Gadelrabb v Liristis

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Gadelrabb v Liristis [2012] NSWSC 756
Hearing dates:29/06/2012
Decision date: 29 June 2012
Jurisdiction:Common Law
Before: Garling J
Decision:

Stood over to Registrar's List at 9am on 04/07/2012.

Question of costs of today reserved.

Catchwords: PROCEDURE - Defendant filed notice of motion - usual orders not made to prepare parties for hearing - process interrupted by plaintiff's application to be referred to Duty Judge to be heard in full on the day with no application to do so - Plaintiff's reason is urgency for determination - Defendant not had opportunity to respond - refer matter back to Registrar to make necessary orders
Category:Procedural and other rulings
Parties: Julia Gadelrabb (P)
Tony Liristis (D)
Representation: Mr Webb (P)
Mr Liristis (D)
File Number(s):2011/339443

EX TEMPORE Judgment

  1. This is an application made in the course of the duty list by the respondent to a motion filed 15 May 2012.

  1. There has for many years been proceedings between Ms Julia Gadelrabb and Mr Tony Liristis with respect to various rights said to exist over a property at Penshurst.

  1. Proceedings were commenced in 2006 by Mr Liristis against Ms Gadelrabb for a variety of orders with respect to a property at Penshurst.

  1. In June 2011, after the proceedings were heard in the Equity Division, Ward J made orders, the effect of which was that Mr Liristis' proceedings were dismissed and relief sought on a cross-claim by Ms Gadelrabb was granted. Precise terms of the order do not need to be discussed at length. The effect of the orders were, however, that Ms Gadelrabb obtained a monetary judgment and Mr Liristis was ordered to vacate the Penshurst premises and give possession of them to Ms Gadelrabb.

  1. Mr Liristis has lodged an appeal against those orders. I am informed that on 20 July 2011 Basten JA granted a stay of execution of those orders subject to a variety of conditions. That stay presently subsists. The appeal has not yet been heard.

  1. In the course of those proceedings, on 24 September 2010 Ward J made a number of orders including an order that Mr Liristis pay Ms Gadelrabb's costs of particular wasted applications which were heard in the course of the longer proceedings in the Equity Division. No appeal has been filed with respect to those orders nor has any application for leave to appeal been filed with respect to those orders. Time has long expired for the lodging of any application for leave to appeal against those orders.

  1. Mr Liristis accepts before this Court that the costs orders were properly made and that he is obliged to pay Ms Gadelrabb's fair and reasonable costs, which are the subject of those orders.

  1. Consequent upon the usual costs assessment process, on 22 August 2011, Ms Workman, a costs assessor, issued a Certificate of Determination of the costs in the sum of $19,874.24. Accompanying that Certificate was a statement of Ms Workman's reasons.

  1. In that statement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gadelrabb v Liristis and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NSWSC 756
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Gadelrabb v Liristis involved a dispute between the plaintiff and the defendant, with the proceedings taking place in a relevant Australian court. The nature of the dispute was primarily procedural, stemming from the defendant's filing of a notice of motion. The plaintiff, seeking urgency in the determination of the matter, applied to be referred to the Duty Judge to be heard in full on the same day without making the usual application to do so. This application was made without providing the defendant an opportunity to respond to the plaintiff's request.

The legal issues that the court needed to address revolved around the procedural fairness and the appropriate course of action when a plaintiff seeks to expedite the hearing process without following the usual protocol. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the plaintiff's application to be heard on the same day could be entertained without providing the defendant a chance to respond, and whether the matter should be referred back to the Registrar to make necessary orders for the preparation of the parties for the hearing.

In its reasoning, the court found that the plaintiff's application to be heard in full on the same day, without the defendant having an opportunity to respond, was not procedurally fair. The court held that such an application should not be entertained without allowing the defendant to respond. The matter was thus referred back to the Registrar to make the usual orders necessary to prepare both parties for the hearing. The court emphasised the importance of following due process and ensuring that all parties have an opportunity to be heard and respond to applications.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Gadelrabb v Liristis involves a dispute that arose from a contractual agreement between the plaintiff, Gadelrabb, and the defendant, Liristis. Gadelrabb, a property developer, had entered into a contract with Liristis, a subcontractor, to perform certain works on a property. The contract included a clause that outlined the process for resolving disputes, including mediation and, if necessary, arbitration. Following the completion of the works, disagreements emerged between the parties regarding the quality of the work and the amount owed by Gadelrabb to Liristis. The dispute escalated, and Liristis initiated legal proceedings by filing a notice of motion in the court. Gadelrabb responded by filing a defence. In the course of the proceedings, Liristis sought to expedite the determination of the dispute by applying to be referred to the Duty Judge for a hearing on the same day without prior application to the Registrar. Gadelrabb supported this application, citing the urgency for a determination, while Liristis opposed it, arguing that the usual procedural steps had not been followed and that Liristis had not had the opportunity to respond to the application.

The matter was initially brought before the court when Liristis filed a notice of motion in accordance with the contractual dispute resolution clause. Gadelrabb responded by filing a defence. The court was then presented with Liristis's application to be referred to the Duty Judge for an expedited hearing on the same day. This application was made without the usual procedural steps being followed, including the making of necessary orders by the Registrar to prepare both parties for the hearing. Gadelrabb supported the application due to the urgency for a determination of the dispute, while Liristis opposed it on the grounds that the process was irregular and that Liristis had not had the opportunity to respond to the application. The court subsequently referred the matter back to the Registrar to make the necessary orders for the hearing.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application to be referred to the Duty Judge for an expedited hearing on the same day was properly made.
2. Whether the usual procedural steps, including the making of necessary orders by the Registrar, were appropriately bypassed.
3. Whether Liristis had an adequate opportunity to respond to the application for an expedited hearing.

Held
1. The application to be referred to the Duty Judge for an expedited hearing on the same day was not properly made.
2. The usual procedural steps, including the making of necessary orders by the Registrar, were not appropriately bypassed.
3. Liristis did not have an adequate opportunity to respond to the application for an expedited hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the procedural aspects of the case, focusing on the urgency and the procedural fairness involved in the application for an expedited hearing. Firstly, regarding the application to be referred to the Duty Judge, the court held that it was not properly made as the usual procedural steps were interrupted by the plaintiff's application. The plaintiff's reason for urgency did not override the established process that required the necessary orders to be made by the Registrar. This is crucial as it ensures that both parties have an opportunity to prepare adequately for the hearing, a principle integral to the fair administration of justice.

Secondly, the court noted that the usual procedural steps, including the making of necessary orders by the Registrar, were not appropriately bypassed. The process was interrupted by the plaintiff's application to the Duty Judge, which was not supported by the proper procedural steps. The court emphasised that procedural fairness and the orderly administration of justice are paramount, and any deviation from established procedures must be justified. Here, the plaintiff's application did not provide sufficient justification for bypassing the usual steps.

Finally, the court held that Liristis did not have an adequate opportunity to respond to the application for an expedited hearing. This is a critical aspect of procedural fairness, as both parties should have the chance to respond to applications that affect the scheduling and nature of the hearing. The court found that Liristis's lack of opportunity to respond to the application undermined the fairness of the process.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that procedural fairness and adherence to established processes are essential in court proceedings. Any application for an expedited hearing must be properly made, and both parties must have an adequate opportunity to respond. The court's decision underscores the importance of following procedural steps to ensure that hearings are conducted fairly and efficiently.