FWGS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review)

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

FWGS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second review) [2021] AATA 305 (24 February 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number:         2019/8491

Re:FWGS

APPLICANT

AndChild Support Registrar

RESPONDENT

AndDZBS

OTHER PARTY

DECISION

Tribunal:L M Gallagher, Member

Date:24 February 2021

Place:Perth

The reviewable decision, being the AAT1 decision dated 13 December 2019, is affirmed.

........ ................[sgd]................................................

L M Gallagher, Member

Names used in all published decisions are pseudonyms. Any references appearing in square brackets indicate that information has been removed from this decision and replaced with generic information so as not to identify involved individuals as required by subsections 16(2AB)–16(2AC) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth).


CATCHWORDS

CHILD SUPPORT – percentage of care – whether there was a change in care – actual care – extent of care – pattern of care – special circumstances – decision under review affirmed

LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act (1975) (Cth) – s 43(6)
Child Support Assessment Act 1989 (Cth) – ss 49, 49(1)(a), 49(1)(b), 49(3), 50, 50(1)(a), 50(1)(b), 50(3), 51, 54A, 54A(1), 54A(3), 54B

Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) – ss 95N1, 95N(2), 96A(c)

CASES

P v Child Support Registrar [2013] FCA 1312

P v Child Support Registrar [2014] FCAFC 98
Parent A and Child Support Registrar and Anor [2013] AATA 562
Polec & Staker & Anor (SSAT Appeal) [2011] FMCAfam 959

Re Drake and Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (No 2) (1979) 2 ALD 634

SECONDARY MATERIALS

Guides to Social Policy Law: Child Support Guide – s 2.2.1

REASONS FOR DECISION

L M Gallagher, Member

24 February 2021

BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant and the Other Party are the separated parents of a child, who is now 18 years of age (the child) and to whom the present application relates.

  2. On 27 July 2015, a child support case was registered in relation to the child


    (R2, T42, page 542).

  3. On 17 August 2018, the child support case was ended (with effect from 9 July 2018) on the basis that the child was no longer in either parent’s care (R2, T9, pages 75-76 and


    T10, pages 77-78).

  4. On 7 February 2019 the Other Party contacted Services Australia[1] (the Agency) to advise that she had 100% care of the child from September 2018 (R2, T41, page 512).


    The Other Party lodged a new application for a child support assessment as required,


    which the Agency acknowledged on 16 February 2019 (R2, T12, page 98).

    [1]
  5. On 11 March 2019, the Agency accepted the Other Party’s application for a child support assessment and decided to record the percentage of care as 100% (the original decision) (R2, T13, pages 100 and 104).

  6. On 12 March 2019, the Applicant objected to the original decision on the bases that


    (R2, T41, pages 523 and 524):

    (a)the child had not been in either parent’s care; and

    (b)both parents were providing financial support.

  7. On 22 July 2019, the Applicant and the Other Party were advised that the Applicant’s objection…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FWGS and Child Support Registrar (Child support second revie... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 305
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned a second review of a child support assessment before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The dispute centred on the percentage of care each parent, the Applicant and the Other Party, had of the child following the cessation of a previous child support assessment on 8 July 2018. The core of the disagreement lay in determining the commencement and cessation dates of any care arrangements and the respective care percentages applicable from that point onwards.

The Tribunal was required to determine whether either parent had a "pattern of care" for the child after 8 July 2018, and if so, what percentage of care each parent held and for what periods. This involved assessing the evidence presented by both parties regarding their involvement in the child's daily life, financial contributions, and decision-making responsibilities. The Tribunal also had to consider the effective date of any revised child support assessment, particularly in light of an earlier decision to extend the time for lodging an application for review due to special circumstances.

In its reasoning, the Tribunal applied the ordinary meaning of "pattern of care" as an undefined term under the Assessment Act. The Tribunal found that the Other Party had established a pattern of care, being responsible for the child's living arrangements, costs, and day-to-day matters, including during periods when the child did not reside with her continuously. Conversely, the Tribunal concluded that the Applicant's involvement, primarily through occasional financial contributions to the child without regularity or specific parameters for use, did not constitute a pattern of care. The Applicant's involvement in decision-making was also found to be significantly less than that of the Other Party.

Consequently, the Tribunal affirmed the reviewable decision. It determined that from September or October 2018, the Other Party held 100% of the care for the child, with this percentage to be applied to the child support assessment from the application date of 7 February 2019.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant and the Other Party are the parents of a child, born in 2007. A child support assessment was in place from 2015 but was ended on 8 July 2018 as the child was found to no longer be in either parent’s care. On 7 February 2019, the Other Party lodged a child support assessment application with the Agency, claiming she had 100% care of the child from September 2018. The Applicant contested this claim and, on 13 December 2019, the AAT set aside the objection decision, deciding that from September or October 2018, the Other Party’s care percentage for the child is 100% and is to be used in the child support assessment from the application date of 7 February 2019. The Applicant applied for a review of the AAT’s decision, contending that the child did not live with the Other Party during the relevant period and the Other Party did not provide financial support for the child. The Applicant also claimed that he provided nearly $4,000 during the period between November 2018 to March 2019. The Tribunal must determine the percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party had of the child after 8 July 2018 and during what period those percentages applied.

For the period July, August and September 2018, the Applicant paid rent each week to the child’s girlfriend’s mother directly into her account and paid money directly into the child’s account. The Applicant claimed he was emotionally involved in the child’s care in that he would speak daily to the child’s girlfriend’s mother and was involved in decisions about school and anything that he paid for. He also claimed that he was focused on ensuring the child attended school, improving his school attendance, and that he and the Other Party were equally involved in the child’s school. The Applicant believed that he had 100% ‘financial and emotional care’ of the child during this period and that the Other Party’s care percentage was 0% because she had minimal contact with the child’s girlfriend’s mother.

In October and November 2018, the Other Party claimed that she had 50% care of the child while he ‘floated for meals and beds’ between her mother’s house, the Applicant when he was in town, and her sisters and friends. She continued to meet the child weekly, pay for some food, and take him shopping for food and clothing. She also contributed to travel, health insurance, and made dentist appointments. In her view, from at least September 2018, the Applicant moved back to Western Australia permanently after four or five years and the child moved in with him. The Applicant became the child’s full-time carer from roughly November 2018.

This case involves a review of a decision by the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) regarding a child support assessment. The Applicant, who is the father, originally contested the child support assessment prompted by the Other Party's claim that she had 100% care of the child from September 2018. The AAT initially ruled in favour of the Other Party, determining that her care percentage for the child was 100% from September or October 2018, thereby setting aside an earlier objection decision. This reviewable decision was subsequently challenged by the Applicant before the Tribunal's General Division. The Applicant argued that the child did not live with the Other Party during the relevant period and that she did not provide financial support for the child. The Tribunal's task was to determine the percentage of care each parent had of the child from a date after the previous child support assessment was ended, which was on 8 July 2018, to a date generally within 12 months from that commencement date. The Tribunal also needed to consider the date from which any variation or setting aside of the AAT's decision should have effect, either from the date the AAT application for review was lodged or from the date of effect of the original decision, subject to special circumstances being identified.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal is satisfied that all the relevant evidence was before the Tribunal and that the parties were provided an opportunity to address it, either orally or in writing.EVIDENCE AND PARTIES’ CONTENTIONSThe Applicant’s evidence and submissions The Applicant gave evidence and made submissions in support of his position (in A1 and A2 within R2)[12] and orally at hearing.[12] The Applicant’s evidence and submissions within R2 appear at T17, T21, T23, T25, T26, T28, T29, T32, T33 and T36. For the periods where the Applicant has indicated his claimed care percentages, in his submission, this ‘care’ is indicated by ‘living costs and emotional costs’.[13] The Applicant stated he has been in contact with the child five to 10 times per day by text message or phone call for the last 10 years and that he has been completely emotionally involved in the child’s life.[14] The Applicant stated however that, ‘obviously, I was living over east so it was complicated for a while’.[15][13] Transcript, page 10 at [35].[14] Transcript, page 10 at [35] – [40] and page 14 at [5]-[10].[15] Transcript, page 10 at [40].July 2018, August 2018 and September 2018 For the period July, August and September 2018, the Applicant stated that he paid the child’s girlfriend’s mother rent each week directly into her account, and he paid money directly into the child’s account.[16] The Applicant said that he was emotionally involved in the child’s care in that he would speak daily to the child’s girlfriend’s mother and was involved in decisions about school and about anything that he paid for.[17][16] See R2, T17, page 128.[17] Transcript, page 12 at [20]-[30]. When asked by the Tribunal to detail his involvement with the child’s school the Applicant said that this consisted of:[18][18] Transcript, page 15 at [25]-[40] and page 16 at [5].Getting him back on track and making sure he attended school. We went from I think it was around 50 per cent of attendance the year before, so it was just about making sure he was there and then focusing on making sure he was getting the best out of what he was achieving …So my number and [the Other Party’s] number was probably the same. Mine was set up with a text message to see whether he attended school or not, and if he didn’t attend school I would speak to the year coordinator in regards to what was going on, and then when there was issues with a couple of teachers when he wasn’t turning up and doing what a teenager does in class, talking to them about fixing that, and then working with [the child] on improving that, and then talking with [the child].obviously about issues because they didn’t want to be involved about the school issues because they want that left up to the parents. …[The Other Party] could well have been involved with the school, I don’t know. I didn’t get any information to say that she was, but … I was worried about my son, not about her.(Without alteration.) The Applicant stated that, therefore, for this three month period, he believes he had 100% ‘financial and emotional care’ of the child.[19] The Applicant said that his belief that the Other Party’s care percentage during this time was 0% was based on his being informed by the child’s girlfriend’s mother that she had had minimal contact with the Other Party.[20][19] Transcript, page 9 at [30]-[35] and page 11 at [20].[20] Transcript, page 13 at [5] and [20].October 2018 and November 2018

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 13 December 2019, the AAT1 set aside the objection decision (R2, T2, pages 6 to 12). In substitution, the AAT1 decided that from September or October 2018, the Other Party’s care percentage for the child is 100% and is to be used in the child support assessment from the application date of 7 February 2019 (R2, T2, page 6) (the reviewable decision). In reaching its decision, the AAT1 decided that special circumstances prevented the Other Party’s application for review being made within the 28 day period after notice of the objection decision was given (R2, T2, page 11). That is, the AAT1 made a determination under s 95N(2) of the Child Support (Registration and Collection) Act 1988 (Cth) (the Collection Act) to extend the period for lodging the application for review to 26 August 2019 (being the date it was lodged). On 20 December 2019, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal’s General Division for a review of the reviewable decision on the basis that, in the Applicant’s view, the child did not live with the Other Party during the relevant period nor did the Other Party provide financial support for the child (R2, T1, page 4). In his application, the Applicant also claims that he provided nearly $4,000 during the period between November 2018 to March 2019 (R2, T4, page 4).ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION The issue for determination by the Tribunal is what percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party had of the child from a date after the previous child support assessment was ended to, generally speaking, a date 12 months from that commencement date.[3] This requires consideration of:(a)Whether the Applicant and/or the Other Party had care of the child after the previous child support assessment was ended, that is, after 8 July 2018; and, if so,(b)What percentage of care the Applicant and the Other Party had of the child, respectively; and(c)During what period (i.e., the start and end dates) those percentages applied to the Applicant and to the Other Party in their respective care of the child.[3] If the Tribunal should vary or set aside the reviewable decision, the date from which its decision should have effect for the purposes of the child support assessment will also fall for consideration. This date will be either the date that the AAT1 application for review was lodged, being 26 August 2019,[4] or if the Tribunal is satisfied that there were special circumstances that prevented the application to the AAT1 from being lodged within 28 days of the Other Party having been notified on the objection decision,[5] the decision will have effect from 7 February 2019.[6] [4] See s 95N(1) of the Collection Act. The Other Party did not lodge her application for review with the AAT1 until 26 August 2019 (R2, T35, page 486), which was more than 28 days after she received notice of the objection decision. The AAT1 determined, in accordance with s 95N(2) of the Collection Act, that the time for lodging an application for review should be extended to 26 August 2019. The Tribunal has jurisdiction to review the AAT1’s decision to make such a determination under s 96A(c) of the Collection Act.[5] The date of notification being 22 July 2019 (see [7] above).[6] Being the date of effect of the original decision (R2, T13, page 102).LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Other Party said that in her view, from at least September 2019[73] and (more) ‘probably … the first week of October’, the Applicant moved back to Western Australian permanently after four or five years and the child moved in with him.[74] The Other Party said that the Applicant became the child’s full-time carer from roughly November 2019.[75] The Other Party that she had 50% care of the child from September 2019 to late October 2019 while the child:[76]… floated for meals and beds between my mums with me, his dad when he was in town and my sisters and friends. I continued to meet [the child] weekly and pay for some food and took him shopping for food and clothing. I continued to contribute to travel, HBF, made dentist appointments etc.(Without alteration.)[73] OP4.[74] Transcript, page 18 at [15] and A2.[75] Transcript, page 24 at [20].[76] Summary table attached to OP4, page 2.CONSIDERATION As noted above, the task for the Tribunal in the present matter is to determine the percentage of care, if any, that each parent, being the Applicant and the Other Party, had of the child. The date from which any such determination would have effect also falls for consideration. The starting position is that the earlier child support assessment that was in place from 2015 was ended with effect from 8 July 2018 because the child was found to no longer be in either parent’s care. The Tribunal understands that this is not in dispute between the Applicant and the Other Party. Rather, the child support assessment that is the subject of the present proceedings is the assessment prompted by the Other Party’s advice to the Agency on 7 February 2019 that she had 100% care of the child and that he had returned to her care from September 2018.Is there a pattern of care? To make a determination of percentage of care in accordance with s 49 or s 50 of the Assessment Act, it is first necessary for the Tribunal to decide whether there is a ‘pattern of care’ (ss 49 and 50(1) of the Assessment Act). In the present matter, the Tribunal is required to determine whether either parent commenced having a care pattern of or a care arrangement for the child at some stage after 8 July 2018. The relevant care period has now passed, and a new child support assessment was made on 1 October 2019 and was in effect from that date. That being so, the Tribunal must identify on what date after 8 July 2018 the care arrangement commenced and on what date it ceased. As noted at paragraph [20] above, ‘pattern of care’ is not a defined term and can be interpreted according to its ordinary meaning. The Tribunal has considered the available evidence, set out at paragraphs [35] to [64], and listed at paragraph [33] above. The Tribunal has formed the view that at the time the Other Party made the application for a child support assessment following her advice that she had 100% of the child (see paragraph [4] above), she had established a ‘pattern of care’ in respect of the child. The Tribunal does not hold the same view in relation to the Applicant and considers the evidence demonstrates no pattern of care for the child. The Tribunal’s view is based on the evidence that:(a)The Other Party has been responsible for the child’s living arrangements, living costs, day-to-day matters and personal care, including during periods where the child did not continuously reside with her personally.(b)The Other Party has been responsible for providing the child with food, health insurance, meeting the costs of his education, transport and other general necessities of daily life.(c)The Applicant provided money, at times, to the child, which he was free to use as he pleased (rather than, for example, his schooling or accommodation). However, there was no particular arrangement, regularity nor pattern to these payments or any parameters regarding appropriate use of the funds.(d)The Applicant was far less involved than the Other Party, in making day to day decisions regarding the child, other than expressing his view at one point that he wanted the Other Party and the Ks to be responsible for the child.