Galicia and Comcare (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read

Galicia and Comcare (Compensation) [2017] AATA 2380 (24 November 2017)

Administrative Appeals Tribunal

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL               )
  )         No: 2016/3211
GENERAL DIVISION  )

Re: Elsa Galicia
Applicant

And: Comcare
Respondent

CORRIGENDUM

TRIBUNAL:    Ms Anna Burke, Member

DATE:            12 December 2017

PLACE:          Melbourne

The Tribunal directs the Registrar, pursuant to subsection 43AA(1) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975, to alter the text of the decision as follows:

  1. The date in paragraph 5 is amended from 20 April 2016 to 2 May 2016;
  1. Paragraph 74 be amended to read as follows:

“[74] Based on the evidence before it the Tribunal affirms the decision under review dated 21 April 2016 and 2 May 2016”

  1. All references to Medibank be replaced with Comcare.

[sgd]...................................................................

Member

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2016/3212, 2016/3213

Re:Elsa Galicia

APPLICANT

AndComcare

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms Anna Burke, Member

Date:24 November 2017

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decisions under review.

[sgd]........................................................................

Ms Anna Burke, Member

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – Medibank Private employee – left shoulder injury - claim for compensation under the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 - whether ongoing incapacity or entitlement to medical expenses – condition no longer attributing to current pain – no ongoing entitlement to compensation for incapacity payments - decisions affirmed

Legislation

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1998

Cases

Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 90 ALD 263.
Canute v Comcare (2006) HCA 47
Kennedy cleaning service Pty Ltd v Petkoska (2000) 200 CLR 286
Darling Island Stevedoring & Lighterage Co Ltd v Hankinson (1967) 117 CLR 19

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms Anna Burke, Member

24 November 2017

INTRODUCTION

  1. Ms Galicia commenced employment with Medibank Private Limited in March 1987 and worked there for 28 years until she was made redundant in July 2014. On 21 August 2012 Ms Galicia submitted an incident report noting that on 29 June 2012 at 12:30pm she had a pain on the left side of the shoulder and that she had sought medical advice on 31 July 2012 where the doctor prescribed anti-inflammatory medicines, advised to rest and to see a physiotherapist/chiropractor. On 26 August 2012 Ms Galicia submitted a claim for compensation under the Safety Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (the SRC Act). In the claim she noted the diagnosed condition of left shoulder trapezius strain, claiming that the injury was a result of sitting all day processing and that the actual injury was a result of the computer keyboard.

  2. On 20 September 2012 an initial workplace assessment was undertaken for Ms Galicia to develop and manage a return to work plan to safe, sustainable and suitable duties. At this time an ergonomic assessment was also performed which recommended numerous adjustments be made to her workstation and posture.

  3. On 6 November 2012 Comcare accepted liability under section 14 of the SRC Act in respect of sprain and strains (left rhomboid muscle only) as it was satisfied that Ms Galicia had suffered from an ailment as defined in the Act which had been significantly…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Galicia and Comcare (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] AATA 2380
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Ms Galicia against a decision by Comcare to cease her compensation payments. Ms Galicia had been employed by Medibank Private for 28 years, primarily in a customer service role involving extensive computer use, repetitive typing, and prolonged sitting. She had a history of intermittent lower back and neck pain, and in 2012, began experiencing significant pain in her left shoulder. This appeal was heard by Ms Anna Burke, Member, of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Ms Galicia's ongoing pain and incapacity for work were a result of a compensable injury sustained during her employment, and whether her employer's liability for her condition had been correctly assessed and managed. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if the cessation of compensation payments by Comcare was justified, given Ms Galicia's persistent symptoms and her belief that further medical treatment was necessary. The Tribunal also considered the respondent's contention that Ms Galicia's pain was due to age-related degeneration rather than a work-related injury.

The Tribunal considered extensive medical evidence from various practitioners, including Ms Galicia's general practitioner, orthopaedic surgeons, and a physiotherapist. While some medical opinions suggested Ms Galicia's shoulder pain was not work-related or was due to age-related degeneration, the Tribunal found that the balance of medical evidence indicated she was suffering from pain in her left shoulder and that the initial acceptance of liability for a compensable injury was correct. The Tribunal noted that Comcare had not followed its own clinical framework for assessing reasonable medical treatment, which prioritises empowering the injured person towards independence. The Tribunal ultimately affirmed Comcare's decision of 31 March 2016, finding that Ms Galicia no longer suffered from the effects of the accepted injury and was therefore not entitled to further compensation under sections 16 and 19 of the SRC Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

The application was heard over 11, 12 and 13 September 2017. At the hearing Ms Galicia was represented by Mr Scott Davison of counsel, instructed by Patrick Robinson & Co. Lawyers. Comcare was represented by Mr Roy Seit of counsel, instructed by Sparke Helmore Lawyers. The Tribunal was provided with the documentation under s 37 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (T‑Documents, Exhibit R1). The Applicant lodged several medical reports and a substantial list of authorities. Ms Galicia, Dr Arthur Papagelis, general practitioner, Mr Ben Jaffe, physiotherapist, Mr Kenneth Myers, consultant general surgeon, Mr Anthony Bonomo, orthopaedic surgeon, Mr Trung Nguyen, orthopaedic surgeon, Dr Tony Kostos, consultant rheumatologist and Dr Dale Curtis, orthopaedic surgeon, gave evidence before the Tribunal.BACKGROUND Ms Galicia came to Australia as a small child from Uruguay. After completing her secondary schooling she commenced work at the antecedent to Medibank Private and worked there for 28 years until she was made redundant in 2014. Ms Galicia commenced work in the mailroom and then predominantly worked in claim processing. At the time of her injury she was an ongoing full-time customer service operator processing hospital claims at the Docklands site. Ms Galicia is married and has three children. Ms Galicia’s responsibilities included the following duties: processing claims via data entry audit and assess claims, checking emails, taking/making phone calls to hospital providers, reading contracts and attending meetings. Her role was described as predominantly computer-based, it making up 95% of her duties. The remaining 5% entailed rest breaks, attending meetings and collecting batches of claims. Her relevant job demands were described as prolonged sitting over an eight hour period five days per week, repetitive but intermediate typing and mousing over eight hours, occasional lifting of heavy batches of claim forms, rare use of the telephone, rare frequency of reading contracts and constant referencing of claim paperwork requiring repetitive neck flexion and rotation. Ms Galicia was required to meet specific allocated time targets for processing claims and on average most claims took 1 minute to 30 minutes to complete. Ms Galicia is right hand dominant. From September 2009 until June 2012 Ms Galicia’s medical history indicates a history of intermittent lower back pain radiating to the left leg and ending at the back of the calf, and neck pain radiating to the left wrist. A functional x-ray and MRI scan at this time indicated the cervical and lumbar spine were all normal. A nerve conductor study of the left upper limb was also conducted which again found no abnormality and there was no evidence of left carpal tunnel syndrome. On 31 July 2012 Ms Galicia consulted Dr Papagelis, general practitioner, in respect of her sore left shoulder which she advised had been sore over the past four weeks. Dr Papagelis recorded in his medical notes that the left shoulder ache was over the rhomboids and trapezius area. He had hoped for a rapid recovery on his diagnoses of a soft tissue bruise/strain, musculoligamentous type injury but it was not to be. Dr Papagelis referred Ms Galicia to Mr Bernard Lynch, but she was not happy with him and so she sought a second referral to Mr Eden Raleigh. Ms Galicia then requested a third referral to Mr Trung Nguyen and was then referred to Mr Clayton Thomas, pain specialist. In 2016 Ms Galicia insisted on seeing another orthopaedic surgeon, Mr Anthony Bonomo.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Ms Galicia advised the Tribunal that she believed surgery was her only option to resolve the ongoing pain in her left shoulder. She stated that she was aware that there was no guarantee that this surgery would be successful but she believed she now had an additional issue of a SLAP tear which needed to be addressed. Ms Galicia was of the belief surgery was her only hope, regardless of the fact she had had numerous cortisone injections and two surgical procedures which to date had not resolved her issue. Indeed, there was some contention that previous surgery had made her condition worse.Medical EvidenceDr Arthur Papagelis, General practitioner Dr Papagelis provided a report to the Tribunal and gave oral evidence at the hearing. In his report of 14 March 2017 he stated:To date we can report that Elsa has had a difficult time over the last four years since she first reported her left shoulder condition. Her management had input from multiple surgeons and required several procedures. She has had a rocky course over this same time and appears to be in not (sic) better condition than at the start him mostly self-initiated surgical interventions. I can say that in my opinion her surgeries in a clear way contributed to a worsening of the left shoulder pain. In summary Elsa currently suffers with chronic pain syndrome, chronic pain, left shoulder movement restriction at extreme range, poor coping with pain and stress, anxiety with depressive ideation and insomnia. Dr Papagelis advised the Tribunal that he had been Ms Galicia’s general practitioner since 2002. He understood her duties to be predominantly data entry which required extensive periods of sitting and as far as he was concerned her injury was work related. However, he was surprised to discover that she did not utilise her left hand in the performance of her duties and at no stage did he believe her problem was associated with the cervical spine. His original diagnosis was pain between the spine and left scapula and this had resulted in ongoing discomfort to her left shoulder. Dr Papagelis further advised Ms Galicia not to have any more surgery, as she had previously undergone a lot of surgery which had not assisted her pain. Indeed, he was of the opinion surgery had not helped but had made her condition worse. He did not think any more would be of benefit to Ms Galicia. In turn, he advised her that a SLAP tear usually settled down in time. Dr Papagelis stated this was also the orthopaedic opinion that she received. He was adamant that he would not recommend any further surgery. Dr Papagelis also advised that Ms Galicia did a lot of research and asked around about her condition as she felt that it could be something more serious and asked for a second opinion. He stated that everyone is entitled to a second opinion or a third if they do not agree with the previous doctor. Mss Galicia had thought it was something else because of the ongoing pain it was causing her and she was suffering so much discomfort at the time.Mr Ben Jaffe, physiotherapist

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Tribunal observed that Comcare’s clinical framework for assessing reasonable medical treatment had not been followed. The framework establishes key measures of treatment effectiveness which empower of the injured person to manage their condition as independently as possible and participate in activities at home, in the community and at work. Independence does not mean being symptom-free, but rather living a functional and productive life while self-managing symptoms if they arise. Failure to empower an injured person to become independent may result in dependency on treatment, which reinforces illness behaviour and can lead to persistent pain or long-term disability.CONCLUSION Based on the evidence before it the Tribunal affirms the decisions under review. In particular it affirms that the determination of 31 March 2016 that Ms Galicia was no longer entitled to compensation pursuant to s 16 and s 19 of the SRC Act as she no longer suffered from the effects of the accepted injury. The decisions under review are affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Dr Curtis did not believe Ms Galicia’s issue was related to her neck or spine but was suffering from a left shoulder pain. He opined if it was a simple musculoskeletal strain it would have been expected to be completely resolved within six months at the most. He believed the treatments so far had been orthodox and had resulted in fixing her genetic shoulder issue which would have deteriorated with age. When he examined Ms Galicia she was neurologically normal and had nearly a full range of movement. He therefore did not believe there was a need to perform another arthroscopy and that is why he made the comment in his report that it was best left alone.Consideration The respondent contended that Ms Galicia had never suffered from a compensable injury and relied upon the opinion of Dr Kostos who opined that Ms Galicia’s condition was not in the shoulder but that she was suffering from age-related disc degeneration and osteoarthritis in the cervical spine which resulted in referred pain in her left shoulder and that this was unrelated to her work. The respondent referred to and relied on the decision in Telstra Corporation Ltd v Hannaford (2006) 90 ALD 263. The Tribunal concurs with the views of Heerey, Dowsett and Conti JJ in Hannaford that the SCR Act is a flexible instrument and notes the following passage of that decision (at 282-283):The statutory scheme allows for progressive and evolving decision-making giving effect to the provisions of ongoing review of relief or entitlement in the nature of course of workers compensation, being reviewed which allows for adjustments or change in the light of events and circumstances which may subsequently happen. The statutory scheme hence reflects a flexible scope for adjustment by way of decisions in the nature of awards to be made and subsequently to the determination of s14 liability whether that determination be made in isolation, or in the context of decision-making concerning consequential relief that may be required in the light of evolving circumstances. It is therefore a scheme which allows progressively for ongoing relief, and is thus not comparable of course with the process of crucial resolution of the traditional common law entitlement of an injured employee for damages as a consequence of the negligent conduct of an employer.…. However, the Tribunal does not concur that a parallel can be drawn in respect of Mr Hannaford’s changing diagnosis of Ross River fever based on a conclusive blood test, and conflicting medical opinions in respect of Ms Galicia’s pain. The Tribunal disagrees with the respondent’s contention and finds that the balance of medical evidence indicates that Ms Galicia is suffering from pain in her left shoulder and that the initial liability for the compensable injury was correctly accepted. Counsel for Ms Galicia contended that her continuing incapacity for work and ongoing requirements for medical treatment results from the compensable injury is a question of fact. They contended that Ms Galicia suffered a compensable injury, that this injury continues to cause her incapacity for work and the ongoing need for medical treatment, and that her injury was contributed to by her employment to a significant degree.