" - whether age a relevant factor - whether issues

raised of fact or of law.

Compensation (Conrmonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 - ss 5, 26, 27

and 29.

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 - S 44(1).

WILLIAM GEORGE G W A G H E R Appellant
- v -
COMMONWE?iLTB OF AUSTRALIA Respondent
PLACE :  Sydney
C O W  : Einfeld J
DATE :  31 July 1989
IN TEE E'EDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA 1
1
NEW SOUTH WALES REGISTRY 1
1
GENERAL DIVISION
1 NO. G 342 of 1988

WILLIAM GEORGE GALLAGEER

Appellant

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

CORAM: Einfeld J
DATE: 31 July 1989

PLACE: Sydney

MINUTE OF ORDERS

1.       The appeal is upheld.

  1. The case is referred back to the Tribunal to be considered according to law.

  2. The respondent to pay the appellant's costs.

NOTE:  Settlement and entry of orders are dealt with in accordance with
order 36 of the Federal Court Rules.
I S

'*.

". '

IN TEE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

1

NEW SOUTH W A L E S REGISTRY )
)
GENERAL DIVISION 1 No. G 342 of 1988

WIUIAM GEORGE G W A G E E R

Appellant

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

CORAM: Einfeld J
DATE: 31 July 1989

PLACE: Sydney

REASONS M R m

This is an appeal from a decision of the General Administrative Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal) constituted by Mr B.J. MacMahon Senior Member given on 8 February 1988 in which the Tribunal held that the Department of Defence was not liable to pay

~om~ensation,;~ to the appellant. Mr Wllliam Gallagher, under the Compensation (Cornonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971 (the Act).

The appellant seeks orders that the determination be set aside. In the notice of appeal he asks that a decision be substituted that he is entitled to compensation as if he were totally incapacitated, but at the hearing his counsel advocated that the matter should be remitted to the Tribunal to consider the matter further.

TEE FACTS

The appellant, who was born in 1930, was employed at the Garden Island Navy Base for two relevant pcriods - 17 July 1985 to 20 August 1985 (the first period) and 18 June 1986 to 25 June 1986 (the second period).

The Tribunal found the following facts as to the first period of employment when the appellant was a cleaner:

He comnenced work on 17 July 1985 in an enclosed machlne shop Here various metals inc1cd:dlng almniun, copper and iron and other substances, lncludlng fibreglass, were ground by mchines in conditions that dld not include the best use of the ventilation systems available After about 5 weeks, he noticed an irritation in hls throat, running eyes and congestion in his…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gallagher, W.G. v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1989] FCA 401
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in this case was brought by William George Gallagher against the Commonwealth of Australia, contesting a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT). The AAT had ruled that the Commonwealth was not liable to pay compensation to Gallagher under the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971. The appeal was heard by Einfeld J in the Federal Court of Australia. The key issues in this case revolved around the interpretation of the Act and the AAT's findings on questions of injury, incapacity, and aggravation. Gallagher argued that the AAT failed to consider whether his incapacity was a continuation of an injury sustained in the first period of employment, rather than an injury from the second period. The court found that the AAT erred in law by not considering this possibility, leading to an improper resolution of the incapacity issue. The appeal was upheld, and the case was referred back to the AAT for reconsideration according to law, with the Commonwealth ordered to pay Gallagher's costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

William George Gallagher, born in 1930, was employed at the Garden Island Navy Base for two periods in 1985 and 1986. During the first period, he worked as a cleaner in a machine shop where he was exposed to various metals and other substances. After about five weeks, he noticed throat irritation, running eyes, and nasal congestion. His general practitioner certified him as suffering from an airborne upper respiratory allergy triggered by workplace exposure. The Department of Defence found him liable to pay compensation. During the second period, he was employed in a light duties capacity as a clerk in an air-conditioned building but left due to discomfort from an open window and nearby grit blasting operation dust. He complained of a return of throat irritation and left the job after five days. Gallagher claimed that his exposure to airborne particles during his employment caused a reaction in the nature of an allergy, which aggravated his condition upon re-exposure, rendering him unable to work or find suitable work since.

This case is an appeal from a decision of the General Administrative Division of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) made on 8 February 1988, which held that the Department of Defence was not liable to pay compensation to Gallagher under the Compensation (Commonwealth Government Employees) Act 1971. Gallagher sought orders to set aside the determination, and at the hearing, his counsel advocated that the matter should be remitted to the AAT to consider further. The appeal was heard in the Federal Court of Australia, with Justice Einfeld presiding.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Tribunal erred in finding that the appellant did not suffer an injury arising out of or in the course of his employment with the Department of Defence.
2. Whether the Tribunal erred in finding that the appellant was not suffering an incapacity within the meaning of the Act.
3. Whether there was no evidence to support the finding that the appellant did not suffer any injury within the meaning of the Act.
4. Whether there was no evidence to support the finding that the appellant was not suffering from any incapacity within the meaning of the Act.
5. Whether the Tribunal misdirected itself as to the meaning of the word "injury" in the Act.
6. Whether the Tribunal misdirected itself as to the meaning of the word "incapacity" as used in the Act.
7. Whether the Tribunal misdirected itself as to the meaning of the words "all reasonable steps to obtain" within the meaning of section 26(2) of the Act.

Held
1. The appeal was upheld. The case was referred back to the Tribunal to be considered according to law.
2. The Tribunal erred in failing to determine whether the appellant's claimed inability to work after the second period of employment might have been due to the injury sustained in the course of his employment in July-August 1985.
3. The Tribunal was also in error for not considering whether the appellant subsequently suffered total or partial incapacity for work involving exposure to particular or various sensitising or irritating agents as a result of the injury, and for not taking into account the appellant's age and personal characteristics in doing so.
4. The respondent was ordered to pay the appellant's costs.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Federal Court found that the Tribunal had erred in law by failing to consider whether the appellant's claimed inability to work after the second period of employment might have been due to the injury sustained in the course of his employment in July-August 1985. The Court held that if the Tribunal had found such a causal connection, it would then be bound to consider whether the appellant subsequently suffered total or partial incapacity for work involving exposure to particular or various sensitising or irritating agents as a result of that injury, and to take into account the appellant's age and personal characteristics in doing so. The error of the Tribunal in this respect was held to be a question of law, as it involved the Tribunal's failure to consider evidence and resolve the issue thereby raised. The Court also noted that the concept of "reasonableness" in determining whether all reasonable steps were taken to obtain suitable employment required a consideration of the appellant's personal attributes and characteristics, including age and the likely types of work that might have been open to him. The appeal was upheld, and the case was referred back to the Tribunal to consider these matters according to law.