Gainsborough Hardware Industries Ltd v Walter Joseph Nugent

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

official notice

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Application  :          No. 662657 in the name of Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited

Title:          Dual function lock mechanism

Action:          Opposition to grant by Walter Joseph Nugent on the ground that the nominated person is not entitled to a grant of a patent for the invention;  hearing.

Decision:          Issued            

Abstract

Walter Nugent asserted that he supplied various lock prototypes to Mr Liebherr an employee of Gainsborough and explained to him their features before the priority date of the claims.  He further asserted that the invention claimed is based on those disclosures and that Gainsborough is not entitled to the grant of a patent for the invention.  Mr Liebherr and Mr Fortune are the named inventors on the patent request.

The conclusions were as follows:

  1. Unable to conclude on the balance of probabilities that Nugent supplied an invention or inventions to Gainsborough, Liebherr or Fortune by way of his three prototypes represented by Exhibits WJN-3, WJN-4 and WJN-5 before the priority date of the opposed application.

  1. Unable to conclude that Nugent is an inventor in respect of the claimed invention.

  1. Found that Gainsborough has sole rights to the invention claimed.

  1. Opposition dismissed.

  1. Costs awarded against the opponent, Walter Joseph Nugent.

patents act 1990

decision of a delegate of the commissioner of patents

Re:Patent Application No. 662657 by Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited and opposition thereto under section 59 by Walter Joseph Nugent.

background

Patent application 662657 was filed on 8 October 1993 by Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited (hereafter referred to as “Gainsborough”).  The patent request indicates that the application is associated with provisional applications PL 5182/92 filed on 9 October 1992 and
PL 6948/93 filed on 27 January 1993.  The application was advertised accepted on 7 September 1995. 

On 7 December 1995 Walter Joseph Nugent (hereafter referred to as “Nugent”) filed an opposition to the grant of a patent on the application.  The sole ground of opposition is stated as follows in the Statement of Grounds and Particulars:

“The nominated person GAINSBOROUGH HARDWARE INDUSTRIES LIMITED
is not entitled to the grant of a patent for the invention, so far as claimed in any of claims
1 to 26.”

Of the Particulars, paragraph (l) asserts:

“The Applicant has obtained the invention from the Opponent or NIPL [Nulock Industries Pty Ltd], and accordingly the Applicant is not entitled to a grant of a patent for the invention.”

Following the completion of the evidence stages, the matter was set for a hearing.  The hearing took place in Canberra on 1 December 1997.  Gainsborough was represented by Mr F Old assisted by Mr R Curnick, both patent attorneys of Spruson & Ferguson.  Mr Nugent represented himself.  Two officials of the applicant company and Mr Nugent’s daughter and a friend also attended the hearing.

EVIDENCE

The evidence filed in this matter consists of the following:

Evidence in support

  • A statutory declaration by the opponent Mr Nugent dated 7 June 1996 with Exhibits WJN-1…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gainsborough Hardware Industries Ltd v Walter Joseph Nugent and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1998] APO 7
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The court considered an opposition to the grant of a patent by Walter Joseph Nugent against Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited. Nugent claimed that Gainsborough was not entitled to the patent for a dual function lock mechanism as the invention was derived from prototypes he supplied to Gainsborough before the priority date. The court had to determine whether Nugent supplied an invention to Gainsborough, Liebherr, or Fortune before the priority date and whether Gainsborough or Nugent had rights to the claimed invention. The court found that Nugent's evidence of supplying prototypes was not convincing and could not conclude on the balance of probabilities that Nugent supplied an invention to Gainsborough, Liebherr, or Fortune before the priority date. The court also found that Nugent did not contribute to the development of the claimed invention and could not conclude that Nugent was an inventor in respect of the claimed invention. Therefore, Gainsborough had sole rights to the invention claimed, and the opposition was dismissed with costs awarded against Nugent.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves a patent application for a dual function lock mechanism filed by Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited. Walter Joseph Nugent opposed the grant of the patent, asserting that he had supplied various lock prototypes to Erwin Liebherr, an employee of Gainsborough, before the priority date of the patent application and that Gainsborough was not entitled to the grant of the patent for the invention. Nugent claimed that he had supplied three prototypes to Liebherr and explained their features before the priority date of the patent application. Gainsborough, represented by patent attorneys, defended the opposition, arguing that Nugent had not supplied the prototypes before the priority date and that the invention was independently developed by Liebherr and Geoffrey Fortune, who are named as inventors on the patent request. The case includes evidence from various declarations and exhibits related to the prototypes, the development of the lock mechanism, and the relationship between Nugent and Gainsborough.

The patent application in question, numbered 662657, was filed by Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited on 8 October 1993, with associated provisional applications. Walter Joseph Nugent filed an opposition to the grant of the patent on 7 December 1995, under section 59 of the Patents Act 1990, asserting that Gainsborough was not entitled to the grant of the patent. The opposition was heard in Canberra on 1 December 1997. The matter involved submissions and evidence from both parties, including statutory declarations and exhibits. The decision was issued by a delegate of the Commissioner of Patents, dismissing the opposition and awarding costs against Nugent.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the invention claimed by Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited disclosed by Walter Joseph Nugent to Gainsborough, Erwin Liebherr, or Geoffrey Fortune before the priority date of the patent application?
2. Did Walter Joseph Nugent contribute to the invention claimed in any way, either directly or indirectly?
3. Do Gainsborough, Erwin Liebherr, or Geoffrey Fortune have sole rights to the invention claimed in the patent application?

Held
1. The court was unable to conclude on the balance of probabilities that Walter Joseph Nugent supplied an invention or inventions to Gainsborough, Erwin Liebherr, or Geoffrey Fortune by way of his three prototypes represented by Exhibits WJN-3, WJN-4, and WJN-5 before the priority date of the opposed application.
2. The court was unable to conclude that Nugent is an inventor in respect of the claimed invention.
3. The court found that Gainsborough had sole rights to the invention claimed.
4. The opposition was dismissed.
5. Costs were awarded against the opponent, Walter Joseph Nugent.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the evidence provided by both Walter Joseph Nugent and Gainsborough Hardware Industries Limited, focusing on whether Nugent had disclosed an invention to Gainsborough, Erwin Liebherr, or Geoffrey Fortune before the priority date of the patent application. The court found that while Nugent's evidence regarding the existence and supply of his prototypes was plausible, it was not convincing. The court was unable to conclude that Nugent had supplied the prototypes at the times Nugent claimed. The evidence provided by Gainsborough was also plausible and corroborated by multiple declarants, suggesting that the invention claimed was developed independently by Gainsborough's employees. Therefore, the court concluded that Nugent had not contributed to the invention claimed. The court further found that Gainsborough had sole rights to the invention as it derived title from the inventors, Liebherr and Fortune, by assignment. Consequently, the court dismissed the opposition and awarded costs against Nugent.