Galecio v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Galecio v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2025] FedCFamC2G 1029

File number(s): SYG 1876 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE GIVEN
Date of judgment: 3 July 2025
Catchwords: MIGRATION – Where non-disclosure certificate issued the existence of which was not initially disclosed to applicant which failure was found on judicial review to be in error – on remittal to Tribunal second non-disclosure certificate issued and then revoked – first non-disclosure certificate remained extant – whether applicant denied procedural fairness – whether Tribunal under obligation to proactively provide documents the subject of revoked non-disclosure certificate
Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 104, 109, 359A, 362A, 375, 275A
Cases cited:

Applicant VEAL of 2002 v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (2005) 225 CLR 88

Hu v Minister for Immigration Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs(No. 3) [2024] FedCFamC2G 398

Kioa v West (1985) 159 CLR 550

LPDT v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 12

Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZMTA (2019) 264 CLR 421

Parvinv Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 269 FCR 247

Zhao v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2019] FCA 1530

Division: General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 74
Date of hearing: 2 September 2024
Place:  Sydney
Counsel for the Applicant: Ms T Baw
Solicitor for the Applicant: Kah Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms K Hooper
Solicitor for the Respondents: Sparke Helmore

ORDERS

SYG 1876 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

LUIS ENRIQUE OLIVARES GALECIO

Applicant

AND:

MINISTER FOR IMMIGRATION, CITIZENSHIP AND MULTICULTURAL AFFAIRS

First Respondent

ADMINISTRATIVE APPEALS TRIBUNAL

Second Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

JUDGE GIVEN

DATE OF ORDER:

3 JULY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The name of the first respondent be amended to read “Minister for Immigration and Citizenship”.

2.The application made on 23 July 2019, as amended, is dismissed.

Note: The form of the order is subject to the entry in the Court’s records.

Note: The Court may vary or set aside a judgment or order to remedy minor typographical or grammatical errors (r 17.05(2)(g) Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth)), or to record a variation to the order pursuant to r 17.05 Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2) (General Federal Law) Rules 2021 (Cth).

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT

JUDGE GIVEN:

  1. Before the Court is an application brought pursuant to s 476 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (Act), by which the applicant seeks judicial review of a decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (Tribunal) made on 18 June 2019, affirming a decision of a delegate of the first respondent (delegate) to cancel the applicant’s Subclass 801 (Spouse) visa (visa).

  2. The following background and summary of the Tribunal’s decision is derived from the parties’ respective written submissions, material in the Court Book (CB)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Galecio v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicul... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 1029
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Galecio v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs involved a Peruvian citizen, the applicant, who had his visa cancelled under the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) due to non-compliance with visa conditions. The central issue was whether the Tribunal denied the applicant procedural fairness by not disclosing documents protected by non-disclosure certificates. The Tribunal had issued a second non-disclosure certificate and then revoked it, but the first certificate remained in effect. The applicant argued that the Tribunal's failure to provide him with the documents subject to the revoked certificate, despite the second certificate's existence, amounted to a denial of procedural fairness. The court had to determine if the Tribunal was under any obligation to proactively disclose the contents of the revoked certificate to the applicant.

The court examined whether the Tribunal's failure to disclose the documents protected by the non-disclosure certificates constituted a breach of procedural fairness. It considered the obligations of the Tribunal under the Migration Act and the principles of natural justice. The court found that the Tribunal did not have a freestanding duty to provide the applicant with every document before it. The applicant was made aware of the existence of the first certificate during the judicial review proceedings and had access to it. The court also noted that the Tribunal had put the applicant on notice of the substance of the adverse material contained in the documents subject to both certificates during the hearings. The court concluded that the Tribunal's actions did not amount to a breach of procedural fairness as the applicant was sufficiently informed of the material and had the opportunity to comment on it.

The court dismissed the application, finding no jurisdictional error. The Tribunal's decision to cancel the applicant's visa was upheld. The applicant's argument that the Tribunal should have proactively provided him with the contents of the revoked certificate was rejected, as there was no obligation for the Tribunal to do so under the circumstances.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Neither Ms Koo nor Ms Wilford was required for cross-examination.BACKGROUND The background to this case is somewhat complicated and the Court has endeavoured to simplify it where possible, limited to the question for determination in the application. Factual and evidential disputes between the parties will be identified where they arise. In addition, the Court has endeavoured to anonymise non-parties where possible. In particular, there is a child who is tangentially relevant to these proceeding but who is not a party. Aspects of this case give rise to questions about that child’s parentage but it is not necessary to identify them by name in order to resolve the issues in the review. The applicant is a citizen of Peru who arrived in Australia on 16 March 2009. Travelling on the same flight was a female friend of the applicant (Ms A). On 9 June 2011, the applicant applied for a combined Partner visa on the basis of his spousal relationship with an Australian woman (applicant’s sponsor). In February 2013, Ms A gave birth to a child (the child). Ms A was allegedly in a relationship with a third person who had sponsored her own partner visa (Ms A’s sponsor). Ms A’s sponsor was recorded on the child’s birth certificate as being the father of the child. On 11 September 2013, a visa was granted to the applicant on the basis of his relationship with his sponsor (CB 1).Cancellation On 15 July 2016, the applicant was issued with a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation under s 109 of the Act (NOICC) (CB 1 to 4). The NOICC said, inter alia, that the Department held (anonymisation added): …information from a credible source that you are the father of [the child]and…credible information that you and [Ms A] have been in a relationship for more than 16 years. The applicant responded to the NOICC on 27 July 2016 (CB 11). The applicant acknowledged he was the father of the child, whom he said had been conceived during an affair with Ms A. On 19 September 2016, the delegate made a decision to cancel the applicant’s visa under s 109 of the Act for non-compliance with s 104 of the Act, on the basis that he did not declare a “change of circumstances”, being that he had a child with Ms A. The delegate considered whether the applicant was aware that he was the father of the child before the visa was granted, and whether the applicant was in a genuine spousal relationship with his sponsor. In the course of the delegate’s reasons, the delegate referred to information the Department had received from a “community informant” (see CB 20 at [10] and [12]). On 22 September 2016, the applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the delegate’s decision (CB 25) and provided a copy of that decision with his application. The first certificate On 14 October 2016 a certificate was issued pursuant to s 375A of the Act (CB 40) (first certificate) in respect of the following folios of file number BCC2015/1460280 (the Department file): (c)1 to 20 (inclusive);[1] (d)38 to 40 (inclusive);[2] and (e)54;[3]on the basis that it would be contrary to the public interest because those folios: contain information that could reveal the identity of the informant and possibility adversely affect their safety.[1] Folios now in evidence at Exhibit “AW-1” to the second Wilford Affidavit at pages 38 to 57[2] Folios now in evidence at Exhibit “AW-1” to the second Wilford Affidavit at pages 58 to 60[3] Folio now in evidence at Exhibit “AW-1” to the second Wilford Affidavit at page 61

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The following background and summary of the Tribunal’s decision is derived from the parties’ respective written submissions, material in the Court Book (CB) and additional evidence of the parties. For that reason, it is sensible to first set out the evidence relied on at hearing.EVIDENCE At the hearing on 2 September 2024, the Court Book was tendered and marked Exhibit “1R”. For the applicant were read the following Affidavits of Rachel Koo affirmed on each of:(a)17 April 2024, with paragraphs [6] to [8] (inclusive) rejected upon objection by the first respondent (first Koo Affidavit); (b)8 May 2024 (second Koo Affidavit); and (c)26 August 2024 with paragraph [8] rejected upon objection by the first respondent (third Koo Affidavit). For the first respondent were read the following Affidavits of Annabelle Victoria Jean Wilford affirmed on each of:(a)13 May 2024 (first Wilford Affidavit); and(b)26 August 2024 (second Wilford Affidavit) annexing (inter alia) a transcript of the applicant’s Tribunal hearing dated 2 August 2018 (Tribunal transcript), which document was ultimately tendered separately at hearing and marked Exhibit “2R”. Neither Ms Koo nor Ms Wilford was required for cross-examination.BACKGROUND The background to this case is somewhat complicated and the Court has endeavoured to simplify it where possible, limited to the question for determination in the application. Factual and evidential disputes between the parties will be identified where they arise. In addition, the Court has endeavoured to anonymise non-parties where possible. In particular, there is a child who is tangentially relevant to these proceeding but who is not a party. Aspects of this case give rise to questions about that child’s parentage but it is not necessary to identify them by name in order to resolve the issues in the review. The applicant is a citizen of Peru who arrived in Australia on 16 March 2009. Travelling on the same flight was a female friend of the applicant (Ms A). On 9 June 2011, the applicant applied for a combined Partner visa on the basis of his spousal relationship with an Australian woman (applicant’s sponsor). In February 2013, Ms A gave birth to a child (the child). Ms A was allegedly in a relationship with a third person who had sponsored her own partner visa (Ms A’s sponsor). Ms A’s sponsor was recorded on the child’s birth certificate as being the father of the child. On 11 September 2013, a visa was granted to the applicant on the basis of his relationship with his sponsor (CB 1).Cancellation On 15 July 2016, the applicant was issued with a Notice of Intention to Consider Cancellation under s 109 of the Act (NOICC) (CB 1 to 4). The NOICC said, inter alia, that the Department held (anonymisation added): …information from a credible source that you are the father of [the child]and…credible information that you and [Ms A] have been in a relationship for more than 16 years. The applicant responded to the NOICC on 27 July 2016 (CB 11). The applicant acknowledged he was the father of the child, whom he said had been conceived during an affair with Ms A. On 19 September 2016, the delegate made a decision to cancel the applicant’s visa under s 109 of the Act for non-compliance with s 104 of the Act, on the basis that he did not declare a “change of circumstances”, being that he had a child with Ms A. The delegate considered whether the applicant was aware that he was the father of the child before the visa was granted, and whether the applicant was in a genuine spousal relationship with his sponsor. In the course of the delegate’s reasons, the delegate referred to information the Department had received from a “community informant” (see CB 20 at [10] and [12]).

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 19 April 2017, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review (first Tribunal decision) (CB 83 to 93). The Tribunal had not disclosed the existence of the first certificate to the applicant prior to making its decision. By that decision the Tribunal made reference to having put to the applicant (anonymisation added): the allegation received by the Department that he was in a relationship with [Ms A] for 16 yearswhich allegation the applicant denied. On 24 May 2017, the applicant commenced proceedings in the (then) Federal Circuit Court (first judicial review proceedings). On 2 November 2017, a Judge of the Court made orders by consent quashing the first Tribunal decision and remitting the matter to the Tribunal on the basis of the following, agreed, jurisdictional error: 1. The first respondent concedes that the second respondent denied the applicant procedural fairness and that this constituted a jurisdictional error of the kind found in Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Singh [2016] FCAFC 183, in circumstances where:(a) A delegate of the first respondent issued a certificate pursuant to sections 375A of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) on 14 October 2016 (Court Book 40) and the existence of the certificate was not disclosed to the applicant in the course of the review by the second respondent; and(b) at least some of the documents subject of the certificates were relevant, or potentially relevant, to the issues arising on the review by the second respondent.The second certificate On 13 November 2017, a further certificate was issued under s 375A (second certificate) in respect of the following folios of the Department file: (a)folio 40, except for the paragraph “relating to Job Number 1 – 1602829845” (Job Details Report);[4](b)folio 41;[5](c)folio 51; and[6](d)folio 53, except for the paragraph relating to the Job Details Report;[7]on the basis it that it would be:…contrary to the public interest because most of the information in these folios is not relevant to the review application and disclosure would result in breach of privacy. [4] Folio now in evidence at Exhibit “AW-1” to the second Wilford Affidavit at 84 (see [5(b)] above and [32] below) [5] Ibid[6] Ibid [7]Ibid On 2 August 2018, the applicant attended a hearing at the Tribunal (CB 143 to 145). The applicant provided written submissions (CB 117 to 126) and statutory declarations (CB 130, 136 to 137) including from Ms A’s brother-in-law (CB 141 to 142) by which he identified himself as being the community information and sought to retract the previous information he had provided to the Department in that capacity. The applicant was represented in the first judicial review by the same legal representative who continued to represent him[8] in the remittal and attended the second Tribunal hearing before the (differently constituted) Tribunal on 2 August 2018 (CB 143). At that hearing, the following exchanges, relevant to the issue of non-disclosure certificates in this matter, took place (Tribunal transcript at 11):[9] [8] Until being replaced by the applicant’s current representative, Ms Koo, on 28 February 2019. Ms Koo is from the same law firm as the previous representative and has represented the applicant in the instant proceedings since their inception[9] Irrelevant sections (for example, directions to the interpreter) omittedTribunal: Mr Olivares, you have had your visa cancelled by the Department. And you’re seeking a review of that decision in the Tribunal for the second time. …The reason for the fact that you’re here for the second time is that the court remitted, or sent, the case back to the Tribunal to be reheard. And the reason for that was because the previous member had neglected to informed you about the section 375A certificate which is attached to the Department file. Now, you might ask yourself what is that particular certificate? What does it mean? What’s it all about? Well, it’s a document that sits on the department file which prevents the disclosure of certain information other than to us here at the tribunal. The reason why that form has information that can’t be disclosed is for the following reason. I will explain it to you by reading the front page of this particular certificate to you. …I certify that in accordance with section 375A of the Migration Act 1958 the disclosure otherwise than to the tribunal of the information contained in folios 40, 41, 51 and 53 of folio number BCC2015 except for the paragraph in folio 40 and 53 relating to job number 1-- and it has got some other numbers:would be contrary to the public interest. And the reason why it is contrary to the public interest is because most of the information in these folios is not relevant to the review applicant and disclosure could result in a breach of privacy. As section 375A applies to the document information identified above, the AAT –- the tribunal - must do all that is necessary to ensure the document of information is not disclosed to any person other than to a member of the tribunal.And that’s enacted pursuant to section 375A(2)(b) of the Migration Act 1958. So being a layperson, that probably sounds like a lot of legal talk to you, so let me explain a little bit more. If the Department puts one of those certificates on there, I have to do a couple of things. All right? Well, firstly, I have to alert you to that certificate, by law. I have to decide whether I think the certificate is valid. And lastly I have to give you the opportunity of commenting. So I observe, Mr Olivares, that you’re here with…your representative…would you like him to make some comment?Representative: Perhaps a question, if that’s okay, Member.Tribunal: Please. Representative: I believe that that certificate might be different. Is that newly issued to the previous certificate?Tribunal: Well, this certificate was issued on the 13th of the 11th of 2017.Representative: So there’s another certificate as well, or does that supersede the previous certificate? Tribunal:Well, this is the most current one that’s on here. And just looking at questions to do with its validity. All right?Representative: Yes. Sorry. Tribunal: Your representative would like to know how current it is, you know. So if you will just excuse me while I speak to him for a couple of minutes, and then we will interpret them for you. So, yes, go ahead, please, Mr Matherson. You seem to think there’s a later certificate? Representative: No. An earlier certificate.Tribunal:Okay.Representative: So I wasn’t aware of this certificate.Tribunal:Okay. Representative: But there was an earlier – I believe that the reason for the remittance was the earlier certificate dated 14 October 2016, which has different folio numbers. Tribunal: Okay.Representative: Some are the same, but some would appear to be different from what you just read now.…Tribunal:…He’s asking me about there being an earlier certificate, and it having different folio numbers. All right? You’re probably thinking, ‘What has this got to do with the price of fish?’ But it is important at this early stage, because there has been a court hearing about it. Okay? Mr Matherson, what often happens and sometimes it’s induced by the tribunal, is where we may have some concerns about the certificate and we seek to have it revised, and at other times the revision just happens by bureaucratic fiat by the Department for some reason best known to themselves, over which we have no control. But only the other day I send one back because I wasn’t satisfied it was valid, for instance. Okay? Mr Olivares, Mr Matherson, the crucial thing in looking at the validity is the identification of the reasons for it, and you can’t just put some broad-brush thing, ‘These pages are off limits because I think they are’ – no. There has to be a reason for it, and some explanation given in the document so that it can be checked for validity. So there it is. I think it’s valid. You have made some comments about it. Would you want to make further comments about it down on another time, or would you like to refer to it? Would you like me to send you a copy of it or something like that?Representative: Yes. A copy would be great, please. Tribunal:Okay. Representative: Thank you, Member.Tribunal:Well, in view of what you have just said, it’s fair enough. And I’m happy to do that for you. You might want to write some little submission or something like that.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Further, the first respondent says that the Tribunal did not deny the applicant procedural fairness by not giving him access to, or putting to him the “formerly confidential information”, as the Tribunal does not have a freestanding duty to provide an applicant with every document before it. The first respondent submitted that the applicant was put on notice of the substance of the adverse material contained in the documents the subject of both the first certificate and the second certificate at hearings before it (and before the previous Tribunal) held pursuant to s 360 of the Act, and in the s 359A letters referred to at [46] above. Consideration By ground 1, the applicant alleged a jurisdictional error constituted by a breach of either ss 359A or 360 of the Act. At hearing, the applicant’s Counsel confirmed that the allegation was no longer pressed in respect of s 359A of the Act.[19] Particulars (a) to (c) set out factual matters. The balance of the particulars allege that the Tribunal had before it material which was no longer confidential and was potentially relevant to the review and that it was necessary for the Tribunal to have disclosed that material or at least put the applicant on notice of it. [19] Transcript T04.28 to T04.42 By submissions in reply filed with the Court on 17 April 2024, the applicant more specifically particularises how it is that the Tribunal is said to have denied him procedural fairness in the context of the ground of review, which can be distilled as follows: (a)disclosure of the revocation certificate is “no defence” because the Tribunal did not signpost to the applicant the ongoing existence of the first certificate; (b)the Tribunal left the applicant’s representative with the understanding that the second certificate was the operative certificate and most likely superseded the first certificate; (c)there was confusion on the part of the Tribunal as to which documents the respective certificates applied; and(d)non-disclosure of the documents the subject of the second certificate was material in the sense they would have made a difference to the outcome of the review. From the exchange which is set out at [20] to [21] above, the applicant’s representative was aware of the first certificate and identified to the Tribunal that the folios which the Tribunal read out from the second certificate differed from those which had been the subject of the first certificate. So much can be accepted from his statement to the Tribunal that: I believe that the certificate might be different. Following this, the events which are recorded at [22] to [25] above transpired. Clearly, by reason of the fact that the first Tribunal decision was remitted as a result of judicial review proceedings, the applicant had access to the first certificate which was disclosed to him as part of those proceedings and was specifically and expressly referred to in the remittal orders of the Court as being the basis of the extant jurisdictional error. I accept that the applicant (and his representative) was clearly on notice of the existence of first certificate because of the first judicial review proceedings.