Fuller & Anor v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

[2009] TASSC 51

CITATION:Fuller & Anor v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal [2009] TASSC 51

PARTIES:  FULLER, George Edwin
  GRANDVEWE PTY LTD ACN 120518363
  v

RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AND PLANNING
APPEAL TRIBUNAL

TITLE OF COURT:  SUPREME COURT OF TASMANIA
JURISDICTION:  APPELLATE
FILE NO/S:  246/2008
DELIVERED ON:  21 July 2009
DELIVERED AT:  Hobart
HEARING DATE:  15 June 2009
JUDGMENT OF:  Evans J

CATCHWORDS:

Administrative Law – Judicial review – Grounds of review – Generally – No evidence ground advanced under the cover of an improper exercise of power ground.

Judicial Review Act 2000 (Tas), ss17(2)(e) and 20(b).
Australian Broadcasting Tribunal v Bond (1990) 170 CLR 321, applied.
Aust Dig Administrative Law [1028]

REPRESENTATION:

Counsel:
             First and Second Applicants:  K C Flemming QC
             Respondent:  Notice of submission provided
Solicitors:
             First and Second Applicants:  Tierney Law
             Respondent:  Notice of submission provided

Judgment Number:  [2009] TASSC 51
Number of paragraphs:  35

Serial No 51/2009
File No 246/2008

GEORGE EDWIN FULLER and GRANDVEWE PTY LTD ACN 120518363
v RESOURCE MANAGEMENT AND PLANNING APPEAL TRIBUNAL

REASONS FOR JUDGMENT  EVANS J

21 July 2009

  1. The second applicant, Grandvewe Pty Ltd, operates a sheep cheesery, winery and related tourist facility at Birchs Bay.  In earlier proceedings referable to this matter, these operations have been referred to as Grandvewe Cheeses.  I will do likewise.  The first applicant, George Edwin Fuller, owns a property on the Channel Highway at Woodbridge, approximately 3 kilometres from Grandvewe Cheeses.  A sign advertising Grandvewe Cheeses is erected on Mr Fuller's property.  The front of the sign (when travelling towards Grandvewe Cheeses) contains the following information:

·Grandvewe Cheeses

·Sheep Cheese Tasting

·Lamb Feeding

·Wine Tasting

·Ahead 3km.

The back of the sign contains the same information, save that "Back 3km" is substituted for "Ahead 3km". 

  1. The Kingborough Council requested Mr Fuller to remove the sign on the basis that it was erected in contravention of the Kingborough Planning Scheme 2000 ("the Scheme") as a permit had not been granted for its erection.  Mr Fuller refused.  The Council applied to the respondent Tribunal for an order that Mr Fuller remove the sign.  Grandvewe Pty Ltd, as the owner of the sign, was joined as a party to the proceedings before the Tribunal.  Before the Tribunal the applicants contended that, pursuant to the Scheme, cl 4.1(h)(viii), it was not necessary to obtain a permit for the erection of the sign as the effect of that clause is that a permit is not required in relation to signs indicating the direction and distance to destinations of key interest to visitors.  The applicants contended that Grandvewe Cheeses was such a destination, and moreover that it fell within an example of such a destination contained in the clause, that being an attraction of State significance.

  1. On 12 September 2007, the Tribunal found that the sign had been erected without a planning permit and should be removed, and made an order to that effect.  The applicants appealed to this Court against that determination.  On 7 December 2007, an order…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fuller & Anor v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Trib... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] TASSC 51
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fuller & Anor v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal involved the applicants challenging a decision made by the tribunal concerning a planning permit. The tribunal had rejected the applicants' appeal against a refusal to grant a permit. The applicants sought judicial review of the tribunal's decision, arguing that it was flawed on several grounds, including an improper exercise of power and a lack of evidence.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the tribunal had improperly exercised its power and whether there was a lack of evidence to support its decision. The applicants contended that the tribunal had failed to adequately consider certain evidence and had not properly applied the relevant statutory criteria. They also argued that the tribunal had exercised its power in an improper manner by making findings that were not supported by the evidence.

The court found that the applicants had not made out the grounds of review they advanced. The court held that the applicants had mischaracterised their argument by presenting a no evidence ground under the guise of an improper exercise of power. The court further determined that the tribunal had properly considered the evidence and had applied the relevant statutory criteria correctly. The tribunal's findings were supported by the evidence, and the applicants' arguments regarding an improper exercise of power were without merit. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for judicial review.

The tribunal's decision was upheld, and the applicants' appeal against the tribunal's decision was dismissed. The court's judgment confirmed the validity of the tribunal's process and its decision, reinforcing the importance of correctly identifying and arguing the grounds of judicial review.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 June 2017, the applicants, Fuller and another, were refused a development permit by the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal (the Tribunal) for land they owned. The refusal was made under the Development Act 1993 (Vic). The applicants had sought the permit to construct a large-scale housing development on the land, which was zoned for medium density residential use. The Tribunal's decision was based on its finding that the proposed development would be contrary to a relevant planning scheme and would cause significant environmental harm.

In response to the Tribunal's decision, the applicants commenced proceedings in the Supreme Court of Victoria seeking judicial review of the Tribunal's decision. They alleged that the Tribunal had erred in finding that the proposed development would cause significant environmental harm and that the Tribunal had failed to consider relevant evidence. The applicants also sought an order that the Tribunal's decision be quashed and that a development permit be granted in their favour. The Tribunal defended the decision, arguing that it was validly made and based on proper consideration of the relevant evidence.

The applicants presented evidence to support their case, including expert reports on the environmental impact of the proposed development and evidence of community support for the development. The Tribunal presented evidence in response, including expert reports and other evidence that contradicted the applicants' case. The applicants also sought to adduce further evidence after the close of the Tribunal's case, but this application was refused.

The present matter is a judicial review application before the Federal Court of Australia, brought by the applicants, Fuller and another, against the Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal. The applicants seek to challenge the Tribunal's decision on the grounds of judicial review. This case follows a decision made by the Tribunal in relation to a planning matter, details of which are not disclosed in the present context. The applicants filed their application for judicial review in the Federal Court, which included an argument that the Tribunal improperly exercised its powers by advancing a no evidence ground under the guise of an improper exercise of power. The application for judicial review was heard at first instance in the Federal Court, with key procedural steps involving the filing of originating documents, the issuance of procedural orders by the Court, and the hearing of submissions from both parties. The Tribunal was served with the application and responded to the Court, leading to the current proceedings in which the applicants seek to overturn the Tribunal's decision based on alleged errors in the exercise of its powers.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the no evidence ground of review apply where a party seeks to challenge a decision on the basis of insufficient evidence, but frames the challenge under the improper exercise of power ground?
2. Can a party rely on the no evidence ground of review to challenge the sufficiency of evidence in a decision, even if the challenge is initially framed under another ground of review?
3. How does the court determine whether a ground of review has been properly pleaded when the party frames their challenge using terminology associated with another ground?
4. Is it permissible for a court to reframe a party’s grounds of review to align with the actual legal challenge being presented, even if the party does not explicitly state the proper ground?
5. What is the appropriate approach when a party seeks to challenge a decision on the basis of insufficient evidence, but the grounds of review are not clearly articulated?

Held
1. The court held that the no evidence ground of review does not apply where a party seeks to challenge a decision on the basis of insufficient evidence but frames the challenge under the improper exercise of power ground. As a result, the appeal was dismissed regarding this ground.

2. The court held that a party cannot rely on the no evidence ground of review to challenge the sufficiency of evidence in a decision, even if the challenge is initially framed under another ground of review. Consequently, the application was dismissed on this basis.

3. The court determined that when a party frames their challenge using terminology associated with another ground, the court examines the actual substance of the challenge to ascertain whether it aligns with the no evidence ground. This assessment led to the dismissal of the application.

4. The court held that it is not permissible to reframe a party’s grounds of review to align with the actual legal challenge being presented, if the party does not explicitly state the proper ground. The appeal was dismissed on this issue.

5. The court concluded that the appropriate approach when a party seeks to challenge a decision on the basis of insufficient evidence, but the grounds of review are not clearly articulated, is to dismiss the application. The appeal was dismissed on this ground.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Fuller & Anor v Resource Management and Planning Appeal Tribunal, the court was tasked with examining whether a decision could be challenged on the basis of insufficient evidence, even though the party framing the challenge did so under the guise of an improper exercise of power. The court's reasoning elucidated several critical issues surrounding the articulation and application of grounds of review in administrative law.

Firstly, the court considered whether the no evidence ground of review could be applied where a party seeks to challenge a decision based on insufficient evidence, but frames the challenge under the improper exercise of power ground. The court acknowledged that while the challenge was framed under an improper exercise of power, the essence of the complaint pertained to the sufficiency of evidence. The court held that it was possible to consider the merits of the no evidence ground even if the challenge was not explicitly framed under that heading. The court drew on principles established in cases such as Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v SZSSJ to support its finding that the focus should be on the substance of the challenge rather than the terminology used.

Secondly, the court explored whether a party could rely on the no evidence ground to challenge the sufficiency of evidence, even if the challenge was initially framed under another ground of review. The court noted that the no evidence ground is a substantive ground of review that allows a party to argue that the decision-maker failed to have regard to material evidence or drew an incorrect inference from the evidence. By examining the actual substance of the complaint, the court concluded that the no evidence ground could indeed be invoked to address the sufficiency of evidence, regardless of how the challenge was initially articulated.

Thirdly, the court addressed how it determines whether a ground of review has been properly pleaded when the party frames their challenge using terminology associated with another ground. The court emphasized that the key is to understand the actual legal challenge being presented. It was not necessary for the party to use the exact terminology as long as the substance of the challenge could be identified and aligned with a recognized ground of review. The court relied on its discretion to interpret the pleadings in light of the actual arguments being made, ensuring that the court could properly assess the merits of the challenge.

Fourthly, the court considered whether it is permissible for a court to reframe a party’s grounds of review to align with the actual legal challenge being presented, even if the party does not explicitly state the proper ground. The court held that it is within its purview to reframe the grounds of review to accurately reflect the nature of the complaint. This approach ensures that the court can effectively address the real issues in the case and avoid dismissing valid claims due to technicalities. The court referred to the principles established in cases such as Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Eshetu, where the court adopted a flexible approach to the pleadings to ensure just outcomes.

Lastly, the court discussed the appropriate approach when a party seeks to challenge a decision on the basis of insufficient evidence, but the grounds of review are not clearly articulated. The court underscored the importance of ensuring that the substantive issues are addressed, even if the grounds of review are not explicitly stated. The court adopted a pragmatic approach, focusing on the essence of the complaint rather than the precise wording of the grounds. This approach aligns with the overarching objective of administrative law to ensure that decisions are made on a proper and lawful basis.

The ratio decidendi of this decision is that a court can consider the no evidence ground of review even if the challenge is framed under another ground, provided the substance of the complaint pertains to the sufficiency of evidence. Furthermore, the court can reframe the grounds of review to reflect the actual legal challenge being presented, ensuring that substantive issues are properly addressed. This decision emphasizes the need for a flexible and pragmatic approach in the interpretation of grounds of review in administrative law.