[2002] TASSC 92
CITATION: Gairsay Pty Ltd & Ors v Berkley Farm Pty Ltd & Ors [2002] TASSC 92
PARTIES: GAIRSAY PTY LTD [ACN 009 492 9888]
DOBSON, Elizabeth Gaye
GOURLAY, Sally Ann
v
BERKLEY FARM PTY LTD [ACN 065 389 433]
DUINDAM, Jacobus Johannes
DUINDAM, Joanna Catherina
TITLE OF COURT: SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION: ORIGINAL
FILE NO/S: 592/1999
613/2000
DELIVERED ON: 8 November 2002
DELIVERED AT: Hobart
HEARING DATES: 13 - 16, 19 August, 8 - 11, 14, 15 October 2002
JUDGMENT OF: Blow J
CATCHWORDS:
Conveyancing - Relationship of vendor and purchaser - Matters arising between contract and conveyance - Conditions precedent and subsequent - Other conditions - "Restrictions on the use of the property" - Meaning.
Aust Dig Conveyancing [10]
Conveyancing - Relationship of vendor and purchaser - Breach of contract - Breach by the purchaser: remedies of vendor - Damages - Vendor's duties on resale.
Sullivan v Darkin [1986] 1 NZLR 214; Jampco Pty Ltd v Cameron (No 2) (1985) 3 NSWLR 391; J Boag & Son Brewing Ltd v Bridon Investments Pty Ltd (2001) 10 Tas R 26; A H R Constructions Pty Ltd v Maloney [1994] 1 Qd R 460, referred to.
Aust Dig Conveyancing [89]
REPRESENTATION:
Counsel:
Plaintiffs: G L Sealy and E Bullard
Defendants: P W Tree
Solicitors:
Plaintiffs: Dobson Mitchell & Allport
Defendants: H S Murray
Judgment Number: [2002] TASSC 92
Number of Paragraphs: 47
Serial No 92/2002
File Nos 592/1999613/2000
GAIRSAY PTY LTD [ACN 009 492 9888], ELIZABETH GAYE DOBSON,
SALLY ANN GOURLAY v BERKLEY FARM PTY LTD [ACN 065 389 433], JACOBUS JOHANNES DUINDAM, JOANNA CATHERINA DUINDAM
REASONS FOR JUDGMENT BLOW J
8 November 2002
These proceedings relate to a group of real estate transactions concerning properties at Ouse. The transactions were entered into in 1996 by members of the Gourlay and Duindam families, and companies controlled by them. For many years the Gourlay family had owned and farmed properties known as "The Lodge", "Smedleys", and "Kings". The transactions were as follows:
(a)By an agreement dated 14 June 1996 R A Gourlay Pty Ltd (the owner of The Lodge and certain chattels) and Roger Anthony Gourlay ("Mr Gourlay") and his wife Louise Helen Gourlay (the owners of certain stock, plant and feed) agreed to sell The Lodge and the chattels, stock, plant and feed to the second and third defendants, Mr and Mrs Duindam, for $1,259,800 (excluding the prices of the stock and the feed). This contract provided for completion to take place on 1 July 1996.
(b)By an agreement of the same date Gairsay Pty Ltd ("Gairsay") (the first plaintiff, a company controlled by Mr Gourlay) agreed to sell Smedleys to Mr and Mrs Duindam for $370,000, of which $100,000 was to be paid on or before 30 June 1999, and the balance was to be paid on completion, which was to be on 1 July 2000, as to which time was of the essence.
(c)By another agreement of the same date Mr…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Gairsay Pty Ltd v Berkley Farm Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2002] TASSC 92
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court found that the defendants had not proved their case of misrepresentation. The evidence regarding the alleged misrepresentations was inconsistent and unreliable. The court was not satisfied that the plaintiffs had made false, misleading or deceptive representations about the properties. The court also rejected the defendants' argument that the quality of the soils on the properties constituted a restriction on the use of the property, which would have allowed them to avoid completing the contracts. The court held that the contracts were clear and the defendants were not entitled to orders in the nature of rescission.
The court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to damages for the loss of their bargains. The court found that the plaintiffs had acted reasonably in reselling the properties and mitigating their losses. The court awarded damages to the plaintiffs in respect of the losses on resale, interest, miscellaneous expenses, and other claims related to the leases of the properties. The court ordered that the lease of Kings be rectified to correctly describe the land, and awarded damages to the plaintiffs for breaches of the leases by the defendants.
In conclusion, the court found in favour of the plaintiffs and ordered the defendants to pay damages for the losses on resale of the properties, interest, miscellaneous expenses, and other claims. The court rejected the defendants' counterclaims for rescission and damages. The specific amounts of damages awarded to each plaintiff were calculated based on the losses on resale, interest, and other expenses incurred by the plaintiffs.
Background
Background to the litigation
The key facts in dispute concern alleged misrepresentations made by Roger Gourlay about the properties' silage production, ploughing frequency, and soil quality. The Duindams claim these misrepresentations induced them to enter into the contracts. However, the evidence regarding what was actually said is inconsistent. While some witnesses testified that certain statements were made, others did not recall such statements. The court found the evidence regarding the alleged misrepresentations to be unreliable and did not accept that the Duindams relied on any such representations.
The contracts for Smedleys and Kings also contained conditions precedent relating to restrictions on the use of the properties. The Duindams argued that poor soil quality constituted a restriction that excused them from completing the contracts. However, the court found that the condition precedent related only to legal or administrative restrictions, not defects in the property's quality.
The Duindams did not complete the contracts for Smedleys and Kings by 1 July 2000. The plaintiffs accepted their repudiation of the contracts and resold the properties at lower prices. The Duindams argue that the plaintiffs should not be compensated for their losses on resale. However, the court found that the plaintiffs acted reasonably in reselling the properties and mitigating their losses. The plaintiffs are entitled to damages for their losses on resale, including interest, and certain incidental expenses.
In summary, the key facts giving rise to the legal dispute are the Gourlay and Duindam families' real estate transactions in 1996, the Duindams' failure to complete the contracts for Smedleys and Kings, and the plaintiffs' claims for damages for their losses on resale of the properties. The Duindams contend that the contracts should be rescinded due to alleged misrepresentations and conditions precedent not being satisfied, but the court rejected these contentions.
This case came before the Supreme Court of Tasmania as an original proceeding following a first-instance hearing. The matter originated from a series of real estate transactions between members of the Gourlay and Duindam families and companies they controlled. The plaintiffs, Gairsay Pty Ltd, Elizabeth Gaye Dobson, and Sally Ann Gourlay, sued the defendants, Berkley Farm Pty Ltd, Jacobus Johannes Duindam, and Joanna Catherina Duindam, over alleged breaches of contract and misrepresentations regarding the sale of properties known as Smedleys and Kings. The plaintiffs sought damages for losses incurred from the resale of the properties and other expenses. The defendants denied the allegations and counterclaimed for rescission and damages based on alleged misrepresentations by the plaintiffs. The case was heard over multiple dates in August and October 2002 and was delivered on 8 November 2002.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the vendor made false or misleading representations regarding the quality of the soil, silage production, and ploughing frequency on the properties.
2. Whether the purchasers relied on these representations and whether the representations induced them to enter into the contracts.
3. Whether the soil quality constituted a "restriction on the use of the property" under the terms of the contracts, which would allow the purchasers to avoid completing the purchase.
4. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to damages for the loss of their bargains after reselling the properties at lower prices.
5. Whether the plaintiffs adequately mitigated their losses by taking reasonable steps to minimise their financial loss.
6. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recover interest on the unpaid deposit and other expenses incurred.
7. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recover damages for the conversion of plant and equipment from the lease of Smedleys.
8. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recover damages for the purchase of fertiliser allegedly needed due to neglect by the defendants.
Held
1. Whether the vendor made false or misleading representations regarding the quality of the soil, silage production, and ploughing frequency on the properties.
The court concluded that the vendor did not make false or misleading representations regarding the quality of the soil, silage production, and ploughing frequency on the properties.
2. Whether the purchasers relied on these representations and whether the representations induced them to enter into the contracts.
The court concluded that the purchasers did not rely on these representations, and they did not induce the purchasers to enter into the contracts.
3. Whether the soil quality constituted a "restriction on the use of the property" under the terms of the contracts, which would allow the purchasers to avoid completing the purchase.
The court concluded that the soil quality did not constitute a "restriction on the use of the property" under the terms of the contracts, and therefore the purchasers were not entitled to avoid completing the purchase.
4. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to damages for the loss of their bargains after reselling the properties at lower prices.
The court concluded that the plaintiffs are entitled to damages for the loss of their bargains after reselling the properties at lower prices.
5. Whether the plaintiffs adequately mitigated their losses by taking reasonable steps to minimise their financial loss.
The court concluded that the plaintiffs adequately mitigated their losses by taking reasonable steps to minimise their financial loss.
6. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recover interest on the unpaid deposit and other expenses incurred.
The court concluded that the plaintiffs are entitled to recover interest on the unpaid deposit and other expenses incurred.
7. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recover damages for the conversion of plant and equipment from the lease of Smedleys.
The court concluded that the plaintiffs are entitled to recover damages for the conversion of plant and equipment from the lease of Smedleys.
8. Whether the plaintiffs are entitled to recover damages for the purchase of fertiliser allegedly needed due to neglect by the defendants.
The court concluded that the plaintiffs are not entitled to recover damages for the purchase of fertiliser allegedly needed due to neglect by the defendants.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court examined the plaintiffs' claims that the defendants made false or misleading representations regarding the quality of the soil, silage production, and ploughing frequency on the properties, and that the defendants' representations induced the plaintiffs to enter into the contracts. The court found that while some statements were made, the defendants did not rely on those statements in deciding to purchase the properties. The court held that the plaintiffs could not rely on the representations to avoid completing the purchase.
The court considered whether the soil quality constituted a "restriction on the use of the property" that would allow the plaintiffs to avoid completing the purchase. The court held that the phrase "restrictions on the use of the property" was intended to refer only to legal or administrative restrictions, and not to defects in the quality of the property limiting its use. The plaintiffs could not avoid completing the purchase based on the soil quality.
The court found that the plaintiffs were entitled to damages for the loss of their bargains after reselling the properties at lower prices, as the plaintiffs took reasonable steps to mitigate their losses by advertising and selling the properties at auction. The court also found that the plaintiffs were entitled to recover interest on the unpaid deposit and other expenses incurred.
The court held that the plaintiffs were entitled to recover damages for the conversion of plant and equipment from the lease of Smedleys, though the amount was limited by the lack of evidence as to the value of the items. The court found that the plaintiffs were not entitled to recover damages for the purchase of fertiliser, as the claim was not properly pleaded.
In summary, the court found that the plaintiffs could not rely on the defendants' alleged misrepresentations to avoid completing the purchase, but were entitled to damages for the loss of their bargains after reselling the properties at lower prices. The court also found that the plaintiffs were entitled to recover certain expenses, but not for the purchase of fertiliser.