Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v Grenadier Manufacturing Pty Ltd (in liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION

S CI 2010 04249

FULTON HOGAN CONSTRUCTION PTY LIMITED Plaintiff
V
GRENADIER MANUFACTURING PTY LIMITED
(In Liquidation) AND OTHERS
Defendants

---

JUDGE:

ALMOND J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATES OF HEARING:

3, 6, 7, 10 to 13, 17 to 20 and 24 to 27 October 2011, 2, 3, 4, 7 to 9, 14 to 17 November 2011

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

23 August 2012

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Limited v Grenadier Manufacturing Pty Limited

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2012] VSC 358

---

Torts — Negligence — Failure of coating applied to the trusses and handrails of a footbridge — Whether the failure of the coating was caused or contributed to by poor application practice by the second defendant or other contractors — Whether the failure of the coating was caused or contributed to by defective product manufactured by the third defendant.

Evidence — Opinion — Expert evidence — Whether an expert can adopt the reasoning and conclusions of subordinates in writing an expert report.

Damages — Goods and services tax (GST) — Whether an award of damages should include GST paid by the plaintiff to third parties as a consequence of rectifying the property damage — Whether damages awarded for loss arising from property damage constitute supply for the purposes of GST — Where the plaintiff is registered for GST purposes and entitled to receive an input tax credit.

Damages — Economic loss in tort and contract from failure to take reasonable care — Concurrent wrongdoers — Proportionate liability — Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) Pt IVAA, s 24AH.

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors
For the Plaintiff Mr P J Hayes and
Ms K J Le Faucheur
Cornwall Stodart
For the Second Defendant Mr J J Isles and Mr D J Cole Acquaro & Co
For the Third Defendant Mr P J Cosgrave SC and
Ms B Lim
Norris Coates

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Questions for determination............................................................................................................ 4

Expert evidence................................................................................................................................... 5

Challenge to expert evidence of Dr Garnys.............................................................................. 5

Other expert evidence................................................................................................................ 11

Question 1 - What were the characteristics of the failure of the coatings on the trusses and the handrails?........................................................................................................................................... 13

Question 2 - Were the coating products used on the project defective?................................ 20

Question 3 - If yes to question 2, did the defective coating products cause or contribute to the failure of the coating on the trusses and handrails?.................................................................................... 20

Dr Garnys..................................................................................................................................... 20

Mr Eccleston................................................................................................................................. 41

Mr Haig......................................................................................................................................... 50

Mr Cook........................................................................................................................................ 56

Mr Pellegrino............................................................................................................................... 61

Complaints history..................................................................................................................... 71

Reformulation of product.......................................................................................................... 73

Age of batch and circumstances of warehousing................................................................... 74

Wattyl’s failure to disclose relevant documents.................................................................... 75

Withdrawal of product from the market................................................................................. 75

Conclusion on question 2 and question 3............................................................................... 76

Question 4 - Was the Wattyl coating system properly applied in accordance with the Wattyl product specifications (a) by Cox to the trusses; and (b) by other contractors to the handrails?..... 78

Application to the trusses.......................................................................................................... 85

Application to the handrails...................................................................................................... 87

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v Grenadier Manufacturing... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] VSC 358
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd was the plaintiff, Grenadier Manufacturing Pty Ltd was the second defendant, and the third defendant was in liquidation. The dispute arose from a footbridge where the coating applied to the trusses and handrails failed. The plaintiff sought damages from the second defendant, alleging that the failure was due to poor application practices, and from the third defendant, claiming the failure resulted from a defective product. The case was heard in the Supreme Court of Victoria.

The court needed to determine whether the failure of the coating was caused or contributed to by the second defendant's application practices or by a defective product from the third defendant. Additionally, the court had to consider whether an expert could rely on the reasoning and conclusions of their subordinates in forming their expert opinion. The court also needed to decide whether damages awarded for rectifying property damage should include the GST paid by the plaintiff to third parties and whether such damages constituted a supply for GST purposes.

The court found that the coating failure was due to the second defendant's poor application practices. The court held that an expert could incorporate the reasoning and conclusions of their subordinates in their report, as long as the expert critically reviewed the work and satisfied themselves that the conclusions were correct. The court determined that the GST paid by the plaintiff to third parties as a result of rectifying the property damage should be included in the damages award. It also found that damages awarded for loss arising from property damage did not constitute a supply for the purposes of GST. Finally, the court applied the provisions of the Wrongs Act 1958 (Vic) Pt IVAA, s 24AH, to apportion the liability between the concurrent wrongdoers.

The court ordered the second defendant to pay damages to the plaintiff, including the GST paid to third parties for rectifying the property damage. The third defendant, being in liquidation, was not ordered to pay any damages. The court also made orders regarding the apportionment of liability between the second defendant and the third defendant.